Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

How do people justify the mass murder of children?

670 replies

cavewoman2026 · 31/10/2026 11:34

Can someone explain this to me in a non emotional way? Like I’m really dense.

Children are innocent and don’t understand the concept of death. In a normal society if somebody murders a child they get locked up. But I see people online who deny or justify the killing of children and I just don’t understand how their brain ends up at that stage.

As a mother and someone who works with children in a school the idea of someone bombing or hurting children genuinely makes me feel faint. I’ll be on playground duty and get horrific intrusive thoughts of the school being bombed and thinking of all our precious children being hurt and society being ah okay well it’s just collateral damage. I truly don’t understand it. Then I bat these thoughts away because I end up feeling confused.

We have seen images of children being ripped apart, being orphaned (I get emotional whenever a child at work asks for their mummy, the idea of an orphaned child being all alone in the world hurts me)and there are people on this site saying hmm not enough, more war! More bombing!

20,000 thousand children have been murdered in Gaza (and 40 Israeli children), how as a society we let this happen? Or justify it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
dairydebris · 02/11/2026 11:01

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 10:56

Yet it seems v clear that the recent elections will not lead to a rethink of actions in Gaza. Not was there significant campaigning on such a rethink. There is an obvious failure within Israeli society to look before October 7th. And also to look critically at the indefensible response to October 7th. Clearly there is a minority who do, such as the directors of Naza and others. But they are clearly a small minority

How on earth are you coming to those conclusions? There has been no government formed yet.

Failure to look at what prior to 7 October?

How are you coming to the conclusion that the large majority of Israelis have no desire to think critically about the response to October 7? Didn't Netanyahu suffer a loss- even if not severe enough for another bloc to take power?

I'm really curious as to how youve formed these such strong and confident views?

nearlylovemyusername · 02/11/2026 11:15

@catabhaile

There is an obvious failure within Israeli society to look before October 7th.

What exactly are you trying to say? are you implying that Israelis should go on soul searching journey and accept that7th October was their fault? can you be a bit more explicit?

GeneralPeter · 02/11/2026 11:21

GeneralPeter · 02/11/2026 10:20

It's not disingenuous. You said you had a genuine question, which is what Palestinians should do. I'm not sure that ordinary Palestinians can do a huge amount, sadly, and your answer hasn't really suggested anything any different.

What do you think Palestinians should do?

Edited

@catabhaile I'd still like to know what you think a good faith answer to your own question looks like, as you called my attempt disingenuous.

What should Palestinians do?

Do you see removing Hamas/IJ and demilitarising as being part of the solution? If not, how to get to a peaceful and prosperous Gaza with them in place?

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

GeneralPeter · 02/11/2026 11:21

@catabhaile I'd still like to know what you think a good faith answer to your own question looks like, as you called my attempt disingenuous.

What should Palestinians do?

Do you see removing Hamas/IJ and demilitarising as being part of the solution? If not, how to get to a peaceful and prosperous Gaza with them in place?

Edited

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

dairydebris · 02/11/2026 11:34

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

Dismantle the Jewish State eh. What a surprise.

Change of direction, change of leadership, why bother. Just dismantle the Jewish State.

At least you are honest.

Do you believe Jewish people would be safe in a mixed State? Do you believe Jewish people would be safe under a Hamas government? A PA government?

nearlylovemyusername · 02/11/2026 11:37

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

Gosh! I think the discussion is over.

Dismantle Israeli state... I can see where ideas to bulldoze Gaza instead are coming from

OpheliaWasntMad · 02/11/2026 11:43

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

So your alternative to my suggestion that a violent terrorist group - Hamas - must surrender and Iran must stop funding Hamas is that the Israeli state must be dismantled ?

OpheliaWasntMad · 02/11/2026 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ellen2shoes · 02/11/2026 11:48

nearlylovemyusername · 02/11/2026 00:29

It's not racists and not crap.

Can you disprove this instead of using lazy argument of racism?

It's a well documented fact that Gazans happily put their children on front line, means risking their lives seems to be a price worth paying for killing Jews.

ETA: to add one of multiple sources, this one is over 20 years old, still stand true
Occupied Territories: Stop Use of Children in Suicide Bombings | Human Rights Watch

Edited

Why are you dredging up a 20 year old report while ignoring the current situation? What do you think the settler terrorist hilltop youth are if not foot soldiers? Recruits are getting increasingly younger with children as young as 12 being recruited off the streets to be indoctrinated with extremist anti Arab ideology.

To answer your question regarding your misquoting of Meir, it’s racist because it draws on the racist trope that Arab parents lack basic love for their children, so dehumanising and othering them.

It is also blatant victim blaming, shifting the agency from the Israeli military on to the parents and communities of the killed children.

PurpleThistle7 · 02/11/2026 11:49

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

Are you also dismantling 52 Arab states? They aren’t exactly free and equal societies. Do you know there are 14 countries that I can’t even visit as a tourist as someone born in israel? Even more I wouldn’t be safe to visit or live as a Jew. So… no thanks to this

inamarina · 02/11/2026 11:51

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 10:16

Such a disingenuous reply which simply ignores the abhorrence of Israeli actions. It's not simply 'bleak' it is continuing war crimes at absolute best and genocide at worst. The entire world except for Israel and a few blinkered and often heavily invested allies can see this. I often wonder why Israelis cannot see that they are actually destroying themselves from within. If they lose the support of young Americans, which they're are rapidly doing, they cannot survive, as they rely so heavily on the US.

Israel’s actions didn’t happen in a vacuum. One can argue that they are disproportionate, but you can’t ignore that they are a direct response to the October 7th massacres, hostage-taking and ongoing rocket fire.

No sovereign nation would tolerate a terrorist proxy state on its border. Any realistic path to peace requires the removal and demilitarisation of Hamas.

OpheliaWasntMad · 02/11/2026 11:51

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

Are there any other countries who you think “we probably need to dismantle” ? Or is it just Israel?

OpheliaWasntMad · 02/11/2026 11:52

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

Are there any other countries you think “we probably need to dismantle” ? Or is it just Israel?

GeneralPeter · 02/11/2026 11:56

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

Thanks for responding. I think you are answering a slightly different question (but still an extremely important one), as I don't think any of those are things that Palestinians are in a position to deliver.

I agree some sort of truth and reconciliation process will be needed, as there is massive de-radicalisation needed (in my view mainly on the Palestinian side, but I recognise on both sides). I can't see any path to this until both sides feel they have run to the end of the road with military options. For Palestine/Gaza, I think that means accepting that they have been comprehensively defeated militarily, with no possible path back via violence. For Israel, maybe concerns about losing US support are what might force some rethink. I think Oct 7 has hardened political views for a generation though so it is going to be a long road.

Regarding the land. I certainly don't support dismantling Israel (depending exactly what you mean), though I agree with fully equal rights within Israel's borders. I think basically there is no solution that is practically viable right now, though a two-state solution is the best ideal of all the currently-impossible options. I don't think a one-state solution works, because it being a Jewish state is an absolute red line for most Israelis and it not being a Jewish state (or it being a Muslim state) is an absolute red line for most Palestinians. I don't think a two-state solution works because there's less and less support for that also. Some sort of three-state solution (Gaza being separate) is theoretically attractive but basically repugnant to most Israelis and Palestinians too. It's really hard. I don't really have any good answer, sadly.

eta:

The best practical way forward is probably to continue to kick the can down the road of what the final settlement will be, and focus on defanging Hamas and demilitarising Gaza, getting some sort of international security guarantees in place via a coalition of US and Arab states, and encouraging investment and rebuilding (impossible without the first two steps). It's not very realistic, but it's the least-bad plan I have.

1dayatatime · 02/11/2026 11:57

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

OK - at least you are being honest and clear. You want to see the end of the State of Israel.

Understandably many will disagree with you on this point.

hiddenvillage · 02/11/2026 12:00

catabhaile · 02/11/2026 11:29

We probably need to dismantle the current Israeli state in the form it takes now, and build a new state with genuine equality for all citizens. Jewish, Arab, Christian and others. There needs something like the truth and reconciliation committee in South Africa to guide the process of rebuilding.

Who is we? Who is going to dismantle an entire country and how? And what should happen to the millions of people living there?

PurpleThistle7 · 02/11/2026 12:08

hiddenvillage · 02/11/2026 12:00

Who is we? Who is going to dismantle an entire country and how? And what should happen to the millions of people living there?

Well if you listen to the hate marches, most should move ‘back’ to Poland. Thats what our local Palestine organisation would say

Dinnerontheterrace · 02/11/2026 12:25

What should the Palestinians do?

Reject Hamas and terrorism. Demilitarise. Accept a two state solution (offered and rejected on 5 separate occasions, previous occasions). Accept that they will have Jews for neighbours.

Then enjoy the benefits of aid and investment pouring in and look forward to prosperous, self determined future.

nearlylovemyusername · 02/11/2026 13:00

Ellen2shoes · 02/11/2026 11:48

Why are you dredging up a 20 year old report while ignoring the current situation? What do you think the settler terrorist hilltop youth are if not foot soldiers? Recruits are getting increasingly younger with children as young as 12 being recruited off the streets to be indoctrinated with extremist anti Arab ideology.

To answer your question regarding your misquoting of Meir, it’s racist because it draws on the racist trope that Arab parents lack basic love for their children, so dehumanising and othering them.

It is also blatant victim blaming, shifting the agency from the Israeli military on to the parents and communities of the killed children.

So you are agreeing that Palestinians use child soldiers? means they are happy for their children, as young as 12 according to you and UN reports, to die assuming they can kill a few Jews before then? Means they do hate Israelis more than they love own children?

This is "other" to me, I will never understand this mentality.

And I'm not "dredging" old report, the situation hasn't changed much, child soldiers report is only a few years old.

Israelis protect their right to exist, they haven't started the war on 6th October, they are responding to the events on 7th and after. They are the victims here who fight back. Given some PPs views here about "dismantling the state of Israel" I can understand Israeli's position, even if it might be considered disproportionate.

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2026 13:11

@Ellen2shoes there are more recent reports re child soldiers, I'm sure you're aware.

Written statement submitted by United Nations Watch, a non-governmental organization in special consultative status (2021)

United Nations Watch is deeply concerned by Palestinian Authority (PA) and Hamas recruitment and use of Palestinian child soldiers in violation of international law...

Both the PA and Hamas routinely indoctrinate Palestinian children to aspire to martyrdom through armed confrontations with Israel. According to Palestinian Media Watch (PMW), “the PA operates a systematic and institutionalized policy and program to recruit child soldiers/terrorists.”

In its reports to the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) on this issue, PMW accused the PA of indoctrinating Palestinian children to admire and emulate terrorists and noted that “The PA openly admits, that the child terrorists are not acting in a vacuum, but rather they consider them to be the PA’s soldiers who the PA has sent to carry out a mission.”

Examples of Palestinian and Hamas incitement include:

• PA television (TV) broadcast quizzes children on songs with “value and meanings” which PA considers expression of Palestinian “national identity.” One of the songs depicts Israel as the “enemy” and encourages armed attacks: “I'm coming with my rifle… I'm coming towards you, my enemy… with cleavers and knives.” (January 2021).

• Official PA TV children’s program commemorated cartoonist Naji al-Ala, by sharing several cartoons encouraging violence among children, including one where Fatima (Palestinian woman cartoon character) presents an AK47 to Handala (the Palestinian refugee cartoon character) and one of her handing rocks to children. (August 2020).

• Fatah Facebook page promotes child soldiers by sharing video of Jordanian boy in military uniform holding slingshot and rifle. He wants to “shoot Jews” who killed terrorist Omar Abu Laila (killed Israeli soldier, stole his weapon and shot to death Israeli father of 12). (February 2020).

• Hamas TV children’s program interviews young children dressed in military fatigues. One child says he wants to be an engineer when he grows up “so that I can blow up the Jews.” The child host responds “Keep waging Jihad…when you grow up you will wage resistance against the Jews…” (September 4, 2015).

www.un.org/unispal/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/AHRC46NGO42_050321.pdf

inamarina · 02/11/2026 13:33

Ellen2shoes · 02/11/2026 11:48

Why are you dredging up a 20 year old report while ignoring the current situation? What do you think the settler terrorist hilltop youth are if not foot soldiers? Recruits are getting increasingly younger with children as young as 12 being recruited off the streets to be indoctrinated with extremist anti Arab ideology.

To answer your question regarding your misquoting of Meir, it’s racist because it draws on the racist trope that Arab parents lack basic love for their children, so dehumanising and othering them.

It is also blatant victim blaming, shifting the agency from the Israeli military on to the parents and communities of the killed children.

The Hilltop Youth are a radical fringe group. They are generally condemned by the mainstream Israeli society. They also frequently get arrested for acts of extremist violence against Palestinians, international observers and the Israeli military itself.
That’s not really comparable with the child soldier recruitment and glorification of martyrdom in Gaza, facilitated by its governing authorities.

The concept of “othering” might be a valid and interesting academic idea, but it shouldn’t gloss over the documented reality that Palestinian militant groups actively weaponise and deploy minors on the front lines.

inamarina · 02/11/2026 13:47

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2026 13:11

@Ellen2shoes there are more recent reports re child soldiers, I'm sure you're aware.

Written statement submitted by United Nations Watch, a non-governmental organization in special consultative status (2021)

United Nations Watch is deeply concerned by Palestinian Authority (PA) and Hamas recruitment and use of Palestinian child soldiers in violation of international law...

Both the PA and Hamas routinely indoctrinate Palestinian children to aspire to martyrdom through armed confrontations with Israel. According to Palestinian Media Watch (PMW), “the PA operates a systematic and institutionalized policy and program to recruit child soldiers/terrorists.”

In its reports to the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) on this issue, PMW accused the PA of indoctrinating Palestinian children to admire and emulate terrorists and noted that “The PA openly admits, that the child terrorists are not acting in a vacuum, but rather they consider them to be the PA’s soldiers who the PA has sent to carry out a mission.”

Examples of Palestinian and Hamas incitement include:

• PA television (TV) broadcast quizzes children on songs with “value and meanings” which PA considers expression of Palestinian “national identity.” One of the songs depicts Israel as the “enemy” and encourages armed attacks: “I'm coming with my rifle… I'm coming towards you, my enemy… with cleavers and knives.” (January 2021).

• Official PA TV children’s program commemorated cartoonist Naji al-Ala, by sharing several cartoons encouraging violence among children, including one where Fatima (Palestinian woman cartoon character) presents an AK47 to Handala (the Palestinian refugee cartoon character) and one of her handing rocks to children. (August 2020).

• Fatah Facebook page promotes child soldiers by sharing video of Jordanian boy in military uniform holding slingshot and rifle. He wants to “shoot Jews” who killed terrorist Omar Abu Laila (killed Israeli soldier, stole his weapon and shot to death Israeli father of 12). (February 2020).

• Hamas TV children’s program interviews young children dressed in military fatigues. One child says he wants to be an engineer when he grows up “so that I can blow up the Jews.” The child host responds “Keep waging Jihad…when you grow up you will wage resistance against the Jews…” (September 4, 2015).

www.un.org/unispal/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/AHRC46NGO42_050321.pdf

That’s really sickening. Children are hardwired to trust the adults around them and believe that whatever they are taught is the truth.

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2026 14:18

inamarina · 02/11/2026 13:47

That’s really sickening. Children are hardwired to trust the adults around them and believe that whatever they are taught is the truth.

Happening in Iran too. Article from Amnesty International (April 2026)

Iran: Recruitment of child soldiers as young as 12 amounts to a war crime

Iranian authorities are trampling upon children’s rights and committing a grave violation of international humanitarian law amounting to a war crime by recruiting and mobilizing children as young as 12 into a military campaign led by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), Amnesty International said today.

On 26 March 2026, a deputy of the IRGC Mohammad Rasoul Allah Corps of Greater Tehran, Rahim Nadali, announced that a recruitment campaign called the “Homeland-Defending Combatants for Iran” is “open to volunteers” aged 12 and above, encouraging registrations at Basij bases in mosques across Tehran to join “combatants defending the homeland.”

Eyewitness accounts and verified audiovisual evidence show child soldiers having been deployed at IRGC checkpoints and patrols, armed with weapons, including AK47pattern rifles.

“The Iranian authorities are shamelessly encouraging children as young as 12 to join an IRGC run military campaign, putting them in grave danger and violating international law, which prohibits the recruitment and use of children in the military.

Recruiting children under 15 into the armed forces constitutes a war crime,” said Erika Guevara-Rosas, Senior Director for Research, Advocacy, Policy and Campaigns.

www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2026/04/iran-recruitment-of-child-soldiers-as-young-as-12-amounts-to-a-war-crime/

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2026 14:21

How do people justify that I wonder? Ignoring the atrocities of one side in a war doesn't mean they don't happen on both sides.

Ihatetomatoes · 02/11/2026 14:43

Twiglets1 · 02/11/2026 14:21

How do people justify that I wonder? Ignoring the atrocities of one side in a war doesn't mean they don't happen on both sides.

This.