Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

(Lack of) US Iran Peace Agreement Part 5

946 replies

OnePeppyFatball · 14/09/2026 10:37

Part 5

OP posts:
Thread gallery
131
Newbutoldfather · 28/10/2026 12:04
  • Iranian oil
RedTagAlan · 28/10/2026 14:17

Newbutoldfather · 28/10/2026 12:04

@trumpredcard ,

‘Tanker rental prices have fallen lately as successful US escorting operations in Hormuz is allowing more oil to flow through. If other countries are hiring vessels to transport oil out of Hormuz, what's to stop China from using its navy to escort Iranian oil bound for for itself, out for transfer to its vessels waiting outside Hormuz.’

I don’t think China is so desperate for Iraqi oil that they need to bring their Navy in direct conflict with the U.S navy so far from home.

If the Chinese want to raise the stakes, all they need to do is restrict exports to the U.S of things that they use U.S oil to make.

For info only, The PRC have a Naval base in Djibouti. Just a few km from the US one.

Could be interesting. They don't even need to leave port to do battle.

trumpredcard · 28/10/2026 21:03

There have been rumours that all is not well health wise,with Xi.
September
https://www.independent.co.uk/asia/china/china-xi-jinping-stroke-brics-health-b3051684.html?reloaded=1

October
https://www.chiangraitimes.com/china/china-xi-jinpings-health/
BEIJING – Fresh reports have raised new questions about China’s President Xi Jinping’s health following his recent United States trip. During his highly anticipated schedule in Washington, Chinese officials reportedly made unusual requests for additional rest time.
They specifically asked for a dedicated private room for the Chinese leader to use between his meetings. These special arrangements immediately caught the intense attention of diplomatic observers and the global international media.
It is quite rare for prominent world leaders to request such specific breaks during high-stakes diplomatic summits. Naturally, this sudden change in standard protocol has fueled intense speculation regarding his overall physical well-being.
However, despite the swirling global rumors, there is absolutely no confirmed report establishing any specific medical condition. Chinese government officials have remained completely silent on the matter, leaving policy experts to actively connect the dots.

Rumours swirl about Xi Jinping’s health after he returns quickly from India

Chinese president attended the Brics summit over the weekend but skipped the gala dinner with the bloc’s leaders

https://www.independent.co.uk/asia/china/china-xi-jinping-stroke-brics-health-b3051684.html?reloaded=1

trumpredcard · 28/10/2026 21:28

@Newbutoldfather , my post was a question on what can the US do, not whether it is a viable option for China to take. After all, China can claim to be simply following the US's own example, but it would be a very provocative move to undermine US sanctions and how will the US react? I agree that China isn't that desperate for Iranian oil atm, but it's an excellent opportunity for China to test brinkmanship Trump's willingness to start WW3.

I find that exploring hypotheticals, particularly strategic ones, in this war theatre, helps me to understand motivators, possible acts, and their results/consequences. Just sharing idle thoughts in the lull before the storm.

trumpredcard · 28/10/2026 21:39

Jesus, I am not alone! I decided to ask AI and got this answer.

This is a scenario analysts have already discussed, because it follows from the current situation.
What escorts would change. The US would face a hard choice. One analyst noted the Navy could interdict Chinese-flagged vessels carrying Iranian oil, and that this gets much more fraught if Chinese warships escort the tankers. If US ships stop an escorted tanker, they risk a direct clash with a major power’s navy. If they back down, the blockade stops working for Iran’s biggest customer. Beijing could also frame it as protecting its own commerce and shipping rather than backing Iran, which makes the US move less politically comfortable.

Likely consequences, roughly in order of probability:

  • A standoff and diplomacy first. Both sides have strong reasons to avoid a shooting incident, so the likeliest early outcome is shadowing, radio warnings, and urgent back-channel talks rather than boarding or firing.
  • Escalation risk from accidents. In a crowded, mine-and-drone-laden waterway, a misread signal or collision between PLA and US ships is the main danger. Navy officials have described the area as an Iranian “kill box” with anti-ship missiles, drones, fast-attack boats and mines.
  • Sanctions and economic retaliation. Constraints on China. Escorting Iranian oil would mean confronting the US Navy at a long distance from Chinese bases. The PLA Navy is large, but it has less experience operating in this theater than the US does. China also buys oil from Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and others, and escorts that look like taking Iran’s side could damage those relationships. A Chinese commentary cited by The National Interest even argued that an escort mission in Hormuz would likely lead to conflict with one or more Gulf states.
US secondary sanctions on Chinese entities and possibly broader trade measures, and Chinese counter-measures such as export controls on critical materials.
  • Oil and insurance markets. Prices would likely spike on any hint of confrontation, and war-risk premiums would rise further.
  • Wider alignment effects. It would be China’s first major use of naval power to defy US maritime enforcement far from home, which would affect how Gulf states, India, and others hedge.

This 2019 article is an eyeopener.
https://nationalinterest.org/feature/should-china-police-strait-hormuz-95206

TopPocketFind · 29/10/2026 11:53

https://www.theatlantic.com/national-security/2026/10/brett-sylvia-hegseth-general-pentagon/689199/?utm_source=apple_news

Earlier this week, the Pentagon’s chief planner, Army Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia, was ousted from the Joint Chiefs of Staff. No explanation was given. This comes at an inopportune moment, given that President Trump may be planning to relaunch the war on Iran. Sylvia, the former commander of the 101st Airborne Division, becomes the latest in a long line of senior officers who have been shown the door since Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth arrived at the Pentagon almost two years ago.

No replacement for Sylvia was named, and it is unclear who will take over his responsibilities. In the past, the deputy or vice director of the relevant directorate of the Joint Chiefs of Staff would fill the role on a temporary basis until the president nominated a candidate for Senate confirmation. Sylvia is the second person to be pushed out of the job of director of the Directorate for Strategy, Plans, and Policy at the Joint Chiefs of Staff, known inside the military as the J5, in the past year. His predecessor, Army Lieutenant General Joseph McGee, was forced to retire. “Now is not the time when you’d want to lose the J5,” a former Joint Chiefs of Staff official said. “This person would serve as a critical link between the operational force, the department policy, and the White House.”

Legsess · 30/10/2026 08:06

TopPocketFind · 29/10/2026 11:53

https://www.theatlantic.com/national-security/2026/10/brett-sylvia-hegseth-general-pentagon/689199/?utm_source=apple_news

Earlier this week, the Pentagon’s chief planner, Army Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia, was ousted from the Joint Chiefs of Staff. No explanation was given. This comes at an inopportune moment, given that President Trump may be planning to relaunch the war on Iran. Sylvia, the former commander of the 101st Airborne Division, becomes the latest in a long line of senior officers who have been shown the door since Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth arrived at the Pentagon almost two years ago.

No replacement for Sylvia was named, and it is unclear who will take over his responsibilities. In the past, the deputy or vice director of the relevant directorate of the Joint Chiefs of Staff would fill the role on a temporary basis until the president nominated a candidate for Senate confirmation. Sylvia is the second person to be pushed out of the job of director of the Directorate for Strategy, Plans, and Policy at the Joint Chiefs of Staff, known inside the military as the J5, in the past year. His predecessor, Army Lieutenant General Joseph McGee, was forced to retire. “Now is not the time when you’d want to lose the J5,” a former Joint Chiefs of Staff official said. “This person would serve as a critical link between the operational force, the department policy, and the White House.”

Hmmm..... i wonder if this has any association with the "insane" plan for after the midterms.

https://abcnews4.com/news/nation-world/connecticut-senator-says-trumps-plan-to-resume-iran-war-after-midterms-is-insane-pentagon-chris-murphy

Connecticut senator says Trump's plan to resume Iran war after midterms is 'insane'

Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy said that President Donald Trump is planning to restart the Iran war after the midterm elections and the plan is “insane."

https://abcnews4.com/news/nation-world/connecticut-senator-says-trumps-plan-to-resume-iran-war-after-midterms-is-insane-pentagon-chris-murphy

trumpredcard · 30/10/2026 09:24

I'm betting on no attack because it won't deliver an Iranian surrender and that it's all taxpayer funded posturing.
But I want to know what's in the Vance letter that Iran will accept as a peace deal proposal.

TopPocketFind · 30/10/2026 09:29

Vance who said at a rally how difficult he finds it to pronounce the names on ME countries?

TopPocketFind · 30/10/2026 09:35

https://www.middleeasteye.net/live-blog/live-blog-update/report-us-sends-10-military-planes-israel-amid-plans-possible-military

The US has transferred 10 military cargo planes to Israeli air bases as preparation for a possible military operation against Iran, according to the Israeli public broadcaster KAN.

The broadcaster said the aircraft landed at Ovda and Nevatim air bases in the southern Negev region.

Several other aircrafts were reportedly dispatched elsewhere in the region, including Jordan, Saudi Arabia and Qatar.

An Israeli official told KAN that Israel and the US are "coordinating closely, and although no decision has yet been made on the matter, the Americans and Israel are preparing for any decision President Donald Trump makes".

trumpredcard · 30/10/2026 09:55

TopPocketFind · 30/10/2026 09:29

Vance who said at a rally how difficult he finds it to pronounce the names on ME countries?

That very Vance, pretending to be as dumb as the avg MAGAT.

Newbutoldfather · 30/10/2026 11:07

I would be AMAZED if they didn’t attack next week. You just don’t move that many military assets into position unless you intend to use them (which we probably should have realised before Russia attacked Ukraine.

Netanyahu is desperate for it to happen. It will help him stay in power and maybe form some kind of a right wing coalition. Trump too is war thirsty. It will allow him to dismiss poor mid term elections and maybe even call them a ‘steal’ (I really really hope that doesn’t happen.

Iran could throw a spanner in the works by keeping Hormuz open (it has been forcibly opened anyway) and being prepared to negotiate away the Uranium (which is doing them little good. However they won’t! They have new plans and new weapons that they want to try out. Personally, I think they are mad, but others on this thread will disagree, I know.

trumpredcard · 30/10/2026 11:42

The Democrats are lining up to prosecute Kegsbreath if they win the midterms. What is the endgame for the US? I agree on Trump's ego being the driving source for an attack, so what will make it palatable to Americans? Nothing.
So in my opinion, an attack will only go ahead if both Iran doesn't agree to engage in peace negotiations, and Trump, his reputation and legacy being toast anyway, decides 'Why not go out with a bang'.

We have a zacharia to go now.

RedTagAlan · 30/10/2026 16:26

trumpredcard · 28/10/2026 21:03

There have been rumours that all is not well health wise,with Xi.
September
https://www.independent.co.uk/asia/china/china-xi-jinping-stroke-brics-health-b3051684.html?reloaded=1

October
https://www.chiangraitimes.com/china/china-xi-jinpings-health/
BEIJING – Fresh reports have raised new questions about China’s President Xi Jinping’s health following his recent United States trip. During his highly anticipated schedule in Washington, Chinese officials reportedly made unusual requests for additional rest time.
They specifically asked for a dedicated private room for the Chinese leader to use between his meetings. These special arrangements immediately caught the intense attention of diplomatic observers and the global international media.
It is quite rare for prominent world leaders to request such specific breaks during high-stakes diplomatic summits. Naturally, this sudden change in standard protocol has fueled intense speculation regarding his overall physical well-being.
However, despite the swirling global rumors, there is absolutely no confirmed report establishing any specific medical condition. Chinese government officials have remained completely silent on the matter, leaving policy experts to actively connect the dots.

So just the usual speculation. I would say he is being sensible asking for more rest time. Trumps last visit to the PRC resulted in a bonanza of jet lag photos for PRC state media. And going from the east to the west, back in time, is worse.

Your second link by the way. Never heard of that site, but I got this where I am.. attached. Same with the Indy by the way.

(Lack of) US Iran Peace Agreement Part 5
RedTagAlan · 30/10/2026 16:44

Newbutoldfather · 30/10/2026 11:07

I would be AMAZED if they didn’t attack next week. You just don’t move that many military assets into position unless you intend to use them (which we probably should have realised before Russia attacked Ukraine.

Netanyahu is desperate for it to happen. It will help him stay in power and maybe form some kind of a right wing coalition. Trump too is war thirsty. It will allow him to dismiss poor mid term elections and maybe even call them a ‘steal’ (I really really hope that doesn’t happen.

Iran could throw a spanner in the works by keeping Hormuz open (it has been forcibly opened anyway) and being prepared to negotiate away the Uranium (which is doing them little good. However they won’t! They have new plans and new weapons that they want to try out. Personally, I think they are mad, but others on this thread will disagree, I know.

Agree and disagree.

Agree cos it is Trump. But disagree because the USA, despite a non stop average military budget of $800 billion, is simply not equipped. No nation is.

The US might have a million troops, 7k tanks, 600 ships, 4k planes etc, but that is all designed for short sharp wars on multiple fronts. To invade Iran, we are talking D day plus levels of kit. And I know you did not mention invasion, but we are talking about a country of 90 million, the size of western Europe. That would take the total economy of multiple nations being converted to war economies. And years of buildup.

And things have changed. As Russia now know. Now it is drones. And nobody has a drone defense. Not yet. If ever. Because the drone defenses, at the moment, will cost more than the drones.

Newbutoldfather · 30/10/2026 18:13

@RedTagAlan ,

I said attack, not invade!

It will be another short but sharp bombing campaign, having a go at Pickaxe mountain and power stations (which is pretty outrageous really).

They will also occupy Kharg Island I think, with their amphibious landing resources.

It will be all about creating a better bargaining position and a bit of shock and awe for their domestic audiences.

trumpredcard · 30/10/2026 22:24

it will be all about creating a better bargaining position

How? While it might appear to be counter intuitive, offering Iran immediate sanctions relief is what would give the US a better bargaining position imo.
#carrot #stick

RedTagAlan · 31/10/2026 01:55

Newbutoldfather · 30/10/2026 18:13

@RedTagAlan ,

I said attack, not invade!

It will be another short but sharp bombing campaign, having a go at Pickaxe mountain and power stations (which is pretty outrageous really).

They will also occupy Kharg Island I think, with their amphibious landing resources.

It will be all about creating a better bargaining position and a bit of shock and awe for their domestic audiences.

Yup. I mentioned in my post that you did not say invasion, but you did mention a troop buildup. And that's what I don't get. Because what will a troop buildup do?

Kharg Island could be taken yes. But why, that is a deep-water port at the end of pipelines. The oil is not extracted there. All Iran has to do is shut the valves on the pipelines on the mainland, and Kharg has no oil. I think it does have offshore gas wells close by in the sea though.

The B2 bombers that carry the bunker buster bombs are back in the USA, and they have world wide range. The B52s are on Diego Garcia. Carrier planes such as the F18 and F35 can't carry the bunker busters.

To me, they could have 5k troops ( one carrier), or 150k troops, It makes no difference, because to actually invade will take at least 500k troops, and all the tanks etc. And if Trump does plan on lots of airstrikes over Iran, he will lose planes. And he will end up with captured Iranian pilots being paraded on Iranian TV.

I also remember from earlier that the US had ran out of targets for airstrikes. That was months ago. So what will they hit? As you suggest, there are the power plants and infrastructure. But would they hit them? With all the legalities involved? Not to mention Ukraine on that. Trump saying to Ukraine "Stop attacking Russian infrastructure", as he bombs Iranian infrastructure?

One thing I do get though. Is that after the midterms, the price of oil will not matter. Trump will probably want it high. So, he can make as much as possible flogging his VZ oil he stole.

RedTagAlan · 31/10/2026 02:14

trumpredcard · 30/10/2026 22:24

it will be all about creating a better bargaining position

How? While it might appear to be counter intuitive, offering Iran immediate sanctions relief is what would give the US a better bargaining position imo.
#carrot #stick

Yes. Basically, as per the JCPOA and the MOU.

Also, he has not offered the Iranian Government any sort of immunity if they step down. He could say for example, step down, just give us the people who ordered the firing on the protestors. (At which point Iran could say "you already killed them"), and we can arrange a new constitution etc,

For the Iranian government, this is existential. Fight to the death or die. And yet Iran has been consistently clear. Let's talk sanctions and frozen assets, then we can talk nukes.

And as has been mentioned before, the Uranium is Irans biggest chip ( as well as the SoH). So why give that up for nothing in return.

Twiglets1 · 31/10/2026 07:52

US delegation said to be joining direct talks with Iran in Doha after negotiation breakthrough

A breakthrough has reportedly been reached in indirect negotiations between the US and Iran, with an American delegation expected to join Iranian officials for direct talks in Doha, according to the Qatari newspaper Al-Araby Al-Jadeed.

Citing sources close to mediation efforts led by Qatar and Pakistan, the report says the sides have agreed on preliminary measures concerning Iran’s nuclear program, navigation through the Strait of Hormuz and financial incentives for Tehran, with China and Russia set to serve as guarantors of an agreement.

The reported progress follows what Axios describes as more than 12 hours of talks between Qatari mediators and Iranian officials in Tehran yesterday, aimed at averting renewed US strikes on Iran after the November 3 midterm elections.

The Iranian negotiating team reportedly accompanied the Qatari delegation back to Doha, where negotiations are set to resume today.

The diplomatic push comes amid reports that Washington has warned Gulf allies to prepare for a possible new round of strikes on Iran as early as November 4, a day after the elections.

www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/us-delegation-said-to-be-joining-direct-talks-with-iran-in-doha-after-negotiation-breakthrough/

OnePeppyFatball · 31/10/2026 08:15

WSJ:

“Iran has hit America’s installations hard. Now, with President Trump considering a new wave of attacks on Iran, the U.S. military pulled some personnel off several of those locations ahead of possible retaliation, the Journal has reported. This comes as Pentagon officials worry that the regime has conserved some of its most sophisticated missiles and could improve its attacks in the next round of fighting.
More than 20 U.S. servicemembers have died in activity related to the Iran war since it began on Feb. 28, according to Defense Department data. More than 400 were wounded before the temporary ceasefire fell apart in July, after which the government stopped publishing casualty figures specific to the war.
The latest cost estimate of the Iran war stands at $47.1 billion as of Oct. 16, according to a document viewed by the Journal. That doesn’t include damage to bases, which the Pentagon separately priced at a minimum of $5 billion, according to U.S. officials familiar with the matter. That number could potentially be as high as $15 billion, according to a separate person briefed on the cost. ”
“The Journal shared its findings on damaged buildings with the Center for Strategic and International Studies, which estimated that the cost of reconstruction alone—without replacing the equipment and systems inside those buildings—would be more than $4 billion.
The U.S. is in talks with allied nations to pay for some repairs, which could help keep costs to the U.S. down, officials have said. Many of the installations are shared with, or owned by, allies, so the damaged buildings aren’t necessarily American or used only by U.S. forces”
“After the war began on Feb. 28, Iranian missiles and drones pounded bases across the Persian Gulf. In the first two weeks, at least 119 buildings at 13 installations, mostly in nearby Kuwait, showed damage—more than in any other stretch of the war.
Naval Support Activity Bahrain, home of the Navy’s Fifth Fleet, took heavy fire in those two weeks. Central Command evacuated most personnel from the base.
On March 13, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth declared Iran’s missile program all but finished. “Iran’s entire ballistic missile production capacity, every company that builds every component of those missiles, has been functionally defeated, destroyed,” he said at a Pentagon press briefing.
But Iran kept striking. Over the rest of the month, damage appeared at six more installations, the Journal’s analysis found.”
“On April 1, Trump told the nation that Iran’s military was nearly spent. “Their navy is gone. Their air force is gone. Their missiles are just about used up or beaten,” he said during a prime-time address.
By then, more than 15 components of the infrastructure that protect the bases—radar, missile-defense and communications systems—appeared damaged, the Journal’s analysis found.”
“After an uneasy ceasefire took hold in early April, satellite imagery showed little new damage to bases.
Administration officials touted the damage the U.S. had inflicted on Iran. “You can dig out for now, but you can’t reconstitute,” Hegseth said, addressing Iran’s leaders at an April 16 press briefing. In early June, Secretary of State Marco Rubio told senators, “Well, the war is over now.”
Behind the public confidence, the military was moving troops off bases. Even before the campaign started, the Pentagon had already shifted troops out of harm’s way. Hegseth told Congress on April 29 that the U.S. had moved 7,500 troops “off of the X”—away from known bases—at the start of the campaign.
Iranian attacks forced the U.S. to move even more troops out of the danger zone, including largely evacuating from Camp Buehring and Camp Arifjan in Kuwait, U.S. officials said.”
“When the ceasefire collapsed on July 7, Iran focused its fire west, to bases hundreds of miles farther from its borders. Through the war’s six-month mark, the Journal found damage from at least 11 separate attacks, five of them in Jordan. The Gulf installations neighboring Iran that had borne the brunt of earlier strikes now only saw sporadic damage.
Within days of the deadly July 17 strike at Muwaffaq Salti, the Journal found damage at three other installations to buildings that current and former U.S. servicemembers said resembled base housing. That same week, U.S. officials privately expressed worry about Iran targeting troops where they sleep.”
“Iran was also hitting smaller buildings, one sign of the precision that has increasingly alarmed U.S. officials. Structures damaged after the ceasefire collapsed were less than half of the size of the ones hit earlier, the Journal found. Base housing—often converted shipping containers or even tents—tends to be small, some of the current and former servicemembers said.
Iran’s own public statements reflected this shift. From July 7 to Aug. 28, Iran claimed more than 40 strikes on U.S. installations, according to a Journal analysis of four Iranian state-affiliated media outlets. More than three-quarters of those claims described specific types of buildings at named installations, compared with less than half earlier in the war—and claims of strikes targeting housing doubled.”
““There’s definitely been an effort by the Iranians to inflict casualties on U.S. forces,” said Brian Carter, an Iran-focused defense analyst at the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative-leaning think tank.
Days after the strike that killed three servicemembers at Muwaffaq Salti, Hegseth continued to call the war a success. Iran had been “completely overmatched and crushed” and was “combat ineffective,” he said on July 21.”
“The Pentagon has disclosed little publicly about the damage. Earlier this month, five Democrats on the Senate Armed Services Committee urged the Defense Department to publicly disclose the estimated cost of damage to U.S. facilities, which was shared in a classified briefing.
On a trip to the Middle East this month, Sen. Chris Murphy (D., Conn.), a member of the Foreign Relations Committee and the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense, was barred from visiting Al Udeid Air Base in Qatar. At least a dozen buildings at the base showed signs of damage, the Journal’s analysis found. U.S. military leaders in the region also refused to brief Murphy, he said.
The Department of Defense has said that Murphy was told before the trip that he would not have access to the base due to travel restrictions in the region.”
“The administration was “withholding information about damages” to “mask the true cost of the war,” Murphy told the Journal.
Iran’s strike patterns could help the Pentagon decide what to keep in the region and where, said Elaine McCusker, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and former acting Pentagon comptroller in the first Trump administration. They reveal how many missiles and drones Iran has left and how quickly it can make more. “The type and number of strikes over time also contains signals about magazine depth,” she said.
Iran has been quickly rebuilding its damaged infrastructure, including missile bases and production facilities, and digging out its buried missile arsenal, while the U.S. has drained its supply of interceptor missiles.
In public, the Pentagon has remained dismissive. “They still have some capabilities, but it’s nowhere near what it was at all,” Hegseth said on Aug. 24.”
One week later—just over six months into the war—Iran hit Camp Titin in Jordan for the first time, the Journal found.

Excerpt From
“How Iran Battered U.S. Bases and Caused Billions in Damage”
Anika Arora Seth, Carl Churchill, John West, Katherine Chui, Lara Seligman, Shelby Holliday
The Wall Street Journal
https://apple.news/ArQxY14PtSZeanZU7La5rOw
This material may be protected by copyright.
Excerpt From
“

U.S. Warns Gulf of Possible Short, Intense Renewal of Iran War After Midterms — The Wall Street Journal

There are signs that American, Israeli militaries preparing potential strikes to muscle Tehran to negotiating table

https://apple.news/PAQu320pP5CHaCRMF86n4dO

OP posts:
Newbutoldfather · 31/10/2026 08:32

@RedTagAlan ,

‘Also, he has not offered the Iranian Government any sort of immunity if they step down. He could say for example, step down, just give us the people who ordered the firing on the protestors. (At which point Iran could say "you already killed them"), and we can arrange a new constitution etc,’

I don’t think any of the above is relevant. Trump has long ago given up regime change as an objective.

‘For the Iranian government, this is existential. Fight to the death or die. And yet Iran has been consistently clear. Let's talk sanctions and frozen assets, then we can talk nukes.’

That is a chicken and egg, and why we will almost certainly have another round of fighting. There is no way Iran is going to be put into a better position than it was before talking about nukes.

‘And as has been mentioned before, the Uranium is Irans biggest chip ( as well as the SoH). So why give that up for nothing in return.’

I think that is where the West (not just the U.S) would tend to disagree. Nuclear weapons are a bridge too far for us. They are not a subject for negotiation; Iran has to unilaterally give up (or dilute) the enriched uranium. There is no question that even Trump would be more than happy to release assets and ease sanctions if Iran gave up the Uranium. He is very transactional.

I guess it is a question of trust (and logic). What do the Americans really want? A non hostile Iran and lower gas prices. They have no desire to invade Iran or really force regime change.

I guess the lack of trust on both sides is why we are going to get another round of fighting.

Twiglets1 · 31/10/2026 08:42

You're right @Newbutoldfather nuclear weapons are a non negotiable issue. This issue matters more to Trump (and of course Israel) than anything else.

It is something Iran will ultimately end up conceding on (in my opinion I should add) in exchange for financial incentives.

OnePeppyFatball · 31/10/2026 08:46

I read in Haaretz I think that at least 3 gulf states are not prepared to conform with any of the US latest plans to attack, and won’t allow it from their bases or allow air space. We shall see.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 31/10/2026 08:58

OnePeppyFatball · 31/10/2026 08:46

I read in Haaretz I think that at least 3 gulf states are not prepared to conform with any of the US latest plans to attack, and won’t allow it from their bases or allow air space. We shall see.

I've read that one senior Gulf official said they “would not be surprised” if some Gulf countries opposed the use of American military bases on their territory to launch the attacks.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/report-us-warns-gulf-allies-of-possible-iran-strikes-as-early-as-november-4/