Despite your vile and inarticulate language to me, a person you have just called a dick and a conspiracy theorist, all because I refuse to answer a question you’ve purposefully misrep’ed in a way that is very harmful to Israelis, I will answer this because I care about the hostages and for the benefit of anyone else who will have read your purposefully misrep’ed question.
Your behaviour is incredibly poor. You’re not welcome to engage with me again.
Possibly, Shani may have died after she was taken hostage - she was reported to have been on life support in a Gaza hospital and died later in Gaza as a result of her injuries at hands of Hamas. Some have also said she was already dead.
Of the hostages kidnapped and killed, the only evidence I have seen so far are two articles today in this thread where the IDF claim Hamas had killed 6 people. I have also said I’m in no position to doubt that. But I have also seen it claimed it was friendly fire. Which is the info I had prior to those posts. I’ve seen footage of the IDF killing other Israeli hostages who had escaped. I saw reports just a month after the kidnapping that the Bibas family had been killed in a shelling attack and the same goes other hostages, dying in shelling attacks. Except for Mr Lifschitz who died of a heart condition - no doubt made worse from the stress of being kidnapped and living under shelled attack.
Of the hostages that have been killed, if there is evidence of whether they were killed by Hamas or IDF, I’ll read it/accept it, if reputable. But one can’t take either the IDF’s or Hamas’s word for it. They’re both lie.
But I do ask myself why Hamas would kill some and keep some alive, when their alive state is much more valuable for negotiation. The hostages know.
Anyway, don’t contact me again.