Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

Christmas presents are getting ridiculous in DH’s family

73 replies

Glimsy · Today 16:31

DH’s sister has suggested we all agree on how much we’re spending on the children this year so it’s fair but I think the amount she’s suggested is a bit ridiculous tbh.

We have 2 DC, 8 and 4. We normally do a main present each, a few smaller bits and stocking fillers and that’s plenty. They get things from grandparents as well and never seem to be short of anything. I’ve never really added up exactly what we spend but probably around £250ish each all in? Sometimes more depending what they’ve asked for.

DH’s family have always been big on Christmas. His mum buys loads for the DC and SIL is the same with hers. It’s always been a bit of a competition over who has the most to open although nobody would admit that. SIL has now suggested we spend £500 per child so they all have roughly the same amount of presents and nobody feels left out. I honestly thought she meant a couple of hundred when she first said it.

We can afford it but I don’t really want to spend £1000 on presents just because we’ve been given a figure to stick to. There’s stuff the DC want but not £500 worth and I don’t want to just buy random crap to make the pile look bigger. We’ve already got the main presents sorted anyway.

She said the children are getting older now and notice things more and it can be a bit unfair when one has loads to open and the others don’t. MIL has also said she thinks it’s nice when the cousins have roughly the same so they can all enjoy Christmas together. I don’t know if that’s aimed at us or not but it’s started to feel like we’re being told what to spend.

DH thinks we should just ignore it and buy what we were going to buy anyway. He said it’s not our job to make sure the other children have the same amount and if they want to spend that much that’s up to them. I do agree with him but I can see SIL getting funny about it if we don’t go along with it.

Would you just say we’re not doing a set budget and leave it at that? I don’t want it turning into a whole thing over Christmas but £500 each seems mad to me.

OP posts:
TY78910 · Today 16:32

£500 per child collectively or pp????
if the latter then they’re bonkers!
I spend roughly £30 on all the kids in the family, probably the same as you on my own

FlyByHere · Today 16:33

Are you all staying in the same house on Christmas Eve? If not then it really doesn’t matter. If you are I kind of see where she is coming from but still seems a bit controlling.

LostNFoundSV · Today 16:34

Ignore SIL, your DH has the right idea.

greenheetah · Today 16:35

SIL doesn’t get to dictate how your family spends its money. She’s nuts!

FlyByHere · Today 16:36

Also number of presents is not the same as total value and at 8 and 4 the number of presents would be what they would notice. But only if the kids are opening the presents from their own parents and stockings at the same time.

Namechangeforthis88 · Today 16:36

Suggest SIL reduces her budget to match yours. She'll say no. You say well there we are then, this isn't going to work.

If she's concerned about it her kids can open some of their's at their house, just do the exchange obeswhen you're together.

Offleyhoo · Today 16:37

You do you! Some years kids need or would like more expensive things like a laptop for uni or whatever, and some years not. Definitely do what suits you. Also you might spend out more on something needed mid year rather than buying something expensive at Christmas for the sake of it.

Sparkletastic · Today 16:38

Ignore
Ideally have Christmas in your own home and avoid mass present opening pressure.

Topseyt123 · Today 16:39

As your DH said, just ignore it and do your own/usual thing. Say nothing about it.

SIL surely won't know exactly how much you spend unless you actually tell her anyway.

If SIL does pick up on it somehow and asks (hopefully unlikely) then just tell her that you don't have a budget of £500 per child so have worked to the budget you do have. Tell her that you can't (and won't) be dictated to. Simple as that.

SethAndReubenTooSendGumboots · Today 16:39

Are they trying to dictate how much YOU spend on your OWN kids? Is she having a laugh??

Pobblewob · Today 16:42

Your DH is right.

Wanttobeok · Today 16:42

Are you all going to be together Christmas morning?

We sometimes go away for Christmas.

We have 1 Dc and my brother has 3 dc

Obviously we spend more on our son as he's an only compared to what each of their children gets spent on them.

We have tried to keep it fair by agreeing to a number of presents for each child (this includes stockings) rather than an amount as that would never work and is a daft suggestion frankly.

So I think last time we said 20 presents each - for context a lip balm would count as one of the presents, but so could a new phone.

Could be a compromise?

DS does get bigger/tech presents because he's older and our budget is bigger but my SIL is brilliant at getting bargains and knowing what her kids will love. To my knowledge none of their children have ever been disappointed.

If you're not spending Xmas morning together tell her to sod off!

Examkit · Today 16:43

Her brother, who knows her a damn sight better than you, has advised that she’s ignored.

So listen to him, ignore him, crack on.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:45

Be honest you don't want to spend that much or have it spent on your family. Then get on with your own limits.

Examkit · Today 16:47

we don’t go along with it.

yes, I assumed as such

Hatty65 · Today 16:47

You laugh. Loudly.

And say, 'Sadly Gemma we can't afford to spend £500 on our children. Or on anyone's else's. But you do you, lovey'. Give her a kind smile and a pat.

And then you put it out your head and continue with whatever kind of Christmas you like.

Ponderingwindow · Today 16:49

I want to be able to select my presents for my child without worrying about balancing with cousins. This is one of the reasons I insist we do the morning at home on our own. We agree on a level for the family exchange later in the day so when the children open gifts from other families they are balanced.

Absobeautely · Today 16:52

Sounds like a great way to raise jealous, grabby, entitled people, obsessed with price and consumer product tat.

Her brother needs to reply to her pathetic demand. Just laugh at her.

Williteverrainagain · Today 16:56

Absobeautely · Today 16:52

Sounds like a great way to raise jealous, grabby, entitled people, obsessed with price and consumer product tat.

Her brother needs to reply to her pathetic demand. Just laugh at her.

Edited

Agree with this

Dontcallmescarface · Today 17:02

" Oh Lucy you are hilarious, for a minute there I actually believed you were telling me how much I can spend on my own kids presents. I know you're not because that would just be silly". <Walk away chuckling>.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Today 17:08

If MIL is so keen on the idea, let her spend her money on your dc then.

Both she and your SIL are being ridiculous. Children do not tot up all the price tags on their presents to check that the same amount of money was spent on them as everyone else. They are thrilled to receive the things they asked for and wanted, plus a couple of stocking filler surprises.

If they continue to insist, then what a good reason for you to stay at home with your own family on Christmas Day, and see them another time.

TheGrimSmile · Today 17:08

A 4 year old will not know the price of things. They will care about the quantity of things to open and the size of each present when wrapped. Just ignore your sil.

OhHobnobs · Today 17:10

Thisnis bonkers.

What can you afford for your kids?
What do your kids want?

Do you also have to buy for nieces/nephews? Instigate a secret santa!

mindutopia · Today 17:18

But why does she care if she spends £500 on each of her children and you and Dh spend £250 and yours are thrilled with their lovely gifts?

It would be one thing if she only had £50 per child and was struggling. Why is she getting herself all twisted that she spends more money than you?

Unless someone got a new iPhone even my teen wouldn’t notice or care about the difference in gifts between £250 and £500. £50 and £500, yes. Your SIL sounds quite insecure. Yes, just ignore her.

ReadingSoManyThreads · Today 17:23

Her children are going to end up as spoilt, entitled brats.