Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

Christmas presents are getting ridiculous in DH’s family

73 replies

Glimsy · Today 16:31

DH’s sister has suggested we all agree on how much we’re spending on the children this year so it’s fair but I think the amount she’s suggested is a bit ridiculous tbh.

We have 2 DC, 8 and 4. We normally do a main present each, a few smaller bits and stocking fillers and that’s plenty. They get things from grandparents as well and never seem to be short of anything. I’ve never really added up exactly what we spend but probably around £250ish each all in? Sometimes more depending what they’ve asked for.

DH’s family have always been big on Christmas. His mum buys loads for the DC and SIL is the same with hers. It’s always been a bit of a competition over who has the most to open although nobody would admit that. SIL has now suggested we spend £500 per child so they all have roughly the same amount of presents and nobody feels left out. I honestly thought she meant a couple of hundred when she first said it.

We can afford it but I don’t really want to spend £1000 on presents just because we’ve been given a figure to stick to. There’s stuff the DC want but not £500 worth and I don’t want to just buy random crap to make the pile look bigger. We’ve already got the main presents sorted anyway.

She said the children are getting older now and notice things more and it can be a bit unfair when one has loads to open and the others don’t. MIL has also said she thinks it’s nice when the cousins have roughly the same so they can all enjoy Christmas together. I don’t know if that’s aimed at us or not but it’s started to feel like we’re being told what to spend.

DH thinks we should just ignore it and buy what we were going to buy anyway. He said it’s not our job to make sure the other children have the same amount and if they want to spend that much that’s up to them. I do agree with him but I can see SIL getting funny about it if we don’t go along with it.

Would you just say we’re not doing a set budget and leave it at that? I don’t want it turning into a whole thing over Christmas but £500 each seems mad to me.

OP posts:
PullTheBricksDown · Today 17:25

TheGrimSmile · Today 17:08

A 4 year old will not know the price of things. They will care about the quantity of things to open and the size of each present when wrapped. Just ignore your sil.

This, it's more the amount of opening that they'll notice - so, is one child still opening things for twenty minutes after all the others have finished? @Wanttobeok has a good system.

Plus as others have said, depends if you're all together on Christmas morning? Is this year going to be the first time you'll have done that?

ItsNotLoveActually · Today 17:26

I'm struggling to understand your s-i-l's issue. So, she spends more on her kids than you do and she's worried about it - rather than thinking she should spend less on hers, she thinks you should spend more?
You/DH needs to tell her that you're happy with the what you spend on your own kids and the kids have never mentioned to you that her kids get more. Obviously she may come back with comments the kids shared with hers (you got more than me) which prompted her suggestion......

BePeachNewt · Today 17:30

You have to make clear to them that you are not going to spend another £500 just for the sake of it, and if they are so concerned about ‘the cousins’ not having exactly the same amount of presents to open, you simply won’t be able to spend Christmas together - or at least, not the present opening part of the day. Either that or they are free to make up the shortfall for your DC, seeing as they think you are depriving them.

Examkit · Today 17:31

PullTheBricksDown · Today 17:25

This, it's more the amount of opening that they'll notice - so, is one child still opening things for twenty minutes after all the others have finished? @Wanttobeok has a good system.

Plus as others have said, depends if you're all together on Christmas morning? Is this year going to be the first time you'll have done that?

Mind wouldn’t even notice how many others got (unless significant!). Too busy and focussed on their own pile

MrsRupert · Today 17:32

Shes batshit, its none of her business how much you spend or what you buy for your children.
Has she given you an amount you must spend on a gift for her children from you ?

Great that DH is on the same page as you. Id reply to her - 'That's not going to work for us. WE will decide what is appropriate amount spend on OUR children' or 'Dont be so ridiculous'

Shinyandnew1 · Today 17:32

‘No, SIL-we won’t be doing that. Best we don’t see you on Christmas Day if you think that’s going to cause any awkwardness with the kids!’

canklesmctacotits · Today 17:37

She wants you to spend a certain amount on stuff for your own children….so she doesn’t feel guilty (not like anyone’s making her feel guilty apart from herself and MIL) about how much she spends on hers?

Ask her if this is really what she’s suggesting, and when she answers just let it sit quietly between you. If she doesn’t get it, ask her why your children and you should be actors in her managing her own feelings about herself.

Or do as your DH suggests and just ignore her.

JoshLymanSwagger · Today 17:39

Your SIL is 🦇💩

Do your own thing and ignore her. If she gets uppity, that's for your DH to deal with.

Chilly80 · Today 17:40

I take it you'll all be together for opening presents?
I much prefer doing that just our family.
Family presents can be opened together.

ReyRey12 · Today 17:48

I was expecting this to be one of those where SIL can't afford to buy as much and was going to ask your kids not to open their tablet, ps5, switch and bike in front of her children.

But she wants you to spend £1000 on your own children's Christmas presents? That is so weird. Have your children made comments or has soemone else pointed out she buys too much and needs you to normalise it? That is so weird.

Everleigh13 · Today 17:55

It is bonkers. It’s not up to anybody else how much you spend on presents. I wouldn’t do it.

Calamitousness · Today 17:55

I would laugh and say but I’ve spent £1000 on each of mine. You’ll need to double your budget. Then don’t. Do whatever you like and say well I’ve spent the money on a holiday for later in the year and that’s part of their Xmas present etc. or just laugh and say clearly you were joking as she must have been as well with her ridiculous suggestion. But whatever you do. Deffo increase it hugely and watch her back down. She’s an arse. Since when do kids need to match. They are largely unaware of cost. They want what they want and that’s it.

Salviania · Today 17:57

We could afford to spend many thousands in presents but we spend around £200 per child. They don't even need what we are buying them, anything else would be pure pointless consumerism. There's no way I'd spend more just so it matched the cousins.

JLou08 · Today 18:01

I never calculated what my presents were worth and compared it to what others had when I was growing up. I don't think my DC ever did either. Just buy what you want and what you think they will be happy with. Buying extra just to reach the same budget as someone else is ridiculous. I'd just ignore any further comments or questions from th in-laws.

WimbyAce · Today 18:13

Sounds like hers are going to get more anyway so I don't understand what the issue is?

Thegirlwhowent · Today 18:19

FlyByHere · Today 16:33

Are you all staying in the same house on Christmas Eve? If not then it really doesn’t matter. If you are I kind of see where she is coming from but still seems a bit controlling.

Even if they're all together, it's a ridiculous suggestion. Children learn early on that not all families are the same and they can't always have what others have. Ignore her.

Bobbybobbins · Today 18:23

Yanbu that is a huge amount of money

MeridianB · Today 18:25

It’s nuts. She’s nuts. Totally OTT. Ignore her.

MMUmum · Today 18:26

Glimsy · Today 16:31

DH’s sister has suggested we all agree on how much we’re spending on the children this year so it’s fair but I think the amount she’s suggested is a bit ridiculous tbh.

We have 2 DC, 8 and 4. We normally do a main present each, a few smaller bits and stocking fillers and that’s plenty. They get things from grandparents as well and never seem to be short of anything. I’ve never really added up exactly what we spend but probably around £250ish each all in? Sometimes more depending what they’ve asked for.

DH’s family have always been big on Christmas. His mum buys loads for the DC and SIL is the same with hers. It’s always been a bit of a competition over who has the most to open although nobody would admit that. SIL has now suggested we spend £500 per child so they all have roughly the same amount of presents and nobody feels left out. I honestly thought she meant a couple of hundred when she first said it.

We can afford it but I don’t really want to spend £1000 on presents just because we’ve been given a figure to stick to. There’s stuff the DC want but not £500 worth and I don’t want to just buy random crap to make the pile look bigger. We’ve already got the main presents sorted anyway.

She said the children are getting older now and notice things more and it can be a bit unfair when one has loads to open and the others don’t. MIL has also said she thinks it’s nice when the cousins have roughly the same so they can all enjoy Christmas together. I don’t know if that’s aimed at us or not but it’s started to feel like we’re being told what to spend.

DH thinks we should just ignore it and buy what we were going to buy anyway. He said it’s not our job to make sure the other children have the same amount and if they want to spend that much that’s up to them. I do agree with him but I can see SIL getting funny about it if we don’t go along with it.

Would you just say we’re not doing a set budget and leave it at that? I don’t want it turning into a whole thing over Christmas but £500 each seems mad to me.

Nobody can tell you how much to spend on your own children surely? Nor for that matter whether you spend £250 on one big gift or lots of little ones. Just do as you wish

Frustrateddiva · Today 18:30

Do you all spend Christmas morning in one house and open the presents all together??

Examkit · Today 18:31

Frustrateddiva · Today 18:30

Do you all spend Christmas morning in one house and open the presents all together??

I bet that’s joyous if they do!

InessaMou · Today 18:40

Glimsy · Today 16:31

DH’s sister has suggested we all agree on how much we’re spending on the children this year so it’s fair but I think the amount she’s suggested is a bit ridiculous tbh.

We have 2 DC, 8 and 4. We normally do a main present each, a few smaller bits and stocking fillers and that’s plenty. They get things from grandparents as well and never seem to be short of anything. I’ve never really added up exactly what we spend but probably around £250ish each all in? Sometimes more depending what they’ve asked for.

DH’s family have always been big on Christmas. His mum buys loads for the DC and SIL is the same with hers. It’s always been a bit of a competition over who has the most to open although nobody would admit that. SIL has now suggested we spend £500 per child so they all have roughly the same amount of presents and nobody feels left out. I honestly thought she meant a couple of hundred when she first said it.

We can afford it but I don’t really want to spend £1000 on presents just because we’ve been given a figure to stick to. There’s stuff the DC want but not £500 worth and I don’t want to just buy random crap to make the pile look bigger. We’ve already got the main presents sorted anyway.

She said the children are getting older now and notice things more and it can be a bit unfair when one has loads to open and the others don’t. MIL has also said she thinks it’s nice when the cousins have roughly the same so they can all enjoy Christmas together. I don’t know if that’s aimed at us or not but it’s started to feel like we’re being told what to spend.

DH thinks we should just ignore it and buy what we were going to buy anyway. He said it’s not our job to make sure the other children have the same amount and if they want to spend that much that’s up to them. I do agree with him but I can see SIL getting funny about it if we don’t go along with it.

Would you just say we’re not doing a set budget and leave it at that? I don’t want it turning into a whole thing over Christmas but £500 each seems mad to me.

Well, the amount of money one spends on gifts isn't an indicative of equality in the amount of gifts people get. A person can choose to buy 500 £1 gifts or 1 gift that costs £500. If she's really worried about some children getting more than others, she should have specified an X number of gifts each child gets - not the total value, as, as I mentioned, that can be administered in a number of ways that still means children get an unequal amount of gifts.

Anyway, I wouldn't entertain her suggestion. She can't control what other people choose to do with their money, she can only make decisions about her own finances.

mysittingduck · Today 18:42

Say no; if there is going to be a limit, you all have to agree it. Suggest 200 or whatever.

OneNewEagle · Today 18:47

You spend what you feel is best on your children.

if you buy main presents for nieces nephews etc £25 gets a great toy or £10 will get you a lovely book and a choc bar. Either are perfect. I would not have someone telling me what to spend.

Bellie710 · Today 18:55

Depending on the age of the kids it is hard to know that spending the same amount would result in the same amount of presents. My kids are all teenagers now and everything they want is much more expensive therefore less presents, when they were under 10 you could spend £200 and have 5 times as many presents as they have now? I would suggest to SIL that she worries about her kids and you will sort yours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread