Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

Christmas presents are getting ridiculous in DH’s family

73 replies

Glimsy · Today 16:31

DH’s sister has suggested we all agree on how much we’re spending on the children this year so it’s fair but I think the amount she’s suggested is a bit ridiculous tbh.

We have 2 DC, 8 and 4. We normally do a main present each, a few smaller bits and stocking fillers and that’s plenty. They get things from grandparents as well and never seem to be short of anything. I’ve never really added up exactly what we spend but probably around £250ish each all in? Sometimes more depending what they’ve asked for.

DH’s family have always been big on Christmas. His mum buys loads for the DC and SIL is the same with hers. It’s always been a bit of a competition over who has the most to open although nobody would admit that. SIL has now suggested we spend £500 per child so they all have roughly the same amount of presents and nobody feels left out. I honestly thought she meant a couple of hundred when she first said it.

We can afford it but I don’t really want to spend £1000 on presents just because we’ve been given a figure to stick to. There’s stuff the DC want but not £500 worth and I don’t want to just buy random crap to make the pile look bigger. We’ve already got the main presents sorted anyway.

She said the children are getting older now and notice things more and it can be a bit unfair when one has loads to open and the others don’t. MIL has also said she thinks it’s nice when the cousins have roughly the same so they can all enjoy Christmas together. I don’t know if that’s aimed at us or not but it’s started to feel like we’re being told what to spend.

DH thinks we should just ignore it and buy what we were going to buy anyway. He said it’s not our job to make sure the other children have the same amount and if they want to spend that much that’s up to them. I do agree with him but I can see SIL getting funny about it if we don’t go along with it.

Would you just say we’re not doing a set budget and leave it at that? I don’t want it turning into a whole thing over Christmas but £500 each seems mad to me.

OP posts:
baftaagain · Today 19:00

TY78910 · Today 16:32

£500 per child collectively or pp????
if the latter then they’re bonkers!
I spend roughly £30 on all the kids in the family, probably the same as you on my own

Awful, the message is "stuff makes you happy"

baftaagain · Today 19:02

Examkit · Today 18:31

I bet that’s joyous if they do!

Joyous? a greed fest.

Baby Jesus would be proud of you.

IWantMoreCats · Today 19:04

Do your own thing. Kids need to learn that families do things differently. If they would whunge because Johnny has three more gifts or had £70 more spent on them, then they are heading for spilt brat behaviour.

TY78910 · Today 19:08

baftaagain · Today 19:02

Joyous? a greed fest.

Baby Jesus would be proud of you.

if the three kings brought baby Jesus one ounce of gold and 50g each of frankincense and myrrh, the combined value today would be roughly £2,725. That’s a greedy little baby.

NorthantsNewbie · Today 19:09

If we are staying with family for Christmas then we do agree in advance how many gifts will be opened in advance, normally reciprocal gifts from everyone there on the day and one or two from parents. But that’s more because we want the cousins to spend time with each other, not knee deep in wrapping paper ignoring each other. Your SIL is bonkers.

CompleteMere · Today 19:09

I’d “misunderstand” and assume she meant £500 per child between you. “Great idea! We are aiming at about £100 each for ours so if you and MIL can top up to £500 that’d be amazing. Let us know much have you spent on yours already and we can make sure it evens out.”

ElizabethGreen · Today 19:15

and THIS is reason 248 of why I don't like Christmas!

LBVAmanda · Today 19:16

I'm guessing you and your husband are financially dependent on your sister, so she gets to dictate how you spend, yes?
There's no other reason you'd even give her nonsense a second thought.

Batsuke1 · Today 19:17

£500 each is an awful lot for young kids. I would spend that on a teenager because they usually want fewer higher value presents, but I certainly wouldn’t have spent that on a 4
and 8yo. I would just say you’re going to do your own thing.

When we did Christmas at the IL’s when their cousin was there, we kept some presents back. His parents didn’t want to do lots of gifts as they lived abroad so didn’t want the hassle of transporting them back. So we opened some before we went on Christmas morning and took just a couple with us to open together.

Examkit · Today 19:17

ElizabethGreen · Today 19:15

and THIS is reason 248 of why I don't like Christmas!

But this is a very very weird family.

I just can’t even imagine anyone in my family saying this and IF they did - no one would agree with them, and in fact everyone would be utterly perplexed because there is no one in my family who would ever even think this let alone suggest it.

dippy567 · Today 19:21

I'd say, we don't want to spend that much as were trying to reduce not increase the amount of crap we have in the house!

Then maybe talk to your kids and say cousins might get more but it is what it is. My kids are teens and tbh apart ftom a few bits they're happy with money - i reckon we usually spend £150-200 per child. More than that seems excessive to me! The odd year they've got a phone or shared play station which is more but thats an exception.

Allswellthatendswelll · Today 19:22

I have a 5 year old and I can not even fathom how I would spend £500 on him! I know this is classic mumsnet performative under spending but we honestly spend £10/15 on nieces and nephews (as reciprocally agreed with their parents) and about £100 on our own kids. I suggest you do presents separately. Small kids will get overwhelmed by the volume of presents anyway.

I wouldn't ask your inlaws to match it. I'd say if they really want to spend the money can it go in their ISAs!

Daisymail · Today 19:30

Absolutely batshit that you would even consider allowing SIL / MIL to dictate the amount you spend on presents. Put some boundaries in place now, otherwise this will go downhill very quickly.

Examkit · Today 19:38

Daisymail · Today 19:30

Absolutely batshit that you would even consider allowing SIL / MIL to dictate the amount you spend on presents. Put some boundaries in place now, otherwise this will go downhill very quickly.

Where would Mumsnet be if we didn’t have families whereby one member suggests something so farcically insane and all other family members either agree with them or meekly say nothing.

oobedobe · Today 19:44

Ignoring this suggestion is perfectly fine or a sensible half-way meet could be you spend what you want on gifts - then (if money is no issue), get your kids $200 savings bond (or similar) to top up to her amount. This could be viewed as petty though :)

Your kids are still young so your budget sounds more than enough. Christmas gets expensive really fast once they want gaming consoles, laptops, driving lessons, phones etc so I would hold off spending more now.

rosagarten · Today 19:49

Glimsy · Today 16:31

DH’s sister has suggested we all agree on how much we’re spending on the children this year so it’s fair but I think the amount she’s suggested is a bit ridiculous tbh.

We have 2 DC, 8 and 4. We normally do a main present each, a few smaller bits and stocking fillers and that’s plenty. They get things from grandparents as well and never seem to be short of anything. I’ve never really added up exactly what we spend but probably around £250ish each all in? Sometimes more depending what they’ve asked for.

DH’s family have always been big on Christmas. His mum buys loads for the DC and SIL is the same with hers. It’s always been a bit of a competition over who has the most to open although nobody would admit that. SIL has now suggested we spend £500 per child so they all have roughly the same amount of presents and nobody feels left out. I honestly thought she meant a couple of hundred when she first said it.

We can afford it but I don’t really want to spend £1000 on presents just because we’ve been given a figure to stick to. There’s stuff the DC want but not £500 worth and I don’t want to just buy random crap to make the pile look bigger. We’ve already got the main presents sorted anyway.

She said the children are getting older now and notice things more and it can be a bit unfair when one has loads to open and the others don’t. MIL has also said she thinks it’s nice when the cousins have roughly the same so they can all enjoy Christmas together. I don’t know if that’s aimed at us or not but it’s started to feel like we’re being told what to spend.

DH thinks we should just ignore it and buy what we were going to buy anyway. He said it’s not our job to make sure the other children have the same amount and if they want to spend that much that’s up to them. I do agree with him but I can see SIL getting funny about it if we don’t go along with it.

Would you just say we’re not doing a set budget and leave it at that? I don’t want it turning into a whole thing over Christmas but £500 each seems mad to me.

Let her "get funny". Your husband is absolutely right and you'll feel much happier and your kids will thrive if you have confidence in whatever it is your would usually do.

Summerfridays · Today 20:02

I do agree with him but I can see SIL getting funny about it if we don’t go along with it.

You're a mother of 2 children. An actual adult. Do you really think you should care about someone getting 'funny' about a minor issue? Honestly just stop. It's none of your sil business what you choose to buy for your own dc

Holidaymodeon · Today 20:05

I would just laugh at her, what a bonkers proposition , even if you’re all mega minted , who is she to dictate what other people spend?

Gettingbysomehow · Today 20:07

That is absolutely absurd. Nobody spends more than £30 to £50 in our family. Christmas isn't about spending vast amounts of money. I find that quite obscene.

MyArtfulGreySloth · Today 20:20

Why is this even a topic of conversation with your sil? It’s none of her bloody business.

runnersfeet · Today 20:35

What exactly is how much you spend on your own kids to do with your SIL? Tell her to butt out

Boreded · Today 20:43

If you spend less I don’t get her problem. If she wants yours to get as much as hers she can buy them some extras…if you raise your children right then they won’t care that they have less and they’ll appreciate what they do have.

I remember one of my son’s friends saying ‘you got an Xbox and a PlayStation?’ (Birthday for one Christmas for the other) I reminded him that he and his brother got one each, and they share, but mine doesn’t have siblings so the only way they can play together on both is if I buy him both. He just said ‘Oh yeah’ and nothing more was said…kids understand that sometimes there’s an imbalance.

The whole group would come to my house because ‘your mum is rich and you have everything’ - I wasn’t, I worked in a contact centre (and it was funny because one of the friends did have very wealthy parents) but I had to buy him the things they shared with siblings or he would be left out, and a bonus was my home became the place they all hung out…so there’s also that benefit to me spending more. I still spent less than their parents did overall but they didn’t realise 🤷‍♀️

Boreded · Today 20:48

Bellie710 · Today 18:55

Depending on the age of the kids it is hard to know that spending the same amount would result in the same amount of presents. My kids are all teenagers now and everything they want is much more expensive therefore less presents, when they were under 10 you could spend £200 and have 5 times as many presents as they have now? I would suggest to SIL that she worries about her kids and you will sort yours.

The petty person in me would spend the extra 200 buying tonnes of little gifts, £1 chocolates, socks, colouring books etc…make sure they had 5 times the number of presents, and the bigger the better. Then when she is mad about the size just go back to spending what I want 😆

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread