Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Family unrest and hosting Christmas

76 replies

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 20:46

My husband and I have alternated Christmas Day between my family and my in-laws for the last 12 years. Every other year, we’ve travelled around 50 minutes to spend Christmas with my in-laws.
We now have two children, aged 4 and 2, and this is the first year I’ve asked if we could host Christmas at ours, even though it’s technically my in-laws’ year. The reason being that I’d really love the children to wake up at home, enjoy their presents and spend the day playing with them without having to worry about travelling or being anywhere. With the journey being over 50 minutes, we’d also have to stay overnight at my in-laws with the children and factor in my daughter’s nap.
My in-laws haven’t taken the suggestion particularly well, and there seems to be a different reason each time as to why it won’t work.
Firstly, my SIL and BIL are going on holiday on Boxing Day and want to spend Christmas Day finishing their packing (they’re 24!). When I suggested they could finish packing and then come to ours for dinner, the next reason was that it’s my BIL’s first Christmas away from his own family and he wants to enjoy it at my in-laws’.
When I explained our situation with the children, the next reason was that they couldn’t leave their three dogs for the day (despite regularly leaving them for around six hours when they’re at work).
Then it was that my other SIL, who has two teenage children, didn’t want to drive them 50 minutes to ours for dinner.
I’ve invited everyone and said they’re all welcome to stay overnight if they want to. I just feel like I’m being made to feel unreasonable, as though I’m asking everyone to make a huge sacrifice by travelling 50 minutes, when we’ve been doing exactly that every other Christmas for the last 12 years (including four Christmases with children).
I completely appreciate that it’s my in-laws’ year, but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask for one Christmas at home now that we have young children, particularly when I’ve offered to host everyone.

The years where we spend Christmas Day with one family we then spend Boxing Day with the other- therefore we’ll be seeing my family this Boxing Day. Which includes my brothers and their wives who each have 2 more children.

Am I being unreasonable, or are my in-laws being a bit unfair?

OP posts:
shellyleppard · 15/11/2026 20:49

Stay home and enjoy your time with your young family. Sod running around the place trying to see everyone.
Let them come to you....if they don't want to enjoy the peace and quiet

PashaMinaMio · 15/11/2026 20:53

There comes a time as family life evolves to break the pattern such as you describe.

You have been kind enough to invite others to yours, it’s now up to them to accept or not.

Bite the bullet and carry on. Stay strong.
Your plan is great. Enjoy every minute.

floofydoofy · 15/11/2026 20:55

You're not being unfair. Do I think all of you are being a bit silly about saying you'd have to stay overnight if you drive 50 minutes? Yes... BUT Christmas Day with young children really is best if they can stay in their own home and I personally wouldn't want to be driving anywhere on xmas day.

It will be a lovely Christmas at home regardless of if In-laws decide to come or not. 4 and 2 are such lovely ages for Christmas but everything can quickly go tits up when naps and bedtimes are messed about with!

cuddlebear · 15/11/2026 20:55

Once I had DC I never went anywhere else for Christmas.

hopingforthemillion · 15/11/2026 20:55

First poster nailed it.

Roastiesarethebestbit · 15/11/2026 20:56

You are being unreasonable expecting all them to change their usual plans and come to you. But you are not being unreasonable deciding that you want to stay at home . It doesn’t need to be drama. You decide to stay At home. You invite them. They stick to their usual routine and you see them sometime later.

NapsForTheWin · 15/11/2026 20:57

Eventually we got to the point where we just said, "You know where we are. You are welcome to join us for Christmas." Apparently doing anything other than let the mothers on both sides have it at their place was 'too hard'.

Rhaidimiddim · 15/11/2026 21:00

The alternate-years arrangement was one made in the past, to suit the way things were in the past.

Tines have moved on. You now have two small children and are absolutely right that, now that they're old enough to understand the gig, would rather hunker down at home and enjoy their Santa haul in the comfort of their own home.

It is time for the old arrangement to morph into a new one. Stay home this year, give everyone time to accept that times and Christmas traditions are changing; and think about how you want to play it next year.

Enjoy your Christmas at home with your little ones, and don't let anyone guilt you - it is a magical time when the DCs are young, and the grandparent - both sides - had their time. Now is yours.

Happy Christmas!

Typos

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 21:01

Roastiesarethebestbit · 15/11/2026 20:56

You are being unreasonable expecting all them to change their usual plans and come to you. But you are not being unreasonable deciding that you want to stay at home . It doesn’t need to be drama. You decide to stay At home. You invite them. They stick to their usual routine and you see them sometime later.

Thanks for commenting ❤️ I just want to add that I’m not expecting them to change their plans at all and I appreciate they would have to if they want to come. I’ve said It’s more than ok if they don’t come but I’ve been made to feel that I’m ruining their Christmas- maybe I need to stop worrying about upsetting people

OP posts:
Shalalaa · 15/11/2026 21:02

You aren’t being unreasonable to want to stay home. Do what works for you!!

I would say though, that I visit family 2.5 hours away and another 6 hours away that require overnights.

my brother is 50 mins away and that is a day visit for us. We went to his for lunch last Christmas (wanted the kids to sleep in their own beds and didn’t want to pack all the presents in the car). We went for lunch and came back in pjs at 7pm. We had a 6 month 2 yo and 5 yo. I think 50 mins is fine for kids your age I don’t think it’s a deal breaker!!

Iloveeverycat · 15/11/2026 21:04

Why don't you do a complete change and say you want to spend Christmas day with just you and your your family for once. I do this every year.

Pumpkindoodles · 15/11/2026 21:07

You don’t need to ‘ask’ for a Christmas at home. You just tell people that you’re staying home this year and you’d love them to join but no worries if not. Your in laws don’t need to agree, or be reasoned with or give you permission and YANBU
your parents get a Christmas, your in laws get a Christmas, when is your Christmas to do what you want to do? Do what you want. Every year in fact. If they don’t want to travel to you that’s their choice. If someone else is busy packing for a holiday, or not wanting to drive 50mins or whatever else then you know their priorities and maybe you should adjust yours accordingly too.

Rhaidimiddim · 15/11/2026 21:07

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 21:01

Thanks for commenting ❤️ I just want to add that I’m not expecting them to change their plans at all and I appreciate they would have to if they want to come. I’ve said It’s more than ok if they don’t come but I’ve been made to feel that I’m ruining their Christmas- maybe I need to stop worrying about upsetting people

You are not ruining their Christmas, they are ruining it for themselves by not being prepared to adapt as the shape of their family changes.

Teado · 15/11/2026 21:11

You’re overthinking this OP. Stay home, tell everyone they’re welcome, job done.

Snoken · 15/11/2026 21:12

It’s fine to opt out of Christmas with family as long as you do the same thing when it’s your side of the family too. I think you are making it all a bit too big of a deal when you say you’d have to stay over though when they are only 50 minutes away.

They have valid reasons not to come to yours and you have valid reasons for not coming to them. Keeping Christmas at the ILs house seems to work best for the majority so it will just be a smaller and quieter Christmas for you without the GPs, aunts/uncles, cousins.

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 21:14

Shalalaa · 15/11/2026 21:02

You aren’t being unreasonable to want to stay home. Do what works for you!!

I would say though, that I visit family 2.5 hours away and another 6 hours away that require overnights.

my brother is 50 mins away and that is a day visit for us. We went to his for lunch last Christmas (wanted the kids to sleep in their own beds and didn’t want to pack all the presents in the car). We went for lunch and came back in pjs at 7pm. We had a 6 month 2 yo and 5 yo. I think 50 mins is fine for kids your age I don’t think it’s a deal breaker!!

Thanks ❤️ I didn’t explain that bit very well- we don’t have to stay over at all, and you’re right 50mins is nothing. We would be expected to stay over, so I do just need to take everyones advice and bite the bullet!

OP posts:
MrsKeats · 15/11/2026 21:16

I am in a Christmas drama myself.
Stay at home op. Your children will enjoy it and it will be much less hassle.

blondieminx · 15/11/2026 21:16

YANBU to want to stay at home with your young children at Christmas.

journeys of less than an hour or so are not massively long ..but I realise the in laws are a long way past “sleep maths” and “danger naps” and may not appreciate just how much the journey will wreck your usual routine. And of course, they aren’t going to be the ones to deal with the aftermath , are they?!

Aiming4Optimistic · 15/11/2026 21:24

They are not the boss of you - you don't need 'permission' and they aren't owed Christmas with you travelling to them every other year. It's your Christmas too and if you don't want to travel then don't! They can either drive to yours, or not.
You are a grown up and it's time to prioritise what suits you and your kids. It's always a bad idea to get stuck in an arrangement where alternating has been set in stone. At some point you have to do things differently, for your own comfort and that of your dc.

Rhaidimiddim · 15/11/2026 21:33

Aiming4Optimistic · 15/11/2026 21:24

They are not the boss of you - you don't need 'permission' and they aren't owed Christmas with you travelling to them every other year. It's your Christmas too and if you don't want to travel then don't! They can either drive to yours, or not.
You are a grown up and it's time to prioritise what suits you and your kids. It's always a bad idea to get stuck in an arrangement where alternating has been set in stone. At some point you have to do things differently, for your own comfort and that of your dc.

This!

With Christmas bells and tinsel.

OneNewEagle · 15/11/2026 21:41

Don’t worry your in laws are busy with your SILs. So you just stay at home with your kids this year.

start doing one year with them, one year with your side, two years at home etc. (I’d stay at home every year personally and just drive over Boxing Day or Christmas Eve for an hour for a mince pie.)

Daisymail · 15/11/2026 21:47

Aiming4Optimistic · 15/11/2026 21:24

They are not the boss of you - you don't need 'permission' and they aren't owed Christmas with you travelling to them every other year. It's your Christmas too and if you don't want to travel then don't! They can either drive to yours, or not.
You are a grown up and it's time to prioritise what suits you and your kids. It's always a bad idea to get stuck in an arrangement where alternating has been set in stone. At some point you have to do things differently, for your own comfort and that of your dc.

Absolutely this. Traipsing around to different family members every year would be my idea of Christmas hell.

theresnolimits · 15/11/2026 21:48

For me, it would be 10x the work having them over. Especially if they had to stay.

Just have presents at home first thing, go over to them about 12. Put the kids in their pjs and leave about 7. 50 mins is nothing - my DPs lived 90 mins away and this is what we would do. Enjoy Boxing Day playing with the new toys. This really isn’t difficult.

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · 15/11/2026 21:52

Time to p
ut dc first..anyone who moans can sod off.

Adults Christmas wants dont trump dc having a good day .

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 21:52

theresnolimits · 15/11/2026 21:48

For me, it would be 10x the work having them over. Especially if they had to stay.

Just have presents at home first thing, go over to them about 12. Put the kids in their pjs and leave about 7. 50 mins is nothing - my DPs lived 90 mins away and this is what we would do. Enjoy Boxing Day playing with the new toys. This really isn’t difficult.

thanks ❤️ It’s not about what’s more hassle for me, it’s about the kids not having to do anything but enjoy their toys in their home and not have to be anywhere else. This is the point I’m trying to make to my in laws.

OP posts: