Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Family unrest and hosting Christmas

77 replies

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 20:46

My husband and I have alternated Christmas Day between my family and my in-laws for the last 12 years. Every other year, we’ve travelled around 50 minutes to spend Christmas with my in-laws.
We now have two children, aged 4 and 2, and this is the first year I’ve asked if we could host Christmas at ours, even though it’s technically my in-laws’ year. The reason being that I’d really love the children to wake up at home, enjoy their presents and spend the day playing with them without having to worry about travelling or being anywhere. With the journey being over 50 minutes, we’d also have to stay overnight at my in-laws with the children and factor in my daughter’s nap.
My in-laws haven’t taken the suggestion particularly well, and there seems to be a different reason each time as to why it won’t work.
Firstly, my SIL and BIL are going on holiday on Boxing Day and want to spend Christmas Day finishing their packing (they’re 24!). When I suggested they could finish packing and then come to ours for dinner, the next reason was that it’s my BIL’s first Christmas away from his own family and he wants to enjoy it at my in-laws’.
When I explained our situation with the children, the next reason was that they couldn’t leave their three dogs for the day (despite regularly leaving them for around six hours when they’re at work).
Then it was that my other SIL, who has two teenage children, didn’t want to drive them 50 minutes to ours for dinner.
I’ve invited everyone and said they’re all welcome to stay overnight if they want to. I just feel like I’m being made to feel unreasonable, as though I’m asking everyone to make a huge sacrifice by travelling 50 minutes, when we’ve been doing exactly that every other Christmas for the last 12 years (including four Christmases with children).
I completely appreciate that it’s my in-laws’ year, but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask for one Christmas at home now that we have young children, particularly when I’ve offered to host everyone.

The years where we spend Christmas Day with one family we then spend Boxing Day with the other- therefore we’ll be seeing my family this Boxing Day. Which includes my brothers and their wives who each have 2 more children.

Am I being unreasonable, or are my in-laws being a bit unfair?

OP posts:
Venice93 · 16/11/2026 05:56

When ours were small we said Christmas always at ours; everyone welcome. Also hosted Boxing Day buffet. Sometimes we had big groups, sometimes just us. So glad I did that. Our parents too old to host now. We visit family between 27th and new year.

Celer · 16/11/2026 06:03

You haven’t said how your husband feels.

You don’t owe anyone else Christmas but you are hopefully together on this decision.

LaAranaPequenita · 16/11/2026 06:12

When you are a child, Christmas is absolutely magical and you and your DH will create lovely memories for both you and them. Right now your DC's memories are going to be of Santa visiting them somewhere else, and being dragged about on Christmas Day.

You need to make a decision about what is best for you and your DC. If that is being at home on Christmas Day then you need to tell them this is what you are doing and do it, otherwise you are going to be doing this for the next 20 years.

As soon as I had DC that was it, I was having Christmas in my own house. Everyone is welcome if they want to come over. I have my own traditions and Christmas Day is their favourite day of the year according to my teen DC.

They are making you feel like you have ruined Christmas by not going there, but actually they are the ones ruining Christmas for your small DC. I'm so over steadying boats that other people rock.

importantupdate · 16/11/2026 06:40

It’s not only not unreasonable to “ask” for one Christmas at home, it’s not unreasonable to do EVERY Christmas at home now you have kids. What’s more, you don’t need to ask permission to do it. You are fully entitled to do whatever you want at Christmas. If they want to get offended, let em.

Newname26 · 16/11/2026 06:54

Then it was that my other SIL, who has two teenage children, didn’t want to drive them 50 minutes to ours for dinner.

Op this jumped out at me, the teens don't want to travel but the family expect your tiny kids to do it.

Your little boy is just 4, absolutely full to the brim of Christmas magic, enjoy it.
Those are very short years when they are old enough to really know what Santa is all about before they become old enough to doubt it.

Just say from now on your having Christmas at home, whoever wants to come is welcome.

Rosiethegrey · 16/11/2026 06:56

I don't think you're unreasonable to want to stay at home. However if you do end up hosting everyone for Christmas day you'll be busy and your time for playing/spending time with your kids will be limited. It happened to me last year and I felt sad at the end of the day that I barely saw my kids as we were busy cooking/tidying/hosting. You might get to spend more tine with them at your PIL's or else just keep xmas day for the 4 of you.

ACCMC · 16/11/2026 07:03

Anneleesa · 16/11/2026 04:10

Have you only just suggested this now? This is the kind of idea I would be floating in August! By mid November, the Christmas Dinner Providers have often ordered their turkeys and Christmas plans are set. It’s really late to be changing customary plans, especially if you are dealing with a matriarch.

Honestly? This year I’d probably cave and say “ok, we will get to your place at around 12pm on Christmas Day so the kids can have Santa at home and play with their toys in the morning.”

This is completely normal.

It is not unreasonable to want Christmas in your own home but I think mid November is very late to be expecting MIL to mentally adjust.

Also - good idea to practice your hospitality skills on your own family first. It’s absolutely exhausting Christmas-hosting ten people (especially if you invite some to stay!) . Your Christmas Day will feel like a marathon, honestly . Save it for next year!

Thanks ❤️ no, we actually told them March time I think so they were aware but when I brought it up a few weeks ago that’s when the excuses started. @watchingthishtread My husband feels exactly the same and has made it clear. He did say to them yesterday that it’s at ours and if they want to come they can but if not then he’s not going to beg.

OP posts:
ACCMC · 16/11/2026 07:04

Celer · 16/11/2026 06:03

You haven’t said how your husband feels.

You don’t owe anyone else Christmas but you are hopefully together on this decision.

He feels exactly the same as me and voiced this as well.

OP posts:
ACCMC · 16/11/2026 07:07

HettyTagliatelli · 16/11/2026 04:20

It’s fine to want to stay at home, but unfair of you to do it for the first time on your in laws year where they have benn expecting you to go to them. Do it next year when it affects your own family seeing as it’s you that wants it.

You are making a big deal out of a 50 minute drive when it’s nothing really. 50 minutes is not a long drive or enough that you have to stay over at your in laws. You could bravely do both there and back in the same day. Or just stay over one of the nights.

Thanks, I wasn’t clear about the 50 mins. I don’t care about the 50 min drive and they expect us to stay over. All I care about is the kids getting to be at home and not have to go anywhere. The reason we decided it this year is it’s the first year my son properly understand Christmas and we’ve finished our renovation and have the room for everyone else

OP posts:
Ethelspagetti · 16/11/2026 07:11

Husband needs to Message them saying, we are staying home for Christmas to make it easier with the children. You are welcome to join us for Christmas dinner. If you want to join us then please let us know by x of December, so we can plan and shop for groceries. If we don’t hear anything past this date then we will assume that you’re not coming.

AFigureWalks · 16/11/2026 07:18

Tell, don’t ask. Things change. It’s not up for debate.

WeDid2 · 16/11/2026 07:37

there is nothing wrong with not wanting to travel -I think though you have left it late in the year to say let’s have it at yours instead. Just stay home this year they can still have it at theirs.

ACCMC · 16/11/2026 07:44

WeDid2 · 16/11/2026 07:37

there is nothing wrong with not wanting to travel -I think though you have left it late in the year to say let’s have it at yours instead. Just stay home this year they can still have it at theirs.

Thanks, we did bring it earlier in the year. This is the result of me reminding them and asking what everyone wants for their Christmas meat 🤣

OP posts:
Newname26 · 16/11/2026 07:51

Well if they don't want to travel and you don't want to travel then 🤷
You all just need to accept Christmas is changing and evolving. I think lots of families things change when the next generation come along.

Lotusina · 16/11/2026 08:20

ACCMC · 16/11/2026 07:44

Thanks, we did bring it earlier in the year. This is the result of me reminding them and asking what everyone wants for their Christmas meat 🤣

So they all agreed in March?

Ally886 · 16/11/2026 08:39

Totally not the question but this year we will leave my family on boxing day, to drive 2 and a half hours to my in laws to see them then drive back that evening. I don't think that's a huge effort.

We drove 55 minutes to the Chinese last week and didn't need to stay the night. 😆

In all seriousness though OP, your in-laws sound a right bunch of wet blankets not able to adjust their plans for one year.

Spend this year just you, DH and the children and they can play with their toys at home, won't do any harm for one year

Screamingabdabz · 16/11/2026 08:43

Anneleesa · 16/11/2026 04:10

Have you only just suggested this now? This is the kind of idea I would be floating in August! By mid November, the Christmas Dinner Providers have often ordered their turkeys and Christmas plans are set. It’s really late to be changing customary plans, especially if you are dealing with a matriarch.

Honestly? This year I’d probably cave and say “ok, we will get to your place at around 12pm on Christmas Day so the kids can have Santa at home and play with their toys in the morning.”

This is completely normal.

It is not unreasonable to want Christmas in your own home but I think mid November is very late to be expecting MIL to mentally adjust.

Also - good idea to practice your hospitality skills on your own family first. It’s absolutely exhausting Christmas-hosting ten people (especially if you invite some to stay!) . Your Christmas Day will feel like a marathon, honestly . Save it for next year!

What a load of cobblers. 🙄

“Mentally adjust”? Fuck me.

LaAranaPequenita · 16/11/2026 08:55

People like this need to be treated like they’re throwing a toddler tantrum.

“As said in March, we are starting to have Christmas at our house as the children are now older. You are very welcome to join us. Please let us know by xxxxx so we can order the turkey.

What’s that Margaret….. you can’t do this and that?

Oh OK, that’s a shame. Anyone want another cup of tea?

Oh, Margaret, sorry to hear your Christmas is ruined. As I said, you’re welcome at our house. I’m sure you’ll still have a lovely time anyway. Has anyone been watching Blue Planet? Isn’t it amazing?”

Ignore the emotional blackmail. This worked brilliantly on my MIL. It showed her that she was wasn’t getting anywhere with me.

Your choices are;

Create gorgeous memories with your small kids,
or
Create memories of being upset and resentful at your in-laws.

You have to do the same with your side.

I’m glad that Christmas is a hill I’m prepared to die on when it comes to extended family. Your children’s childhoods will flash before your eyes. Don’t give away the best bits.

ACCMC · 16/11/2026 08:56

Lotusina · 16/11/2026 08:20

So they all agreed in March?

Yeah all agreed in March.y MIL says she remembers it but my FIL doesn’t 🤣 they were supposed to mention it to my SILs but this didn’t happen. One live with them and the other is there most days.

OP posts:
StencilCupChair · 16/11/2026 09:08

When we were children we had Christmas Eve with one set of Grandparents, Christmas Day just us at home no visitors. then Boxing Day with another set of Grandparents.

When children come along then the dynamic changes. It doesn't matter that you are "expected" to stay over you can do what you want as an adult. It doesn't matter if it upsets anyone, let them be upset. Your children deserve to wake up in their own house Christmas day morning and you as parents get to enjoy all your hard work. I wouldn't share that with anyone. My parents certainly didn't expect to be at my house for that either as my Mum had set the tradition for us as children.

Stop seeing Christmas Day as the only day to see people. When children are little it is best to try to spread it out, so start the tradition this year. Tell them this is what we are doing. Stop offering to host. Have Christmas Day to yourselves. People always say this could be X's last Christmas but it isn't always old people who die. So think about if you realised your last Christmas with someone was actually last year. How pissed would you be that you didn't do what you wanted?

Rainbow1901 · 16/11/2026 10:02

Have Christmas your way. You have given the invite out to family who may or may not want to change their plans. That's okay - just tell them it's fine and to enjoy their Christmas. Then have fun with your children and enjoy yourselves.

Hoppinggreen · 16/11/2026 10:06

You have invted them, they can come or not but they can't tell you what to do
Hopefully DH has your back
We used to run ourself ragged trying to see/make everytone happy and once we had DC we just stopped
We still saw everyone at some point and eventually everyone got over themselves and we had lovely chilled Christmases at home

TorroFerney · 16/11/2026 10:36

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 21:01

Thanks for commenting ❤️ I just want to add that I’m not expecting them to change their plans at all and I appreciate they would have to if they want to come. I’ve said It’s more than ok if they don’t come but I’ve been made to feel that I’m ruining their Christmas- maybe I need to stop worrying about upsetting people

I think I’d reframe this, they can’t make you feel anything, you are creating the feelings yourself. You’ve an internal niggle that what you are doing is wrong/unreadinable and that’s why their comments are getting to you.

its not wrong by the way, doing what you want to do is never wrong ( you aren’t hurting anyone else are you). So as others have said, “not discussing this any further, we are at home and will feed anyone who comes, let me know by x date”. Stop discussing and offering compromises, by doing this you are suggesting this is something to be negotiated.

Cherrysoup · 16/11/2026 12:07

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 21:01

Thanks for commenting ❤️ I just want to add that I’m not expecting them to change their plans at all and I appreciate they would have to if they want to come. I’ve said It’s more than ok if they don’t come but I’ve been made to feel that I’m ruining their Christmas- maybe I need to stop worrying about upsetting people

Exactly. It’s an invitation, not a summons. They can choose to come or not, but at the age your dc are now, I’d suggest that you stick to your guns. Children would probably far prefer not to be dragged round to relatives and have to leave toys behind. Time to make your own traditions, just as your in-laws did. I’m assuming your dp is backing you.

mindutopia · 16/11/2026 18:55

They don’t have to come to yours. That’s totally fine. See them Christmas Eve or sometime after Boxing Day. Have a lovely Christmas at home. Your family on Boxing Day. We long since stopped seeing family on Christmas. We see them Christmas Eve or Boxing Day. It works fine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread