Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Family unrest and hosting Christmas

77 replies

ACCMC · 15/11/2026 20:46

My husband and I have alternated Christmas Day between my family and my in-laws for the last 12 years. Every other year, we’ve travelled around 50 minutes to spend Christmas with my in-laws.
We now have two children, aged 4 and 2, and this is the first year I’ve asked if we could host Christmas at ours, even though it’s technically my in-laws’ year. The reason being that I’d really love the children to wake up at home, enjoy their presents and spend the day playing with them without having to worry about travelling or being anywhere. With the journey being over 50 minutes, we’d also have to stay overnight at my in-laws with the children and factor in my daughter’s nap.
My in-laws haven’t taken the suggestion particularly well, and there seems to be a different reason each time as to why it won’t work.
Firstly, my SIL and BIL are going on holiday on Boxing Day and want to spend Christmas Day finishing their packing (they’re 24!). When I suggested they could finish packing and then come to ours for dinner, the next reason was that it’s my BIL’s first Christmas away from his own family and he wants to enjoy it at my in-laws’.
When I explained our situation with the children, the next reason was that they couldn’t leave their three dogs for the day (despite regularly leaving them for around six hours when they’re at work).
Then it was that my other SIL, who has two teenage children, didn’t want to drive them 50 minutes to ours for dinner.
I’ve invited everyone and said they’re all welcome to stay overnight if they want to. I just feel like I’m being made to feel unreasonable, as though I’m asking everyone to make a huge sacrifice by travelling 50 minutes, when we’ve been doing exactly that every other Christmas for the last 12 years (including four Christmases with children).
I completely appreciate that it’s my in-laws’ year, but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask for one Christmas at home now that we have young children, particularly when I’ve offered to host everyone.

The years where we spend Christmas Day with one family we then spend Boxing Day with the other- therefore we’ll be seeing my family this Boxing Day. Which includes my brothers and their wives who each have 2 more children.

Am I being unreasonable, or are my in-laws being a bit unfair?

OP posts:
Redragtoabull · 16/11/2026 23:39

I really don't understand others palpable reactions to suggestions of something different at Christmas. You do what is right for your family unit. I wouldn't get het up by anyone's reactions, they'll react how they want to react in the same way you should do what you want to do. People get weird around the holidays, leave them to it. I would not be dragging my children anywhere on Christmas Day. Spend it with them, have Christmas dinner on Christmas Eve or Boxing Day so you can actually enjoy the big day with your unit. Have fun

Goldengirl123 · Yesterday 08:23

What is convenient for you isn’t convenient for everyone else so yes, you AIBU. You could just say that you are staying home this year

New posts on this thread. Refresh page