Please or to access all these features

Child mental health

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

3 year old suspected ASD/PDA and escalating aggression. Feeling really lost

106 replies

charlotte444 · 27/10/2026 09:11

My DS has just turned 3 and we're currently on the ASD pathway. We've suspected autism for a while due to some speech differences, repetitive play, rigidity etc but more recently I'm wondering about PDA too...

He's always been an intense child even as a baby, but the last few months things have got a lot harder. He's become v controlling, lots of telling us where to sit, what to do, not to look at him, don't touch his toys etc. Transitions can be really hard, getting dressed, bath, bedtime etc although sometimes he's absolutely fine with all of these things which is confusing!

The hardest thing atm is the aggression. He can be absolutely lovely and happy one minute and then suddenly furious over something tiny. This morning we had a lovely half an hour playing together, I touched one of his toy cars and he immediately started hitting me, calling me names and throwing toys. He then went into another room and carried on throwing things. Last night he was hitting DH when it was time for bed.

He's also incredibly rigid about his toys and how things are done. It's like we're constantly walking on eggshells and I'm becoming quite anxious around him which I hate admitting.

The confusing thing is nursery say he's generally fine. He e does have some additional support for his speech and sensory needs but they don't see the level of aggression we get at home. He also sleeps pretty well and can manage days out, parks, cafes etc, so it's not like he can't cope with anything.

We also have a new baby (4 months) and things have definitely got worse since he arrived. I know that's a huge change for DS and could be contributing but I'm worried about how things are escalating.

I guess I'm wondering if anyone had a similar child at 3? Particularly the extreme rigidity, controlling behaviour and sudden aggression. Did things improve as they got older? Was it ASD, PDA or something else?

We're trying a lower demand approach but I'm finding it hard to know where to draw the line, especially with the hitting and throwing. I don't want to make things worse by constantly accommodating everything but equally don't want him distressed all the time.

I'm feeling v overwhelmed atm and would really appreciate some positive stories or practical advice from parents who've been through similar. We are looking for specialist support too but it's hard to know where to start.

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 14:13

BertieBotts · 28/10/2026 09:48

The control thing can be wider than PDA - it's quite common for 2-3 year olds to go through a phase of seeking control because by the fact of being little, they don't have very much. Imagine being stuck in an environment where somebody else is dictating almost everything you do and what happens to you. Plus there is a completely normal psychological reaction called "reactance" which happens to everybody whenever we fear that somebody is trying to force us into something, aka take away our autonomy. It's sort of an instant pushback and resistance of the (sometimes perceived) demand.

Silly analogy - but think of reactance being like a sneeze, whereas PDA is more like hayfever. Not every sneeze is hayfever, even if you're sneezing a lot, you might just be in a dusty environment, or have a cold.

It is very common for reactance to occur more during the toddler years and the teenage years - I know the writer Lisa Damour describes this as being when the child's emotional development has leapt forward faster than their social development. So they are very sensitive to perceived threats to their autonomy. I'm not saying your DC does not have PDA or that PDA advice/content won't ever be useful because it absolutely can be. I do find the discussion around autonomy in PDA helpful, I just think it's actually helpful for all children.

When you frame children seeking autonomy rather than control, it helps it feel a bit less like a battle that you need to win, because there are ways for both of you to retain autonomy in most situations, whereas control feels a bit more zero sum - like only one person can be in control, and most people find it feels wrong to let a small child be the one with that control. But IME even very young children can understand that it makes sense for adults to take the lead in certain things, they just want some control, or autonomy, of their own, which is fair.

When transitions are tricky these are some things which can help, you'll probably need to try different things and see what works for your child, because all children are different.

Simply allowing more time, and talking less. Some children esp on the autism spectrum or simply younger children can need more processing time to understand what is happening. They can feel rushed and stressed if you're trying to maintain a faster pace, especially if you're talking a lot trying to get them engaged. Try making a simple statement like "It's time to get dressed." and then waiting 30 seconds. (Count this - it will feel uncomfortably long). Then you will have either brought the clothes with you so you could gesture to them, or you could now say something like "Let's choose your clothes" to indicate that they should follow you to the place you keep their clothes. Again, wait 30 seconds. Really slow down the process and take it step by step, leave space between verbal instruction or announcement, giving them time to process and respond. Also, having allowed 2-3 times the amount of time you think it should need means that you can be less stressed about being late or running out of time.
> Linda K Murphy's Co-Regulation Handbook is great here.

Use "Yes, and" or join them in their world first. Young children often hate being interrupted - everyone hates being interrupted. People on the autistic spectrum particularly can struggle with this because of monotropic focus, which is an especially deep, strong type of focus. You can help by going and sort of joining in their world first, like put your hand on their shoulder rather than calling their name from across the room. Ask to see what they are doing, join in with their play, after a few minutes, let them know what you came to ask of them, perhaps with a countdown or time warning, or find out if there is a good place to stop their activity. Or you can transition using the activity itself, e.g. if they are playing with trains you could announce the last trip of the night and all trains to return to depot.

Get them involved. Let them make choices within the framework of the thing you're doing. Choose clothing, push their own arm through a sleeve, whatever it is. Again Linda Murphy's Coregulation Handbook is great.

Visual schedules. This can work really well at supporting children knowing what to do next especially with routine type activities. It can help to have a full picture of how the day will look, but it can also help just to have small step by steps. Social stories can help a lot too.

Some great advice thank you! X

OP posts:
roaringdragon · 28/10/2026 14:14

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 13:56

Thank you will have a look into the ECHP process and speak to nursery to see if they can help. He currently gets the middle band of inclusion funding so we're one foot in the door I hope!

In terms of the specialists we've done so much including two autism parenting courses but a lot of the strategies with visual timetables and rewards and timers don't seem to work at home as he's so disregulated. Need to be a bit more joined up with all of the professionals we're talking to though! Doing all of it's a full time job alongside everything else isn't it 😂

It is like a full time job.

While it is a good idea to speak to the nursery, don’t be put off if they dismiss the idea of requesting an EHCNA or say to delay. Unfortunately, some do.

An EHCP will help with the joined up approach. An EHCP can include MDTs and professionals working together.

Has DS had his hearing tested?

Are you receiving DLA for DS?

Phineyj · 28/10/2026 14:25

Regarding the hitting (we also had shin kicking and for a while, spitting), I wouldn't say DD learned not to do it so much as gained the self control to be able to stop herself doing it.

You can see she still sometimes wants to!

Believe me she knew it was not OK.

Yawningalldaylong · 28/10/2026 14:37

I’ve been through this, as my sons getting older he is starting to regulate himself a little better. What helped me was to remember it wasn’t bad behaviour, it was anxiety, fear and frustration. Putting myself in my sons shoes it must have been so frightening for him.

Ponderingwindow · 28/10/2026 14:43

It is normal for a child to behave at school and then seem like a completely different child at home. They mask at school, perhaps even seeming like an ideal student, and then have to destress at home where they feel safe.

One thing that helped for us is taking ourselves out of the equation for routines and transitions as much as possible. We used picture charts for anything and everything. It lets the child be in charge without having to remember the steps of something like getting ready for bed. You are still there supervising, but you aren’t telling them to do the next step so there is no reaction.

BertieBotts · 28/10/2026 15:25

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 13:58

Thank you so much Bertie, this is really helpful. I hadn't really considered how much processing goes into answering questions, especially as his language has only really taken off in the last 9 months.

The thing is he often doesn't respond to really simple questions either, like would you like some toast or shall we go to the park, even when they're things he enjoys. So I do wonder if there's an element of demand avoidance too. But I'll definitely think more about how many questions we're asking and try making more observations instead.

I'm just so happy he's verbal now given where we were a year ago! Really appreciate you taking the time to explain all of this x

The Declarative Language book by Linda K Murphy might be good - and Conscious Discipline has some great resources around how to make observational type comments, as well.

Does he ever respond to questions with the same question, or use questions to indicate that he wants something? Those patterns can be a sign of Gestalt language processing, which I found really interesting to read about.

I think you're right that "Would you like toast?" is a simple question BTW so it makes sense to keep an eye on how he does with questions like that, as I suspect they might be the first kind of question to get an answer. But I am no expert in children's language development, I only know what I've read in relatoin to my own DC and random curiosity.

Kevinbaconsrealwife · 28/10/2026 15:47

startthedaywithkindnesd · 27/10/2026 09:36

A 3 year old who is hitting and throwing things needs to realise there are consequences for such behaviour. A sanction that he will immediately equate with the message that hitting and throwing are serious and unacceptable social behaviours. He doesn’t need a name as an excuse for it , nor does he need understanding and negotiation. You are the parent. Positive reinforcement for good behaviour, stickers, soft play etc. Bad behaviour , and this has to be recognised by you as the sort of behaviour that is unacceptable in all environments. must not be tolerated.
So standard autistic behaviour, such as rigidity in play, intensity are not bad behaviours and need understanding and patience. If my autistic son was hitting anyone he would be immediately removed and placed in an area where there is no fun or attention. Until he apologised. Autism is not an excuse for antisocial behaviour. The reason he manages at nursery is because they have rules which he obviously sticks to. You need firm boundaries and also to stick to them

Excellent advice x

Kevinbaconsrealwife · 28/10/2026 15:49

Namechangingagain12345 · 27/10/2026 10:54

My ds has asd and very controlling. At 2-3 he was very aggressive, hitting, throwing and punching walls. Massive meltdowns.

one child with asd is one child with asd. What helped me might not help you so I'm only suggesting for you to try.

visual timetable. We have this one
https://www.createvisualaids.co.uk/collections/bundles/products/the-routine-bundle-for-children
for my son it helps knowing what's next and how his day is going to be. If there was anything different he needed pre-warning. So for example dad was picking up from nursery when it's normally mum. Days that have no fixed routine absolutely still need a visual timetable and anytime he is stressed he will timetable everything. We are now at a stage where he finds a whiteboard and pen easier because he can detail as much as he wants and allows for things we don't have a visual for.

I have a zero tolerance for aggression. Especially towards another person. I would remove him to a boring place usually with supervision. He had a play tent for a while that worked. It wasn't a punishment it was a you need to calm down space. I would hold his arm if he was punching me and say you are allowed to be cross/angry/upset but you are not allowed to hurt people. We did a lot of conversations (when calm not in the moment) about would you like to be hit/kicked/hurt? No? Neither do I/sibling. It's ok to feel things but you need to express that in an appropriate way. He was allowed to punch his pillow. Stamp his feet, scream. (He was non verbal at this point) was not allowed to hurt people.

I had no idea if this was the right approach but it seems to of been effective for us and the violence has significantly reduced.

Brilliant advice x

Kevinbaconsrealwife · 28/10/2026 16:01

DrRuthGalloway · 28/10/2026 10:04

A 3 year old who might be autistic and who has a new sibling is being perfectly rational in finding the new situation they find themselves in has rocked their world.

PDA is rare. In 25 years as an autism specialist (and parent to a now adult with demand avoidant tendencies in an autistic profile) I have seen it twice.

Demand avoidance is common. It's just an avoidant coping style going rampant.

Outside of profound, non verbal autism with learning disabilities, a child hitting people needs to learn that they cannot do this. We do no favours to autistic children by just changing the world around them so they stop feeling difficult feelings as much as possible. We have to teach them that in life you WILL feel difficult feelings, AND you will be ok.

So a 3 year old hits mum because she touched a car? Firm voice, "No hitting. Hitting is not allowed."
He is allowed to be upset that you touched his car. He isn't allowed to smack you because of it.

As his language gets better you can explain more "I can see it bothered you when I touched your car. Hitting is not allowed. Use your words to tell me not to touch it."

Teach him about sharing by playing back and forth games. You chased him, he chases you. You tickle him, he tickles you. You roll a ball to him, he rolls it back to you. Turn taking and sharing, over and over.

I worry about adopting low demand parenting, which definitely has its place and I have used it with my own child, in a 3 year old. 3 year olds NEED to learn how the world works; that we all have big feelings, and we learn to manage them. No 3 year old "regulates" well. They need rules, play, co-regulation.

Name the emotion, normalise it, teach a better way to manage it.
"You are very cross because baby brother is crying loud. Babies do cry, they are still learning and they can't talk like you can because you are a big boy. We can't shout at babies when we are cross. It is scary for them and makes them cry even louder! If baby's crying is too loud, you could go play in the bedroom, or we could put your headphones on? Baby is sleepy so I think soon he will have a nap and then we can play trains together."

This is all very wise x

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 17:55

Yawningalldaylong · 28/10/2026 14:37

I’ve been through this, as my sons getting older he is starting to regulate himself a little better. What helped me was to remember it wasn’t bad behaviour, it was anxiety, fear and frustration. Putting myself in my sons shoes it must have been so frightening for him.

How old is your son now? What things did you do tj help him regulate?

Does he go to school?

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 17:57

roaringdragon · 28/10/2026 14:14

It is like a full time job.

While it is a good idea to speak to the nursery, don’t be put off if they dismiss the idea of requesting an EHCNA or say to delay. Unfortunately, some do.

An EHCP will help with the joined up approach. An EHCP can include MDTs and professionals working together.

Has DS had his hearing tested?

Are you receiving DLA for DS?

Will definitely think about starting the process. It's quite daunting as I've heard it's a lot of work but it'd be good to get the ball rolling.

We don't have DLA but I'm considering applying

OP posts:
Lostatsea10 · 28/10/2026 18:02

I think time has helped and age has helped a lot. He is still physical but not to the extent he was by any means. He is in a school where those behaviours are expected and managed through ‘holds’ when required and that has been game changing for him actually in terms of consistency and feeling safe. Mostly it’s been age, different approach at home and really comprehensive, extensive work at school around emotions and feelings.

His go to reaction for anything is anger when anything is too much- too excited/happy/sad he will tip over into verbal anger and rudeness and then it would lead to physical. The hardest bit is the recognising what demands he can tolerate and when his ‘demand cup’ is full.

It’s not easy and by no means am I wishing your DS’ time away but ageing and specialist provision has been the key.

roaringdragon · 28/10/2026 20:10

Definitely apply for DLA. On their website, Cerebra has a guide you can use. If you want help completing the form, Contact has a form filling you can use.

It is daunting, but you can do this. Start with IPSEA’s model letter for requesting an EHCNA.

Minasama · 28/10/2026 20:20

My daughter was a nightmare at 3. It’s a difficult age.

He needs to learn it is not ok to hit you and that bad behaviour has consequences.

You need to use a stern voice and face and words like “We don’t hit. If you don’t stop hitting right now (insert consequence.)” Maybe it’s as simple as you leaving the room? Maybe it’s him going to his room. Or immediate screen removal etc etc.

Be firm - but use judgement as if he is neurodiverse some of his reactions will be different from other kids.

Tantrumming was easy to resolve for us - I just made sure she was safe and walked out. She literally did it twice before she learned that it got her nowhere.

charlotte444 · 29/10/2026 19:37

Lostatsea10 · 28/10/2026 18:02

I think time has helped and age has helped a lot. He is still physical but not to the extent he was by any means. He is in a school where those behaviours are expected and managed through ‘holds’ when required and that has been game changing for him actually in terms of consistency and feeling safe. Mostly it’s been age, different approach at home and really comprehensive, extensive work at school around emotions and feelings.

His go to reaction for anything is anger when anything is too much- too excited/happy/sad he will tip over into verbal anger and rudeness and then it would lead to physical. The hardest bit is the recognising what demands he can tolerate and when his ‘demand cup’ is full.

It’s not easy and by no means am I wishing your DS’ time away but ageing and specialist provision has been the key.

Thank you

I know this might sound silly and I'm living in a future world but do you still do yearly holidays or has that been too difficult?

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 29/10/2026 19:38

roaringdragon · 28/10/2026 20:10

Definitely apply for DLA. On their website, Cerebra has a guide you can use. If you want help completing the form, Contact has a form filling you can use.

It is daunting, but you can do this. Start with IPSEA’s model letter for requesting an EHCNA.

Thank you xx

OP posts:
Phineyj · 29/10/2026 19:51

There was a great holiday suggestions thread on here for those of us with challenges in that department. I'll try to find it.

Lostatsea10 · 29/10/2026 23:25

charlotte444 · 29/10/2026 19:37

Thank you

I know this might sound silly and I'm living in a future world but do you still do yearly holidays or has that been too difficult?

We do, in fact we’re on one now. We have found what works for us and have done self catering holidays in the UK, mainly caravan parks as they provide the activities/physical elements like swimming that both my boys love. Although he has no learning disabilities he is, in many ways younger than his years so still loves the Parkdean Halloween party today for example.

We did Disneyland Paris a couple of years ago as well and are going to Spain next year for the first time as think he seems ready for it.

They’re hard, behaviours can be magnified as anxiety is magnified and we stick to meals in the caravan etc as eating out is very difficult but we have a lovely time and they’re successful (by our measures). I quickly learnt that I need to not care about other people’s holidays and experiences and not measure us by them but by our own experiences.

My ‘rule/motto’ for him is “we’ll always try and if you (DS) can’t manage it, we can leave and try again”. I’ve been totally consistent with that, we’ve left endless things at home and on holiday and routinely travel to events/holidays in separate cars so he can leave if needed without impacting younger DS. Consequently he knows he can pull the plug at any time and I’ll listen to him but it’s made him feel safe to try. He’s noise sensitive but feels he wants to try fireworks this year so, we’re heading to a display next weekend.

There’s hope, beautiful times ahead and success’ for your boy (and family). It will look so different to what you imagined but it’s there.

NovemberNext · 30/10/2026 07:43

I have two young adult dc with it and they were worse at school than they were at home. They were not aggressive or destructive at three (they were when they were older) but they would refuse to do anything they were told which in a school environment was impossible. School life was horrendous and they went to separate PRUs, no we could not do holidays and even today just a trip to the shops can end in disaster.

There is more advice and support for the condition these days so I would be open to learning what you can and adapting around his needs.

charlotte444 · 30/10/2026 07:56

Lostatsea10 · 29/10/2026 23:25

We do, in fact we’re on one now. We have found what works for us and have done self catering holidays in the UK, mainly caravan parks as they provide the activities/physical elements like swimming that both my boys love. Although he has no learning disabilities he is, in many ways younger than his years so still loves the Parkdean Halloween party today for example.

We did Disneyland Paris a couple of years ago as well and are going to Spain next year for the first time as think he seems ready for it.

They’re hard, behaviours can be magnified as anxiety is magnified and we stick to meals in the caravan etc as eating out is very difficult but we have a lovely time and they’re successful (by our measures). I quickly learnt that I need to not care about other people’s holidays and experiences and not measure us by them but by our own experiences.

My ‘rule/motto’ for him is “we’ll always try and if you (DS) can’t manage it, we can leave and try again”. I’ve been totally consistent with that, we’ve left endless things at home and on holiday and routinely travel to events/holidays in separate cars so he can leave if needed without impacting younger DS. Consequently he knows he can pull the plug at any time and I’ll listen to him but it’s made him feel safe to try. He’s noise sensitive but feels he wants to try fireworks this year so, we’re heading to a display next weekend.

There’s hope, beautiful times ahead and success’ for your boy (and family). It will look so different to what you imagined but it’s there.

Really good advice thank you. I'm glad youve found joy in those moments and I agree it's good to keep trying to ensure their world stays open

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 30/10/2026 07:58

NovemberNext · 30/10/2026 07:43

I have two young adult dc with it and they were worse at school than they were at home. They were not aggressive or destructive at three (they were when they were older) but they would refuse to do anything they were told which in a school environment was impossible. School life was horrendous and they went to separate PRUs, no we could not do holidays and even today just a trip to the shops can end in disaster.

There is more advice and support for the condition these days so I would be open to learning what you can and adapting around his needs.

That sounds really hard. Have you found things that have helped over the years? Did they find the PRUs okay? Are they still violent?

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 30/10/2026 08:02

Thank you for all your tips and advice ❤️ I really appreciate it and makes me feel less alone x

OP posts:
NovemberNext · 30/10/2026 09:30

charlotte444 · 30/10/2026 07:58

That sounds really hard. Have you found things that have helped over the years? Did they find the PRUs okay? Are they still violent?

They both needed masses of support just to get to school and stay there. They spent several years out of school and they hated the PRU. Puberty age was particularly hard.

I can’t say there were strategies that worked except as they got older I severely curtailed what we would do ie keep it simple. I did have some support from carers who would take them out once a week.

Your child is so young I would not panic and also every child is different so he and your family might find your own way. Plus you have one child and I had two who did not get on!

Yawningalldaylong · 30/10/2026 18:39

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 17:55

How old is your son now? What things did you do tj help him regulate?

Does he go to school?

He’s 12 now, we modified our behaviour and tried to limit any difficult situation. Then slowly started to reintroduce difficult situations slowly. When he was aggressive, we learnt to back away and give him space, rather than try to ‘fix’ things. I think the biggest change was simply as he got older his understanding and communication has increased. He was so frustrated at times. He’s still nonverbal with a few words but he understands so much more and he knows we are prepared to support him (we will try and prepare him or leave somewhere if needed). We go at his pace. He’s taught himself to read. He loves school as well now, that helps.