Please or to access all these features

Child mental health

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

3 year old suspected ASD/PDA and escalating aggression. Feeling really lost

106 replies

charlotte444 · 27/10/2026 09:11

My DS has just turned 3 and we're currently on the ASD pathway. We've suspected autism for a while due to some speech differences, repetitive play, rigidity etc but more recently I'm wondering about PDA too...

He's always been an intense child even as a baby, but the last few months things have got a lot harder. He's become v controlling, lots of telling us where to sit, what to do, not to look at him, don't touch his toys etc. Transitions can be really hard, getting dressed, bath, bedtime etc although sometimes he's absolutely fine with all of these things which is confusing!

The hardest thing atm is the aggression. He can be absolutely lovely and happy one minute and then suddenly furious over something tiny. This morning we had a lovely half an hour playing together, I touched one of his toy cars and he immediately started hitting me, calling me names and throwing toys. He then went into another room and carried on throwing things. Last night he was hitting DH when it was time for bed.

He's also incredibly rigid about his toys and how things are done. It's like we're constantly walking on eggshells and I'm becoming quite anxious around him which I hate admitting.

The confusing thing is nursery say he's generally fine. He e does have some additional support for his speech and sensory needs but they don't see the level of aggression we get at home. He also sleeps pretty well and can manage days out, parks, cafes etc, so it's not like he can't cope with anything.

We also have a new baby (4 months) and things have definitely got worse since he arrived. I know that's a huge change for DS and could be contributing but I'm worried about how things are escalating.

I guess I'm wondering if anyone had a similar child at 3? Particularly the extreme rigidity, controlling behaviour and sudden aggression. Did things improve as they got older? Was it ASD, PDA or something else?

We're trying a lower demand approach but I'm finding it hard to know where to draw the line, especially with the hitting and throwing. I don't want to make things worse by constantly accommodating everything but equally don't want him distressed all the time.

I'm feeling v overwhelmed atm and would really appreciate some positive stories or practical advice from parents who've been through similar. We are looking for specialist support too but it's hard to know where to start.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 28/10/2026 09:44

Regarding the violence, there's a useful set of techniques called NVR (non violent resistance). DH and I did some sessions with an online provider. It was probably one of the most useful things we did as it got us on the same page.

There is a taboo about mentioning child to parent violence in my experience and people can react unhelpfully. I suspect it is much more common than people realise.

Lostatsea10 · 28/10/2026 09:46

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 09:33

Thank you - have things gotten easier for you as time has gone on? Does your DC go to school? How have you handled violence if that's been part of the picture

He does go to school now, but it took 3 years of fighting and he’s in a specialist school. He is physically aggressive and always has been. It is much better now and the last 6 months have been huge in terms of progress, though to be clear it’s still present but less so. He has thrived at school with the highly specialist support, scaffolding of strategies and consistency of staff plus a better understanding from me at home and my consistency with low demand and hills to die on/compromise. I’ll be honest though, 3-7 was really really rough and on more than one occasion I sobbed down the phone to professionals telling them he will put me in hospital one day.

It’s much easier now compared to then but I’ll be honest, it’s not easy by any means. It does limit his life but it also limits ours and probably his younger brothers. We work really hard though to make sure that impact is limited and younger brother is also thriving.

Life looks so different from what I thought it would, I still have grief for the what could have been a bit have realised I can’t wallow in that or it will suffocate me. The ‘cost’ of having a complex needs child has been enormous and I choose not to think about it too much as I find that very difficult to process.

BertieBotts · 28/10/2026 09:48

The control thing can be wider than PDA - it's quite common for 2-3 year olds to go through a phase of seeking control because by the fact of being little, they don't have very much. Imagine being stuck in an environment where somebody else is dictating almost everything you do and what happens to you. Plus there is a completely normal psychological reaction called "reactance" which happens to everybody whenever we fear that somebody is trying to force us into something, aka take away our autonomy. It's sort of an instant pushback and resistance of the (sometimes perceived) demand.

Silly analogy - but think of reactance being like a sneeze, whereas PDA is more like hayfever. Not every sneeze is hayfever, even if you're sneezing a lot, you might just be in a dusty environment, or have a cold.

It is very common for reactance to occur more during the toddler years and the teenage years - I know the writer Lisa Damour describes this as being when the child's emotional development has leapt forward faster than their social development. So they are very sensitive to perceived threats to their autonomy. I'm not saying your DC does not have PDA or that PDA advice/content won't ever be useful because it absolutely can be. I do find the discussion around autonomy in PDA helpful, I just think it's actually helpful for all children.

When you frame children seeking autonomy rather than control, it helps it feel a bit less like a battle that you need to win, because there are ways for both of you to retain autonomy in most situations, whereas control feels a bit more zero sum - like only one person can be in control, and most people find it feels wrong to let a small child be the one with that control. But IME even very young children can understand that it makes sense for adults to take the lead in certain things, they just want some control, or autonomy, of their own, which is fair.

When transitions are tricky these are some things which can help, you'll probably need to try different things and see what works for your child, because all children are different.

Simply allowing more time, and talking less. Some children esp on the autism spectrum or simply younger children can need more processing time to understand what is happening. They can feel rushed and stressed if you're trying to maintain a faster pace, especially if you're talking a lot trying to get them engaged. Try making a simple statement like "It's time to get dressed." and then waiting 30 seconds. (Count this - it will feel uncomfortably long). Then you will have either brought the clothes with you so you could gesture to them, or you could now say something like "Let's choose your clothes" to indicate that they should follow you to the place you keep their clothes. Again, wait 30 seconds. Really slow down the process and take it step by step, leave space between verbal instruction or announcement, giving them time to process and respond. Also, having allowed 2-3 times the amount of time you think it should need means that you can be less stressed about being late or running out of time.
> Linda K Murphy's Co-Regulation Handbook is great here.

Use "Yes, and" or join them in their world first. Young children often hate being interrupted - everyone hates being interrupted. People on the autistic spectrum particularly can struggle with this because of monotropic focus, which is an especially deep, strong type of focus. You can help by going and sort of joining in their world first, like put your hand on their shoulder rather than calling their name from across the room. Ask to see what they are doing, join in with their play, after a few minutes, let them know what you came to ask of them, perhaps with a countdown or time warning, or find out if there is a good place to stop their activity. Or you can transition using the activity itself, e.g. if they are playing with trains you could announce the last trip of the night and all trains to return to depot.

Get them involved. Let them make choices within the framework of the thing you're doing. Choose clothing, push their own arm through a sleeve, whatever it is. Again Linda Murphy's Coregulation Handbook is great.

Visual schedules. This can work really well at supporting children knowing what to do next especially with routine type activities. It can help to have a full picture of how the day will look, but it can also help just to have small step by steps. Social stories can help a lot too.

Nightmanagerfan · 28/10/2026 09:53

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 09:24

That sounds v hard for you - I';m glad he's doing so well at school but the weekends sound tricky. COuld you introduce a nanny gradually?

That is amazing advice though, thank you and something we are exploring getting a part-time nanny

We have thought about a nanny but at the moment we don’t have the bandwidth to research and find someone and then manage the introduction. We are in the thick of assessment prep and surviving (we also have a five year old). If my son settles more into school and has more capacity we could potentially look into introducing someone

Phineyj · 28/10/2026 09:54

Oh dear @Lostatsea10 that sounds so difficult! You have done incredibly well although I'm sure it doesn't feel like it.

Ages 3-7 were the hardest here too but the lockdown occurring when we'd just realised we needed professional help was a right nuisance.

Something else I want to add OP is to take care of your relationship. DH and I finally got to a couples' counsellor when DD was about 6 and after a few sessions the counsellor remarked "you've spent ALL the sessions talking about your daughter...:

Phineyj · 28/10/2026 10:00

I use a lot of @BertieBotts 's techniques.

For instance, DD struggles with appetite. I just plonk plates of food near her at regular intervals and try not to talk about it.

School stuff all lives in the same place.

Stationery supplies are on a table.

Keys are on a hook (with an Apple tag because she kept leaving them at the neighbours).

Spares of everything.

Lostatsea10 · 28/10/2026 10:01

Thank you @Phineyj thats very kind and actually reading that back I think it was too negatively phrased and I’m sorry for that @charlotte444. I was trying to recount my experience at the same stage as you and whilst it was and is, incredibly hard it’s not been all doom and gloom and I’m sorry to you that my post didn’t reflect that.

There are lots of beautiful, good bits in your life to come and real moments of magic. It will just look different to what you’d imagined. It won’t all be horrendously hard forever with no joy but it also probably won’t look like you imagined it would be.

I would say at this stage it’s a real trial and error phase which I found makes things worse before it got better. For example, visual cues/timetables as mentioned above are so incredibly effective for many children. For others (as my son) they become a visual cues of the demand and so exacerbate the anxiety.

heedmywords · 28/10/2026 10:03

I have 2 children who have very high demand avoidance. I questioned PDA with both (eldest appeared fairly textbook in many ways) but now I don’t think they have PDA ..just massive amounts of demand avoidance. When I dig deeper I can see their demand avoidance often stems from sensory avoidance, executive function avoidance, anxiety driven avoidance and fear of failure/ low self esteem. Occasionally it’s the demand itself but actually more often than not I can find an alternative reason other than the demand itself. Some of the examples you give could be demand avoidance for many reasons other than the demand itself.
I don’t think you can know at aged 3 and there are many reasons not to pursue a PDA label if you aren’t 100% sure. Many specialist schools will say they can’t meet needs if you say they are ‘PDA’ so you really only want a PDA diagnosis on your EHCP if you don’t think a ‘regular’ ASD specialist school will work. My children attend a specialist school which does cater for demand avoidance (and has a few children diagnosed with PDA but they must be able to cope with some demands). I know of more than 1 parent who has tried to remove wording re PDA from their EHCP to get a school. So in your shoes I would read up, try some low demand approaches to see if they help but I wouldn’t be keen to use ‘PDA’ just yet. I would start the EHCP process. I would also check out all local schools and speak to their Head/SENCo - approaches and understanding can vary considerably. High demand avoidance will often need 1:1 (although not always welcome especially if high masking).

DrRuthGalloway · 28/10/2026 10:04

A 3 year old who might be autistic and who has a new sibling is being perfectly rational in finding the new situation they find themselves in has rocked their world.

PDA is rare. In 25 years as an autism specialist (and parent to a now adult with demand avoidant tendencies in an autistic profile) I have seen it twice.

Demand avoidance is common. It's just an avoidant coping style going rampant.

Outside of profound, non verbal autism with learning disabilities, a child hitting people needs to learn that they cannot do this. We do no favours to autistic children by just changing the world around them so they stop feeling difficult feelings as much as possible. We have to teach them that in life you WILL feel difficult feelings, AND you will be ok.

So a 3 year old hits mum because she touched a car? Firm voice, "No hitting. Hitting is not allowed."
He is allowed to be upset that you touched his car. He isn't allowed to smack you because of it.

As his language gets better you can explain more "I can see it bothered you when I touched your car. Hitting is not allowed. Use your words to tell me not to touch it."

Teach him about sharing by playing back and forth games. You chased him, he chases you. You tickle him, he tickles you. You roll a ball to him, he rolls it back to you. Turn taking and sharing, over and over.

I worry about adopting low demand parenting, which definitely has its place and I have used it with my own child, in a 3 year old. 3 year olds NEED to learn how the world works; that we all have big feelings, and we learn to manage them. No 3 year old "regulates" well. They need rules, play, co-regulation.

Name the emotion, normalise it, teach a better way to manage it.
"You are very cross because baby brother is crying loud. Babies do cry, they are still learning and they can't talk like you can because you are a big boy. We can't shout at babies when we are cross. It is scary for them and makes them cry even louder! If baby's crying is too loud, you could go play in the bedroom, or we could put your headphones on? Baby is sleepy so I think soon he will have a nap and then we can play trains together."

tripleginandtonic · 28/10/2026 10:04

Sounds quite normal, young children can be quite " bossy". However, you can't let the violence slide, and becoming scared of him is a recipe for disaster, particularly now there's a younger siblings in the mix.

GrumpyOleEyeore · 28/10/2026 10:14

Yes I’m in England. If you are spending a lot of money then I would put it into a good ABA provider as that’s a one stop shop - you don’t need all the other professionals the ABA curriculum covers everything. We had EHCP by age 4 with home/centre/nursery ABA and that transferred into mainstream primary - he only went to school parttime it was built up based on his skill level and ability to tolerate that environment. At 3 we paid an ABA consultant to teach us and we were the therapists and it was fairly easy at that age to teach him as we were only concentrating on 6-8 skills and we saw progress very quickly. There is so much fake news about modern ABA I would suggest you go and see a provider - many will let you sit in on sessions (I often give consent for this) and then you can get a sense of whether it will work / is for you. There’s a big difference between a child like mine with classic autism and LD diagnosed at 2 and someone who is highly able and diagnosed as an adult. He is much more receptive to adult direction (and needs it to stay safe). His ABA tutors have been the most caring dedicated people I’ve come across. They have a great rapport with him. In my experience if your child has a lot of rules and rituals and they dominate their life this means they won’t be available to learn anything if they don’t have adults who know how to manage that. They will just spend the day tuned out and the more they are allowed to withdraw into their world of repetitive behaviours and rituals the bigger the aggressive response will be when you interrupt their activities with any demand. DS sort of needs a very consistent level of demands - which do go up and down based on what he can cope with - but if he had a more free learning environment he couldn’t make good choices he just used to flit from activity to activity every few seconds and then end up in a corner reciting the alphabet over and over. He needed adults skilled to interrupt and redirect him. A reward approach worked well for him. When he was small there were alot of awful news stories about adults with autism in long stay hospitals dying or being restrained and I was very aware that could have been his trajectory. I agree 3-7 was tough even with help. Developmentally DS has always been far behind his actual age. A lot of the structure and predictability and adjusting demands is what we do but we also had strategies that stopped the aggression, self harm, destruction of items etc He went to various mainstream and special schools and I’ve never found the expertise the ABA team have elsewhere and he’s never made the same level of progress with other approaches. He’s smart enough to find the loopholes in more relaxed teaching approaches and exploits them so he can avoid any work and withdraw into doing his own thing. I’ve seen qualified teachers sit and read him the same book 20 times over because they don’t want to refuse and cope with an escalation in his behaviour by saying no but obviously he’s not learning anything through them doing that. They were just babysitting or warehousing him not teaching him.

PassTheCranberrySauce · 28/10/2026 10:34

PDA is not in the DSM, and I tend to think ‘spirited and controlling’ ASD-ers are actually AuDHD rather than PDA. It’s an internal struggle between two presentations and medication eases this presentation a lot (when they’re a bit older).

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 11:01

DrRuthGalloway · 28/10/2026 10:04

A 3 year old who might be autistic and who has a new sibling is being perfectly rational in finding the new situation they find themselves in has rocked their world.

PDA is rare. In 25 years as an autism specialist (and parent to a now adult with demand avoidant tendencies in an autistic profile) I have seen it twice.

Demand avoidance is common. It's just an avoidant coping style going rampant.

Outside of profound, non verbal autism with learning disabilities, a child hitting people needs to learn that they cannot do this. We do no favours to autistic children by just changing the world around them so they stop feeling difficult feelings as much as possible. We have to teach them that in life you WILL feel difficult feelings, AND you will be ok.

So a 3 year old hits mum because she touched a car? Firm voice, "No hitting. Hitting is not allowed."
He is allowed to be upset that you touched his car. He isn't allowed to smack you because of it.

As his language gets better you can explain more "I can see it bothered you when I touched your car. Hitting is not allowed. Use your words to tell me not to touch it."

Teach him about sharing by playing back and forth games. You chased him, he chases you. You tickle him, he tickles you. You roll a ball to him, he rolls it back to you. Turn taking and sharing, over and over.

I worry about adopting low demand parenting, which definitely has its place and I have used it with my own child, in a 3 year old. 3 year olds NEED to learn how the world works; that we all have big feelings, and we learn to manage them. No 3 year old "regulates" well. They need rules, play, co-regulation.

Name the emotion, normalise it, teach a better way to manage it.
"You are very cross because baby brother is crying loud. Babies do cry, they are still learning and they can't talk like you can because you are a big boy. We can't shout at babies when we are cross. It is scary for them and makes them cry even louder! If baby's crying is too loud, you could go play in the bedroom, or we could put your headphones on? Baby is sleepy so I think soon he will have a nap and then we can play trains together."

Thank you, I really hope he doesn't have PDA and that it is as rare as you say. I know demand avoidance can be part of autism more generally and I'm really hoping that's what we're seeing.

I think what worries me is that it's not just rigidity or struggling with transitions, but also the controlling behaviour and how quickly he can switch if we ask him to do something he doesn't want to do.

Another thing I've been wondering about is his response to questions. His speech has improved massively in the last 9 months, from barely talking to almost catching up, which is brilliant. But he often won't answer even really simple questions like "how was your day at nursery?", "would you like to do X?" or "which book would you like to read?". He'll either ignore us, nod or say "Mummy choose". I'm wondering whether he experiences even being asked a question as a demand? Or whether this is more likely to be a language processing thing?

It's so hard to unpick what's autism, what's normal three year old behaviour and what might be PDA. I really hope I'm overthinking the latter!

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 11:02

PassTheCranberrySauce · 28/10/2026 10:34

PDA is not in the DSM, and I tend to think ‘spirited and controlling’ ASD-ers are actually AuDHD rather than PDA. It’s an internal struggle between two presentations and medication eases this presentation a lot (when they’re a bit older).

That's what I'm hoping for! Spirited and demand avoidant but without the nervous system disability 😢 fight or flight response

OP posts:
iwonderificould · 28/10/2026 11:12

"You are very cross because baby brother is crying loud. Babies do cry, they are still learning and they can't talk like you can because you are a big boy. We can't shout at babies when we are cross. It is scary for them and makes them cry even louder! If baby's crying is too loud, you could go play in the bedroom, or we could put your headphones on? Baby is sleepy so I think soon he will have a nap and then we can play trains together."

I have (afaik) a totally NT three year old who would never follow all that.

DrRuthGalloway · 28/10/2026 11:28

iwonderificould · 28/10/2026 11:12

"You are very cross because baby brother is crying loud. Babies do cry, they are still learning and they can't talk like you can because you are a big boy. We can't shout at babies when we are cross. It is scary for them and makes them cry even louder! If baby's crying is too loud, you could go play in the bedroom, or we could put your headphones on? Baby is sleepy so I think soon he will have a nap and then we can play trains together."

I have (afaik) a totally NT three year old who would never follow all that.

Which is why I suggested this is the type of script one can use once his language has developed further.

roaringdragon · 28/10/2026 11:38

Yes, I would request an EHCNA now.

Right now it doesn’t so much matter if DS has a PDA profile or not. What matters more is finding strategies that work for you and DS.

If you have been paying for SALT, OT and CP, have they professionals not helped you understand strategies to use? They should have. It shouldn’t be about stand alone sessions.

You could check if Home Start has anyone if your area who can support you.

Not a comment on OP’s DS specifically, but DC who are verbal and don’t have an LD can’t always learn not to hit. Many can, but not all. I agree with @Phineyj, there is a lot of stigma.

HotGrapefruit · 28/10/2026 11:39

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 11:01

Thank you, I really hope he doesn't have PDA and that it is as rare as you say. I know demand avoidance can be part of autism more generally and I'm really hoping that's what we're seeing.

I think what worries me is that it's not just rigidity or struggling with transitions, but also the controlling behaviour and how quickly he can switch if we ask him to do something he doesn't want to do.

Another thing I've been wondering about is his response to questions. His speech has improved massively in the last 9 months, from barely talking to almost catching up, which is brilliant. But he often won't answer even really simple questions like "how was your day at nursery?", "would you like to do X?" or "which book would you like to read?". He'll either ignore us, nod or say "Mummy choose". I'm wondering whether he experiences even being asked a question as a demand? Or whether this is more likely to be a language processing thing?

It's so hard to unpick what's autism, what's normal three year old behaviour and what might be PDA. I really hope I'm overthinking the latter!

I think your expectations are way too high.

> But he often won't answer even really simple questions like "how was your day at nursery?"

This is normal whether he is 3, 14 or my husband. What about "What did you have for lunch? Can you remember? Was it yummy?"

> "which book would you like to read?"

Why not just pick a book? If he doesn't want it, he can tell you. You are giving him too much agency over dull things IMO.

You are in charge!!

HotGrapefruit · 28/10/2026 11:41

It might also be worth saying that my DC HATED choices - and they still do, as adults. They experience choices as overwhelming and stressful. It sounds like you are giving him a lot of choices and 'life admin' that he doesn't need. Making choices for him might be MUCH easier for both of you.

BertieBotts · 28/10/2026 12:30

Another thing I've been wondering about is his response to questions. His speech has improved massively in the last 9 months, from barely talking to almost catching up, which is brilliant. But he often won't answer even really simple questions like "how was your day at nursery?", "would you like to do X?" or "which book would you like to read?". He'll either ignore us, nod or say "Mummy choose". I'm wondering whether he experiences even being asked a question as a demand? Or whether this is more likely to be a language processing thing?

I trained as a language teacher (EFL) and it really made me rethink what I understood as simple vs complex language. How was your day is not a simple question, if you think about it. We think about it as simple, because it's commonly used, but that does not mean that it's a simple thing you're asking him to do.

Consider this: How was your day means you're asking him to 1, recall the events of the day, in its entirety. 2. consider how those events made him feel, and/or rate them, perhaps in comparison to other days. (So, also, recall other days' event summaries). 3. Summarise this down into a single sentence.

Any one of those tasks would be enormous for a 3yo, even with completely typical language processing, and certainly at the end of a nursery session, where he is likely to be still in a moderate-to-high stress state because a transition is ongoing, and where he is also likely to be tired because of all the cognitive processing he has been doing at nursery. Many ND children also struggle with using the toilets at nursery or school so he may also have this discomfort. Best practice IME is quiet, or extremely predictable verbal input after nursery. Perhaps a snack. Allow them to transition back to mum/dad and to home before asking them to produce any language at all.

One of the absolute best things a nursery can do, IME, and you could ask your nursery if they don't already do this, is if the nursery can provide some kind of touchpoint relating to something like an activity which is planned that day, or a daily menu, or just a current theme they are planning activities around. Or if you can pick up any clues like a craft which is sent home which you can admire, if their clothes have paint or mud on them, and so on. Commenting on something you know is likely to have come up can be fantastic for communication, because it gives them a single event to focus on, and if you start just by observing or making more of a declarative statement (e.g. pasta and tomato sauce for lunch today, yummy yum, I do love pasta.) which means they can choose whether to respond or not.

It DOES feel natural to want to ask questions because we tend to be burning with curiosity about school and want to know everything they have been up to.

To come back to "how was your day", in reality when we do ask this question, we're not actually expecting the person to do all of those tasks, although it is much easier for an older (10+) child or adult to do them. What we're really doing is expressing a social convention where there are a few "standard" answers, which basically boil down to:

it was OK (normal day, I'm fine)
it was good, thanks (polite response to stranger)
the thing which was hard before has got easier (continuation from previous discussion)
I'm tired (don't expect much from me)
not great because XYZ is hard right now (I need sympathy and maybe more support)
everything kept going wrong (I need sympathy/have a story to tell)
this really bad/scary/annoying thing happened (I want to tell you about it)
this really exciting/funny thing happened (I want to tell you about it)

So we're really trying to find out - do you need any extra support / space / sympathy this evening, and we might be looking to open up a conversation about interesting or unusual things which happened that day.

What I've found interesting is we've been making more of an effort to have family dinners and we go around the table and ask this question, and it is really helping my 4/5yo (just turned 5) understand what this question is actually about because he is learning that it's more of a social ritual than a literal request. He still can't answer the question if I ask him as soon as I pick him up, but he will happily chat away or rattle off one of the "standard" answers when we go around and ask it at dinner.

charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 13:56

roaringdragon · 28/10/2026 11:38

Yes, I would request an EHCNA now.

Right now it doesn’t so much matter if DS has a PDA profile or not. What matters more is finding strategies that work for you and DS.

If you have been paying for SALT, OT and CP, have they professionals not helped you understand strategies to use? They should have. It shouldn’t be about stand alone sessions.

You could check if Home Start has anyone if your area who can support you.

Not a comment on OP’s DS specifically, but DC who are verbal and don’t have an LD can’t always learn not to hit. Many can, but not all. I agree with @Phineyj, there is a lot of stigma.

Thank you will have a look into the ECHP process and speak to nursery to see if they can help. He currently gets the middle band of inclusion funding so we're one foot in the door I hope!

In terms of the specialists we've done so much including two autism parenting courses but a lot of the strategies with visual timetables and rewards and timers don't seem to work at home as he's so disregulated. Need to be a bit more joined up with all of the professionals we're talking to though! Doing all of it's a full time job alongside everything else isn't it 😂

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 13:58

BertieBotts · 28/10/2026 12:30

Another thing I've been wondering about is his response to questions. His speech has improved massively in the last 9 months, from barely talking to almost catching up, which is brilliant. But he often won't answer even really simple questions like "how was your day at nursery?", "would you like to do X?" or "which book would you like to read?". He'll either ignore us, nod or say "Mummy choose". I'm wondering whether he experiences even being asked a question as a demand? Or whether this is more likely to be a language processing thing?

I trained as a language teacher (EFL) and it really made me rethink what I understood as simple vs complex language. How was your day is not a simple question, if you think about it. We think about it as simple, because it's commonly used, but that does not mean that it's a simple thing you're asking him to do.

Consider this: How was your day means you're asking him to 1, recall the events of the day, in its entirety. 2. consider how those events made him feel, and/or rate them, perhaps in comparison to other days. (So, also, recall other days' event summaries). 3. Summarise this down into a single sentence.

Any one of those tasks would be enormous for a 3yo, even with completely typical language processing, and certainly at the end of a nursery session, where he is likely to be still in a moderate-to-high stress state because a transition is ongoing, and where he is also likely to be tired because of all the cognitive processing he has been doing at nursery. Many ND children also struggle with using the toilets at nursery or school so he may also have this discomfort. Best practice IME is quiet, or extremely predictable verbal input after nursery. Perhaps a snack. Allow them to transition back to mum/dad and to home before asking them to produce any language at all.

One of the absolute best things a nursery can do, IME, and you could ask your nursery if they don't already do this, is if the nursery can provide some kind of touchpoint relating to something like an activity which is planned that day, or a daily menu, or just a current theme they are planning activities around. Or if you can pick up any clues like a craft which is sent home which you can admire, if their clothes have paint or mud on them, and so on. Commenting on something you know is likely to have come up can be fantastic for communication, because it gives them a single event to focus on, and if you start just by observing or making more of a declarative statement (e.g. pasta and tomato sauce for lunch today, yummy yum, I do love pasta.) which means they can choose whether to respond or not.

It DOES feel natural to want to ask questions because we tend to be burning with curiosity about school and want to know everything they have been up to.

To come back to "how was your day", in reality when we do ask this question, we're not actually expecting the person to do all of those tasks, although it is much easier for an older (10+) child or adult to do them. What we're really doing is expressing a social convention where there are a few "standard" answers, which basically boil down to:

it was OK (normal day, I'm fine)
it was good, thanks (polite response to stranger)
the thing which was hard before has got easier (continuation from previous discussion)
I'm tired (don't expect much from me)
not great because XYZ is hard right now (I need sympathy and maybe more support)
everything kept going wrong (I need sympathy/have a story to tell)
this really bad/scary/annoying thing happened (I want to tell you about it)
this really exciting/funny thing happened (I want to tell you about it)

So we're really trying to find out - do you need any extra support / space / sympathy this evening, and we might be looking to open up a conversation about interesting or unusual things which happened that day.

What I've found interesting is we've been making more of an effort to have family dinners and we go around the table and ask this question, and it is really helping my 4/5yo (just turned 5) understand what this question is actually about because he is learning that it's more of a social ritual than a literal request. He still can't answer the question if I ask him as soon as I pick him up, but he will happily chat away or rattle off one of the "standard" answers when we go around and ask it at dinner.

Thank you so much Bertie, this is really helpful. I hadn't really considered how much processing goes into answering questions, especially as his language has only really taken off in the last 9 months.

The thing is he often doesn't respond to really simple questions either, like would you like some toast or shall we go to the park, even when they're things he enjoys. So I do wonder if there's an element of demand avoidance too. But I'll definitely think more about how many questions we're asking and try making more observations instead.

I'm just so happy he's verbal now given where we were a year ago! Really appreciate you taking the time to explain all of this x

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 14:00

heedmywords · 28/10/2026 10:03

I have 2 children who have very high demand avoidance. I questioned PDA with both (eldest appeared fairly textbook in many ways) but now I don’t think they have PDA ..just massive amounts of demand avoidance. When I dig deeper I can see their demand avoidance often stems from sensory avoidance, executive function avoidance, anxiety driven avoidance and fear of failure/ low self esteem. Occasionally it’s the demand itself but actually more often than not I can find an alternative reason other than the demand itself. Some of the examples you give could be demand avoidance for many reasons other than the demand itself.
I don’t think you can know at aged 3 and there are many reasons not to pursue a PDA label if you aren’t 100% sure. Many specialist schools will say they can’t meet needs if you say they are ‘PDA’ so you really only want a PDA diagnosis on your EHCP if you don’t think a ‘regular’ ASD specialist school will work. My children attend a specialist school which does cater for demand avoidance (and has a few children diagnosed with PDA but they must be able to cope with some demands). I know of more than 1 parent who has tried to remove wording re PDA from their EHCP to get a school. So in your shoes I would read up, try some low demand approaches to see if they help but I wouldn’t be keen to use ‘PDA’ just yet. I would start the EHCP process. I would also check out all local schools and speak to their Head/SENCo - approaches and understanding can vary considerably. High demand avoidance will often need 1:1 (although not always welcome especially if high masking).

Good advice thanks so much x

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 14:08

Lostatsea10 · 28/10/2026 09:28

I have a nearly 9 year old with PDA. His official diagnosis is ADHD/ASD with a Demand Avoidant Profile as PDA isn’t in the DSM for a diagnosis. It’s incredibly hard and ultimately what works for my son won’t work for yours in terms of specifics.

I completely understand how difficult it is and how scared of an unknown future you are. As hard as this sounds, you need to try and stop panicking about an unknown future and take each day as it comes and at a time. So much will change in the next few years with starting schools etc and so much is out of your control and panicking doesn’t change that. I’m aware it’s no where near that easy and I’m not pretending it is, but you will drown in it otherwise.

In general terms, follow At Peace Parenting on social media, she’s incredible and will make you feel understood when you’re surrounded by people who don’t get it. If you can, implement low demand parenting, work out what your ‘hills to die on’ are and what you’ll compromise on. Good luck, it’s a long, hard and lonely journey at times but always, always look for the glimmers of magic. They’ll be there and they’ll be the things that keep you getting up each morning.

Thank you so much for sharing, it sounds like you've had such a tough few years. I'm really glad things are improving ❤️ Can I ask what's changed in the last 6 months? Is it mainly the school or has he started to find things easier as he's got older? x

OP posts:
charlotte444 · 28/10/2026 14:09

Phineyj · 28/10/2026 09:44

Regarding the violence, there's a useful set of techniques called NVR (non violent resistance). DH and I did some sessions with an online provider. It was probably one of the most useful things we did as it got us on the same page.

There is a taboo about mentioning child to parent violence in my experience and people can react unhelpfully. I suspect it is much more common than people realise.

Thank you! Will look into this!

OP posts: