Maci, Piper or jayda?

[Sophielaser11]

I love Maci but my husband loves Jayda and Piper. Thoughts?

Do the calling the name out in the supermarket test. Where I live it would be:
Mehseeeeeh or Mace
Pipooooooh
Jaydooooooh

Piper is my favorite and was on my girls list (had 2 boys).

I know a little Macy, she's very cute.

I wouldn't bother with the "chav" test. As if anyone of sound mind would worry about what the names sound like in the local supermarket.

I mean if you were of a decent class, you'll not be doing your own grocery shopping anyway! 😉

Standards? What does that mean? Hating ‘chavy’ poor people. That’s all you get on these name threads.

I read 'Maci' as 'Macky'. They're all fine but I like Piper best.

Awful, awful, and awful.

Piper is my favourite.

Some horrible snobbery on this thread.

I wish there was a like button as on Facebook . . . because I agree, awful.

Sorry they sound really common, like love Island contestant names.

This! 👏🏼

I know 2 Pipers, one is a dog and one is a 12 year old, but she is constantly correcting people who have thought her name was Pippa. (The human Piper, the dog Piper doesn't have this issue.)

I really like the name Piper and am not keen on the other 2. But it does make me think of a dog, sorry!

Piper. I also like Liberty - by the time she's walking no-one'll remember last year's Love Island.

At first I thought this was a joke post but I worry the OP is actually considering these names.
I think they are all awful but Jayda is by far the worst.

Christ ... none of them. Life chances and all that ...

I knew a little Piper; not in the UK. I quite like it. How about Avery, Willow, Harley?

Piper is OK

The other two - hard no.

I prefer Maci spelt as Macy (like Macy Gray or the friend in As Told By Ginger). Piper is nice, like in Charmed. Jayda is ok but, as others have said, it seems a bit more conventional spelt as Jada (like Jada Pinkett Smith). Ahhh I miss the 2000s.

I love the name Piper!
I'd put Macy second and Jayda third :)

Definitely Piper!

If you choose any of those names and spellings for your child, people will, even if this is utterly wrong they still will, apply stereotypes to your child and none of them are positive.

Shaya is better name then Jayda. I know one aged around 40, so its not exactly a new aged name. Though you don't hear it a lot.

I like Piper from your list. It’s a pretty name, a bit different.

I agree that Maci brings pronunciation problems. So I’d go for Macey. I also like the suggestion of Maisie if you don’t mind the hard z sound.

Pick a proper name?

Yep hence people's response to them.

There's a Jada on eastenders