Is Phoebes sister Heidi or Daisy?

[mumofthehs]

Cast your votes?

daisy as i think the other two sound very similar

My vote for Heidi

They both go equally well with Phoebe but Daisy has been a bit overused in the past 15 years so Heidi is my choice

Heidi.

There's loads of little Daisys here, it's a very popular name!

Phoebe sister is Ursula

Prefer Heidi

Daisy is a different genre to Phoebe and Heidi but I'm not sure it goes.

Alexandra, Georgia/ina, Xara, Xanthe, Marina, Beatrice, Gudrun, Celia, Edith, etc, are the sorts of names that go with Phoebe.

Heidi.

Or a different name that doesn’t end with an ie sound.

Crock I came on to say Ursula!
I prefer Heidi

Do you know I thought of Ursula too but also thought it was a step too far if Daisy was in the frame.

Hm neither goes with Phoebe, which is a nice classic grown-up name. Heidi is terribly cutesy. Daisy is ok as a flower name but it’s a bit cutesy too. Daisy is best.

Daisy

Neither (sorry).
You need a name that doesn't end in the same "ee" sound.

Daisy because Heidi is too similar.

However, I always wanted 2 girls called Phoebe and Harriet

Harriet goes.

Heidi

Abigail
Ava
Beth
Ella
Emma
Faye
Grace
Isabel
Laura
Louise
Lyra
Maya
Megan
Sophia
Thea

Alice

I’d say neither too.

Harriet
Jemima
Clara
Florence
Alice
Beatrice
Lucy
Martha

Heidi is great with phoebe. Not so keen on daisy personally, and I don't think it's sophisticated enough to go with Phoebe.

Heidi is sweet. Do people really choose names based on what will 'go' with the sibling? Just let them have their own name!

Daisy

I like Florence and it goes well with Phoebe
I think I'd pick Florence or Alice

Heidi

malope but “sweet* is not something to want for a name, surely. It’s derogatory.

"Sweet" is not derogatory. Patronising, maybe, in some contexts, but not derogatory.

I think Daisy works really well as Phoebe's sister - lovely name. Heidi feels dated (I know several adult Heidis), like it's the wrong generation to go with the modern Phoebe.