Baby is here, still stuck between two names!

[jinglebellmel]

Totally stuck and it's starting to stress me out now! I thought she might look like one or the other once she'd arrived but it's not become any clearer. It will be one of these two so please don't suggest any others!

Imogen (immy) or matilda (mattie).

Imogen seems a little more timeless and elegant to me, maybe better for an adult? But there is something lovely about the sound of matilda and mattie seems so much cuter and cuddlier! I'm not keen on tilly though and realise she may choose that herself I the future if we go with matilda. I know both are reasonably popular and I'm not bothered about that, would be interested to hear opinions (not too harsh please as it will def be one of these two)

Both are lovely so you can't really go wrong, but Matilda is one of my all time favourite names.

Why don't you flip a coin? You don't have to go with the results but your initial gut reaction (happiness or disappointment) might make you realise you do have a preference you're not currently aware of

Imogen

Imogen

But really I couldn't possibly say without seeing a photo of your new DD.

Love both and also love Immy and Tilda so I'm no help. Looks like you'll have to have another so you can use both

We had the exact same dilemma 16 months ago. We went with Imogen. I love it, and we haven't met another yet.

Congratulations.

Please post a picture

Incase you don't I prefer Imogen

Congratulations .
Imogen for me.

Imogen from me too!

I really don't like 'Mattie'

Imogen, love Immy.

Congratulations. Billions of Imogens round here, not so many Matildas. I prefer Matilda too.

Congratulations I would go with Imogen.

Imogen. I know an Imogen and she is a lovely person, a very kind soul.

Matilda is the best name ever (not that I'm biased) but it automatically got shortened to
Tilly so I'd be careful.

Congratulations

I agree with Lemondrops suggestion. ... otherwise.. Matilda

Matilda.

Thanks for all your responses :) so general consensus seems to be imogen - I think my head says imogen too but I keep going back to mattie so wondering if this is where my heart lies! So rubish at decisions! For those saying they needed a pic to decide this is little immy-mat....

I prefer Immy/Imogen. I like Matilda but people will assume they are Tilly and I'm not so keen. Mattie is cute.

She's beautiful congratulations :)

Imogen!

Matilda has been quite popular recently, so though a pretty name, I think Imogen would be the better choice.

She's beautiful can't believe how much hair she has already. Congratulations again.

I love Matilda

I love Immy to but don't like Imogen as much

Ahhhh so cute and so much hair! 😍

It hasn't helped though, I think both names would suit her.

What does your DH/DP think?

I wasn't sure which I preferred but after seeing her, I'm certain she's a Mattie. She's absolutely beautiful. So cute, congratulations 😊

Aww look at all that hair! She's gorgeous!

Imogen

That's a Matilda