Please or to access all these features

Aussie and NZ Mumsnetters

Welcome to Aussie & NZ Mumsnetters - discuss all aspects of parenting life in Australia and New Zealand, including relocating, schools and local areas.

Erin Patterson - We the members of the MN jury find the defendant Guilty or Not Guilty?

799 replies

Dustyblue · 22/06/2025 03:51

Well here we are, after 2 years of head-scratching speculation and many weeks of trial detail-thrashing. It looks like the Judge will give his directions to the jury on Tuesday, after which they'll be sequestered in a local motel (I do not envy them this) to reach a verdict.

Clearly we're not privy to every last piece of evidence shown at the trial, but those of us who've been following closely will surely have formed an opinion one war or the other.

So, I ask you- if you were on the jury- what would your verdict be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
36
FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 06:17

@ExplodingSmittens I believe that they are still married, yes. I would hope that he’s getting the divorce paperwork lodged.

Good outcome. Now to see if the High Court approves her application for an appeal.

ExplodingSmittens · 30/10/2026 09:45

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 06:17

@ExplodingSmittens I believe that they are still married, yes. I would hope that he’s getting the divorce paperwork lodged.

Good outcome. Now to see if the High Court approves her application for an appeal.

How many times did he say that she tried to kill him before she committed these murders? Was it two or three? Surely that must be grounds enough for divorce let alone the fact that she’s now murdered 3 members of his family and won’t now ever get out of prison?

I found it really bizarre that they were still married when the news story first broke. Now she’s been found guilty I find it truly incredulous and wonder what his thinking is regarding staying married to her.

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 11:50

ExplodingSmittens · 30/10/2026 09:45

How many times did he say that she tried to kill him before she committed these murders? Was it two or three? Surely that must be grounds enough for divorce let alone the fact that she’s now murdered 3 members of his family and won’t now ever get out of prison?

I found it really bizarre that they were still married when the news story first broke. Now she’s been found guilty I find it truly incredulous and wonder what his thinking is regarding staying married to her.

Australia has no fault divorce nationwide. Don’t need to have a reason. Maybe he avoided divorcing her because he didn’t want to deal with her bullshit and manipulation.

Anzena · 30/10/2026 12:08

Maybe not divorcing on religious grounds or financial complications or something?

They could be divorced already, who would know unless it was broadcast. I'd imagine only certain parties can access divorce registers, not sure if media could find out.

On another note, her assets should have been seized and transferred to her husband and kids. She is so bad she might make a will in favour of a mushroom farm and disinherit them.

velvetandsatin · 30/10/2026 12:23

Anzena · 30/10/2026 12:08

Maybe not divorcing on religious grounds or financial complications or something?

They could be divorced already, who would know unless it was broadcast. I'd imagine only certain parties can access divorce registers, not sure if media could find out.

On another note, her assets should have been seized and transferred to her husband and kids. She is so bad she might make a will in favour of a mushroom farm and disinherit them.

The Supreme Court of Victoria have a restraining order on her house, and presumably all other assets, to provide for possible victim compensation; her lawyers also have a mortgage on her house to cover their costs. No chance she gets access to any proceeds from the eventual sale of the house.

Anzena · 30/10/2026 12:38

velvetandsatin · 30/10/2026 12:23

The Supreme Court of Victoria have a restraining order on her house, and presumably all other assets, to provide for possible victim compensation; her lawyers also have a mortgage on her house to cover their costs. No chance she gets access to any proceeds from the eventual sale of the house.

The State of Victoria is on the ball! Good to hear her assets are frozen. The family are the victims so hopefully they will get everything she owns, minus the legal costs of course.

ExplodingSmittens · 30/10/2026 13:44

Glad that Australia has no fault divorce. I guess she must have been really sure that the appeal would be successful if the legal fees were from her assets so that her DC wouldn’t be benefiting from any sale.

All through this I’ve had the impression that she’s probably bright but not nearly as bright as she thinks that she’s probably is. Things like keeping her phone with her when she was foraging and leaving the instructions for the dehydrator in a kitchen drawer are frankly laughable errors if she planned multiple murders.

Sugarnspicenallthingsnaice · 30/10/2026 18:39

Generally under Australian family law, once a divorce is granted you have 1 year to settle financial matters. Maybe he's waiting until her issues are sorted out and her assets are unfrozen; it could be unnecessarily complicated and expensive otherwise.

velvetandsatin · 30/10/2026 23:03

Given they have been separated since I think 2015, he is not in a hurry to get a divorce. Possibly for religious reasons. I don't know.

InWalksBarberalla · 30/10/2026 23:37

I think he's always been a bit afraid of upsetting her, particularly with the kids involved. Which considering she's a cold blooded triple murderer isn't that surprising.

velvetandsatin · 31/10/2026 00:04

InWalksBarberalla · 30/10/2026 23:37

I think he's always been a bit afraid of upsetting her, particularly with the kids involved. Which considering she's a cold blooded triple murderer isn't that surprising.

Good point. It will be interesting to see if he divorces her now she is safely locked up. I am looking forward to reading his book, which may be able to be published now, or soonish, given her appeal was unsuccessful.

ExplodingSmittens · 31/10/2026 07:24

velvetandsatin · 31/10/2026 00:04

Good point. It will be interesting to see if he divorces her now she is safely locked up. I am looking forward to reading his book, which may be able to be published now, or soonish, given her appeal was unsuccessful.

I hadn’t realised that he’d written a book. It’s a good point about not wanting to upset her too. It’s not just the triple murder and attempted murder, he maintains that she also tried to kill him more than once.

velvetandsatin · 31/10/2026 09:52

ExplodingSmittens · 31/10/2026 07:24

I hadn’t realised that he’d written a book. It’s a good point about not wanting to upset her too. It’s not just the triple murder and attempted murder, he maintains that she also tried to kill him more than once.

There was enough evidence for the DPP to bring charges of multiple accounts of attempted murder for her attempts to kill Simon, and her intention to kill him with the others, but the judge at the trial ruled that they had to be tried separately to the lunch murders. It meant a lot of evidence against her had to be left out.

TheMadGardener · 01/11/2026 00:41

Apparently she still has regular video calls with her children. Not sure how healthy this is for her children. One hopes they have had some therapy since mum killed their grandparents. I wonder how reading dad's book will be for them too.

velvetandsatin · 01/11/2026 02:20

Those poor kids. It will take a lifetime of therapy to unwind this influence. Last I heard, albeit a long while ago, they still believed she was innocent.

Simon seems a very careful man, and the editors involved will also be careful, I expect.

Anzena · 13/11/2026 09:46

Seems like the suppression of further or other evidence is only valid in case she applies for leave to appeal to the High Court by November 27th? So if she doesn't, it looks like this evidence can be reported.

I'm guessing she will try to appeal, but I'd imagine the grounds are pretty strict at High Court level. Anyway, we'll see.....

NoCommentingFromNowOn · 14/11/2026 00:01

Just by saying that, it has hit the newspapers and any potential jurors have read it now, so I don’t see what the point of even releasing it to the public was?

’There are things we know that are so awful they would be remembered by any potential jury members. We’re not going to tell you though, but we now know you are all going to sit there and speculate’.

And yes, poor, poor children. At least their father seems decent (I think?).

velvetandsatin · 14/11/2026 02:37

It's newsworthy that there is a further suppression order. The courts can't make suppression orders without the press being aware of them. They want to be allowed to report on this stuff, and have pressured for that, but the order is there to disallow this information getting out to the public until it is clear whether or not this loon is going to attempt to waste more money on a high court appeal.

HoppingPavlova · 14/11/2026 08:12

She’ll attempt an appeal, she’s a loon with no respect for her children so will happily piss any money that could have been their future away. Tye question is, will her appeal be entertained, who knows but I really hope not. She just needs to fade into obscurity.

NoCommentingFromNowOn · 14/11/2026 10:11

HoppingPavlova · 14/11/2026 08:12

She’ll attempt an appeal, she’s a loon with no respect for her children so will happily piss any money that could have been their future away. Tye question is, will her appeal be entertained, who knows but I really hope not. She just needs to fade into obscurity.

Oh she’s paying for this herself?

HoppingPavlova · 14/11/2026 23:13

NoCommentingFromNowOn · 14/11/2026 10:11

Oh she’s paying for this herself?

My understanding is she has funded her legal defence so far and that her assets have been frozen to allow clawback of legal fees incurred to date and that she has the ability to use any remaining (if any remains) for continued legal defence. Once it’s over, any remaining would then be available as compo for her victims of crime, then any remaining would be free for her kids theoretically if end state after possible appeals is life without parole.

NoCommentingFromNowOn · 14/11/2026 23:36

@HoppingPavlova thank you for that. I have to admit I assumed the state would pay for all legal fees and to hear she has paid it was unexpected.

So the victims would be the pastor, plus whoever the children are of the deceased? So her ex husband plus siblings, and the children of his aunt and uncle I guess?

I’m horrified to think her children still think (or previously thought) she was innocent.

HoppingPavlova · 15/11/2026 02:59

@NoCommentingFromNowOn I have to admit I assumed the state would pay for all legal fees and to hear she has paid it was unexpected.

Everyone here is entitled a public defender free of charge, but you can also opt to hire a private defender/defense team instead if you want, which is not uncommon if you have the means. If you don’t have cash ready, they will apply for a caveat on whatever asset(s) they believe would provide money to pay them if sold, which is usually property.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page