Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Drowning in DH's family heirlooms

53 replies

MinorHoardersAnonymous · Today 19:07

DH is extremely sentimental and a borderline hoarder. When we got married about a year ago, I moved into his place. The space is FILLED. Kitchen cupboards are filled with endless china + endless number of pots and pans, a whole room is filled with bits and bobs, living room is filled up with so many things that we have to walk around them to get to the sofa, bedroom has basically shrunk by 1/3 because 1/3 is filled with more stuff.

I hate it. It's cluttered and a mess.

We are currently in the process of furnishing our new house. Bought the furniture and everything is very 'clean' and modern. We've agreed that most of his things will go into his study which is a full-sized bedroom.

Previously when we talked about his things, he said that no problem he will slowly get rid of stuff so it'd fit without cluttering things up. Now that he actually has to get rid of them, he can't because they're family heirlooms (even the IKEA pots and pans because his grandmother owned them) or things he's had since young or things his parents or family had given to him.

Let's talk about the kitchen for example. There are so many different sets of plates, some hideously coloured (even DH thinks so), some chipped. The non-stick coating on the pans have completely peeled off, pots are dented and the plastic handle on one has even partially melted. Doesn't matter. DH wants to bring them over.

We initially agreed to get a new set of our choice. I even said I'd pay 100% for all things!! Something we both chose together. Now I honestly am dreading the move because it feels like we're just moving from his house to his house again.

AIBU? I hate cluttered I just want a nice modern, clean place.

OP posts:
parrap · Today 20:45

Did you/do you live together in the hoarder's house and are now moving to another? How did you feel about being there with all that stuff.

I think you feel that the new house will solve all the problem hoarding. I don't think it will. The study will soon not be big enough to hold the crap that has yet to come, and soon your new home will be filled with stuff. Even a storage unit may not be enough if that gets filled up, where does the surplus go then? Your new house I reckon.

OK I suppose you have to give it a try and see how it goes. I'm being flippant but not joking when I say you might remain married alright, but live apart, him in his hoarder house and you in your neat new house. That might be a reality.

It's seems to be practically impossible to get a hoarder to let go of stuff. Well at least any of the programs I've seen show this. And even if the place is cleared out and all is neat and tidy again, it doesn't take long for things and stuff to creep back in. It is a mental illness.

I hope it all works out for you, but be prepared for it not to.

Offherrockingchair · Today 20:46

Throw him out with the crap and have a lovely clean house all to yourself 😂

ItsWouldHaveNotWouldOf · Today 20:47

My late DH was a hoarder. He would buy new clothes, hobby equipment etc, but would never get rid of old stuff. When his DP died, he brought loads of stuff back from their house (including broken or half finished model kits) because "he couldn't bear to throw them away". When he died a few years ago it was very cathartic to get rid of all his hoarded junk and have a clutter free house for the first time.

Tell DH he can take with him only items that can be stored comfortably in his study. If he can't get rid of the rest, he rents a lock up, at his sole expense, to store it. Once it's out of sight for a period of time, maybe he'll come to terms with not having it. I'd also encourage him to seek some counselling because this level of hoarding is a mental health issue.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page