Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Drowning in DH's family heirlooms

57 replies

MinorHoardersAnonymous · Today 19:07

DH is extremely sentimental and a borderline hoarder. When we got married about a year ago, I moved into his place. The space is FILLED. Kitchen cupboards are filled with endless china + endless number of pots and pans, a whole room is filled with bits and bobs, living room is filled up with so many things that we have to walk around them to get to the sofa, bedroom has basically shrunk by 1/3 because 1/3 is filled with more stuff.

I hate it. It's cluttered and a mess.

We are currently in the process of furnishing our new house. Bought the furniture and everything is very 'clean' and modern. We've agreed that most of his things will go into his study which is a full-sized bedroom.

Previously when we talked about his things, he said that no problem he will slowly get rid of stuff so it'd fit without cluttering things up. Now that he actually has to get rid of them, he can't because they're family heirlooms (even the IKEA pots and pans because his grandmother owned them) or things he's had since young or things his parents or family had given to him.

Let's talk about the kitchen for example. There are so many different sets of plates, some hideously coloured (even DH thinks so), some chipped. The non-stick coating on the pans have completely peeled off, pots are dented and the plastic handle on one has even partially melted. Doesn't matter. DH wants to bring them over.

We initially agreed to get a new set of our choice. I even said I'd pay 100% for all things!! Something we both chose together. Now I honestly am dreading the move because it feels like we're just moving from his house to his house again.

AIBU? I hate cluttered I just want a nice modern, clean place.

OP posts:
Moonflower12 · Today 19:10

You have my utmost sympathy. My DH is like this too. I really don’t know what to suggest. My DH also decides we need to streamline etc and then when it comes to the crunch, doesn’t.

Arineerine · Today 19:10

He sounds like he has a mental health illness

Arineerine · Today 19:11

borderline hoarder

bona fide full throttle hoarder more like

Nighttimenoise · Today 19:13

I would ask him to get counselling, hoarders are notoriously difficult to live with.
in the meantime I would lay out the china and tell him he can take for example 5 plates. Or he can rent a garage and keep it all in there.

oviraptor21 · Today 19:16

Just stick with the agreed plan - he keeps it all in his study, no matter what it is. Buy nice new things for the rest of the house.

Alittlefrustrated · Today 19:18

He needs to pay for storage, if he must keep stuff.
If this would place a financial burden on you, then it all just needs to go.
He won't miss stuff once it's gone.

Gogar · Today 19:18

He rents a storage unit. That saved my friends’ marriage.

Octavia64 · Today 19:20

Storage unit.

or my ExH kept it all in the garage. It was a triple garage

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · Today 19:20

Get him to watch some Sort Your Life Out

FKAT · Today 19:22

Leave.

I'm serious.

Error404FucksNotFound · Today 19:22

If you wanted a clean modern place then marrying a hoarder was never going to go well for you.
Hoarding is very difficult to treat.
Maybe you could get a shed or storage unit if he will agree.

Vintagevincent · Today 19:23

This doesn't sound " borderline" at all.

He's a full on hoarder and sounds like he needs to look at treatment because the situation won't get better on its own.

CherryKerry · Today 19:26

My DH was the same with his Granny's stuff. I managed to persuade him to box it up and put it in the attic. Nearly 30 years later we're currently emptying the attic for house move prep and the sentimenality seems to have vanished as he's binned the vast majority of it now.

Moral of the story, can you stuff it in the attic for a couple of decades?

AhBiscuits · Today 19:28

We have so much of DH's old shit in our house. MIL keeps threatening to bring more from her loft. He is 45 years old, seems unlikely he's going to need his GCSE coursework? I've told him that if he dies first all of his crap will go straight in a skip, so what is the actual point in keeping it? Then he wonders why the kids won't let us ditch old toys and clothes. It's his DNA!

You have my sympathy. I fantasise about throwing out 80% of the things in our house.

Newname26 · Today 19:28

Honestly I'd start in the kitchen.
And bin danaged pots and crockery. Don't negotiate just do it.
Non-stick pealing can be toxic and chipped plates etc can be a habour for bacteria bin.

Badvocthebad · Today 19:31

You aren't compatible.

AhBiscuits · Today 19:32

I think the suggest above that anything he wants to keep has to go his study is a good one. If he won't bin it, box it up for the move, stack those boxes in the study and close the door. He stuff stays in there and is not allowed to leak out into the rest of the house.

sweeneytoddsrazor · Today 19:32

It's often difficult for people to get rid of sentimental stuff. In my mind this is different to hoarding tons of stuff because it might come in useful one day or you might fit back into it one day or whatever.

That said some of it will have to go so ask him what things are of particular sentimental value and start from there

Hugeandfedup · Today 19:37

You have my complete sympathy. When my MIL died my DH moved tons of her stuff to our house. Coming up for a year later I have managed to stuff lots in the attic and reduce to one corner of our babies room, but the amount of kitchen stuff is still insane.

Fieldmiceears · Today 19:38

YABU, you saw the way he lived before marrying him. Hoarding is a mental illness and people who have it, don't know they have it. It is very serious and not easy to change. You married him knowing you were going to try and change him. That's not really fair.

Try this video to understand the different levels and why he doesn't see himself as having a problem

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/CpyLYc3ThT0

somanychristmaslights · Today 19:41

Don’t get a storage unit. That’s just a temporary solution. What happens when that is full? He needs therapy. What does he say if you were to clear it out. Maybe he goes away for the weekend and you just do it? (With his permission).

Nearly50omg · Today 19:41

Pack it ALL up and put it in his “study” and make ir very clear to him that the crap stays in there unless it’s coming out to go to the tip/charity shop or being sold!

NotMeNoNo · Today 19:41

Storage unit or counselling.

The question has to be, what would we typically want if we were starting over? Five or six pans, with lids, in good condition, ideally that match/stack. Six or eight settings of matching crockery. Large medium and small frying pans. Work it out and pick the best out of the hoard. Anything more than that, or in bad condition, there is no reason to keep. NONE. Maybe a couple of keepsake boxes in the loft.

You can apply that logic when you've just accumulated over the years and need to downsize. It sounds like your DH has got some significant emotional baggage (grieving/bereavement?). Therapy would be an investment if he's up for it.

You will probably never get clean and modern, he obviously needs some familiar things around him, but you might get to a more average level.

Redburnett · Today 19:46

Just pack the stuff in boxes and store it somewhere out of the way (eg roof space, piled up in garage, rented unit). Then you won't be bothered by it but he will still have it should he ever actually want it. Coming from a family of hoarders, including me, I suggest this is likely to be more successful than trying to persuade him to get rid of stuff.

HortiGal · Today 19:47

Why you married him is a mystery!
Be firm that it is all binned or he can stay there and you move to new house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread