Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Drowning in DH's family heirlooms

53 replies

MinorHoardersAnonymous · Today 19:07

DH is extremely sentimental and a borderline hoarder. When we got married about a year ago, I moved into his place. The space is FILLED. Kitchen cupboards are filled with endless china + endless number of pots and pans, a whole room is filled with bits and bobs, living room is filled up with so many things that we have to walk around them to get to the sofa, bedroom has basically shrunk by 1/3 because 1/3 is filled with more stuff.

I hate it. It's cluttered and a mess.

We are currently in the process of furnishing our new house. Bought the furniture and everything is very 'clean' and modern. We've agreed that most of his things will go into his study which is a full-sized bedroom.

Previously when we talked about his things, he said that no problem he will slowly get rid of stuff so it'd fit without cluttering things up. Now that he actually has to get rid of them, he can't because they're family heirlooms (even the IKEA pots and pans because his grandmother owned them) or things he's had since young or things his parents or family had given to him.

Let's talk about the kitchen for example. There are so many different sets of plates, some hideously coloured (even DH thinks so), some chipped. The non-stick coating on the pans have completely peeled off, pots are dented and the plastic handle on one has even partially melted. Doesn't matter. DH wants to bring them over.

We initially agreed to get a new set of our choice. I even said I'd pay 100% for all things!! Something we both chose together. Now I honestly am dreading the move because it feels like we're just moving from his house to his house again.

AIBU? I hate cluttered I just want a nice modern, clean place.

OP posts:
ThePM · Today 19:49

Ooh yikes, you have a fight on your hands here.

He obviously feels like granny is the IKEA pot, and throwing it out would be equivalent to throwing her body in the bin.

Are his parents still alive? Could they advise?
He needs to get with the program here- but if things get invested with meaning then that actually is the hoarders mentality and you are screwed.

Coralsunset · Today 19:56

I know it’s not helpful but you married him and chose to live with him, knowing he’s a hoarder.

I would call off the move if he won’t get rid of the majority of his hoard. I absolutely couldn’t live like it, my MH would be shot to pieces.

Lucyccfc68 · Today 20:00

If he can’t part with the stuff, tell him it has to be taken to a storage unit. Guarantee, if you agree for him to have his stuff in 1 room or his study, then within 12 months your lovely new house will be full of his crap.

Newname26 · Today 20:01

NotMeNoNo · Today 19:41

Storage unit or counselling.

The question has to be, what would we typically want if we were starting over? Five or six pans, with lids, in good condition, ideally that match/stack. Six or eight settings of matching crockery. Large medium and small frying pans. Work it out and pick the best out of the hoard. Anything more than that, or in bad condition, there is no reason to keep. NONE. Maybe a couple of keepsake boxes in the loft.

You can apply that logic when you've just accumulated over the years and need to downsize. It sounds like your DH has got some significant emotional baggage (grieving/bereavement?). Therapy would be an investment if he's up for it.

You will probably never get clean and modern, he obviously needs some familiar things around him, but you might get to a more average level.

That's partly why I think the kitchen is a good place to start, nobody could get that sentimental about pots.

Decide what your keeping, split the rest into charity shop / tip.
The alternative it bung stuff on FB theyll always be someone moving into a new house starting from scratch needing things.

DollydaydreamTheThird · Today 20:01

AhBiscuits · Today 19:28

We have so much of DH's old shit in our house. MIL keeps threatening to bring more from her loft. He is 45 years old, seems unlikely he's going to need his GCSE coursework? I've told him that if he dies first all of his crap will go straight in a skip, so what is the actual point in keeping it? Then he wonders why the kids won't let us ditch old toys and clothes. It's his DNA!

You have my sympathy. I fantasise about throwing out 80% of the things in our house.

Edited

Same here. We live in MIL old house now and the loft was never cleared and neither was the garage (thanks a lot DSILs). It is all full of his Mum and Dad's life. I sometimes dream that Stacey will turn up with the gang and Sort our life out. I wouldn't mind so much if it was my life that needed sorting. It is depressing as fuck.

AluckyEllie · Today 20:02

I genuinely couldn’t live like that, it would be a da breaker for me. You have my sympathy but I have no idea what to suggest except - why did you think he would change?

Goldencoast2 · Today 20:02

Either throw it out when he’s not around or storage unit. He might find he’s less sentimental when the monthly fees start coming out of his pocket.

SwingAndRelax · Today 20:07

If the items are useless and not something you would use (like old pans etc) can you suggest taking photos of them for the 'memories' and then throwing them out?

If it's only got the sentimental reasons then he should pick a handful of the most treasures things to keep and photograph the rest.

You cannot start a new house like this. It needs to go.

MasterGland · Today 20:07

Sympathies. We have two huge cupboards full of 'rare' beer glasses.

SpottyAlpaca · Today 20:08

He doesn’t sound like a ‘borderline hoarder’ to me. He sounds like a full-on hoarder if he can’t bear to part with what is objectively junk. In your position, OP, I would be seriously concerned that his hoarding is only going to get worse.

OnTheTop · Today 20:08

It’s definitely not borderline, it’s pretty extreme in my opinion.

My husband is very sentimental and struggles to part with (shit) objects. However, our house is tidy and clutter free. He keeps his objects out of the communal living areas, so in the garage or his wardrobe.

BigSuse · Today 20:09

It’s a mental illness, it will only get worse. Point out to him that melted, dented pans from IKEA and chipped plates aren’t usually considered sentimental, and would he consider counselling?

SpottyAlpaca · Today 20:11

Renting a storage unit for all the junk treasured heirlooms sounds like an excellent compromise here. As long as he’s paying for it out of his own money, obv.

FallingFlying · Today 20:12

How is he with other stuff, is it just the 'sentimental' stuff he needs to keep? If so, at least there's a limit to it.

He packs it all up and keeps it in his study/shed/storage unit.

Minasama · Today 20:12

I think you need to insist that he pick one item for each room from the old house and the rest goes into storage.

Every sympathy as my parents were like this, they have done a big declutter now in order to downsize.

Trottersup · Today 20:12

It's curious why you married him. In your shoes I would be throwing it away when he's out. The chipped plates, the damaged pans. You need to be firm, then stick to it. No wiggle room. If he refuses to stop hording you might have to end the relationship as it's going to make you miserable.

SerenaCat93 · Today 20:15

Let him keep one of each of the kitchen stuff. We have a shelf in our cupboard of sentimental plates bowls etc from grannies that never get used but all fit on one shelf and then a matching dinner set we chose together and use. For the broken pots and pans just tell him he needs to bin the lot because they're a health hazard to cook in. Stuff as much in his study as will fit and everything else has to be "you can keep one but not the whole set"

DeedlessIndeed · Today 20:16

Can you take a look at the Dana K White's container method?

I grew up with a Mother with hoarding tendencies (not too bad, kept in check by my Dad) and I started going down the same path. This method helped me let go of a lot of stuff, simply because it wasn't me choosing to throw away anything. It was a physical limitation of the space that made the "decision" for me.

So you have space for 12 mugs, 6 plates, 6 bowls etc, etc.

And if I really want to keep Granny's chipped plate, then one of the decent ones that I use everyday will have to be thrown away instead.

OneZanyMintQuoter · Today 20:16

Agree this sounds more extreme than borderline. IKEA and dented pans etc. can you suggest counselling?

TFImBackIn · Today 20:18

You'd be crazy to think this will change. Honestly, I'm sure he's a lovely man but there's no way I'd live with him. Resentment will blossom faster than his collection of old pans.

arethereanyleftatall · Today 20:20

I put Yabu but what I mean by that is obviously Yanbu so why would you marry a hoarder and move in together?

user99337611 · Today 20:21

This sounds extreme. My husband is a bit of a hoarder but not too bad. MIL is constantly dumping family heirloom crap on us and DH won’t get rid of any of it. Even his siblings use us as a junkyard. I put my foot down in the end and DH agreed to put the stuff in the loft, but he still won’t get rid of it. You have my sympathies.

AnOldCynic · Today 20:30

You need to both read The Minimalist Home by Joshua Becker. Better still get an audiobook and listen to it at the same time together.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Today 20:31

Moonflower12 · Today 19:10

You have my utmost sympathy. My DH is like this too. I really don’t know what to suggest. My DH also decides we need to streamline etc and then when it comes to the crunch, doesn’t.

My ex was the same, only it was larger than mere china: bookcases and tables and a piano. One of my friends, a lawyer, suggested once that I ought to divorce him on the grounds of unreasonable furniture.

aaja · Today 20:36

If he can’t part with a damaged non stick pan, he is a hoarder. Almost all hoarding stems from traumatic events. If I were you, I would make sure to get floor to ceiling storage across walls where you can, box up (tightly pack) the hoard and get the boxes into the shelves with doors on so it can’t be seen.