Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some affluent people don’t know what real problems are?

61 replies

ThatDeepGoose · Today 16:53

I’ve lived in affluent areas and socialised with quite wealthy people over the years, and something I’ve noticed is how utterly trivial some of the things they complain about are.

For example, someone lamenting the fact that they’re buying a new house but the driveway is smaller than their current one, meaning their mother won’t be able to drive up in her Range Rover and fully open all her car doors so her dogs can get out and greet everyone.

Or people posting in local Facebook groups asking neighbours to change the materials of their garden fences because they’ve witnessed an incident involving a deer.

I just find myself thinking… people have real problems. These aren’t them.

I’m not suggesting that having money makes someone immune to illness, bereavement, relationship breakdowns or genuine hardship. Of course it doesn’t.

I do sometimes wonder whether living a particularly comfortable, privileged life can leave people so insulated from genuine hardship that relatively minor inconveniences start to feel like major problems.

I appreciate that everything is relative but sometimes I genuinely struggle to take these complaints seriously.

AIBU?

OP posts:
MellowSubmarine · Today 18:04

I really want to know about the deer incident and how it relates to a change of fence material.

ShanghaiDiva · Today 18:04

FirmSnake · Today 17:44

Poorer people moan about driveways and fences too though.
Perhaps they are just using their manners and not telling an acquaintance their biggest struggles.
Do you go around announcing that your granny has cancer? Or that you can't pay uour credit card bill this month? Or that your antidepressants aren't working? Probably not. But you might well whinge about the dishwasher or the weather. It's the same thing.

Exactly. I might moan something trivial because I don’t want to share the more challenging aspects of life with acquaintances. Doesn’t mean I don’t recognise that other people are struggling: its just a superficial conversation along the same lines as ‘what did you do at the weekend?’.
edit to add
equally it doesn’t mean that I attach huge importance to the issue I am whinging about.

Abitofalark · Today 18:06

People deal with whatever according to where they are in life. Drives and fences and the like feature prominently if they are contemplating buying a house. If people have money they are preoccupied with many things including where to put it and how to avoid tax and so on. People who don't have enough money worry constantly about how they are going to survive and how to get more, how to pay the bills and so on..

I once had someone in a BMW stop at my house and ask me how wide the drive and the garage were and ended up driving into my garage to see if it would fit.

Yogafiend · Today 18:06

@ThatDeepGoose I personally think you ade being completely unreasonable. Just because they are trivial in your view, doesn’t mean they aren’t inconvenient. And just because they complain about it I’m sure people don’t think these are on par with someone with dealing with cancer for example. I am not sure how you determined they seem them hardship.

My mother has some similar views - if you have money then everything can be solved - and your issues don’t really qualify as issues which is only view, completely unreasonable.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 18:06

Nevs · Today 18:01

but it doesn’t negate the possibility that some affluent people can be rather out of touch

But of course they are out of touch, why wouldn’t they be? I’d be suprised if they weren’t if they grew up affluent. As I said in my previous post everything is relative and it’s all they know. The fact you have taken time to post about this implies you believe this is some sort of character flaw, but I do not view it this way.

I’m questioning the level of importance some people attach to relatively trivial matters. You can acknowledge that something is irritating without treating it as though it’s a major hardship.

I’m curious how you differentiate a person treating something as a mild inconvenience, and major hardship. How do you measure this? Can you give examples? Because from your post, (the person complaining his mum cannot park her Range Rover on their now smaller driveway) I cannot see how the people you mention have treated such things as a “major hardship”. Can you elaborate?

I don’t necessarily regard being out of touch as a character flaw but I do think it’s something worth questioning, particularly when it stems from considerable privilege. As for your question, I’m not suggesting there’s some objective scale by which we can measure how seriously someone regards an inconvenience.

It’s about context, tone, the language used and the degree of importance attached to something. Someone casually mentioning that their new driveway is smaller is rather different from someone genuinely lamenting the fact that their mother’s Range Rover won’t be able to open all its doors so the dogs can greet everyone.

I’m not claiming these people have explicitly described their circumstances as major hardships. I’m saying that, from my interactions with them, the level of concern expressed about certain relatively trivial matters has struck me as disproportionate. Of course that’s a subjective judgement but AIBU is a forum for discussing those kinds of observations.

OP posts:
SKIDSNETwaynekurr · Today 18:08

ASM WINS BETCHEZ
[ASM] [PHG]
.s5SSSs. .s5SSSs. .s5ssSs. SS. SS. SS SS. sS S%S sS :; sS SS S%S SS S%S SS SS :; S%S SSSs. S%S :;;;;. SS S%S SS S%S ;;. SS S%S SS :; :; SS :; SS ;,. .,; ;,. SS ;,. :; ;:' :;;;;;:' :; ;:' #SKIDSNET

mincepye · Today 18:09

Last Friday I had surgery for cancer, on Thursday my friend and I had a good old moan because the water temperature at our five star, 5 bubbles spa that we are both members of wasn’t quite warm enough to enjoy a full hour in the outside hydrotherapy pool.

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 18:10

You think less affluent people don’t make trivial complaints? I could come up with multiple people I know or have come across on tight incomes and living in poor housing and I assure you they also complained about things that on the face of it were fairly unimportant - a particular flavour of crisps being discontinued, complaints the local high street Christmas lights were not good enough, why their child wasn’t selected for angel Gabriel and had to play a donkey in the reception class nativity, there were no conkers left at the park because the other children had picked them all up….

People complain. I’m not saying affluent people don’t, on the whole, have things easier but I’m not buying that poverty makes you immune to complaining about trivial stuff.

ThisOliveKoala · Today 18:12

ThatDeepGoose · Today 16:53

I’ve lived in affluent areas and socialised with quite wealthy people over the years, and something I’ve noticed is how utterly trivial some of the things they complain about are.

For example, someone lamenting the fact that they’re buying a new house but the driveway is smaller than their current one, meaning their mother won’t be able to drive up in her Range Rover and fully open all her car doors so her dogs can get out and greet everyone.

Or people posting in local Facebook groups asking neighbours to change the materials of their garden fences because they’ve witnessed an incident involving a deer.

I just find myself thinking… people have real problems. These aren’t them.

I’m not suggesting that having money makes someone immune to illness, bereavement, relationship breakdowns or genuine hardship. Of course it doesn’t.

I do sometimes wonder whether living a particularly comfortable, privileged life can leave people so insulated from genuine hardship that relatively minor inconveniences start to feel like major problems.

I appreciate that everything is relative but sometimes I genuinely struggle to take these complaints seriously.

AIBU?

Everything is relative, so are they not supposed to complain about their problems? If we are talking about poverty for eg its very relative, in this country the poor have access to water and food. Should they not complain about rising cost of living because there are children in Gaza who don’t have access to clean water, people in Congo who don’t have access to basic medicines? People in Ethiopia who are malnourished? Then your post in itself is the same thing. There are people around the world dodging bullets, bombs, no access to clean water or even food. There are people literally dying of starvation.

so if affluent people cannot complain, neither can anyone in the uk, if we are comparing relative poverty in a developed country to abject poverty.

your post is a moot point, people can complain about what they like. Although I will say practicing gratitude leads to a better life and better mood.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 18:16

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 18:10

You think less affluent people don’t make trivial complaints? I could come up with multiple people I know or have come across on tight incomes and living in poor housing and I assure you they also complained about things that on the face of it were fairly unimportant - a particular flavour of crisps being discontinued, complaints the local high street Christmas lights were not good enough, why their child wasn’t selected for angel Gabriel and had to play a donkey in the reception class nativity, there were no conkers left at the park because the other children had picked them all up….

People complain. I’m not saying affluent people don’t, on the whole, have things easier but I’m not buying that poverty makes you immune to complaining about trivial stuff.

I don’t think poverty makes anyone immune to complaining about trivial things and I haven’t suggested that it does. Of course people from all socioeconomic backgrounds complain about relatively minor inconveniences. That’s not in dispute.

My observation is specifically about some affluent people I’ve encountered and the disproportionate importance they appear to attach to certain inconveniences. I’m not suggesting that poorer people are inherently more grateful, more grounded or less inclined to complain.

I do think considerable financial comfort can sometimes insulate people from certain realities and influence their sense of perspective. That doesn’t mean every affluent person lacks perspective, just as it doesn’t mean every less affluent person possesses it.

OP posts:
ginasevern · Today 18:17

MellowSubmarine · Today 18:04

I really want to know about the deer incident and how it relates to a change of fence material.

Some types of fencing and fence material can cause severe injuries to deer. They can cut themselves, break limbs or become entangled in it causing fatal exhaustion and blood loss. Many parks, farmlands and forests are replacing their fencing these days because of the danger posed to deer and other wildlife.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page