Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some affluent people don’t know what real problems are?

61 replies

ThatDeepGoose · Today 16:53

I’ve lived in affluent areas and socialised with quite wealthy people over the years, and something I’ve noticed is how utterly trivial some of the things they complain about are.

For example, someone lamenting the fact that they’re buying a new house but the driveway is smaller than their current one, meaning their mother won’t be able to drive up in her Range Rover and fully open all her car doors so her dogs can get out and greet everyone.

Or people posting in local Facebook groups asking neighbours to change the materials of their garden fences because they’ve witnessed an incident involving a deer.

I just find myself thinking… people have real problems. These aren’t them.

I’m not suggesting that having money makes someone immune to illness, bereavement, relationship breakdowns or genuine hardship. Of course it doesn’t.

I do sometimes wonder whether living a particularly comfortable, privileged life can leave people so insulated from genuine hardship that relatively minor inconveniences start to feel like major problems.

I appreciate that everything is relative but sometimes I genuinely struggle to take these complaints seriously.

AIBU?

OP posts:
FirmSnake · Today 17:44

Poorer people moan about driveways and fences too though.
Perhaps they are just using their manners and not telling an acquaintance their biggest struggles.
Do you go around announcing that your granny has cancer? Or that you can't pay uour credit card bill this month? Or that your antidepressants aren't working? Probably not. But you might well whinge about the dishwasher or the weather. It's the same thing.

JudyTeeny · Today 17:47

I agree with @SoThatsTheWayItIs , often people moan about very trivial things when they don't mention the serious stuff they're worrying about. I have a friend who complains about having two houses, the long flights on her luxury holidays etc. but she battles a serious health condition and has a horrible nasty bully for a husband.

curious79 · Today 17:47

Your ‘real problems’ are also trivial compared to someone living on a mud floor somewhere shit and war prone, who has lost all their family and has no safety net.

it’s not a race to the bottom and every person’s complaints need to be seen in context

godmum56 · Today 17:48

BMW6 · Today 16:58

You only know about the problems they talk about publicly.

No-one knows truly what any other person's life is like - most of us are trying to be like swans, appearing effortlessly elegant whilst paddling like fuck underneath.

absolutely this.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 17:48

Coconutter24 · Today 17:02

What was your last complaint about OP?

People not having "real" reasons to complain 😂😂😂

godmum56 · Today 17:49

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 17:48

People not having "real" reasons to complain 😂😂😂

lol.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:50

FirmSnake · Today 17:44

Poorer people moan about driveways and fences too though.
Perhaps they are just using their manners and not telling an acquaintance their biggest struggles.
Do you go around announcing that your granny has cancer? Or that you can't pay uour credit card bill this month? Or that your antidepressants aren't working? Probably not. But you might well whinge about the dishwasher or the weather. It's the same thing.

Of course poorer people complain about everyday inconveniences too. I’ve never suggested otherwise. I completely accept that people don’t necessarily disclose their most serious personal struggles to acquaintances.

My point isn’t that someone complaining about a driveway or a fence must therefore have nothing more serious going on in their life. It’s about the degree of importance attached to these things. There’s a difference between casually moaning about something being inconvenient and treating it as though it’s a significant hardship.

I’m not claiming to know everything going on in these people’s lives. I’m simply questioning the sense of proportion sometimes displayed when relatively trivial matters are discussed.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · Today 17:51

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:33

I’m not sure where you’ve got the idea that I think anyone needs to care about my opinion or that less affluent people are owed some sort of lip service. Neither is something I’ve suggested.

This is AIBU, a discussion forum where people express opinions and others are free to agree or disagree with them. That’s rather the point.

I’m perfectly entitled to find certain complaints disproportionate, just as others are entitled to make them. Nobody is being prevented from complaining about anything.

Surely the same logic applies to you? If you don’t like my opinion, you’re equally free not to engage with it.

Of course. I’m choosing to engage, obviously.

Where do I get the impression that you think people need to care? Because you seem to think of yourself as the arbiter of what constitutes something worthy of complaint or not. You also seem to be laboring under the illusion that not being ‘in touch’ with how you see the world is some sort of failing, moral and otherwise.

I grew up in a country that no longer exists, that collapsed into civil war. I narrowly avoided being blown into stewing meat at least twice. I don’t expect that to be important to other people, or feature in their thoughts at all. Nor do I compete in the hard-done-by Olympics by walking around whingeing because they may choose to complain about small parking spaces, or a bad haircut. Why shouldn’t they? Hell, why wouldn’t I?

Fluffyhats · Today 17:51

YANBU. My boss is absolutely minted, like inherited whole estates minted but she's also as thick as mince and the worst businesswoman you could ever meet. She likes to think she is "down with the kids" and often offers unsolicited advice. She is very aware that we have a disabled child and life is hard for us and we have nothing financially compared to her i.e. we can't ever go on holiday.

So it grates when she talks about only being able to go to her villa in Mykonos for 3 weeks over Christmas this year and not her usual 4.

Just Fuck off and read the room.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 17:53

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:50

Of course poorer people complain about everyday inconveniences too. I’ve never suggested otherwise. I completely accept that people don’t necessarily disclose their most serious personal struggles to acquaintances.

My point isn’t that someone complaining about a driveway or a fence must therefore have nothing more serious going on in their life. It’s about the degree of importance attached to these things. There’s a difference between casually moaning about something being inconvenient and treating it as though it’s a significant hardship.

I’m not claiming to know everything going on in these people’s lives. I’m simply questioning the sense of proportion sometimes displayed when relatively trivial matters are discussed.

Ah, but sometimes it's the little things that we share, because we can't do the big things.

A lot of these "affluent" people are living in credit, and whilst it's a choice they're making to live that lifestyle, it can be stressful. Especially if you're tied into mortgages or school fees, car hire or whatever and one gets made redundant.

Coconutter24 · Today 17:54

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:07

I’m sure I’ve complained about trivial things before, as most people have. The difference is that I can recognise when something is a minor inconvenience rather than a genuine problem. That’s rather the point of my OP.

But what you see as a minor inconvenience might be a real problem for someone else. I would actually see buying a house with a smaller drive as a problem, yeh it might be trivial but it would still be an issue and maybe a deciding factor for me.

Coconutter24 · Today 17:55

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 17:48

People not having "real" reasons to complain 😂😂😂

😂😂

FirmSnake · Today 17:55

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:50

Of course poorer people complain about everyday inconveniences too. I’ve never suggested otherwise. I completely accept that people don’t necessarily disclose their most serious personal struggles to acquaintances.

My point isn’t that someone complaining about a driveway or a fence must therefore have nothing more serious going on in their life. It’s about the degree of importance attached to these things. There’s a difference between casually moaning about something being inconvenient and treating it as though it’s a significant hardship.

I’m not claiming to know everything going on in these people’s lives. I’m simply questioning the sense of proportion sometimes displayed when relatively trivial matters are discussed.

Why must they not have anything more serious to going on in their lives? By that logic nobody should be allowed to moan about those things.
Who are you to them that they would be sharing "real" problems with you?

notspringingback · Today 17:55

By this token, surely no one can really complain about anything unless it’s life or death? Most problems are trivial (fortunately) and the more privileged someone is, the more trivial their problems are likely to be.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:56

InterIgnis · Today 17:51

Of course. I’m choosing to engage, obviously.

Where do I get the impression that you think people need to care? Because you seem to think of yourself as the arbiter of what constitutes something worthy of complaint or not. You also seem to be laboring under the illusion that not being ‘in touch’ with how you see the world is some sort of failing, moral and otherwise.

I grew up in a country that no longer exists, that collapsed into civil war. I narrowly avoided being blown into stewing meat at least twice. I don’t expect that to be important to other people, or feature in their thoughts at all. Nor do I compete in the hard-done-by Olympics by walking around whingeing because they may choose to complain about small parking spaces, or a bad haircut. Why shouldn’t they? Hell, why wouldn’t I?

I’m sorry you experienced that but I’m struggling to see how it contradicts anything I’ve actually said.

At no point have I suggested that I’m the arbiter of what people are allowed to complain about nor have I suggested that anyone should centre my worldview or personal experiences.

You’re repeatedly framing my argument as though I’m attempting to police what people are permitted to find frustrating, when I’m simply expressing an opinion about the disproportionate importance sometimes attached to relatively minor inconveniences.

I’m also not sure where the “hard-done-by Olympics” comes into this, given that I haven’t compared my personal hardships with anyone else’s.

People are perfectly entitled to complain about small parking spaces and bad haircuts. Equally, I’m entitled to find some of those complaints rather ridiculous, particularly when they’re presented as significant hardships.
Those two things can coexist.

OP posts:
LumieCake · Today 17:56

I live in an affluent area, and I can say that the majority of people here don't know that they are born and are extremely entitled. I also work at a University and in general, university staff are from a certain class. I came from an average background, didn't have luxuries but had a roof over my head. I had to work hard for a mortgage and this is the first time I have mixed with people from privileged backgrounds and it has been an eye opener and in truth it pisses me off. I have trivial issues too, but I stay quiet about them, as having been on the other side I know that people have real issues, like surviving in this world.

Cadenza12 · Today 17:57

I've a relative who doesn't believe that anyone in this country is hard up. Can't grasp the concept.

Brunchandcoke · Today 17:59

Can I complain about people posting ridiculous posts on MN or is that too trivial for you OP?

We would probably be considered fairly affluent so we obviously wouldn’t be complaining about issues caused by lack of money. Any other issues affect people irrespective of their wealth so YABU to suggest that affluent people don’t know what “real” problems are.

ColinISabirthdaycake · Today 17:59

I understand where you are coming from OP and I also think some people have no idea how the other half live.

In fact that applies in both directions - living on a council estate in inner city Bradford is not in my frame of reference. Neither is living in a £5 million house in Wimbledon.

People do complain about ridiculous things. And it's true that wealth insulates you from real issues while making other things seem massive.

If your drive is too small, get a smaller car.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Today 17:59

Person A - Our kitchen is too small.
Person B - Buy a big house then.

FirmSnake · Today 18:00

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Today 17:59

Person A - Our kitchen is too small.
Person B - Buy a big house then.

Person B is my mother 😂

ThatDeepGoose · Today 18:00

FirmSnake · Today 17:55

Why must they not have anything more serious to going on in their lives? By that logic nobody should be allowed to moan about those things.
Who are you to them that they would be sharing "real" problems with you?

I’ve literally just said that someone complaining about a driveway or fence doesn’t mean they have nothing more serious going on in their life.

I’m not asking anyone to share their personal struggles with me, nor am I suggesting they shouldn’t be allowed to complain about minor inconveniences.I’m questioning the degree of importance attached to those inconveniences, not demanding disclosure of people’s private lives.

I’m really not sure how much more clearly I can make that distinction.

OP posts:
ThatDeepGoose · Today 18:01

notspringingback · Today 17:55

By this token, surely no one can really complain about anything unless it’s life or death? Most problems are trivial (fortunately) and the more privileged someone is, the more trivial their problems are likely to be.

No, I don’t think something needs to be a matter of life or death to constitute a genuine problem. I actually agree with your final sentence. The more privileged someone’s circumstances, the more likely it is that some of their everyday frustrations will be relatively trivial.

I’m talking about perspective and proportion not whether people should be allowed to complain. There’s a difference between acknowledging that something is a minor inconvenience and treating it as though it’s a significant hardship. It’s the latter that I find rather absurd.

OP posts:
Nevs · Today 18:01

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:27

I haven’t suggested that affluent people shouldn’t be allowed to complain, nor that experiencing financial comfort means someone has never known hardship.

Your experience of growing up in poverty is entirely valid but it doesn’t negate the possibility that some affluent people can be rather out of touch. Yes, everything is relative, but that doesn’t mean every problem is equally significant or that we’re unable to distinguish between a minor inconvenience and genuine hardship.

I’m not suggesting someone should constantly compare their circumstances to those of people living in poverty before expressing frustration. I’m questioning the level of importance some people attach to relatively trivial matters. You can acknowledge that something is irritating without treating it as though it’s a major hardship.

but it doesn’t negate the possibility that some affluent people can be rather out of touch

But of course they are out of touch, why wouldn’t they be? I’d be suprised if they weren’t if they grew up affluent. As I said in my previous post everything is relative and it’s all they know. The fact you have taken time to post about this implies you believe this is some sort of character flaw, but I do not view it this way.

I’m questioning the level of importance some people attach to relatively trivial matters. You can acknowledge that something is irritating without treating it as though it’s a major hardship.

I’m curious how you differentiate a person treating something as a mild inconvenience, and major hardship. How do you measure this? Can you give examples? Because from your post, (the person complaining his mum cannot park her Range Rover on their now smaller driveway) I cannot see how the people you mention have treated such things as a “major hardship”. Can you elaborate?

FirmSnake · Today 18:02

ThatDeepGoose · Today 18:00

I’ve literally just said that someone complaining about a driveway or fence doesn’t mean they have nothing more serious going on in their life.

I’m not asking anyone to share their personal struggles with me, nor am I suggesting they shouldn’t be allowed to complain about minor inconveniences.I’m questioning the degree of importance attached to those inconveniences, not demanding disclosure of people’s private lives.

I’m really not sure how much more clearly I can make that distinction.

But what makes you think they attach enormous importance to these issues?
That it is what they choose to share with you doesn't actually mean they consider them to be massive issues. Unless you're their therapist perhaps.