Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some affluent people don’t know what real problems are?

68 replies

ThatDeepGoose · Today 16:53

I’ve lived in affluent areas and socialised with quite wealthy people over the years, and something I’ve noticed is how utterly trivial some of the things they complain about are.

For example, someone lamenting the fact that they’re buying a new house but the driveway is smaller than their current one, meaning their mother won’t be able to drive up in her Range Rover and fully open all her car doors so her dogs can get out and greet everyone.

Or people posting in local Facebook groups asking neighbours to change the materials of their garden fences because they’ve witnessed an incident involving a deer.

I just find myself thinking… people have real problems. These aren’t them.

I’m not suggesting that having money makes someone immune to illness, bereavement, relationship breakdowns or genuine hardship. Of course it doesn’t.

I do sometimes wonder whether living a particularly comfortable, privileged life can leave people so insulated from genuine hardship that relatively minor inconveniences start to feel like major problems.

I appreciate that everything is relative but sometimes I genuinely struggle to take these complaints seriously.

AIBU?

OP posts:
HermioneWeasley · Today 16:55

Viktor Frankl observed that misery is like a gas in that however much you have expands to fill its container.

he was reflecting on how trivial his pre Auschwitz problems were

Shelby33 · Today 16:58

I agree, I remember talking to someone when we had the last financial crisis. They said " I don't know what people are worried about, just shape at Iceland instead of M & S."

Oh and listening to two ladies chatting about their holidays and moaning about the long flights. " My husband has said no more long haul this year."

BMW6 · Today 16:58

You only know about the problems they talk about publicly.

No-one knows truly what any other person's life is like - most of us are trying to be like swans, appearing effortlessly elegant whilst paddling like fuck underneath.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · Today 17:00

That’s just what comes out in that moment though- sometimes I say something and think ‘where did that come from?’ Not affluent by the way but I think if you have an issue on a given day you should be able to air it, it’s not just the everyday person who gets to have gripes!!

Coconutter24 · Today 17:02

What was your last complaint about OP?

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Today 17:04

I'm down to my last seven bottles of olive oil . . . . 😐

Estepony · Today 17:04

If they’re claiming they’re on a par with serious problems, they ABU.

If they’re just chit chatting about things that irritate them, YABU.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:07

Coconutter24 · Today 17:02

What was your last complaint about OP?

I’m sure I’ve complained about trivial things before, as most people have. The difference is that I can recognise when something is a minor inconvenience rather than a genuine problem. That’s rather the point of my OP.

OP posts:
SoThatsTheWayItIs · Today 17:07

I’ve just spent an afternoon with friends not sure I would call us affluent but all of us have fairly stable well paid jobs. We all had a first world moan about something. I was whining about my £5k patio not being quite as well finished as I would like. I didn’t talk about the fact I had a biopsy on Tuesday and am waiting for results.

I also know for a fact one of the group is battling depression and most of the others are none the wiser.

Fairly certain people of all financial backgrounds have a whinge about pointless shit all the time not just affluent people.

ICanBuyMyselfFlowerz · Today 17:15

Ive just been made redundant, well about 6 weeks ago. It’s a bit crap. In my uni friend WhatsApp group, one of my mates, who I adore, was moaning that she had put her three rental properties up for sale and they just weren’t shifting. Meanwhile in the real world.

Ponderingwindow · Today 17:15

What makes you think they lack the perspective that these issues are trivial compared to issues of survival?

People talk about their day to day lives. That does not mean they do not understand the greater world around them

They may also only speak to you about socially acceptable things. Polite society says I can complain about my car shuffling situation due to the lumber from the remodel blocking my garage. People in real life tend to become uncomfortable about discussions of the trials and tribulations of living with health problems.

We pick topics of conversation that are light and easy. That does not mean our lives are light and easy.

InterIgnis · Today 17:20

And your problems pale in comparison to those of someone living in a shanty town. Presumably you don’t centre those people and their problems in your day to day life, so why do you expect other people to centre you and yours?

People focus on what’s relevant to them, and that doesn’t look the same for everyone. It doesn’t have to.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:21

Ponderingwindow · Today 17:15

What makes you think they lack the perspective that these issues are trivial compared to issues of survival?

People talk about their day to day lives. That does not mean they do not understand the greater world around them

They may also only speak to you about socially acceptable things. Polite society says I can complain about my car shuffling situation due to the lumber from the remodel blocking my garage. People in real life tend to become uncomfortable about discussions of the trials and tribulations of living with health problems.

We pick topics of conversation that are light and easy. That does not mean our lives are light and easy.

I don’t disagree that people discuss everyday inconveniences nor am I suggesting that wealthy people don’t experience genuine hardship behind closed doors. I’m talking more about the level of importance and distress attached to some of these things, rather than simply the fact that they’re mentioned.

There’s a difference between casually saying something is mildly annoying and genuinely lamenting something as though it’s a significant problem. While I accept that people may have struggles I’m unaware of, I also don’t think it’s unreasonable to suggest that considerable financial comfort can sometimes distort someone’s sense of perspective.

OP posts:
Nevs · Today 17:22

ThatDeepGoose · Today 16:53

I’ve lived in affluent areas and socialised with quite wealthy people over the years, and something I’ve noticed is how utterly trivial some of the things they complain about are.

For example, someone lamenting the fact that they’re buying a new house but the driveway is smaller than their current one, meaning their mother won’t be able to drive up in her Range Rover and fully open all her car doors so her dogs can get out and greet everyone.

Or people posting in local Facebook groups asking neighbours to change the materials of their garden fences because they’ve witnessed an incident involving a deer.

I just find myself thinking… people have real problems. These aren’t them.

I’m not suggesting that having money makes someone immune to illness, bereavement, relationship breakdowns or genuine hardship. Of course it doesn’t.

I do sometimes wonder whether living a particularly comfortable, privileged life can leave people so insulated from genuine hardship that relatively minor inconveniences start to feel like major problems.

I appreciate that everything is relative but sometimes I genuinely struggle to take these complaints seriously.

AIBU?

I am Russian and grew up in poverty. I now live in the UK, and have a well paid profession.

Funnily enough I drive a Range Rover and have also complained about where I can or can’t park it. I know what real struggles are, me complaining about things that affect my present day to day life does not mean I’m out of touch.

As for people who grew up financially stable, I also wouldn’t can’t blame them for complaining about what you consider trivial things. To an extent it’s all they know, and it’s their reality which they live. This doesn’t make them bad people, or that they mean to come across tone deaf. Just because there are others that live a more frugal way of life, doesn’t mean they don’t have a right to let off steam. Everything is relative, would you say to an average earner in the UK that they shouldn’t complain because people are starving in Africa?

HardShoulders · Today 17:25

People not upholstered by wealth complain all the time on here about things I wouldn’t give a second thought to. It’s not a wealth thing.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:25

InterIgnis · Today 17:20

And your problems pale in comparison to those of someone living in a shanty town. Presumably you don’t centre those people and their problems in your day to day life, so why do you expect other people to centre you and yours?

People focus on what’s relevant to them, and that doesn’t look the same for everyone. It doesn’t have to.

Where have I suggested that anyone should centre me or my problems?

Of course there are people whose circumstances are significantly worse than mine and I’m perfectly capable of acknowledging that without dismissing my own difficulties.

My point isn’t that people aren’t allowed to complain about everyday inconveniences. It’s about the degree of importance some people attach to them, particularly when they’re living in considerable comfort.

There’s a difference between recognising something as a minor annoyance and treating it as though it’s a significant hardship.

OP posts:
ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:27

Nevs · Today 17:22

I am Russian and grew up in poverty. I now live in the UK, and have a well paid profession.

Funnily enough I drive a Range Rover and have also complained about where I can or can’t park it. I know what real struggles are, me complaining about things that affect my present day to day life does not mean I’m out of touch.

As for people who grew up financially stable, I also wouldn’t can’t blame them for complaining about what you consider trivial things. To an extent it’s all they know, and it’s their reality which they live. This doesn’t make them bad people, or that they mean to come across tone deaf. Just because there are others that live a more frugal way of life, doesn’t mean they don’t have a right to let off steam. Everything is relative, would you say to an average earner in the UK that they shouldn’t complain because people are starving in Africa?

Edited

I haven’t suggested that affluent people shouldn’t be allowed to complain, nor that experiencing financial comfort means someone has never known hardship.

Your experience of growing up in poverty is entirely valid but it doesn’t negate the possibility that some affluent people can be rather out of touch. Yes, everything is relative, but that doesn’t mean every problem is equally significant or that we’re unable to distinguish between a minor inconvenience and genuine hardship.

I’m not suggesting someone should constantly compare their circumstances to those of people living in poverty before expressing frustration. I’m questioning the level of importance some people attach to relatively trivial matters. You can acknowledge that something is irritating without treating it as though it’s a major hardship.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · Today 17:28

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:25

Where have I suggested that anyone should centre me or my problems?

Of course there are people whose circumstances are significantly worse than mine and I’m perfectly capable of acknowledging that without dismissing my own difficulties.

My point isn’t that people aren’t allowed to complain about everyday inconveniences. It’s about the degree of importance some people attach to them, particularly when they’re living in considerable comfort.

There’s a difference between recognising something as a minor annoyance and treating it as though it’s a significant hardship.

Why do you think anyone else needs to care about what you think they should be allowed to consider important and complain about, and/or what lip service you think those less affluent are owed?

If you don’t like what people complain another then don’t engage in conversation with them. Or log off.

Iwishicouldflyhigh · Today 17:29

We are probably’affluent’ but I wouldn’t consider those problems. Driveways are a consideration though (ours is small!)

sausageth · Today 17:29

Nevs · Today 17:22

I am Russian and grew up in poverty. I now live in the UK, and have a well paid profession.

Funnily enough I drive a Range Rover and have also complained about where I can or can’t park it. I know what real struggles are, me complaining about things that affect my present day to day life does not mean I’m out of touch.

As for people who grew up financially stable, I also wouldn’t can’t blame them for complaining about what you consider trivial things. To an extent it’s all they know, and it’s their reality which they live. This doesn’t make them bad people, or that they mean to come across tone deaf. Just because there are others that live a more frugal way of life, doesn’t mean they don’t have a right to let off steam. Everything is relative, would you say to an average earner in the UK that they shouldn’t complain because people are starving in Africa?

Edited

Yes, this is what I was thinking. It's all they know. What does the OP expect them to do about it? Yes you can be sensitive about what you complain about, but someone will always have it worse somewhere. Something trivial to one person may be quite big to another because of their lifestyle differences.

All you can really do is knows your audience and sometimes you don't.

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:33

InterIgnis · Today 17:28

Why do you think anyone else needs to care about what you think they should be allowed to consider important and complain about, and/or what lip service you think those less affluent are owed?

If you don’t like what people complain another then don’t engage in conversation with them. Or log off.

I’m not sure where you’ve got the idea that I think anyone needs to care about my opinion or that less affluent people are owed some sort of lip service. Neither is something I’ve suggested.

This is AIBU, a discussion forum where people express opinions and others are free to agree or disagree with them. That’s rather the point.

I’m perfectly entitled to find certain complaints disproportionate, just as others are entitled to make them. Nobody is being prevented from complaining about anything.

Surely the same logic applies to you? If you don’t like my opinion, you’re equally free not to engage with it.

OP posts:
BillieWiper · Today 17:35

Wouldn't you rather live in an area where most people are happy and things they think are issues seem trivial? Rather than there being murders, gangs, burglaries, overdoses being discussed?

ThatDeepGoose · Today 17:40

BillieWiper · Today 17:35

Wouldn't you rather live in an area where most people are happy and things they think are issues seem trivial? Rather than there being murders, gangs, burglaries, overdoses being discussed?

Edited

Of course I’d rather live somewhere safe and relatively peaceful. I’m not sure why the alternative to people complaining about trivial inconveniences has to be murders, gangs and overdoses.

I can appreciate the benefits of living in an affluent area while simultaneously finding some of the things people complain about rather absurd. The two aren’t mutually exclusive. In fact, that’s partly my point. Some people are fortunate enough to live in circumstances where relatively minor inconveniences become their biggest grievances.

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · Today 17:40

I once worked with a man who had his sunglasses stolen from his car and described it as putting him in a bad mood (which resulted in him behaving badly to me) and he said we’d both gone through things. I’d been in hospital having emergency abdominal surgery (from which I had a very long recovery). He’d lost sunglasses.sone people are just a bit lacking in empathy.

Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 17:42

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Today 17:04

I'm down to my last seven bottles of olive oil . . . . 😐

I’ll have to fly over to the Mediterranean to “source “ some more 🤣