Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

467 replies

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:17

I'm American, DH is British and we've lived in England for nearly 10 years now, we came back after Trump, I am from Georgia, which has now turned blue!! We do plan to go back once all children are finished with education/at university. All 3 of our children were born in the states, have dual citizenship so can go to university in either country.

Our eldest DS is due to start university next September, although he's still undecided whether to go straight away or take a gap year. He's interested in Economics and Maths and has applied to several universities through UCAS, choosing slightly different courses at each but all along those lines. He's already had offers from most of them and is currently preparing for his Cambridge interview.As he's our eldest, we've never been through any of this before. I've only really started looking into student finance over the last couple of years, especially with all the news about Plan 2 loans, interest, repayment thresholds and people wanting loans written off.

DH and I have been going back and forth about whether to let him take out a student loan or just pay the tuition fees ourselves. DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off? I'm looking at it quite differently, probably because I'm American. I actually came to university in the UK myself because my parents worked out that even paying international student fees here was cheaper than going to an American university.

When I told my parents how much home student fees are here, they genuinely couldn't believe it. To them it's pennies, I do understand that is a privilege. They've now said they would happily just pay the tuition fees for all our children themselves rather than have them take out loans.For context, my brother's children go to a private day school in America where fees are approaching $100k each per year, and he's already planning for them to come to university in the UK because of how much cheaper it is.

I've also spoken to a few parents at DS's school and some seem to be planning on paying their children's fees outright, some are undecided. One mum I spoke to has an eldest son who finished university about seven years ago. She said she wishes they'd just paid his fees at the time rather than let him take out SFE. He's got a decent job straight out of university, and she said seeing how much was coming out of his salary between tax, NI and student loan repayments was quite an eye opener. His parents eventually decided to pay off the remaining loan for him.

I do understand that student loans here aren't like normal loans and that plenty of people never pay them off in full. But if you can afford to pay the fees without it affecting your finances, surely that makes more sense, even more so now. DH thinks I'm looking at this through my American upbringing and not understanding how the UK system works. Maybe he's right!

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?
Interested to hear from people who've actually been through this, especially those with older children who've graduated and you either paid or took our the tuition fees loans?

OP posts:
PerfectPaula · Yesterday 20:09

We paid all four of ours.

AliTheMinx · Yesterday 20:12

We have one child and are hoping to pay everything for him to avoid loans/debts.

RecalcitrantRow · Yesterday 20:15

MyManinCaracas · Yesterday 13:18

In fairness to the OP her question would never cause so much vitriol with other Americans. She wouldn’t be seen as boasting or lol “ghastly” because we don’t have tall poppy syndrome. And Americans are largely unaware that there is vast poverty in the U.K. - it’s just lack of awareness, not anything evil or deliberately tone deaf.

Even after living here for nearly a decade? That’s quite a lack of awareness.

Gonners · Yesterday 20:16

To state the bleeding obvious, I think what all this boils down to is that if you can afford to pay for it and want to pay for it, then do. If you can't, then don't. In between, maybe contribute what you can.

Am I being unreasonable or perhaps just too sensible?

XenoBitch · Yesterday 20:17

If you can afford it then go right ahead.
But to say the fees are cheap is just tone deaf.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · Yesterday 20:19

I agree. A year of tuition is similar to a single twrm
at private school. I will pay my kids' fees.

DearCrab · Yesterday 20:33

indianaboys · Yesterday 16:03

Hi OP, have not read a lot of the flaming above; to me just illustrates the difference between US where success and affluence are nothing to be ashamed of, and a particular kind of UK approach! We live in quite an international area and most kids we knew with a US passport went to the US for college. There are just so many more opportunities and the graduate market here is incredibly tough. I can see an Oxbridge offer is tempting though or somewhere else super prestigious.

our kids aren’t in that position, but we are paying their uni fees and reasonable expenses (still expected to get holiday jobs etc)

I think there is a stark difference. My parents and DHs parents are very different in terms of discussing money or just acknowledging that you are well off. I don’t believe acknowledging that means that I don’t know my privilege it is why I can acknowledge it. it’s two different culture with lots of differences. We don’t live in the US anymore but growing up there I had friends who’s parents sold their houses and grandparents, dipped into pensions etc just for them to go to college in the states and saw that as an investment into their children in hopes they get a return from the investment and they do. The salaries there in comparison to here are insane, for instance nurses can make a lot of money there but here nurses aren’t really seen as valuable enough to be making a lot but then again you have the NHS which we don’t have. If you don’t have good health insurance which is often tied to having a good job then you just have to hope your health is in top shape.

I do agree US has a lot more opportunities if you can get your foot the door and are surrounded by people who know the system. A lot of college finances is based on household income if you get the grades you can go to Yale/Havard full ride but it’s also about knowing you’d like to attend Yale from a young age and having all the extras etc. I think with the student loan system here you can come from a low socioeconomic background and end up at a good university like Oxford that opened door (I know there’s a graduate unemployment crisis currently) but as a history universities like Oxford Cambridge open lots more doors. I was never Oxford or Cambridge material so never looked into that. My sister was but she wanted to stay and study in the US and so our parents sold what they could, mum dipped into her pension and my sister got through 4 years at college and then went to med school and now a neurosurgeon. To my parents that investment paid off and she’s given them back every single cent (and more) it cost them to get her through school. To them it was worth it but also they were in a good enough position to be able to sacrifice such things. Not every family can but it’s not rare to hear families having to sell houses dip into pensions, crowdfund, my parents church crowdfunded for my sister too when she got into med school. Again we lived in a town in Georgia where everyone new each other and wanted to help each other if they could in certain communities.

OP posts:
Dublassie · Yesterday 20:37

As an aside the fees in Ireland are amazing . My daughter has just graduated with a degree in Veterinary Medicine that cost us 12,500 euro in total . SUCH a privilege .
We were just chatting about this the other day - how the US perpetuates both wealth and poverty through the ridiculous fees for education. Dreadful system that I would hate to be part of .
OP back to you - I think your question is a bit silly .If you can afford to pay , just pay . Or get your mum and dad to pay or whatever . But surely you understand that MANY are not able to do this????

Butchyrestingface · Yesterday 20:39

DearCrab · Yesterday 14:10

I do not understand the uproar? I haven't been snarky or nasty at all. I have simply explained my own experience. MN allows for all experiences, not my intention to cause an uproar or 'rage bait' I think some are taking it too personally despite me not saying anything in realms of nasty or rudeness towards them. I wanted to hear other parents views I have said from the get go with are very privileged, so if we are privileged does that mean I cannot post on mumsnet? I am not boasting, some think I am but that is not the case at all you are just making an assumption and adding tone that is not there genuinely. If you genuinely dislike the post and it has made you that angry or upset you are able to not look at the post. This topic has been in the news recently especially now with Burnham stating that he would like for EU students to have home status fees as low as 9K instead of 30k for some. Its an ongoing topic with the state of the country at the minute. I have even said I am all for free education, I do believe everyone should have the opportunity to study at university if they would like to. The UK is still better than the states in terms of access and price, not sure why that is such a radical take? its simply just facts it is cheaper to study here. I am not saying every parent will think its cheaper, I am purely stating that by cost it is cheaper that is all even for international students its cheaper to come here and other European countries than study in the US

Because your posts are breathtakingly tone deaf.

You admit you are privileged yet came on here and started a thread entitled

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

Isn't it obvious to you that most people can't AFFORD to because they are not in your cosy financial situation? And even if they were, they might think twice about spunking £££ on university related fees when so many young graduates are struggling even to get min wage entry level roles.

Imagine if I started a thread asking why don't people just wear Dior Air Jordan 1 sneakers instead of Tesco standard issue, because they're soooo much more comfortable and stylish. Good taste post?

DearCrab · Yesterday 20:40

PoppetDog · Yesterday 16:54

She didn't say it was "comparatively cheaper" in her question though. She said it was "so cheap". There's a difference - and that's what's pissed people off.

I apologise for my choice of words but I did mean it in the literal fact. Higher education is cheaper here than it is in the states. Home student fees are even the same for every single university whether you attend Cambridge or Bristol. In the states that’s not how it works. This system is new to me, I studied here as an interview student, a while back but even then it was cheaper for me to come here and study History at a reputable university than at home. I wanted to attend a good university not go to community college. I would have loved to have studied in the states but my sister also wanted to attend med school in the states so I chose to come here so my parents could focus on making sure she got through med school.

Once again sorry for my choice of words. I have explained a few time what I meant more just in the comparison sense not meaning that it’s so cheap every single person should be able to afford it. Just that £10k a year compared to some of the universities our son would have loved to attend in the uk they’re ranging from £75k to 110k per years. I also stated that middle class families in the states are very different to here there’s just lots of stat differences. I digress, neither was meant to offend anyone or state that every single person in the uk should be able to afford it. Wrong choices or words my fault.

OP posts:
AmethystDeceiver · Yesterday 20:41

DearCrab · Yesterday 20:40

I apologise for my choice of words but I did mean it in the literal fact. Higher education is cheaper here than it is in the states. Home student fees are even the same for every single university whether you attend Cambridge or Bristol. In the states that’s not how it works. This system is new to me, I studied here as an interview student, a while back but even then it was cheaper for me to come here and study History at a reputable university than at home. I wanted to attend a good university not go to community college. I would have loved to have studied in the states but my sister also wanted to attend med school in the states so I chose to come here so my parents could focus on making sure she got through med school.

Once again sorry for my choice of words. I have explained a few time what I meant more just in the comparison sense not meaning that it’s so cheap every single person should be able to afford it. Just that £10k a year compared to some of the universities our son would have loved to attend in the uk they’re ranging from £75k to 110k per years. I also stated that middle class families in the states are very different to here there’s just lots of stat differences. I digress, neither was meant to offend anyone or state that every single person in the uk should be able to afford it. Wrong choices or words my fault.

you don't get it

you're 'here' not 'there'.

read the room

DearCrab · Yesterday 20:46

Butchyrestingface · Yesterday 20:39

Because your posts are breathtakingly tone deaf.

You admit you are privileged yet came on here and started a thread entitled

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

Isn't it obvious to you that most people can't AFFORD to because they are not in your cosy financial situation? And even if they were, they might think twice about spunking £££ on university related fees when so many young graduates are struggling even to get min wage entry level roles.

Imagine if I started a thread asking why don't people just wear Dior Air Jordan 1 sneakers instead of Tesco standard issue, because they're soooo much more comfortable and stylish. Good taste post?

But I don’t think I’ve said “why don’t people pay it” ? I’m slightly confused. I just many it in comparison cost wise without looking at the other factors at play 10k a year I believe is incredibly cheap compared to 75k a year plus for universities in the states with the same stature as universities here. That is all. Sorry for the choice of wording at the start I have accepted I should I have worded it better/differrently. As I said it’s been a topic in the news quite a lot recently comparing plan 2 and plan 5 and our son will hopefully start university so I’ve taken an interest that’s all. I don’t believe you’re required to have a certain socioeconomic status to post on here it’s just my experience and it’s not superior to anyone else’s everyone experience is very valid. I do however think if my post is making people quite upset they are able to disengage as I didn’t come to argue. I just wanted to hear from parents who are debating on tuition fees or not. I’m coming at it from a very different angle and I suppose culture. I didn’t grow here so I haven’t seen the fees go up the way some have. I grew up in a place where fees have always just been quite high in comparison that’s all. I do believe higher education should be accessible for all no matter their background. I can’t keep apologising I’ve said my choice or wording was wrong that’s all I can do now.

OP posts:
DearCrab · Yesterday 20:48

AmethystDeceiver · Yesterday 20:41

you don't get it

you're 'here' not 'there'.

read the room

I don’t get the uproar I have said the choice is wording is wrong. I think it’s hard at times to convey in writing what you’re trying to get at. I have apologise for the wording choice I can’t turn back time and change the wording choice.

OP posts:
DearCrab · Yesterday 20:49

RecalcitrantRow · Yesterday 20:15

Even after living here for nearly a decade? That’s quite a lack of awareness.

We do live around lots of Americans and our children’s school has lots of Americans that could be why albeit I did attend university here. Even back then Edinburgh had lots of Americans maybe not as much as St Andrews but still a fair few.

OP posts:
PeloMom · Yesterday 20:50

Haven’t read the full thread. I had student loans including maintenance loans. Initially wasn’t in a very well paid job but after 3-4 yrs moved jobs and my pay increased 50%. After another 2 yrs I was offered transfer to the USA- at that point had about 50-60% of my total loan balance outstanding (wasn’t on the high interest plan thankfully). I had to inform SLF about the transfer/ moving abroad and my payments jumped massively - I’m telling you this in case your kids decide to get loans in the UK and then go work in the US for better money. If I were you, I’d just pay the loans off. I believe now the repayment time increased from 20 to 25 yrs? So likely they’ll end up repaying them.(Not sure, I believe I read that somewhere).

Butchyrestingface · Yesterday 20:51

DearCrab · Yesterday 20:46

But I don’t think I’ve said “why don’t people pay it” ? I’m slightly confused. I just many it in comparison cost wise without looking at the other factors at play 10k a year I believe is incredibly cheap compared to 75k a year plus for universities in the states with the same stature as universities here. That is all. Sorry for the choice of wording at the start I have accepted I should I have worded it better/differrently. As I said it’s been a topic in the news quite a lot recently comparing plan 2 and plan 5 and our son will hopefully start university so I’ve taken an interest that’s all. I don’t believe you’re required to have a certain socioeconomic status to post on here it’s just my experience and it’s not superior to anyone else’s everyone experience is very valid. I do however think if my post is making people quite upset they are able to disengage as I didn’t come to argue. I just wanted to hear from parents who are debating on tuition fees or not. I’m coming at it from a very different angle and I suppose culture. I didn’t grow here so I haven’t seen the fees go up the way some have. I grew up in a place where fees have always just been quite high in comparison that’s all. I do believe higher education should be accessible for all no matter their background. I can’t keep apologising I’ve said my choice or wording was wrong that’s all I can do now.

Nobody has suggested you're required to have a certain socioeconomic status to post here. Attempting to portray yourself as being victimised on the basis of your privilege isn't terribly attractive.

You should certainly be more mindful of what you post given how this extremely unwise thread has - very predictably - been received. But it's obvious you just don't get it.

DearCrab · Yesterday 20:55

Butchyrestingface · Yesterday 20:51

Nobody has suggested you're required to have a certain socioeconomic status to post here. Attempting to portray yourself as being victimised on the basis of your privilege isn't terribly attractive.

You should certainly be more mindful of what you post given how this extremely unwise thread has - very predictably - been received. But it's obvious you just don't get it.

Not victimising myself at all. I’ve said I was in the wrong with my wording choice it wasn’t what I was trying to convey. Essentially what I was trying to say was “10k a year is far cheaper that 75k a year” at least I think that is a big difference. You don’t get to got Harvard or Yale for 10k a year but my son has the possibility of attending Cambridge for 10k a year if he gets an offer after interview. That’s all to me I believe it’s quite a stark difference even how for home students every university is the same price…that’s not the case in the states. There isn’t a universal price for all universities for home students.

OP posts:
pinck · Yesterday 20:58

BerryTwister · Yesterday 09:48

Mind-blowing tone deafness OP. Just because you come from an incredibly rich family, it doesn’t mean that the rest of us have a spare £50k just sitting in a bank account!

But actually, in many cases, even if there is some spare money knocking around, it can make more sense to get what is actually an extremely cheap loan.

I’ve added a screenshot of my son’s repayment schedule. Even if he earns £40,000, he’ll only pay £104/month on his loan. If I had had £50k spare, I think it would have made more sense to give it to him as a deposit for a house when he’s older, rather than save him from getting a cheap loan.

Obviously if there is infinite money, then of course you wouldn’t bother with a loan. But for most of us there’s no choice, and the sensible option is often to save any spare cash for other things.

“Mind-blowing tone deafness” is a bit much. My grandparents spent upwards of $1 million putting me and my eight cousins through college, and my parents plan to do the same for the next generation. I’m American as well, so I’m talking about the costs and loans we actually deal with here. If my kid could graduate owing $200,000 or graduate debt-free because we could afford to help, why the hell would I choose the debt? He’ll have an easier time saving for a house if he can put his paycheck toward a deposit from day one.

If your son’s loan costs him £104 a month and you’d rather put spare cash toward a house deposit, fair enough and if a family can’t afford the fees, they have absolutely nothing to feel guilty about. The OP asked whether parents who can afford it should pay. That’s a perfectly reasonable question, and in my family the answer is yes.

MadMumOfTwoHorrors · Yesterday 21:00

We are paying for our son’s fees and accommodation, but I appreciate most people aren’t in a position to do that. It’s almost £19k a year for both so it’s a big decision. Obviously if you live near the university they want to go to, you don’t have accommodation on top, but lots of kids don’t want to be in their own town.
Luckily our other son is doing an apprenticeship, so his tuition is paid for by his employer.

Boreded · Yesterday 21:03

EvieBB · Yesterday 17:42

I understand that it's still better to pay over the longer term as it's only a percentage of anything above the threshold (this is what my DS tells me and she had 2 DD's that finished uni about 7 years back)

Depends on how long you pay and how much you earn.

Adding a screenshot for a guide (picture incoming). But basically a middle income earner at 50k would pay 90k on a 50k loan and never repay it.

At 30k a year on the same loan you would get it written off after paying only £18k

But even someone earning 70k will pay £70k overall on the loan, 20k more than they borrowed.

This is all based on current rates and a flat salary so not fully representative but it’s the simplest way to look at it.

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?
FramboiseFraise · Yesterday 21:07

UK IS cheap compared to US. UK is also a low salary country compared to US so for a lot of people it is unaffordable.

We have fully funded ours through university because we didn't want them lumbered with debt for life and we can afford it.

MN is weird about this and many things money related. It is stuffed full of women allegedly earning over £100k, yet able to hang out here half the day, while also paradoxically competitive about being far too poor to support their children to graduate without debt.

MotherofTeenDragons · Yesterday 21:08

Do you actually think most families have a spare £10k a year? USA salaries are much higher than here - my friend is a PA in Texas - £90k a year salary - whereas a PA here is on £35-40k. And housing costs more.

My brother works in Canada but his company is run from Denver where they pay those doing his job more than twice what he earns. Canadian salaries are similar to ours.

Boreded · Yesterday 21:13

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 20:01

"Better off", yes, but not if a position says you need X degree to be considered for a role, which is probably what prospective students are basing their course decisions on. (Doing your coaches' badges in football costs huge amounts of money once you get to UEFA C level and above, and you have to start somewhere even to get to that point...)

UEFA C is £650, and it’s less than that if you are in grassroots. You don’t even need it to coach at that level.

UEFA B is only £1250, you don’t need that until semi professional, most coaches aren’t doing this because they’re in grassroots.

UEFA A is a little more expensive at £4150 but that isn’t needed until professional academy level or senior professional - your club will pay for that

And if you need UEFA Pro then you won’t care about the £14k price tag (which is still only half the cost of a degree) because you’re an EFL or Premier League manager and your club is paying for it.

But you see how at least with these you can see the level progression before you need to get them. Professional footballers are often put through them at the expense of their clubs, and move into coaching in the leagues. But regular coaches don’t need them to the top level, and the levels they do need are inexpensive. The coaches I know are both at grassroots and do have UEFA B even though it isn’t required because their organisation paid for it for them and it was a short course to complete.

Boreded · Yesterday 21:19

DearCrab · Yesterday 20:48

I don’t get the uproar I have said the choice is wording is wrong. I think it’s hard at times to convey in writing what you’re trying to get at. I have apologise for the wording choice I can’t turn back time and change the wording choice.

You need to stop apologising, you did nothing wrong, people are raging because they’re read the title and didn’t bother reading the rest of the post where you fully explain the dilemma.

Too many people want to police who posts on mumsnet. And it splits off into two groups, the benefits bashers and those who hate anyone who has a little more than them.

You’ve asked a question about what to do and whether to pay the fees. Those who are in the same position can give their opinion on that. Those who have had to pay their own and now have loans can also give their opinion on that. Those who had their fees paid by parents can give their opinion on that.

There are such a wide spectrum of people who could offer help here from different perspectives, ignore the haters who are jealous that they don’t have wealthy family who can pay this for them. They need to just move along instead of tearing strips off you to make themselves feel better.

Boreded · Yesterday 21:22

Butchyrestingface · Yesterday 20:39

Because your posts are breathtakingly tone deaf.

You admit you are privileged yet came on here and started a thread entitled

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

Isn't it obvious to you that most people can't AFFORD to because they are not in your cosy financial situation? And even if they were, they might think twice about spunking £££ on university related fees when so many young graduates are struggling even to get min wage entry level roles.

Imagine if I started a thread asking why don't people just wear Dior Air Jordan 1 sneakers instead of Tesco standard issue, because they're soooo much more comfortable and stylish. Good taste post?

What an unnecessarily unpleasant response.

The OP hasn’t suggested that everyone can afford to pay their children’s university fees. She’s asking whether, for those who can afford to do so, paying the fees upfront might be a better financial decision than allowing their children to accumulate tens of thousands of pounds of debt.

Acknowledging that some people are in a more fortunate financial position than others doesn’t mean they should be prohibited from discussing their finances or asking questions about the decisions they make.

And your comparison with designer trainers is frankly ridiculous. We’re talking about the financial implications of student loans, interest and potentially 40 years of repayments, not whether someone should buy expensive shoes.

Ironically, your point about graduates struggling to secure well-paid employment actually strengthens the argument for considering whether avoiding student debt is worthwhile.

You can recognise that not everyone has the same financial opportunities without being openly hostile towards someone who does have them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread