Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

467 replies

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:17

I'm American, DH is British and we've lived in England for nearly 10 years now, we came back after Trump, I am from Georgia, which has now turned blue!! We do plan to go back once all children are finished with education/at university. All 3 of our children were born in the states, have dual citizenship so can go to university in either country.

Our eldest DS is due to start university next September, although he's still undecided whether to go straight away or take a gap year. He's interested in Economics and Maths and has applied to several universities through UCAS, choosing slightly different courses at each but all along those lines. He's already had offers from most of them and is currently preparing for his Cambridge interview.As he's our eldest, we've never been through any of this before. I've only really started looking into student finance over the last couple of years, especially with all the news about Plan 2 loans, interest, repayment thresholds and people wanting loans written off.

DH and I have been going back and forth about whether to let him take out a student loan or just pay the tuition fees ourselves. DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off? I'm looking at it quite differently, probably because I'm American. I actually came to university in the UK myself because my parents worked out that even paying international student fees here was cheaper than going to an American university.

When I told my parents how much home student fees are here, they genuinely couldn't believe it. To them it's pennies, I do understand that is a privilege. They've now said they would happily just pay the tuition fees for all our children themselves rather than have them take out loans.For context, my brother's children go to a private day school in America where fees are approaching $100k each per year, and he's already planning for them to come to university in the UK because of how much cheaper it is.

I've also spoken to a few parents at DS's school and some seem to be planning on paying their children's fees outright, some are undecided. One mum I spoke to has an eldest son who finished university about seven years ago. She said she wishes they'd just paid his fees at the time rather than let him take out SFE. He's got a decent job straight out of university, and she said seeing how much was coming out of his salary between tax, NI and student loan repayments was quite an eye opener. His parents eventually decided to pay off the remaining loan for him.

I do understand that student loans here aren't like normal loans and that plenty of people never pay them off in full. But if you can afford to pay the fees without it affecting your finances, surely that makes more sense, even more so now. DH thinks I'm looking at this through my American upbringing and not understanding how the UK system works. Maybe he's right!

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?
Interested to hear from people who've actually been through this, especially those with older children who've graduated and you either paid or took our the tuition fees loans?

OP posts:
indianaboys · Yesterday 16:03

Hi OP, have not read a lot of the flaming above; to me just illustrates the difference between US where success and affluence are nothing to be ashamed of, and a particular kind of UK approach! We live in quite an international area and most kids we knew with a US passport went to the US for college. There are just so many more opportunities and the graduate market here is incredibly tough. I can see an Oxbridge offer is tempting though or somewhere else super prestigious.

our kids aren’t in that position, but we are paying their uni fees and reasonable expenses (still expected to get holiday jobs etc)

seahorsessky · Yesterday 16:08

Thirteenblackcats · Yesterday 09:20

My colleague graduated in 2020 with £50000 debt. Sure cheap if you can afford it

I took it as a wind-up, because most of us don't consider it cheap. If you do OP, well ok, but American uni is cheaper for low income families, in some cases, according to Americans I've met. When the UK government first brought in fees, didn't they say some unis would be £3K? And surely it should be possible to provide an online degree, with decent teaching, for far less than £9K?

SockGene · Yesterday 16:12

PinkBottle75 · Yesterday 15:04

But it does feel really cheap compared to the USA! it's $100k per year there. £10k feels cheap

That's a 90% discount...

You could say that about anything because there’s always something more expensive. That in itself doesn’t make it cheap. A £50 million yacht isn’t cheap because there are £200 million yachts. But yes I guess they are all cheap if you have very deep pockets.

OneNewLeader · Yesterday 16:14

I think if you can afford to, why not?
I’ve also tried to put away money for my children, I just don’t earn a lot, so the amounts were modest. So in principle terms I’m no different to a US parent, except I wouldn’t sell my flat to fund their education.

Wadsworthy · Yesterday 16:17

DearCrab · Yesterday 11:55

Literally this. We have friends still in the states who laughed when I told them the fees here. My friends are still shocked at the thought that our son could get the opportunity to study at Cambridge for 10k as we told them he was applying.

I do understand that thinking 10k for home student fees is cheap but in comparison it is just a fact. Higher education is just cheaper here. I think people are under the assumption that just because I am saying it is cheap in comparison to the states, that I think everyone can afford it. It is just a fact that higher education is cheaper here.

I should have added, that I don't think UK parents realise how cheap a world class university education is in the UK for domestic undergrads. And I don't think they value it.

The degrees are not differentiated by cost, as they are for international students.

And in international/global rankings, the best UK universities punch way above their weight. My own discipline at my institution is in the top 50 in the world.

Although given attitudes I read regularly on MN, and the current binfire of UK university finances - because the tuition fee people complain about does not cover the costs of even the so-called "cheapest" undergrad degrees - I'm not sure how much longer we'll be able to be proud of the UK HE system. IT is one of the best in the world, and UK citizens & governments seem intent on throwing it away.

PutYourSpecsOnJean · Yesterday 16:25

DearCrab · Yesterday 12:12

10K to study degrees such as medicine is still fascinating to me, let alone the European countries that have free education for their citizens. We are in the process of working out the costs for rent and other living expenses, depending on how we decide to go about everything. My parents have been kind enough to offer to cover the tuition fees and if he gets into Cambridge, they are willing to pay all 4 years tuition fees for him up front. I think each college is different on how self funded tuition fees can be paid, he is only at interview stage so we will have to wait. It depends on what University he decides to attend. This is also impacted by the fact that he has an interview at Cambridge, he did not expect that and Cambridge isn't the cheapest city.

We have been saving and investing for all three since they were little so there is money put aside. Same was we were able to give him money for his driving lessons and now he has passed. Our son works part time in a supermarket and has done so since he was 16 and he saved up for his own first car and paid his car insurance for the year up front with savings from his part time job he isn't just being bank rolled by me or his father, he does know the value of money and also that he is very privileged.

You are correct that Cambridge is not the cheapest city, but having had one of my DC study at Cambridge and another at Edinburgh I can tell you that living expenses in Edinburgh are way higher (given that you have mentioned your DS' first choice is likely to be Edinburgh)

EvieBB · Yesterday 16:30

My DH's nephew's parents paid for his 3 years of Uni tuitiion up front (approx 15 years back). After graduation, he never ended up working in that field and has been in and out of minimum wage jobs ever since. They wouldve been far better off never paying the fees, letting their son take the loans - which he wouldn't have had to pay back in any case as never earned above the minimum threshold to start paying back.....
You've got to weight everything up
In this day and age with shitty job prospects you do wonder....

DunnoBut · Yesterday 16:31

If you can afford it, I would. I don't really understand why you wouldn't want to help your DC if it's an option.

I don't consider UK university education to be cheap, but haven't really considered that it might be good value compared to elsewhere.

My oldest is also set to go to uni next September and divorce means that there isn't really anything saved towards it. The most I will be able to do is to £200/month towards living costs, and I realise that that will sound well off to some people. I live quite frugally and haven't changed my spending habits much since I changed jobs a year ago, so I'm saving my pay rise for uni rather than improving our current lifestyle.

If I could do more for my DC, I would.

If I inherit anything in the future (DF keeps saying I'll "be alright" when he and DM die, but there are no guarantees, as who knows what level of care DPs will need), one of my priorities would be paying off DC's student debt.

EvieBB · Yesterday 16:31

Wadsworthy · Yesterday 16:17

I should have added, that I don't think UK parents realise how cheap a world class university education is in the UK for domestic undergrads. And I don't think they value it.

The degrees are not differentiated by cost, as they are for international students.

And in international/global rankings, the best UK universities punch way above their weight. My own discipline at my institution is in the top 50 in the world.

Although given attitudes I read regularly on MN, and the current binfire of UK university finances - because the tuition fee people complain about does not cover the costs of even the so-called "cheapest" undergrad degrees - I'm not sure how much longer we'll be able to be proud of the UK HE system. IT is one of the best in the world, and UK citizens & governments seem intent on throwing it away.

It used to be free back in the day....
What changed?

XelaM · Yesterday 16:34

EvieBB · Yesterday 16:30

My DH's nephew's parents paid for his 3 years of Uni tuitiion up front (approx 15 years back). After graduation, he never ended up working in that field and has been in and out of minimum wage jobs ever since. They wouldve been far better off never paying the fees, letting their son take the loans - which he wouldn't have had to pay back in any case as never earned above the minimum threshold to start paying back.....
You've got to weight everything up
In this day and age with shitty job prospects you do wonder....

Isn't the theshold like 25K now? Are you expecting them never to earn above that in 40 years?

XelaM · Yesterday 16:38

Wadsworthy · Yesterday 16:17

I should have added, that I don't think UK parents realise how cheap a world class university education is in the UK for domestic undergrads. And I don't think they value it.

The degrees are not differentiated by cost, as they are for international students.

And in international/global rankings, the best UK universities punch way above their weight. My own discipline at my institution is in the top 50 in the world.

Although given attitudes I read regularly on MN, and the current binfire of UK university finances - because the tuition fee people complain about does not cover the costs of even the so-called "cheapest" undergrad degrees - I'm not sure how much longer we'll be able to be proud of the UK HE system. IT is one of the best in the world, and UK citizens & governments seem intent on throwing it away.

Race to the bottom as usual with MN. It's free or MUCH cheaper throughout Europe. German or Dutch universities aren't any different to UK universities (outside of Oxford/Cambridge and that's only because of their name). I went to one of the best unis in London that's usually ranked no.3 in the UK behind the two, but can tell you it was absolutely nothing special.

Someone I know is currently putting up with stikes and cancelled lectures at another big-name uni.

It's like with the NHS, people always think it's this amazing unique system and accept totally awful service whereas medical care is much better in many places abroad.

Boreded · Yesterday 16:47

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 15:22

Yes, but that's also a bit like saying that chartering a jet for occasional private use works out cheaper than buying one outright. It might be entirely true, but it's completely irrelevant to 99% of people who might be unable to afford business class or even Ryanair.

That’s a rather ridiculous comparison, isn’t it?

The vast majority of people on Mumsnet couldn’t possibly afford to buy a private jet, so it would be a completely pointless financial comparison to make.

University tuition fees, on the other hand, are affordable to a meaningful minority of families. That’s the fundamental difference you’re ignoring. We’re not talking about something that’s financially inaccessible to 99.99% of the population, but something that a significant enough proportion of families can afford for the comparison to be relevant.

In fact, HESA data for 2023/24 shows that 16.7% of full-time university students from England, studying at English universities, did not have their tuition fees mainly funded by the Student Loans Company. That doesn’t necessarily mean they all paid their own fees, but it demonstrates that student finance arrangements aren’t universal.

And that doesn’t even account for families like mine, where my son has taken out the tuition fee loan for cash-flow purposes, allowing me time to get the money together to pay it off myself.

Given that Mumsnet generally skews towards a wealthier demographic than the population as a whole, families who can afford to fund university fees may well be particularly well represented here.

A comparison doesn’t become irrelevant simply because it doesn’t apply to everyone. It only needs to be relevant to a meaningful proportion of the people involved.

And saying something is comparatively cheaper is not the same as suggesting everyone can afford it.

Endorewitch · Yesterday 16:48

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:17

I'm American, DH is British and we've lived in England for nearly 10 years now, we came back after Trump, I am from Georgia, which has now turned blue!! We do plan to go back once all children are finished with education/at university. All 3 of our children were born in the states, have dual citizenship so can go to university in either country.

Our eldest DS is due to start university next September, although he's still undecided whether to go straight away or take a gap year. He's interested in Economics and Maths and has applied to several universities through UCAS, choosing slightly different courses at each but all along those lines. He's already had offers from most of them and is currently preparing for his Cambridge interview.As he's our eldest, we've never been through any of this before. I've only really started looking into student finance over the last couple of years, especially with all the news about Plan 2 loans, interest, repayment thresholds and people wanting loans written off.

DH and I have been going back and forth about whether to let him take out a student loan or just pay the tuition fees ourselves. DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off? I'm looking at it quite differently, probably because I'm American. I actually came to university in the UK myself because my parents worked out that even paying international student fees here was cheaper than going to an American university.

When I told my parents how much home student fees are here, they genuinely couldn't believe it. To them it's pennies, I do understand that is a privilege. They've now said they would happily just pay the tuition fees for all our children themselves rather than have them take out loans.For context, my brother's children go to a private day school in America where fees are approaching $100k each per year, and he's already planning for them to come to university in the UK because of how much cheaper it is.

I've also spoken to a few parents at DS's school and some seem to be planning on paying their children's fees outright, some are undecided. One mum I spoke to has an eldest son who finished university about seven years ago. She said she wishes they'd just paid his fees at the time rather than let him take out SFE. He's got a decent job straight out of university, and she said seeing how much was coming out of his salary between tax, NI and student loan repayments was quite an eye opener. His parents eventually decided to pay off the remaining loan for him.

I do understand that student loans here aren't like normal loans and that plenty of people never pay them off in full. But if you can afford to pay the fees without it affecting your finances, surely that makes more sense, even more so now. DH thinks I'm looking at this through my American upbringing and not understanding how the UK system works. Maybe he's right!

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?
Interested to hear from people who've actually been through this, especially those with older children who've graduated and you either paid or took our the tuition fees loans?

It depends what you mean by cheap!50k debt plus interest not cheap.
Of course if your parents can pay outright let themm. Why rack up interest rates and debts if you don't need to?Think an odd question.

PoppetDog · Yesterday 16:52

DearCrab · Yesterday 15:08

This is what people are failing to realise. I am purely speaking on facts in regards to how much it costs. 10K is different to everyone but in the grand scheme of things purely at the price it is cheaper than 100k fees a year in the states.

I don't think people are "failing to realise" anything. Yes, American universities cost a lot more in fees, but your use of the phrase "so cheap" in your question is insulting to the many, many families and former students who are on their knees trying to pay them. Language matters. Vocabulary matters. You could have phrased your question in a lot of different ways that would not have offended and upset so many people - but you chose not to, and now pretend you don't know what's happening.

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 16:52

Boreded · Yesterday 16:47

That’s a rather ridiculous comparison, isn’t it?

The vast majority of people on Mumsnet couldn’t possibly afford to buy a private jet, so it would be a completely pointless financial comparison to make.

University tuition fees, on the other hand, are affordable to a meaningful minority of families. That’s the fundamental difference you’re ignoring. We’re not talking about something that’s financially inaccessible to 99.99% of the population, but something that a significant enough proportion of families can afford for the comparison to be relevant.

In fact, HESA data for 2023/24 shows that 16.7% of full-time university students from England, studying at English universities, did not have their tuition fees mainly funded by the Student Loans Company. That doesn’t necessarily mean they all paid their own fees, but it demonstrates that student finance arrangements aren’t universal.

And that doesn’t even account for families like mine, where my son has taken out the tuition fee loan for cash-flow purposes, allowing me time to get the money together to pay it off myself.

Given that Mumsnet generally skews towards a wealthier demographic than the population as a whole, families who can afford to fund university fees may well be particularly well represented here.

A comparison doesn’t become irrelevant simply because it doesn’t apply to everyone. It only needs to be relevant to a meaningful proportion of the people involved.

And saying something is comparatively cheaper is not the same as suggesting everyone can afford it.

The ridiculousness of the comparison was on purpose, because being able to pay fees upfront is just as likely as this for a lot of families. And this divide - as you say, there is a reasonable minority of parents who can - is going to further entrench economic differences between Gen Alpha kids, potentially much more than for those who are being helped with housing costs vs those who aren't.

InterIgnis · Yesterday 16:53

SockGene · Yesterday 16:12

You could say that about anything because there’s always something more expensive. That in itself doesn’t make it cheap. A £50 million yacht isn’t cheap because there are £200 million yachts. But yes I guess they are all cheap if you have very deep pockets.

If judging on a global scale, sure. By the same token, very few citizens of the UK are in poverty, or poor at all.

Context matters, and OP made the context in which she was making statement explicitly clear. In comparison to the US, tuition in the UK is cheap.

PoppetDog · Yesterday 16:54

Boreded · Yesterday 16:47

That’s a rather ridiculous comparison, isn’t it?

The vast majority of people on Mumsnet couldn’t possibly afford to buy a private jet, so it would be a completely pointless financial comparison to make.

University tuition fees, on the other hand, are affordable to a meaningful minority of families. That’s the fundamental difference you’re ignoring. We’re not talking about something that’s financially inaccessible to 99.99% of the population, but something that a significant enough proportion of families can afford for the comparison to be relevant.

In fact, HESA data for 2023/24 shows that 16.7% of full-time university students from England, studying at English universities, did not have their tuition fees mainly funded by the Student Loans Company. That doesn’t necessarily mean they all paid their own fees, but it demonstrates that student finance arrangements aren’t universal.

And that doesn’t even account for families like mine, where my son has taken out the tuition fee loan for cash-flow purposes, allowing me time to get the money together to pay it off myself.

Given that Mumsnet generally skews towards a wealthier demographic than the population as a whole, families who can afford to fund university fees may well be particularly well represented here.

A comparison doesn’t become irrelevant simply because it doesn’t apply to everyone. It only needs to be relevant to a meaningful proportion of the people involved.

And saying something is comparatively cheaper is not the same as suggesting everyone can afford it.

She didn't say it was "comparatively cheaper" in her question though. She said it was "so cheap". There's a difference - and that's what's pissed people off.

Boreded · Yesterday 16:58

SockGene · Yesterday 16:12

You could say that about anything because there’s always something more expensive. That in itself doesn’t make it cheap. A £50 million yacht isn’t cheap because there are £200 million yachts. But yes I guess they are all cheap if you have very deep pockets.

Well, by that logic, a £2 bus fare is expensive because walking is free.

You can make an equally ridiculous comparison in the opposite direction, but it doesn’t make either argument particularly meaningful.

And why do these comparisons always involve multimillion-pound luxury purchases? We’re talking about university tuition fees, something that a meaningful proportion of ordinary families can afford, not £50 million yachts.

The original poster said UK university fees feel cheap compared with the US. They were making a comparison between the cost of the same service in two different countries, not claiming that £10,000 is objectively cheap or affordable to everyone.

That’s a perfectly reasonable distinction, and one that seems to be getting rather unnecessarily picked apart.

Stowickthevast · Yesterday 16:59

I think the problem lies in what you're comparing. For most people with children who are university aged or close to it, their own uni fees would have been far cheaper since the current system only came in under the coalition government in 2010-15. So for the majority of parents of current students, the fees are incredibly expensive relative to what we experienced. And if you're comparing them to at least some European countries - NL, Germany, France, Scandinavia - they are still far more expensive. They may seem cheap compared to the US but I believe that has the most expensive fees in the world.

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 17:04

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:41

That is true, Most countries that do not offer free higher education, the fees are usually more than 10k even for home students so to be honest it is still quite cheap but I understand it will not stay that way forever. Growing up in the states most people I knew their parents had been saving up for college since they were born, that seemed to be the culture there. If you save up for your child from the day they are born to say 18 or 19, compound interest, I don't believe it requires parents to save millions every month, just a little each month and reinvest that money for 18 years.

The idea that England is cheap compared to the US is pretty out of date.

I'm in California and public universities are mainly cheaper than the UK.

Local community colleges, where you can do the first two years of a degree before transferring to a more prestigious university, are gnerally free to a few thousand dollars a year.

State universities are about $8k a year including campus fees, (that's about £6k).

University California, which includes world renowned campuses like UCLA and Berkeley are a bit more expensive at $16k (about £12k).

But kids from low income family will normally have those fees completely covered and get thousands in living expenses covered by grants. So would be better off than in England.

If you're from a well off family, so paying full whack, and going to a private university like Stanford, you can expect fees and living expenses to come to around $100k a year. But most universities offer significant needs based and merit scholarships so that's not the normal experience for the vast majority of Americans.

Boreded · Yesterday 17:05

PoppetDog · Yesterday 16:54

She didn't say it was "comparatively cheaper" in her question though. She said it was "so cheap". There's a difference - and that's what's pissed people off.

But you’re responding to a discussion that arose specifically from MY comment, in which I explicitly described UK university tuition fees as “comparatively inexpensive” in relation to American university fees and UK private school fees.

That is the statement people have been challenging, and the one I’ve been defending throughout this exchange. So I’m not sure why you’ve suddenly decided to argue about the precise wording of the OP’s thread title instead.

And even if we do go back to the OP, have you actually read the post rather than just the title?

She’s American, explicitly compares UK tuition fees with American university costs, explains that her own parents sent her to university here because it was cheaper, and acknowledges that her family’s financial position is privileged.

She then asks whether people would pay their children’s tuition fees upfront IF they had the money.

The comparative context couldn’t be much clearer, and neither could the fact that she’s discussing a decision for families who can afford it.

It seems rather pointless to challenge my argument by taking issue with wording I didn’t use, particularly when the OP’s full post makes her intended meaning perfectly clear anyway.

And I suspect the people taking offense have nothing better to do, or are jealous of someone being in a decent financial position so wanting to tear them down

InterIgnis · Yesterday 17:06

PoppetDog · Yesterday 16:52

I don't think people are "failing to realise" anything. Yes, American universities cost a lot more in fees, but your use of the phrase "so cheap" in your question is insulting to the many, many families and former students who are on their knees trying to pay them. Language matters. Vocabulary matters. You could have phrased your question in a lot of different ways that would not have offended and upset so many people - but you chose not to, and now pretend you don't know what's happening.

As if they have to read or engage with a thread they find offensive, or cannot relate to. The onus is on them to take responsibility for their feelings and limit their own exposure to topics they find upsetting. They cannot expect strangers online, on a forum that is for users across the socioeconomic spectrum, to do that for them.

Those taking offense and accusing OP of ‘stealth bragging’ are vastly overestimating their own importance in assuming they feature in OP’s thoughts at all, or indeed need to.

pumpkinperchance · Yesterday 17:09

PutYourSpecsOnJean · Yesterday 16:25

You are correct that Cambridge is not the cheapest city, but having had one of my DC study at Cambridge and another at Edinburgh I can tell you that living expenses in Edinburgh are way higher (given that you have mentioned your DS' first choice is likely to be Edinburgh)

I don't think this is actually the case if you're an international student? It definitely is if you're a home student though!

Wadsworthy · Yesterday 17:11

EvieBB · Yesterday 16:31

It used to be free back in the day....
What changed?

British taxpayers were unwilling to pay the taxes that would support a world-class system. British parents & undergrads now rely on international students to subsidise their degrees, rather than UK taxpayers.

pumpkinperchance · Yesterday 17:14

One thing I don't understand is, aren't the cost of degrees in the US means tested according to family income?

I have relatives there (admittedly all quite high earners) and they all talk about college being about 100k a year! But surely the majority of people can't afford that?! And what happens with international students?