Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

467 replies

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:17

I'm American, DH is British and we've lived in England for nearly 10 years now, we came back after Trump, I am from Georgia, which has now turned blue!! We do plan to go back once all children are finished with education/at university. All 3 of our children were born in the states, have dual citizenship so can go to university in either country.

Our eldest DS is due to start university next September, although he's still undecided whether to go straight away or take a gap year. He's interested in Economics and Maths and has applied to several universities through UCAS, choosing slightly different courses at each but all along those lines. He's already had offers from most of them and is currently preparing for his Cambridge interview.As he's our eldest, we've never been through any of this before. I've only really started looking into student finance over the last couple of years, especially with all the news about Plan 2 loans, interest, repayment thresholds and people wanting loans written off.

DH and I have been going back and forth about whether to let him take out a student loan or just pay the tuition fees ourselves. DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off? I'm looking at it quite differently, probably because I'm American. I actually came to university in the UK myself because my parents worked out that even paying international student fees here was cheaper than going to an American university.

When I told my parents how much home student fees are here, they genuinely couldn't believe it. To them it's pennies, I do understand that is a privilege. They've now said they would happily just pay the tuition fees for all our children themselves rather than have them take out loans.For context, my brother's children go to a private day school in America where fees are approaching $100k each per year, and he's already planning for them to come to university in the UK because of how much cheaper it is.

I've also spoken to a few parents at DS's school and some seem to be planning on paying their children's fees outright, some are undecided. One mum I spoke to has an eldest son who finished university about seven years ago. She said she wishes they'd just paid his fees at the time rather than let him take out SFE. He's got a decent job straight out of university, and she said seeing how much was coming out of his salary between tax, NI and student loan repayments was quite an eye opener. His parents eventually decided to pay off the remaining loan for him.

I do understand that student loans here aren't like normal loans and that plenty of people never pay them off in full. But if you can afford to pay the fees without it affecting your finances, surely that makes more sense, even more so now. DH thinks I'm looking at this through my American upbringing and not understanding how the UK system works. Maybe he's right!

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?
Interested to hear from people who've actually been through this, especially those with older children who've graduated and you either paid or took our the tuition fees loans?

OP posts:
Wadsworthy · Yesterday 17:17

I went to one of the best unis in London that's usually ranked no.3 in the UK behind the two, but can tell you it was absolutely nothing special.

Well, unless you've been to several universities across the world, in order to compare, I don't think your "nothing special" holds much cogency. I've taught in a variety of universities in 3 national systems. I know how good the UK system is in comparison with others.

And a student's opinion of their university tends to be as much a reflection of their own engagement & work ethic as it is a reliable evaluation of the university they attended.

Boreded · Yesterday 17:23

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 16:52

The ridiculousness of the comparison was on purpose, because being able to pay fees upfront is just as likely as this for a lot of families. And this divide - as you say, there is a reasonable minority of parents who can - is going to further entrench economic differences between Gen Alpha kids, potentially much more than for those who are being helped with housing costs vs those who aren't.

I actually agree with you about the inequality, which is precisely why, despite not being wealthy, I’ve decided to pay my son’s university tuition fees myself.

But I think there’s another group being overlooked here, and that’s children from middle-income families.

Students from lower-income households can access higher maintenance loans, bursaries and other financial support, as well as contextual admissions offers, which I absolutely agree with. Wealthy families, meanwhile, can simply pay for their children’s education and living costs.

But what about the families in the middle? Their children aren’t entitled to the maximum maintenance loans because the system assumes their parents can make up the difference. Yet those parents might be struggling with a substantial mortgage in the South East, or have only recently reached a higher income after years of earning considerably less. A household’s current income tells you very little about its accumulated wealth or ability to provide thousands of pounds a year.

That’s exactly my situation. I earn enough that my son doesn’t qualify for the maximum support, but I don’t earn enough (or for long enough) to have had the opportunity to accumulate the savings needed to pay his tuition fees outright. That’s why he’s taken the loan initially, while I get the money together to repay it.

And there’s another inequality in university admissions that I find particularly frustrating.
International students can be charged fees several times higher than those paid by UK students, creating an obvious financial incentive for universities to recruit them.

My son applied to a leading UK university for Computer Science and was rejected despite achieving the required grades. On Clearing day, the university still had places available, but only for international applicants. I know this because I telephoned the university myself and was explicitly told that the remaining places weren’t available to UK students.

The university has published ambitions to increase its international student population to around 40%, and its own admissions figures showed an offer rate of just 27% for home Computer Science applicants, compared with 80% for overseas applicants.

So we have a system where universities can charge overseas students substantially more, set separate recruitment targets, and still have places available for international applicants while qualified UK applicants are turned away.

I’m not suggesting every international student is taking a place that would otherwise have gone to a UK student, but I do question whether the financial incentives are producing fair outcomes.

As for your suggestion that paying university fees could create a greater economic divide than helping children with housing costs, I’m not convinced that’s the case.

A student loan is income-contingent, with repayments determined by earnings and any remaining balance eventually written off. By contrast, parents who can provide a substantial house deposit give their children an immediate financial advantage that can last for decades. They can avoid years of renting, build equity and potentially benefit from rising property values.

And if we’re considering the wider issue of intergenerational inequality, inheritance arguably creates an even greater divide. Someone inheriting a £500,000 property starts from an entirely different financial position from someone who inherits nothing. That advantage can then be passed down to their own children, perpetuating the wealth gap across generations.

So if we’re concerned about the economic divide between children from wealthy and less wealthy families, I think we need to look at the whole picture. Paying university fees is just one relatively small part of a much larger system in which parental wealth influences children’s opportunities, financial security and ability to accumulate wealth themselves.

I agree that family wealth creates inequality. But I also think we need to recognise that children from middle-income families can find themselves caught between two systems: not disadvantaged enough to qualify for the greatest support, but nowhere near wealthy enough to have everything paid for them.

And as for your original analogy, I appreciate that the comparison was deliberately ridiculous, but that doesn’t change the fundamental difference between something affordable to a meaningful minority of families and something almost nobody can afford. Your exaggeration doesn’t invalidate the comparison I was making.

And none of that changes my original observation about the comparative cost of UK university tuition fees.

Boreded · Yesterday 17:25

InterIgnis · Yesterday 17:06

As if they have to read or engage with a thread they find offensive, or cannot relate to. The onus is on them to take responsibility for their feelings and limit their own exposure to topics they find upsetting. They cannot expect strangers online, on a forum that is for users across the socioeconomic spectrum, to do that for them.

Those taking offense and accusing OP of ‘stealth bragging’ are vastly overestimating their own importance in assuming they feature in OP’s thoughts at all, or indeed need to.

Omg…please tell me this isn’t what I think it is…some common sense 🫣

People are still going to disagree with you though

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 17:26

@EvieBB ,

’What changed?’

What changed is the percentage of students going to university.

Back in the mid 1980s, only about 7% of people went to uni (15% if you include polytechnics. Now it is around 38%.

Some people see this as progress, but I think it is the opposite. Loads of meaningless degrees are given to people who are very average academically, whilst the government can’t afford to properly support those who are worthy of a university education:

Absolutelyawefull · Yesterday 17:27

Interested to know what sort of school your DC go to is it state or privately funded?

EvieBB · Yesterday 17:28

XelaM · Yesterday 16:34

Isn't the theshold like 25K now? Are you expecting them never to earn above that in 40 years?

I thought it was more like 35k....no?
In this current job climate I do worry.
My 16 yr old can't even get a Saturday job as so many going for the same role, despite her being polite, eager, hardworking, competent etc etc :(

Boreded · Yesterday 17:29

EvieBB · Yesterday 17:28

I thought it was more like 35k....no?
In this current job climate I do worry.
My 16 yr old can't even get a Saturday job as so many going for the same role, despite her being polite, eager, hardworking, competent etc etc :(

It’s 25k

LeftBoobGoneRogue · Yesterday 17:33

My eldest DC graduated with a MPHARM in 2019 and her student debt is nearly £90k. We paid her rent for the 4 years of her course and she was entitled to the minimum loan.
I most certainly don’t think student tuition fees are ‘pennies’.

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 17:39

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 17:26

@EvieBB ,

’What changed?’

What changed is the percentage of students going to university.

Back in the mid 1980s, only about 7% of people went to uni (15% if you include polytechnics. Now it is around 38%.

Some people see this as progress, but I think it is the opposite. Loads of meaningless degrees are given to people who are very average academically, whilst the government can’t afford to properly support those who are worthy of a university education:

What are the 'meaningless degrees'?

EvieBB · Yesterday 17:40

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 17:26

@EvieBB ,

’What changed?’

What changed is the percentage of students going to university.

Back in the mid 1980s, only about 7% of people went to uni (15% if you include polytechnics. Now it is around 38%.

Some people see this as progress, but I think it is the opposite. Loads of meaningless degrees are given to people who are very average academically, whilst the government can’t afford to properly support those who are worthy of a university education:

Thanks. Yes I tend to agree with you!

clamshell24 · Yesterday 17:40

loans now are pegged to retail price index so in theory no interest. The old system was scandalously high.

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 17:41

Boreded · Yesterday 17:29

It’s 25k

That's mad, given that's around full-time minimum wage, which is already difficult when it comes to rent and bills as it is.

When I graduated in the 00s, the threshold was around £20k then, when full-time minimum wage work would have paid about £11k a year.

EvieBB · Yesterday 17:42

Boreded · Yesterday 17:29

It’s 25k

I understand that it's still better to pay over the longer term as it's only a percentage of anything above the threshold (this is what my DS tells me and she had 2 DD's that finished uni about 7 years back)

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 17:42

pumpkinperchance · Yesterday 17:14

One thing I don't understand is, aren't the cost of degrees in the US means tested according to family income?

I have relatives there (admittedly all quite high earners) and they all talk about college being about 100k a year! But surely the majority of people can't afford that?! And what happens with international students?

A private university will be about $100k a year including living costs, but public universities are normally about half that or less AND most places, public or private, have scholarships and grants that provide significant funding. I posted up thread about costs in California - if your income is under $100k a year, you will get grants (not loans) that cover pretty much all expenses. Under ~$250K you get grants that will cover a significant chunk and a modest amount of subsidized loan. If you're richer than that you can only fall back on merit scholarships or family money.

Average family income in California is ~$102k a year, so the full ride is for kids on just under average. It is a bit of a cliff, but there is still significant help up to $250k. Only about 15% of California families earn over $250k a year.

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 17:44

@YouHaveAnArse ,

Degrees in not very useful subjects awarded to people with grades like CCC at A level. Ultimately, if you are struggling at A levels, you can’t access tertiary level content. (Of course, there are exceptions like late developers, people who did not achieve their potential at A level etc, but it works as a general rule).

People haven’t become smarter over the last 40 years and neither do they work harder. In fact, due to increased distractions, the reverse is true. What is the point of nearly 40% of the population staying in education until 21 or older, when only a few will really gain from it.

Comtesse · Yesterday 17:51

PinkBottle75 · Yesterday 15:04

But it does feel really cheap compared to the USA! it's $100k per year there. £10k feels cheap

That's a 90% discount...

Right - Cambridge for £10k or Ivy League for $100k means that it is comparatively cheap. Even for international students at £35k it’s very competitive.

Meand2Ls · Yesterday 18:12

I’m in Scotland where university is free but I’m from a deprived area so I took out a student loan every year then I took a pan out for my masters tuition. I ended up with about £45K all in. It’s been 10 years, I’m in senior management and earn not far off £100K and student loan hammers me every single month. It’s income based so if your children end up being high earners it will affect their wage. I would always pay it if I could afford it

Whydoweputupwiththiscrap · Yesterday 18:14

stuffedanimalsandchocolate · Yesterday 14:31

I think it's just the American perspective

American parents save for college from the moment their child is born. They might take out an extra mortgage or draw from their pensions to facilitate

Parent plus loans are pretty common, where the parents take out the loan to pay for the fees

Interest rates are much higher. Parent plus loans are at 9% plus a 4.5% fee at the time of taking out the loans

There's also no such thing as deferring payments until the student is earning a certain amount, you accrue interest from the day the loan is taken out

It's kind of crazy. Against that context I can imagine paying just paying £30,000 upfront is seen as cheap, although of course it's not really

Oh yes, I do understand all of this and thank you for your balanced comments. We’re not in the USA however, and it’s the title of this thread that does the real damage here - “(fees) so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?”, which reads very clumsily - that and waiting until para 4 to give the context around the grandparents. It’s completely the OPs business and choice of course, but it is a little provocative. Also it would be wise to anticipate a whole range of reactions when asking for financial advice on MN…

Boreded · Yesterday 18:15

LeftBoobGoneRogue · Yesterday 17:33

My eldest DC graduated with a MPHARM in 2019 and her student debt is nearly £90k. We paid her rent for the 4 years of her course and she was entitled to the minimum loan.
I most certainly don’t think student tuition fees are ‘pennies’.

They’re not to most…to the OPs parents they are.

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 18:19

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 17:44

@YouHaveAnArse ,

Degrees in not very useful subjects awarded to people with grades like CCC at A level. Ultimately, if you are struggling at A levels, you can’t access tertiary level content. (Of course, there are exceptions like late developers, people who did not achieve their potential at A level etc, but it works as a general rule).

People haven’t become smarter over the last 40 years and neither do they work harder. In fact, due to increased distractions, the reverse is true. What is the point of nearly 40% of the population staying in education until 21 or older, when only a few will really gain from it.

OK, but what are "not very useful subjects"?

Boreded · Yesterday 18:21

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 17:39

What are the 'meaningless degrees'?

Oooo pick me…I have an answer for this. Bit of google searching needed to find all of the bottom ones, but here goes. This is my list of degrees where I question whether the cost is justified by the employment prospects, particularly when practical experience or vocational qualifications could be just as valuable:

  1. Media Studies
  2. Film Studies
  3. Creative Writing
  4. Events Management
  5. Tourism Management
  6. Hospitality Management
  7. Fashion Marketing
  8. Popular Music Studies
  9. Acting
  10. Drama Studies
  11. Photography
  12. Sports Coaching
  13. Fine Art
  14. Sociology
  15. Philosophy
  16. Religious Studies

And then there are some of the more unusual courses that universities have actually offered:

  • Surf Science - Cornwall College
  • Contemporary Circus and Physical Theatre - Circomedia
  • Puppetry Design and Performance - Royal Central School of Speech and Drama
  • Viking and Old Norse Studies - UCL
  • Hand Embroidery - Royal School of Needlework
  • Floristry Design - University Centre Bishop Burton
  • Horology - Birmingham City University
  • Brewing and Distilling - Heriot-Watt University
  • Baking Science and Technology - London South Bank University

And there are the nonsense ones like Taylor Swift and Literature at Queen Mary University of London, although that’s a short course rather than a full degree.

I’m not saying these subjects have no value, but I question whether everything needs to be turned into a university qualification, particularly when students are paying thousands of pounds a year and there may be cheaper, more practical routes into the same careers. I would suspect that the vast majority of these are not profitable for the people who take them and don’t afford them higher earnings or opportunities.

Smoggy1 · Yesterday 18:23

There's a good chance it's not worth it. My plan 2 debt is currently £100k. I borrowed £60k (fees plus maintenance for 4 year degree and teacher training). My interst far outstrips the repayments. However....I've done the maths on it. If I stay on an average salary of £35-40k throughout my career, I'll repay around £20k. It's not worth me overpaying. It wouldn't have been worth my parents paying fees upfront. I would have to be a particularly high earner for it to have been worth it for my parents to pay upfront. However, if they do a Master's - pay that up front. My postgraduate repayments every month are more than my Plan 2 repayments, and I would repay double what I borrowed. I came into some inheritance, so I've now repaid before it grows too much.

JJMama · Yesterday 18:26

Stealth wealth flex much 😂

Get back in your corner

Rocknrollstar · Yesterday 18:28

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:23

Weren't the fees £9/9250k per year ? That would still be under 30k for 3 years. How did it get to 50k straight out of University, unless you mean a few years after, when it accrued interest, I am assuming that is Plan 2

Because they take out loans for living expenses as well. Many families can’t afford to keep a child, maybe two, at uni out of their income.

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 18:29

Having been jobsearching fairly recently, you'd be surprised how many job ads cite degrees like Fashion Marketing, Events Management or sports science-related courses. (And the use of 'digital native' for some roles, but that's another kettle of fish...) The brewery trade is also fairly large around where Heriot-Watt is, I can see the use of a specialist degree there. Nobody's going to the Royal School of Needlework for shits and giggles, either - that course is for people already seriously working in embroidery as a visual art, not for people who noodle about with it in front of the telly like me.

I find it quite funny, in an age of AI slop, fake news and doomscrolling, that Media Studies is still seen as a pointless subject rather than entirely essential to understanding how we got where we are.