I actually agree with you about the inequality, which is precisely why, despite not being wealthy, I’ve decided to pay my son’s university tuition fees myself.
But I think there’s another group being overlooked here, and that’s children from middle-income families.
Students from lower-income households can access higher maintenance loans, bursaries and other financial support, as well as contextual admissions offers, which I absolutely agree with. Wealthy families, meanwhile, can simply pay for their children’s education and living costs.
But what about the families in the middle? Their children aren’t entitled to the maximum maintenance loans because the system assumes their parents can make up the difference. Yet those parents might be struggling with a substantial mortgage in the South East, or have only recently reached a higher income after years of earning considerably less. A household’s current income tells you very little about its accumulated wealth or ability to provide thousands of pounds a year.
That’s exactly my situation. I earn enough that my son doesn’t qualify for the maximum support, but I don’t earn enough (or for long enough) to have had the opportunity to accumulate the savings needed to pay his tuition fees outright. That’s why he’s taken the loan initially, while I get the money together to repay it.
And there’s another inequality in university admissions that I find particularly frustrating.
International students can be charged fees several times higher than those paid by UK students, creating an obvious financial incentive for universities to recruit them.
My son applied to a leading UK university for Computer Science and was rejected despite achieving the required grades. On Clearing day, the university still had places available, but only for international applicants. I know this because I telephoned the university myself and was explicitly told that the remaining places weren’t available to UK students.
The university has published ambitions to increase its international student population to around 40%, and its own admissions figures showed an offer rate of just 27% for home Computer Science applicants, compared with 80% for overseas applicants.
So we have a system where universities can charge overseas students substantially more, set separate recruitment targets, and still have places available for international applicants while qualified UK applicants are turned away.
I’m not suggesting every international student is taking a place that would otherwise have gone to a UK student, but I do question whether the financial incentives are producing fair outcomes.
As for your suggestion that paying university fees could create a greater economic divide than helping children with housing costs, I’m not convinced that’s the case.
A student loan is income-contingent, with repayments determined by earnings and any remaining balance eventually written off. By contrast, parents who can provide a substantial house deposit give their children an immediate financial advantage that can last for decades. They can avoid years of renting, build equity and potentially benefit from rising property values.
And if we’re considering the wider issue of intergenerational inequality, inheritance arguably creates an even greater divide. Someone inheriting a £500,000 property starts from an entirely different financial position from someone who inherits nothing. That advantage can then be passed down to their own children, perpetuating the wealth gap across generations.
So if we’re concerned about the economic divide between children from wealthy and less wealthy families, I think we need to look at the whole picture. Paying university fees is just one relatively small part of a much larger system in which parental wealth influences children’s opportunities, financial security and ability to accumulate wealth themselves.
I agree that family wealth creates inequality. But I also think we need to recognise that children from middle-income families can find themselves caught between two systems: not disadvantaged enough to qualify for the greatest support, but nowhere near wealthy enough to have everything paid for them.
And as for your original analogy, I appreciate that the comparison was deliberately ridiculous, but that doesn’t change the fundamental difference between something affordable to a meaningful minority of families and something almost nobody can afford. Your exaggeration doesn’t invalidate the comparison I was making.
And none of that changes my original observation about the comparative cost of UK university tuition fees.