Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find cat owners who boast about their cats killing wildlife really weird?

60 replies

ThatQuickLimePombear · Today 18:15

I’m talking about the ones who seem genuinely proud of how many birds and other small animals their cats kill. Whenever anyone questions it, out comes the predictable, “Oooh, but it’s just in their nature!”

Yes, we know cats have hunting instincts. That doesn’t mean you have to celebrate the destruction of wildlife. I find the whole attitude bizarre, frankly. Fuck off with that excuse.

OP posts:
Thiscantbeyourjobsurely · Today 18:15

Never ever ever heard anyone boast about this
ever

Thiscantbeyourjobsurely · Today 18:16

And is saying in response that it’s “in their nature”… boasting? No

sprigatito · Today 18:16

I would think it very weird indeed if I had ever come across it.

PaddyMcGintysGoats · Today 18:17

Genuinely never heard a cat owner doing any such thing.

I've known a few who have been pleased they've helped sort a mouse problem indoors though.

HostaCentral · Today 18:23

I've never celebrated when Arthur catches mice, but then he does eat them, which is good for his health. He's thankfully never caught a bird. The mice that escape I attempt to rescue. Those who defy my best efforts, I am afraid get snap trapped, which is sad, but necessary. They go off into the field opposite to get eaten by Mr Foxy, or the raptors.

I don't know any cat owners who would celebrate. We just see it as nature. Which it is.

EveryoneUsingOutro · Today 18:25

Yeah I met a woman at a work event. Over dinner she regaled us with tales and photos (!!) of her cat’s kills - dead birds in her living room and so on. She was proud. Her cat ownership appeared to be her entire personality.

Most of us felt quite sick and finally a manager told her it wasn’t appropriate while people were eating!

Kepler22B · Today 18:25

Keeps the mice population down.

Meadowfinch · Today 18:26

I guess if you have an outside cat as a ratter, and that cat catches rats regularly, it is doing its job and earning its keep.

YeOldeGreyhound · Today 18:26

I have never heard anyone bragging about something like that.
However, I can not get worked up about a cat catching a mouse they found indoors.

FreshInk · Today 18:29

That isn’t boasting.

DuchesseChou · Today 18:31

I’ve never heard anyone say this. Two cats regularly visit my garden. I saw one with a mouse which wasn’t nice but acceptable and another with a red squirrel and I felt really cross about that as there aren’t very many in my garden.

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · Today 18:38

It is strange I agree.

Ny friend has a greyhound that would 100% eat any rabbit that he catches - and the idea of a dog doing that is just unthinkable and socially unacceptable. My dog is raw fed and does enjoy rabbit meat and regularly eats it with the fur on! (Bought from a shop obvs) but the idea of allowing either if them to chase after a wild rabbit for a kill and meal is just socially unacceptable.

But cats there is a different social contract it seems.

It is a weird one, I agree. I think it is the whole roaming thing - it just changes the conversation entirely.

LetMeButterYourParsnips · Today 18:40

I read a very sad bit of news this week, apparently a cat killed a very rare bird, only ever 12 sightings in the UK.

Just keep the bloody killing things on.

YeOldeGreyhound · Today 18:44

MarysSilverBells · Today 18:42

Cat owners are pretty selfish full stop.

‘Incredibly unusual’ bird migrating from Siberia found in Cumbria – killed by cat https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/13/siberian-rubythroat-bird-migrating-siberia-cumbria-killed-by-cat?CMP=share_btn_url

Oh that is sad.
But it also could have been killed by other wildlife.

Zephyro2 · Today 18:48

I like cats, but that's part of the reason I wouldn't have one.

Agree with the double standards compared to dogs- my dog is a JRT and I don't let him roam free killing every small furry thing he sees ! That would be mad and irresponsible but people think it's ok for cats to do so.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · Today 18:51

My cat used to kill slow worms. A colleague told me that they were a protected species, so, I said he was welcome to come over and explain the legality to my cat.

KnittedPenguinHat · Today 18:56

It’s more natural than buying a dead plucked chicken from the shops at least.

Cats do less harm to wildlife than humans anyway.

Keepingthingsinteresting · Today 19:03

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · Today 18:51

My cat used to kill slow worms. A colleague told me that they were a protected species, so, I said he was welcome to come over and explain the legality to my cat.

That’s wildly irresponsible and unreasonable of you. Keep your murderous animal inside of you can’t control it, similarly your sarcasm.

HettyTagliatelli · Today 19:07

Cat owners are usually selfish and blinkered when it comes to their cats. They don’t care what they kill
or who they bother.

I have heard cat owners proudly announce that their cat ‘brought them a present’ plenty of times. It’s gross.

Churchbell · Today 19:09

I've never heard anyone boasting about this.

sprigatito · Today 19:09

HettyTagliatelli · Today 19:07

Cat owners are usually selfish and blinkered when it comes to their cats. They don’t care what they kill
or who they bother.

I have heard cat owners proudly announce that their cat ‘brought them a present’ plenty of times. It’s gross.

That’s not “proudly announcing”, it’s just a bit of wry humour about how revolting it is to be gifted a partially eviscerated mouse/bird to dispose of. Your misinterpretation is a bit strange tbh.

PinkPerpetue · Today 19:10

I’ve never known anyone do this

mondaytosunday · Today 19:11

i had a hunter in the past. Anything was fair game. Hated it. Another brought things in alive and I gut good at quickly catching them and putting them out (mice, snakes, cicadas). My current Maine Coons are not hunters thank goodness!

But other than those who get cats specifically to keep the vermin down (farm cats for example), I’ve never heard anyone be proud of the ability of their animals to kill.

Swipe left for the next trending thread