Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find cat owners who boast about their cats killing wildlife really weird?

60 replies

ThatQuickLimePombear · Today 18:15

I’m talking about the ones who seem genuinely proud of how many birds and other small animals their cats kill. Whenever anyone questions it, out comes the predictable, “Oooh, but it’s just in their nature!”

Yes, we know cats have hunting instincts. That doesn’t mean you have to celebrate the destruction of wildlife. I find the whole attitude bizarre, frankly. Fuck off with that excuse.

OP posts:
Truinio · Today 19:14

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · Today 18:51

My cat used to kill slow worms. A colleague told me that they were a protected species, so, I said he was welcome to come over and explain the legality to my cat.

The interesting thing about protected species is that not only is harming them a criminal offence, but, by inaction, permitting them to be harmed is also an offence.

sprigatito · Today 19:16

Truinio · Today 19:14

The interesting thing about protected species is that not only is harming them a criminal offence, but, by inaction, permitting them to be harmed is also an offence.

The other interesting thing about protected species is that you’re not liable if your cat kills one, as the law relating to cats roaming recognises that you aren’t in control of their actions.

Goldensprat · Today 19:18

I'd be proud if he killed a mouse or a rat as part of the reason I got him is so I'd never have to worry about rodents in the house again - it's not fun. I wouldn't be proud if he killed a bird.

He spends 95% of his time indoors sleeping (he's not kept in, he just likes being mostly in) and has never to my knowledge bothered killing anything.

I do hope he'd step up to the plate if a mouse actually came inside. He's probably doing a good job as a deterrent just by being here, though, as they never do anymore. I suppose they can smell him.

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 19:20

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · Today 18:38

It is strange I agree.

Ny friend has a greyhound that would 100% eat any rabbit that he catches - and the idea of a dog doing that is just unthinkable and socially unacceptable. My dog is raw fed and does enjoy rabbit meat and regularly eats it with the fur on! (Bought from a shop obvs) but the idea of allowing either if them to chase after a wild rabbit for a kill and meal is just socially unacceptable.

But cats there is a different social contract it seems.

It is a weird one, I agree. I think it is the whole roaming thing - it just changes the conversation entirely.

So true. A greyhound killed a greyhound squirrel locally and there was almost a public mob. Cats do it every day

fireplacetime · Today 19:22

Mine brought me a butterfly once (alive, and still alive) and looked confused when it flew off
he also brought me a bird who I think dropped dead at the sight of a 7kg cat or flew into the window as it didn’t have a single injury. He didn’t eat it or anything

Lovelylydia · Today 19:22

I’ve never heard anyone boast about this before.

I have a cat whom I adore but she regularly brings in mice (usually alive that we then rescue). I hate this behaviour, whilst recognizing it’s very natural for a cat. For this reason we will not have another cat once she goes.

FYI - you can buy cat flaps that do not allow the cat inside if they are carrying prey. It’s a face recognition flap.

HRTtoHeart · Today 19:23

The only time I've ever heard cat owners speak with admiration about their pet's hunting abilities were wh n they were good ratters/mousers.

Mine was excellent with dealing with the influx of rodents after we got hens and they were after the chicken feed.

CandidMintCat · Today 19:23

I talk quite a lot about how many my 2 savages catch, I have had many cats (these 2 are my 14th and 15th) and they catch staggering amounts. But it’s not something I am proud of, just absolutely gobsmacked by.

I live in the countryside, backing on to farmland, and it’s just mad how much they get each day. They’ve moved on to pheasants and rabbits now which is not what I want on the sitting room carpet.

I find it quite fascinating, and DD has learnt a lot about anatomy from half eaten bodies, but it’s not pride.

Nopenott0day · Today 19:23

Would those who say it's 'nature' like to explain the part of Britain your cat is native to?

Keep the bloody thing in.

UserNameWalkingShoes · Today 19:24

The only mice problem we have in our house is when our cat brings in a mouse to torture play with and it escapes.

Truinio · Today 19:24

Goldensprat · Today 19:18

I'd be proud if he killed a mouse or a rat as part of the reason I got him is so I'd never have to worry about rodents in the house again - it's not fun. I wouldn't be proud if he killed a bird.

He spends 95% of his time indoors sleeping (he's not kept in, he just likes being mostly in) and has never to my knowledge bothered killing anything.

I do hope he'd step up to the plate if a mouse actually came inside. He's probably doing a good job as a deterrent just by being here, though, as they never do anymore. I suppose they can smell him.

There’s only one species of mouse that regularly enters dwellings (the aptly named house mouse).

Wood mice, harvest mice, yellow necked mice, bank voles, field voles are not pests and yet are all regularly predated by domestic cats.

CandidMintCat · Today 19:25

Nopenott0day · Today 19:23

Would those who say it's 'nature' like to explain the part of Britain your cat is native to?

Keep the bloody thing in.

No

YeOldeGreyhound · Today 19:27

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 19:20

So true. A greyhound killed a greyhound squirrel locally and there was almost a public mob. Cats do it every day

I have seen similar on social media. Cries of it could be a child next 🙄

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · Today 19:28

UserNameWalkingShoes · Today 19:24

The only mice problem we have in our house is when our cat brings in a mouse to torture play with and it escapes.

This is the strangest thing for me. Cats (with very few exceptions) don't actually want to eat what they catch - they just torture, maim and leave half dead for their own entertainment.

Cats have such a dark side and I don't know that I could ever bond with one.

MarysSilverBells · Today 19:28

CandidMintCat · Today 19:23

I talk quite a lot about how many my 2 savages catch, I have had many cats (these 2 are my 14th and 15th) and they catch staggering amounts. But it’s not something I am proud of, just absolutely gobsmacked by.

I live in the countryside, backing on to farmland, and it’s just mad how much they get each day. They’ve moved on to pheasants and rabbits now which is not what I want on the sitting room carpet.

I find it quite fascinating, and DD has learnt a lot about anatomy from half eaten bodies, but it’s not pride.

Why? Why do you not keep your cats in, or build a catio? Why are you inflicting them on wildlife that is already under serious pressure? The UK is one of the most nature depleted country in the world, don't you think that it would be good to try and help your local wildlife rather than saying 'well shucks, nothing I can do'.

HettyTagliatelli · Today 19:32

sprigatito · Today 19:09

That’s not “proudly announcing”, it’s just a bit of wry humour about how revolting it is to be gifted a partially eviscerated mouse/bird to dispose of. Your misinterpretation is a bit strange tbh.

I disagree that it’s wry humour, but either way, it’s not the shame or embarrassment that should accompany an admission that your pet is out killing wildlife for fun.

CandidMintCat · Today 19:34

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · Today 19:28

This is the strangest thing for me. Cats (with very few exceptions) don't actually want to eat what they catch - they just torture, maim and leave half dead for their own entertainment.

Cats have such a dark side and I don't know that I could ever bond with one.

Oh mine eat most of what they catch, but they often like it to mature first 🤢

The only thing they never eat is the shrews because they taste bad apparently so I wish they would leave them alone. They also make an awful noise when caught. I spend a lot of time catching them. I’ve got a little set up for traumatised rodents that I catch which is fairly successful. But there was one day in the heatwave when I lost my shit when I was presented with the 7th in a day.

The not quite dead bunnies are what I dread though.

Photo of the little bastards 🥰

To find cat owners who boast about their cats killing wildlife really weird?
RedDwerf · Today 19:35

I know exactly what you mean OP. Talking proudly about the cat bringing them 'gifts', as if it was a toddler doing something cute. I love cats but mine are strictly indoors only. I have a lot of insect and bird life in my garden and want to protect it as best I can.

Greenmouldycheese · Today 19:36

I've only ever hear of cat owners being disgusted when their cat brings him a rat, mouse or whatever.

CandidMintCat · Today 19:39

MarysSilverBells · Today 19:28

Why? Why do you not keep your cats in, or build a catio? Why are you inflicting them on wildlife that is already under serious pressure? The UK is one of the most nature depleted country in the world, don't you think that it would be good to try and help your local wildlife rather than saying 'well shucks, nothing I can do'.

I do a huge amount for local wildlife actually, I work as a volunteer on several local projects and foster hedgehogs with a local
rescue. What do you do?

Cats are not indoor animals, they are predators. I prefer all my animals to live naturally. My horses do, my cats do.

I’m not some soppy townie that thinks nothing should ever die.

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · Today 19:45

CandidMintCat · Today 19:34

Oh mine eat most of what they catch, but they often like it to mature first 🤢

The only thing they never eat is the shrews because they taste bad apparently so I wish they would leave them alone. They also make an awful noise when caught. I spend a lot of time catching them. I’ve got a little set up for traumatised rodents that I catch which is fairly successful. But there was one day in the heatwave when I lost my shit when I was presented with the 7th in a day.

The not quite dead bunnies are what I dread though.

Photo of the little bastards 🥰

Yes I find this aspect of domestic cats deeply unpleasant.

The apparent playfulness of it of is twisted. The prey animal isn't food in the conventional sense. Most predators chase their prey, catch it, eat it.

But with cats, their "prey" is a living creature being chased, caught, maimed, released, re-caught, released, chased, re-caught, tortured etc etc to the point of exhaustion, then left to die when it stops moving and becomes less stimulating.

It's sick. Twisted. And dark.

I find calling it "letting the prey "mature first" " particularly grim.

I could never get all "awwwwwww" over a pet like that.

Dragonflyy · Today 19:52

Cats should not be allowed to roam free. Why do cats gets a free pass? They are catastrophic for wild birds.
Should dogs be able to roam and kill cats because they enjoy it? Should dogs be running free and shitting in other people's gardens? No, so why do we allow cat owners to do this?

BillieWiper · Today 19:56

I've never ever heard anyone boasting about that. It's the one really sad side of cat ownership.

Saying it's in their nature is true. It doesn't mean the person is happy. We cry with sadness when we find dead baby birds or the cat had one in his mouth.

I'm glad they catch pests such as mice though. That's kind of one of the reasons we have domestic cats isn't it?

AlwaysSometimesNever · Today 20:04

CandidMintCat · Today 19:39

I do a huge amount for local wildlife actually, I work as a volunteer on several local projects and foster hedgehogs with a local
rescue. What do you do?

Cats are not indoor animals, they are predators. I prefer all my animals to live naturally. My horses do, my cats do.

I’m not some soppy townie that thinks nothing should ever die.

I get this but it’s a difficult argument to take to its logical conclusion. If cats made their way, while free to roam naturally, onto my land and were killed by my dogs, as is their nature equally, I’d be pilloried.

Keepingthingsinteresting · Today 20:06

CandidMintCat · Today 19:25

No

Then you are selfish & irresponsible. Bet you’d be bitching if your cat got hit by a car or chased by a dog, but I’m sure you’d find an excuse.