Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find cat owners who boast about their cats killing wildlife really weird?

60 replies

ThatQuickLimePombear · Today 18:15

I’m talking about the ones who seem genuinely proud of how many birds and other small animals their cats kill. Whenever anyone questions it, out comes the predictable, “Oooh, but it’s just in their nature!”

Yes, we know cats have hunting instincts. That doesn’t mean you have to celebrate the destruction of wildlife. I find the whole attitude bizarre, frankly. Fuck off with that excuse.

OP posts:
Keepingthingsinteresting · Today 20:08

BillieWiper · Today 19:56

I've never ever heard anyone boasting about that. It's the one really sad side of cat ownership.

Saying it's in their nature is true. It doesn't mean the person is happy. We cry with sadness when we find dead baby birds or the cat had one in his mouth.

I'm glad they catch pests such as mice though. That's kind of one of the reasons we have domestic cats isn't it?

I’m sure the baby birds are comforted by your tears. FFS keep the cat inside or build it a catio, there is no point allowing it to fuck up wildlife and thinking a little bit of sad face makes any difference other than perhaps to assuage your conscience, which I guess is why you do it, so much easier than actually doing something useful.

Greenmouldycheese · Today 20:12

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · Today 19:45

Yes I find this aspect of domestic cats deeply unpleasant.

The apparent playfulness of it of is twisted. The prey animal isn't food in the conventional sense. Most predators chase their prey, catch it, eat it.

But with cats, their "prey" is a living creature being chased, caught, maimed, released, re-caught, released, chased, re-caught, tortured etc etc to the point of exhaustion, then left to die when it stops moving and becomes less stimulating.

It's sick. Twisted. And dark.

I find calling it "letting the prey "mature first" " particularly grim.

I could never get all "awwwwwww" over a pet like that.

Edited

Never had a cat and had no idea that they did this. No wonder so many people hate cats. Ive heard some people talk about purposely running them over too.

GreenFrameDot · Today 20:23

Yes, DM does this and finds it funny that the cats bring at least two dead birds in a day. We used to get daily updates on the family WhatsApp with specifics which I found distasteful.

Any comments from me about putting a collar on/feeding them more filling, meaty food/keeping them in at dawn and dusk/playing with them were swept aside with ‘it’s just their nature’. It seems so callous.

Goldensprat · Today 20:27

Truinio · Today 19:24

There’s only one species of mouse that regularly enters dwellings (the aptly named house mouse).

Wood mice, harvest mice, yellow necked mice, bank voles, field voles are not pests and yet are all regularly predated by domestic cats.

Edited

Yes, house mice kept coming in my house in the winters. Now they don't, which is why cats were domesticated in the first place, so I am pleased with the cat even though as I say he is not a hunter. If a mouse came in I would be proud of him if he hunted it, that's his job.

I think I'd need to get another one if I lived on a farm and needed serious rodent control though, as I picked one with very little get and up go.

PerfectPaula · Today 20:30

I think you must have a slightly odd perception of what boasting sounds like. Unless it's a farm/stable cat who is an excellent rat killer and that is the main purpose for having it, I can't see why anyone would 'boast' about such a thing. Especially not about killing birds. It's a fact of life and they may not feel the need to apologise for it, but boast? I really don't think so.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · Today 20:47

I’ve talked about my cat doing this but always by saying it’s awful I felt awful etc

Alconleigh · Today 20:54

Like many others have said, no cat owners I have ever met, including myself, boast about this. It is pretty grim. Red in tooth and claw, and all that. Having said that mine mostly hunts rubber bands from the sorting office next door. It is an anomaly that we have one type of pet that roams freely where other pets don’t. I’ve heard Americans don’t really let cats out at all, but don’t know if that’s true.

lljkk · Today 21:02

My cats are amazing predators.

Especially good ratters. I discovered that when neighbour took herself & her 2 dogs away giving my cats easy access to next door's garden. I did feel sorry for the very noisy squeaking rats, tbh.

It's not boasting if I admire capable hunting cats. I can't take credit for their propensity.

lljkk · Today 21:03

I'm American, of course our cats get out. It's Australians who are often banned from letting cats roam. Their eco-system developed without a cat-like predator.

TerribleEntrepreneur · Today 21:05

I wouldn’t boast about this and I don’t know any cat owners that do.

My cat catches rodents. We live in the centre of farmland and have chickens, so I’m happy about this. I have nothing against rats and mice as creatures, but it’s necessary to deter them and the presence of a predator does that much more kindly and naturally than the methods some use, like poison.

If all cats had to be indoors I wouldn’t have one at all.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page