Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

513 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
Noras · Today 17:10

ShutupLwren · Today 15:23

I have a child similar to how you describe your own son. Mine is 8. I am genuinely terrified for the future. Nothing to add, sending solidarity I suppose 💐

They are exempt

my son is more borderline due to spiky profile - not sure how he could work in a normal paid job with white matter issues / demylination.

It was hard thinking of best equipment for university as he has the ASD speech pattern for talk to write and he has motor coordination that tired in for typing - we opted for him to type but he has soft ware to abbreviate notes / record lectures and mind maps etc. It’s hard to overcome disability with tools.

Happyindevon · Today 17:11

I also see a lot of PIP piss takers at work. It’s all for MH and anxiety, yet their ‘anxiety’ still allows them to do basically anything apart from work, including things that actually require confidence/executive function.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:12

Happyindevon · Today 17:09

I think they just need to look holistically and pragmatically at the whole grift.

If you’re not too anxious/ND to date, go on holiday, have kids, take them to school, take them to medical appointments etc, then you’re not too anxious to work.

Honestly I’m amazed the piss taking has reached a point where people seriously expect you to be accepting of somebody on benefits because they’re too mentally ill to work, but can do anything else.

Working is totally different to going on holiday and dating. Totally different demands.

LaAranaPequenita · Today 17:13

Of course there are people who really cannot work, and children who need extra support, and our benefit system is meant to be for them.

I know 2 people who get PIP and they shouldn’t. One hasn’t worked since they were 40 and with the money they get from the state and other means they are living the life of Riley. How come they need PIP but are perfectly able to self drive down to the south coast of Spain 3 times a year?

I work with someone who didn’t live here since they were 22 (after graduated) and then came back aged 65 as they run out of money, healthcare was too expensive and they had no pension. They now get pension credit for 2, housing paid for, and 2 sets of attendance allowance, but have never paid any NI. That’s over £4K a month in benefits.

People are taking the absolute piss and my household is getting hammered in tax to sub it.

I don’t want to pay tax for other people to suck the country dry. I only want it to go to those who really can’t, rather than won’t.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:13

Well if we've learnt anything from this thread its terrifying some off the people who are working with the most vulnerable in society

SuddenDaredJelly · Today 17:13

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

I suspect they will carve out a new benefit for those with severe learning disabilities eg very low iq or diagnosed genetic disorders etc. Over time its likely I'd expect it to gradually replace pip but will be much harder to access & will essentially only be available to very very disabled individuals, eg those unlikely to live independently as adults.

mummymeister · Today 17:14

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:12

Working is totally different to going on holiday and dating. Totally different demands.

why do you say that? surely if someone can navigate booking a holiday, getting to the place on time, planning activities and days out or talking to a stranger, planning a date, getting ready for it dressed appropriately, arriving on time, making small talk etc. how is there not some sort of job out there that they could do? Genuine question.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 17:15

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

He isn’t - young people like your son aren’t the people the changes are aimed at.

Happyindevon · Today 17:15

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:12

Working is totally different to going on holiday and dating. Totally different demands.

Yes it’s less enjoyable and actually requires a bit of stress sometimes. Whoopdey doo, we all have to do it. (Or should)

Happyindevon · Today 17:16

mummymeister · Today 17:14

why do you say that? surely if someone can navigate booking a holiday, getting to the place on time, planning activities and days out or talking to a stranger, planning a date, getting ready for it dressed appropriately, arriving on time, making small talk etc. how is there not some sort of job out there that they could do? Genuine question.

They’ll tell you about a mythical condition that means you can exercise, date, go on holiday, socialise, have kids, broadcast your life on Instagram, but means you absolutely cannot work and expect you to believe them

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:16

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 17:15

He isn’t - young people like your son aren’t the people the changes are aimed at.

But they will be if they target all under 25s. People don't get it. Everytime people tell there story they say well they don't mean you.

Heatedblankettime · Today 17:18

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:12

Working is totally different to going on holiday and dating. Totally different demands.

Tell me about it. I am well enough to work but not well enough to go on holiday or manage a social life outside of work.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 17:19

Happyindevon · Today 17:11

I also see a lot of PIP piss takers at work. It’s all for MH and anxiety, yet their ‘anxiety’ still allows them to do basically anything apart from work, including things that actually require confidence/executive function.

It’s so strange for me to see the way people use their supposed mental health issues as either badges of honour or at least excuses to get what they want.

I have struggled with severe mental illness since the early 1990s when anything like that was such a shameful secret to be hidden from everyone at all costs. I suffered so much discrimination when I returned to work each time after sick leave and was automatically written off by managers despite being highly thought of before being ill.

It seems to have swung too far in the opposite direction now when you see people desperately trying to self diagnose with MH labels.

LaAranaPequenita · Today 17:20

Happyindevon · Today 17:16

They’ll tell you about a mythical condition that means you can exercise, date, go on holiday, socialise, have kids, broadcast your life on Instagram, but means you absolutely cannot work and expect you to believe them

What % of jobs are now work from home? It’s a lot more than it was.

My DH WFH 50% of the time and my friend 100%

Why can’t incentives be given to companies to employ people who are unable to leave the house and be given the opportunity to WFH? For a start, the local councils could give out some of their cushy roles.

Yep, all the PIP claimants I know claim it for MH issues. One can run marathons and do triathlons but doesn’t have the mental resilience to hold down a job.

Lambch0p · Today 17:20

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 17:15

He isn’t - young people like your son aren’t the people the changes are aimed at.

It isn’t either or. There are people all the way through the spectrum of need and also those who are on very long difficulties journeys. It’s utter madness just taking it from all. Many people are using it to fill gaps from the NHS. They will no longer be able to have treatment or therapy! What happens to them and the NHS lists they will need to go on?

Simonjt · Today 17:22

Ubertomusic · Today 14:13

Where do you usually find supportive employers?

This is a huge issue.

We have left the UK now, but my husband has a significant physical disability he was born with. Due to that so many jobs are completely out of his reach, no matter what adaptations are provided. But lots of careers and jobs are within his reach. He’s lucky that hes academic, so he could gain a career based on those skills. When he qualified and was looking for work he was on three occasions told when he booked in for his interview that the post had been filled. On two of those occasions another guy on the same training scheme was interviewed on the same day at a later time. When he did finally get a job his line manager actively moaned that he needed a different keyboard, mouse and for when he was tired eyegaze technology and would ask at every single line management meeting for him to just try harder at using normal equipment. He was hitting all of his targets and often early, but that didn’t matter to then.

So many employers actively discriminate against people with disabilities.

As I said, hes academic, if he wasn’t all the trades, shop work, care work, cleaning, driving jobs, and anything that requires you to hold something heavier than a bag of sugar, or to type/use a mouse for more than about 40 minutes without a break just aren’t possible for him.

Truinio · Today 17:22

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:45

This news is great. It’s all about getting disabled people off benefits and into work, giving them a proper future to look forward to. What is the issue? Why the negativity? A life on benefits is surely the worst possible option for someone.

Yep all those employers queuing up to employ disabled people. They can’t get enough of them and prefer them over the hoards of able bodied young jobseekers.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:23

mummymeister · Today 17:14

why do you say that? surely if someone can navigate booking a holiday, getting to the place on time, planning activities and days out or talking to a stranger, planning a date, getting ready for it dressed appropriately, arriving on time, making small talk etc. how is there not some sort of job out there that they could do? Genuine question.

What job involves dressing your self and spending time by a pool.

Why are you assuming that someone is actually doing all of those things with no issues or help? I know someone who goes on a holiday a few times a year. He just has to pack. His family do everything else. He does not date, but has friendships. He can't hold down a job. No one wants to work with a paranoid schizophrenic that is in about out of hospital, let alone give him a job.

But disabled people that can go on holiday and date must somehow be scammers?

BurntBroccoli · Today 17:23

Blackcat2026 · Today 14:36

People don't think of it as a severe condition because so many people are now diagnosed with it! People who were once deemed 'socially awkward' or 'picky', people who were once diagnosed with Aspergers and could work.

This dilution is extremely unhelpful to people with classically autistic people in their care and this is what the government are striving to move away from. It's targeting young people who might find work more difficult than some others do, but who are work capable. Young people with anxiety, who are sitting home on games consols or puffing on joints in their parents' houses, instead of overcoming their difficulties and getting out in the world. If the already overweight tax burden is not relieved soon, life is going to be very difficult for everyone - there simply won't be enough tax payers to pay.

Tax burden pensioners
£177 billion

Tax burden PIP
£27.3 billion

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:25

LaAranaPequenita · Today 17:20

What % of jobs are now work from home? It’s a lot more than it was.

My DH WFH 50% of the time and my friend 100%

Why can’t incentives be given to companies to employ people who are unable to leave the house and be given the opportunity to WFH? For a start, the local councils could give out some of their cushy roles.

Yep, all the PIP claimants I know claim it for MH issues. One can run marathons and do triathlons but doesn’t have the mental resilience to hold down a job.

Edited

And what jobs do they do? What % of WFH are entry level?

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 17:26

BurntBroccoli · Today 17:23

Tax burden pensioners
£177 billion

Tax burden PIP
£27.3 billion

The difference is that pensioners have contributed towards their pensions during their working lives

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:30

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 17:19

It’s so strange for me to see the way people use their supposed mental health issues as either badges of honour or at least excuses to get what they want.

I have struggled with severe mental illness since the early 1990s when anything like that was such a shameful secret to be hidden from everyone at all costs. I suffered so much discrimination when I returned to work each time after sick leave and was automatically written off by managers despite being highly thought of before being ill.

It seems to have swung too far in the opposite direction now when you see people desperately trying to self diagnose with MH labels.

There is still a significant stigma around mental illness. My work certainly don't pander to my health conditions I use all my holidays on hospital appointments and the rest I have to take unpaid. Occy health reports are just suggestions. So no help there.

LaAranaPequenita · Today 17:30

BurntBroccoli · Today 17:23

Tax burden pensioners
£177 billion

Tax burden PIP
£27.3 billion

If someone receives a state pension, that means they worked for at least 30 years, paid NI and other taxes out of their earnings and contributed to society.

If you want to save money, look at the work shy, not those who understand what hard work is.

zen1 · Today 17:31

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:07

Yes and alan Milburn has specifically said that instead of cash benefits those with certain conditions (ADHD, anxiety etc) should be given help to overcome them.

If only it was as simple as that. I would give anything for my son to be able to overcome the anxiety he suffers due to his autism. He has been having weekly NHS therapies associated with the co-morbidities of his autism since he was 3 (now 18). He has not ‘overcome’ them and never will due to it being a lifelong condition (also has learning disabilities). If some untrained pen-pushing assessor with no lived experience of autism assesses him, they will see the word ‘anxiety’ and not realise he will not ‘overcome’ it. He can’t work. He can’t leave the house without a carer due to debilitating fear.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:32

zen1 · Today 17:31

If only it was as simple as that. I would give anything for my son to be able to overcome the anxiety he suffers due to his autism. He has been having weekly NHS therapies associated with the co-morbidities of his autism since he was 3 (now 18). He has not ‘overcome’ them and never will due to it being a lifelong condition (also has learning disabilities). If some untrained pen-pushing assessor with no lived experience of autism assesses him, they will see the word ‘anxiety’ and not realise he will not ‘overcome’ it. He can’t work. He can’t leave the house without a carer due to debilitating fear.

I've been under cmht for over 20 years and guess what still not fixed and there was a couple off inpatient stays in that time aswell