Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

507 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
PollyPocket80 · Today 16:56

Sadly I don't think it's possible to have a reasonable conversation about this here as has been proved-those on PIP, refused PIP, disabled family etc are getting on the defensive automatically without even trying to see the intent or context of the posts. This is clearly not an anti-disabled thread but I give up.
I also think MN being a heavily middle-class demographic isn't helping, maybe these people have no lived experience or exposure to the darker sides of life (lucky them).

Kirbert2 · Today 16:56

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:55

So share with the group then how do we easily get pip without medical evidence. Because I have nearly 40 years off medical evidence from multiple consultants across multiple trusts and that wasn't good enough.

I was going to say, I can't imagine they have much interest in 'evidence' from GP's.

Toomanyminifigs · Today 16:56

Benefits and Work have done a very helpful breakdown of all the proposed changes to PIP for young people.

I'm not sure if this has been picked up in the thread yet but it looks like the government is proposing to extend DLA to 18. I have long suspected this was coming. Given the increase in the number of DLA claims, it would seem a logical move to try and 'stop the flow' of those DC moving on to PIP so in the long term the numbers of people on disability benefits naturally decreases.

I also imagine there's not much political appetite to tackle DLA claims as 'going for' disabled children probably isn't great optics. So the idea - rather like what they're proposing with EHCPs will be that DC/YP will lose their entitlement to both at a transfer phase.

https://benefitsandwork.co.uk/news/milburn-review-final-report

hoolaho · Today 16:56

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:51

People are fighting against something they may need themselves one day. You know what's vile and nasty ableists. I should just sit here while multiple people who know absolutely nothing about pip or disability say how where all scammers and how easy it is to get pip and we all sit in spoons all day. Yet you've said not one word to them

Nobody has ever said that!

mummymeister · Today 16:58

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:49

Its amazing how you have access to all these people's bank accounts and medical records. You know absolutely nothing about random people's lives or even the real lives off people your closest to

If you work in organisations which help people complete pip forms then you have access to both their bank accounts and their medical history. because they share it with you to help you complete the form.

I am assuming you completed the forms yourself and got refused? if so go and seek some professional help and resubmit.

You disagree with my pov, fair enough. there is absolutely no need to start slinging around nasty comments.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:59

Chiefunderling · Today 16:34

It’s not just completing a form though. You need to provide substantial legitimate evidence for everything you are claiming in the PIP form. This evidence is heavily scrutinised. You then get assessed, face to face or over the phone, by an assessor working for the DWP. This person is a healthcare professional employed by the DWP. This assessment will go over everything you put in the form & all the evidence you submitted. You can certainly lie in the form, but you won’t get PIP without a substantial amount of evidence to back up EVERYTHING you are claiming. Most of this evidence needs to come from professionals; Doctors, consultants, therapists, support workers, & Clinical Psychologists. You also need to give permission for the DWP to contact those treating you themselves.

There is a world of difference between applying for PIP & being successful in your application. In fact, many people who provide all of the above are still denied & end up in a tribunal (if they don’t take their owns lives first). Tribunals overturn approximately 60% of DWP PIP refusals. That tells us the DWP is not doing its job & is actually denying genuinely disabled people the money they need to survive. A tribunal panel is made up of multiple experts & a judge, & considers all the evidence provided in addition to your medical records. Scamming the system is incredibly hard to do. It’s so hard, genuine claimants are routinely denied PIP! This is the cold hard truth.

edited for typos.

Edited

Just because “genuine claimants are routinely denied PIP” that doesn’t mean that it is “incredibly hard to scam the system”.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:00

Kirbert2 · Today 16:56

I was going to say, I can't imagine they have much interest in 'evidence' from GP's.

They don't in my renewal it specifically stated not to send gp reports. All my evidence was from decades under secondary care. People just genuinely believe you just go along to your gp once get sent for no further investigation and then just get given pip. Its so frustrating when you've been through the process yourself and know exactly how it works. But people prefer to listen to people who know a friend of a friends uncles neighbour

Heatedblankettime · Today 17:00

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:55

So share with the group then how do we easily get pip without medical evidence. Because I have nearly 40 years off medical evidence from multiple consultants across multiple trusts and that wasn't good enough.

Well dont you see that that is exactly why the PIP system is so problematic? Because some people are getting it who don't really need it but others don't get it and yet life is a real daily struggle.
We need to stop pretending that it's a binary between people in rude health who have no adverse life circumstances and people who are profoundly disabled and very worthy of their benefits. The current system has a whole mess between those two points

hoolaho · Today 17:00

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:55

So share with the group then how do we easily get pip without medical evidence. Because I have nearly 40 years off medical evidence from multiple consultants across multiple trusts and that wasn't good enough.

Your medical evidence needs to say some very specific things. And sending 40 years of evidence will not help. A succinct pack of around 10 pages, supporting evidence (not just if a diagnosis but crucially how it affects you, how often, how severely).

I can not believe that people still don’t know this is going on.

mummymeister · Today 17:01

hoolaho · Today 16:56

Nobody has ever said that!

100% agree and its because people dont actually read whats written and debate it.

@mamaof4losingmymind is yet another poster who isnt letting the facts of what is actually being said get in the way of the fiction in their minds that we are all ableists ganging up against them.

and as for the 1% fraud. thats of the ones that they prosecute not the ones who they find out and deter. because no govt is ever going to admit that a benefit has widespread fraud.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:01

mummymeister · Today 16:58

If you work in organisations which help people complete pip forms then you have access to both their bank accounts and their medical history. because they share it with you to help you complete the form.

I am assuming you completed the forms yourself and got refused? if so go and seek some professional help and resubmit.

You disagree with my pov, fair enough. there is absolutely no need to start slinging around nasty comments.

No my cpn filled it out with me but she didn't have access to my bank statements why on earth would she

Irishlinen · Today 17:02

There has to be a change to incentivise work - too many people young and old are in receipt of benefits when they are able to work and work is available. Of course there are many who are unable to work and they should be supported. The problem is the system has made it too easy to obtain benefits.

pilates · Today 17:02

I would like to think this new proposal will not affect the moderately/severely disabled but clamp down on the benefit cheats as we all know they do exist.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:03

mummymeister · Today 16:58

If you work in organisations which help people complete pip forms then you have access to both their bank accounts and their medical history. because they share it with you to help you complete the form.

I am assuming you completed the forms yourself and got refused? if so go and seek some professional help and resubmit.

You disagree with my pov, fair enough. there is absolutely no need to start slinging around nasty comments.

PIP is not means tested, so why would people be taking their bank statements?

Even with UC, you take them to the Job Centre when you first apply. No one else needs to see them.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:04

hoolaho · Today 17:00

Your medical evidence needs to say some very specific things. And sending 40 years of evidence will not help. A succinct pack of around 10 pages, supporting evidence (not just if a diagnosis but crucially how it affects you, how often, how severely).

I can not believe that people still don’t know this is going on.

Obviously I didn't send 40 years off evidence thats about 10 thousand pages. I sent reports from all my consultants, cpn, care co. Test results, imagining

mummymeister · Today 17:04

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:01

No my cpn filled it out with me but she didn't have access to my bank statements why on earth would she

as part of a wider check on what benefits you might be entitled to. people do often pitch up with all sorts of evidence. you didnt. it doesnt mean other people dont.

Kirbert2 · Today 17:04

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:00

They don't in my renewal it specifically stated not to send gp reports. All my evidence was from decades under secondary care. People just genuinely believe you just go along to your gp once get sent for no further investigation and then just get given pip. Its so frustrating when you've been through the process yourself and know exactly how it works. But people prefer to listen to people who know a friend of a friends uncles neighbour

My son is DLA because he's (almost) 11 but I was told the same thing.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:04

pilates · Today 17:02

I would like to think this new proposal will not affect the moderately/severely disabled but clamp down on the benefit cheats as we all know they do exist.

But it will

mummymeister · Today 17:05

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:03

PIP is not means tested, so why would people be taking their bank statements?

Even with UC, you take them to the Job Centre when you first apply. No one else needs to see them.

Edited

a lot of people go to independent organisations for help first and will bring along all sorts of documents and discuss in detail a lot of very irrelevant things. No one else needs to see them but they often do.

Kirbert2 · Today 17:06

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:04

But it will

Of course it will.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:07

mummymeister · Today 17:04

as part of a wider check on what benefits you might be entitled to. people do often pitch up with all sorts of evidence. you didnt. it doesnt mean other people dont.

As a professional you should be saying no you don't show anyone your private finances these are vulnerable people and you need to explain the seriousness off this not root through them for your own benefit. Thats concerning

mummymeister · Today 17:07

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:04

But it will

so you dont believe anything I and other posters are saying about scammers, or people gaming the system. but you know as an actual fact that those who need benefits are going to be adversely impacted. and you know this how? when it hasnt even gone before Parliament. do tell, I am all ears.....

Happyindevon · Today 17:09

mummymeister · Today 16:26

Believe me when I say that the facebook forum where the scammers congregate are literally shitting themselves that they are going to be found out and lose their PIP. they know that with a proper robust reassessment they dont have a leg to stand on (no pun intended) They know that the minute they are expected to attend therapies etc the game will be up. they do not want this to come in because then its game over.

I think they just need to look holistically and pragmatically at the whole grift.

If you’re not too anxious/ND to date, go on holiday, have kids, take them to school, take them to medical appointments etc, then you’re not too anxious to work.

Honestly I’m amazed the piss taking has reached a point where people seriously expect you to be accepting of somebody on benefits because they’re too mentally ill to work, but can do anything else.

mummymeister · Today 17:09

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:07

As a professional you should be saying no you don't show anyone your private finances these are vulnerable people and you need to explain the seriousness off this not root through them for your own benefit. Thats concerning

you dont like me because you dont agree with me I get that. thats fine.

But stop it please just stop it. you have absolutely no idea what my interactions with people are.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 17:10

I think I agree with the previous poster who said it is impossible to have a reasoned discussion about this on MN. Some seem determined to feel victimised and attacked by posters who are actually supporting the genuinely disabled.