Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

503 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:46

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:44

Again , lots of people are disabled or battling chronic health conditions or dealing with some other adversity but they are just too honest to submit a scammy PIP application

It's simply not the case that everyone who doesn't get PIP is neurotypical and bouncing around running marathons in their spare time.

Well obviously because pips incredibly hard to get so obviously every disabled person isn't going to get it.

Lambch0p · Today 16:46

hoolaho · Today 16:44

Who are you referring to?

All I see is posters who want genuinely disabled people to get a higher amount of benefits and support than they do now. And for the scammers to be stopped.

What are you talking about? Fraud numbers for PIP is low and the entire cohort of 18-25s on PIP are not scammers!

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:47

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:43

Tattoos too. Oh, and the latest iPhone.

Well, in fairness I have seen bank statements of parents claiming the whole suite of benefits and their expenditure on take away coffee/iPhones /deliveroo caused my eyes to literally (well, almost) pop out of my head. I am surprised people aren't more angry about how well it can pay to claim benefits Vs working your butt off. It's a mugs game to work these days and it's important government tackles this

(And yes I know PIP can be an in work benefit. But it also makes being on other benefits a much nicer lifestyle)

hoolaho · Today 16:47

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:40

Whole towns? Which towns? If this is happening, then you can name them.

Ok, not the actual whole town 😂 some people want to work.

I could name plenty of towns, starting with some I have lived in. But how would that help? It would just change the direction of this thread into a “shithole” bashing thread.

Anneleesa · Today 16:47

I would like to know who on earth is going to employ all these younger people with MH and ADHD and autism? Jobs don’t exist for these people at the margins, they will fail at work. Throwing the burden onto employers isn’t going to be a good solution.

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:48

Lambch0p · Today 16:46

What are you talking about? Fraud numbers for PIP is low and the entire cohort of 18-25s on PIP are not scammers!

Fraud numbers are based on actual investigations. If there aren't sufficient resources to investigate we will never know how extensive it is

Plus it's often not pure fraud but very creative embellishments

mummymeister · Today 16:48

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:42

There are a few people on this thread who are going to get one hell of a harsh lesson one day when they get ill one day and just never get better or end up in an accident through no fault of there own. Or give birth to a disabled child. Some people really do think their above becoming disabled

What a vile nasty post. I have a child with disabilities. I have a disability myself. one of my parents has been in a wheelchair for the past 50 years.

You do realise that this is how people react when they have lost the argument?

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:49

mummymeister · Today 16:45

This is an anonymous forum. no one is going to tell you where they live as you well know.

I have been on MN for years - since it started. I am not a liar. I see these posts every single fucking day on the facebook "gossip girls" type forums.

I drink coffee in spoons. I hear the conversations.

You choose not to believe me, thats fine, I can live with that. But it doesnt change the actual facts - the system is being scammed. The govt accept that that is why its being changed yet you dont?

Its amazing how you have access to all these people's bank accounts and medical records. You know absolutely nothing about random people's lives or even the real lives off people your closest to

thatsgotit · Today 16:49

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:47

Well, in fairness I have seen bank statements of parents claiming the whole suite of benefits and their expenditure on take away coffee/iPhones /deliveroo caused my eyes to literally (well, almost) pop out of my head. I am surprised people aren't more angry about how well it can pay to claim benefits Vs working your butt off. It's a mugs game to work these days and it's important government tackles this

(And yes I know PIP can be an in work benefit. But it also makes being on other benefits a much nicer lifestyle)

How have you seen these people's bank statements?

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:49

mummymeister · Today 16:45

This is an anonymous forum. no one is going to tell you where they live as you well know.

I have been on MN for years - since it started. I am not a liar. I see these posts every single fucking day on the facebook "gossip girls" type forums.

I drink coffee in spoons. I hear the conversations.

You choose not to believe me, thats fine, I can live with that. But it doesnt change the actual facts - the system is being scammed. The govt accept that that is why its being changed yet you dont?

The gov own figures for PIP fraud is less than 1%. It is not being changed because of scammers. It is being changed because young people people are going without support and are being written off.
If you know people are scamming the system, then why are you not reporting them?
Seeing a stranger in a Wetherspoons in the day does not mean they are scamming the system. That sounds awfully like you think disabled people should never leave their house.

emuloc · Today 16:49

hoolaho · Today 16:38

Maybe you should RTFT

It’s absolutely NOT incredibly hard to fraudulently claim PIP. In fact whole estates and even towns are doing it!

They really are not. It is very difficult to obtain a PIP award, despite what some people may say. Anyone can say anything, that is why medical evidence is what really matters.

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:50

Anneleesa · Today 16:47

I would like to know who on earth is going to employ all these younger people with MH and ADHD and autism? Jobs don’t exist for these people at the margins, they will fail at work. Throwing the burden onto employers isn’t going to be a good solution.

ADHD and autism can be real strengths in the work place. I know so many adults with autism who have not just survived but thrived at work because 20-30 years ago there wasn't an option to get diagnosed and then stay at home getting benefits

LurgyMagnet · Today 16:50

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:27

Oh and disability assessments will be taken from the NHS and given to the job centre.

The NHS haven't done disability assessments for donkeys' years. It's Capita or some other outsourced company that does it.

Kirbert2 · Today 16:50

I'm glad that my son still has 5 years of DLA yet.

Will be interesting to see where all of these jobs are going to come from and the employers and colleagues who will employ and welcome them and their reasonable adjustments with open arms and no complaints as it is what was asked for.

Lambch0p · Today 16:51

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:48

Fraud numbers are based on actual investigations. If there aren't sufficient resources to investigate we will never know how extensive it is

Plus it's often not pure fraud but very creative embellishments

Care to share your links of evidence for this or did you just make it up?

And as I said the entire cohort of 18-25s are not scammers! Would love to know why those above who have had better access to treatment and a lifetime of NHS treatment and taxpayers money are somehow more worthy.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:51

mummymeister · Today 16:48

What a vile nasty post. I have a child with disabilities. I have a disability myself. one of my parents has been in a wheelchair for the past 50 years.

You do realise that this is how people react when they have lost the argument?

People are fighting against something they may need themselves one day. You know what's vile and nasty ableists. I should just sit here while multiple people who know absolutely nothing about pip or disability say how where all scammers and how easy it is to get pip and we all sit in spoons all day. Yet you've said not one word to them

Chiefunderling · Today 16:52

mummymeister · Today 16:41

Nope scamming the system is most definately not incredibly hard to do. private experts paid to do reports so its in their interests to over egg the symptoms. people are liars and cheats because if they do this the money they receive to sit on their arses all day and not work is considerable.

You need to get out more if you think this isnt going on on a huge wide scale across the country.

I do indeed wish my health would let me get out more. Having worked for organisations supporting sick & disabled people through the PIP claims process, I know your claims are completely false. Almost 2/3 PIP claims are overturned at tribunal, meaning the DWP is trying its best to deny disabled people the support they need. This is the exact opposite of what you suggest! Beliefs & facts are two very different things. Have the day you deserve 😊

BurntBroccoli · Today 16:52

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:27

We have to shift away from the "handouts for everything" culture. It's created a country of people who don't want to work. So yes it will be painful but it needs to happen

Benefits should be a safety net not a lifestyle choice

Where are they going to work?

It’s difficult enough for young people to get any job at all at the moment. Many just don’t exist anymore.

IzzyLeng · Today 16:52

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:39

I honestly think people think that you just tell the dwp I can't dress myself because I hurt my finger and the dwp say ok mate no probs heres £800

If you have various diagnosed conditions where that’s a possibility then yes this could happen. Obviously a bit more than a hurt finger, but ME, fibromyalgia, eds, etc. I have one of the above as a diagnosis and am in various support groups. I see people talking about making claims, etc.

a colleague who I’m on good terms with and has the same condition told me what to do to get pip. How would my gp know if I was telling them the truth or not if I told them dh has to help me dress every day.

Gp could say stand up and touch your toes (which I can do) but I could stand there looking like I’m trying but unable to bend forward. I could fail every grip strength test going by not trying and then say I can’t open jars or grate cheese. That my ankles are so painful I can’t walk. I could buy a walker and make sure I use it every time I go to the gp.

Someone locally I see him walking to the shop every day, striding along quickly with a crutch in each hand Never actually using them. He walks faster than me. I always laugh and think he must be on pip and worried about surveillance.

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:53

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:51

People are fighting against something they may need themselves one day. You know what's vile and nasty ableists. I should just sit here while multiple people who know absolutely nothing about pip or disability say how where all scammers and how easy it is to get pip and we all sit in spoons all day. Yet you've said not one word to them

I literally have a disability. My opinion is formed by seeing the advice people give each other to game the system and by being shocked at the push from people at the charity for my condition to exaggerate symptoms and struggles in order to get PIP. The whole thing is a mess

hoolaho · Today 16:53

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:44

I've been sectioned twice been under the cmht for years have bpd, bipolar, anxiety disorder, multiple organ failure. And I got zero points first try getting pip. Stop believing the newspapers

Ok, so you told them the truth, or they changed or twisted your words, and it meant that you didn’t meet the criteria.

I haven’t read about this in a newspaper, it is true lived experience of people I know well.

They apply knowing exactly what they need to provide, do and say to meet the criteria. When they go for the assessment they are ready, they already know it inside out and what they need to do.

They aim for higher rate if they can but the first step is simply to qualify.

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 16:53

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:59

PIP claims in the under 25’s has risen 2.3 x in the last 7 years. Totally unrealistic without widespread gaming the system.

Or possibly the effects of Covid on developing children ? We just don’t know.

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:55

IzzyLeng · Today 16:52

If you have various diagnosed conditions where that’s a possibility then yes this could happen. Obviously a bit more than a hurt finger, but ME, fibromyalgia, eds, etc. I have one of the above as a diagnosis and am in various support groups. I see people talking about making claims, etc.

a colleague who I’m on good terms with and has the same condition told me what to do to get pip. How would my gp know if I was telling them the truth or not if I told them dh has to help me dress every day.

Gp could say stand up and touch your toes (which I can do) but I could stand there looking like I’m trying but unable to bend forward. I could fail every grip strength test going by not trying and then say I can’t open jars or grate cheese. That my ankles are so painful I can’t walk. I could buy a walker and make sure I use it every time I go to the gp.

Someone locally I see him walking to the shop every day, striding along quickly with a crutch in each hand Never actually using them. He walks faster than me. I always laugh and think he must be on pip and worried about surveillance.

So share with the group then how do we easily get pip without medical evidence. Because I have nearly 40 years off medical evidence from multiple consultants across multiple trusts and that wasn't good enough.

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:55

IzzyLeng · Today 16:52

If you have various diagnosed conditions where that’s a possibility then yes this could happen. Obviously a bit more than a hurt finger, but ME, fibromyalgia, eds, etc. I have one of the above as a diagnosis and am in various support groups. I see people talking about making claims, etc.

a colleague who I’m on good terms with and has the same condition told me what to do to get pip. How would my gp know if I was telling them the truth or not if I told them dh has to help me dress every day.

Gp could say stand up and touch your toes (which I can do) but I could stand there looking like I’m trying but unable to bend forward. I could fail every grip strength test going by not trying and then say I can’t open jars or grate cheese. That my ankles are so painful I can’t walk. I could buy a walker and make sure I use it every time I go to the gp.

Someone locally I see him walking to the shop every day, striding along quickly with a crutch in each hand Never actually using them. He walks faster than me. I always laugh and think he must be on pip and worried about surveillance.

In fairness - re the crutches. I don't claim PIp but I do need a stick to stand. I don't need it to walk with just for standing (eg when queuing) so I must look suspect walking but carrying it!

MrsMurphyIWish · Today 16:55

Kirbert2 · Today 16:50

I'm glad that my son still has 5 years of DLA yet.

Will be interesting to see where all of these jobs are going to come from and the employers and colleagues who will employ and welcome them and their reasonable adjustments with open arms and no complaints as it is what was asked for.

Edited

Me too.

In principle I would love DS to have a job. I want him to have a happy, healthy, fulfilled life with employment, a house, activities, a family - not much to ask!

He manages daily at school because of the accommodations out in place for him. I’m not sure an employer will be so supportive!

Swipe left for the next trending thread