Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a perfectly acceptable reason to take the day off work?

320 replies

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:45

Dd (23) has an ongoing issue with her arm, she keeps getting horrendous pain (waiting for investigations but it’s likely to be due to hypermobility/ joint issues). The pain is severe and excruciating to the point she can’t talk eat move etc as it’s so bad.
standard painkillers don’t touch it. Codeine makes her uncontrollably vomit so can’t take that. She has called in sick to work today and been told that it’s not acceptable and they need to have a meeting as it’s the third time it’s happened this year. She literally can’t do her job safely (nursery) so surely they are BU?

OP posts:
TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 15:31

Putyhtgrf · Yesterday 15:26

I’m confused now. If she loves working with children and has been fine in this role until she picked up the injury then why not focus on getting that treated quickly rather than going back to the drawing board to study and retrain?

Because although she loves it she’s not managed full time and seems to have issues with the additional responsibilities of being an employee. I also feel that physically it’s taking a toll and I wasn’t as insistent previously for her to get qualifications aside from childcare

OP posts:
TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 15:34

Childcare was the only way we could get her to go to college we just went with that so she at least did something

OP posts:
DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 15:36

JustFrustrated · Yesterday 12:12

At my place we wouldn’t allow a family member to attend

colleague/team member or union rep. That’s it

Yes, she could have someone else support her.

MissMoneyFairy · Yesterday 15:37

If she has issues being an employee how will that change with a new job, what additional issues does this cause her. What college certificate did she get, would she be interested in a more structured job with children like nursery support worker in the NHS

Putyhtgrf · Yesterday 15:37

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 15:31

Because although she loves it she’s not managed full time and seems to have issues with the additional responsibilities of being an employee. I also feel that physically it’s taking a toll and I wasn’t as insistent previously for her to get qualifications aside from childcare

Maybe she should just resign then as there isn’t any point going off sick or attending the meeting if she isn’t going to return to that role.
Has she said what she would prefer to do?

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 15:40

Putyhtgrf · Yesterday 15:37

Maybe she should just resign then as there isn’t any point going off sick or attending the meeting if she isn’t going to return to that role.
Has she said what she would prefer to do?

Financially it’s better I guess to be signed off sick than resign for the notice period ?

OP posts:
DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 15:41

Periperi2025 · Yesterday 15:12

She needs to get her shit together Autism or not, if she is burnt out at 23. She has a long time left to work and contribute to society. Maybe this isn't the career for her, but she needs to find something that is not take a 'break'.

Edited

Burnt out doesn't mean giving up work forever.

But it might mean a long break from work if you don't recognise burn out. While she is young and living at home she has options also. Why not use them?

in my 30s I had two years (still working but something completely different) away from my main career while DCs were small as I tried to keep going for so long in a burnt out state and became quite depressed.

Putyhtgrf · Yesterday 15:42

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 15:40

Financially it’s better I guess to be signed off sick than resign for the notice period ?

True but it’s not really fair on her employer if she has no intention of returning. Will she just get SSP?

lessglittermoremud · Yesterday 15:44

I work in a similar setting and it’s full on, the rules, extra training, key children responsibilities, planning, EYFS all take extra time as well as being in the room and looking after the children.
I love it however I’m old compared to most of my colleagues, have my own children and I am used to being pulled in a million and one directions.
There is a high turn over of staff in most nurseries because people go into thinking it’s a doddle (it really isn’t) or they’ve struggled academically and have been funnelled down that route by colleges etc without anyone really considering the toll it’s going to take because it’s not ‘just’ playing and hugging babies…
I really enjoy it but tbh it doesn’t sound like a progression that suits your daughter I personally would advise her to resign and re-charge if you’re able to support her.
Then look at volunteering etc to try and get an idea of what it is that may fit her better, then look to retrain. She can always use her qualifications for babysitting/nannying in the meantime.
My eldest is Autistic I couldn’t see him coping in an environment that is similar to a nursery, the noise and pressure wouldn’t suit him at all, thankfully he’s still a teen and has plenty of time to decide what he wants to do, your daughter needs to consider something else, 3 nurseries in 3 years is quite a few moves.

MissMoneyFairy · Yesterday 15:44

Qqwhaqt what sick pay is she getting now, what does her contract say about giving notice from either side and pay?

Sladuf1 · Yesterday 15:50

Clarabell77 · Yesterday 14:18

That was a request made as part of a right to be accompanied though. The employer should be confirming in writing if this is a formal meeting with the right to be accompanied and only at that point might the daughter request a family member as the companion.

From the information OP has given, it sounds like the employer is planning on arranging an absence management meeting.

You’d be a brave employer to hold out the reasoning that underpinned those 2 decisions in the cases I mentioned is dependant on the right to being accompanied being engaged or a particular type of meeting.
Having read the judgments, the key points, when considering to allow an employee who is/could be disabled to be accompanied by a relative at a meeting, are as per the letter of the law (Equality Act s.20 being a big part of that). Therefore:
(i) does the duty to make reasonable adjustments arise?;
(ii) is there a PCP that puts the employee at a substantial disadvantage compared to people who aren’t disabled?;
(iii)would the thing the employer hasn’t done or could do have amounted/ amount to reasonable steps to take, to avoid the disadvantage?

LetMeGoogleThat · Yesterday 15:51

If she works in a nursery, its a physically demanding job and linked to the children's H&S, also they have legal ratios to maintain so need to be on top of this. I think it should be a 2 way meeting, what can they do for her to support, but also what can your daughter do. I'm not suggesting she should work when she is unwell, but can she let them know earlier? Its an absolute nightmare trying to cover staff from an agency in the early morning, and having been that manager! Balancing whether you need to close for the day.

Doritochaser · Yesterday 16:21

shhblackbag · Yesterday 12:38

If she needs someone there for these meetings encourage her to sign up for a union. You can't go with your adult daughter to a work meeting.

agreed. Your mother coming to a work meeting is a big no-no.

suki1964 · Yesterday 16:21

Regarding the pain

You say its the arm, but she is also unable to move her head or speak because the severity of. the pain

Is it more in the neck and around the TMJ area so that any movement of the arm aggravates and turning the head and moving the jaw can all trigger it?

I ask because I had severe pain after a fall, Im talking so severe I couldn't lie down , couldn't move the arm, couldn't even get my knickers down to go to the loo. So severe I was screaming in pain

I was put on to tramadol - and no - work was out of the question when on those , until I was pain free enough to get physio. When I fell I ripped the ligaments in my shoulder and managed to pinch a nerve and it was weeks later , carrying a bag with £10 of shopping ( so not heavy ) set it off

5 years later I still get the odd episode but I keep on with the exercises and and now weight training, and they are no where near as severe and come along a lot less

seahorsessky · Yesterday 16:24

How many people have said you're unreasonable?
Would they be happy with their child being cared for by a person who is in agony and presumably can't lift a baby safely? Before anyone says not all parents have two working arms, there is a difference if someone is in absolute agony and incapable of doing it safely. Parents I know who do have chronic conditions and disabilities discuss this with HCPs before birth, and some have OH assessments etc.

MsPrufrockk · Yesterday 16:28

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:52

It wasn’t about what it makes her look like it’s about making sure she isn’t spoken to inappropriately or taken advantage of, which I feel they have been doing as she’s very quiet and compliant when under stress. This situation with such a high level of pain has really been awful and she’s suddenly realised they don’t care they just want her in regardless of whether she will suffer or not.

It sounds like she isn't up to working unless she has a lot more support than she currently has. Does she have a support/disability worker?

You said this is the only job she can do, but she can't deal with stress or adults. There seems to be a much more serious issue at play than arm pain.

VioletOtter · Yesterday 16:32

Just wanted to send you some huge hugs! I have a child with ASD and suspected ASD myself and work can be very very complex. I’m amazing at my job and highly regarded but you wouldn’t know if it you saw me on a tricky day. I manage by working part time and working in the third sector - charity’s often have a varied mixture of people and life experiences and thus understanding. My current workplace is extremely flexible, good pay, hybrid working, enhanced AL and my boss and CEO face similar difficulties to myself. I also have no GCSEs etc. I’d definitely suggest being signed off due to her stress and burn out, letting her have a little breather and then working with her to explore her options. Volunteering for some charities or causes she is passionate about may get her foot in the door or atleast some experience and still help her going forward, there are also some organisations that support Autistic young adults and young people into employment. It’s about the right organisation as much as it is the right type of job. You sound like an amazing mum that is keen to advocate and that’s amazing!

disorganisedcrow · Yesterday 16:38

Mygreyhair · Yesterday 11:50

From a manager point of view, 3 absences within a 12-month period is high and a meeting should be called to find out if there is anything underlying.

If, as you say, there is an in-going medical issue, they should look at what adjustments they could make to her working day so she could attend. They may offer an occupational health assessment.

Ultimately though, she needs to be able to do her job. In the long term, is this job something she can realistically do?

When I read things like this I am so glad I am not in the UK.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · Yesterday 16:56

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 15:31

Because although she loves it she’s not managed full time and seems to have issues with the additional responsibilities of being an employee. I also feel that physically it’s taking a toll and I wasn’t as insistent previously for her to get qualifications aside from childcare

Whatever job she has she'll have responsibilities as an employee.

You need to support her to understand this. Calling in sick, and explaining to a manager what is wrong and how long you will be off shouldn't be a big deal

She needs to understand the consequences of not attending work on a regular basis, ie all contracted days, unless on annual leave

ilovepuppies2019 · Yesterday 17:02

I don’t understand how you all survive the sick leave approach in the UK. Three separate sicknesses is complete normal. You get a cold, get D and V, get a virus and have an accident in most years. I can’t think of many people who haven’t taken three separate incidents off work. Aus has a certain number of sick leave days and you use them with no questions asked beyond providing a doctors certificate after a certain number of days.

GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 17:06

I would recommend getting signed off by the GP for now until she is assessed, diagnosed and treated. That will get work off her back too, so she can focus on recovery. Work have every right to query as they need to ensure correct staffing levels in the nursery.

Further down the line, I’d recommend she look into
https://www.gov.uk/access-to-work For support while she is in employment. They can provide things like ADHD and autism coaching. There is a learning and development opportunity here. It may also be worth working with the nursery occ health to see if they could make any reasonable adjustments that help her to carry out her role, and prevent future burn out. If after that, she’s still struggling with the role, it may be worth considering alternative options and an environment that is better suited.

I hope that is helpful…

Access to Work: get support if you have a disability or health condition

Get help at work, including an Access to Work grant, if you have a disability or health condition - eligibility, how to apply.

https://www.gov.uk/access-to-work

Putyhtgrf · Yesterday 17:06

ilovepuppies2019 · Yesterday 17:02

I don’t understand how you all survive the sick leave approach in the UK. Three separate sicknesses is complete normal. You get a cold, get D and V, get a virus and have an accident in most years. I can’t think of many people who haven’t taken three separate incidents off work. Aus has a certain number of sick leave days and you use them with no questions asked beyond providing a doctors certificate after a certain number of days.

It varies in the UK though. A lot of professional roles have six months on full pay followed by six months on half pay and then Group Income protection insurance which covers up to 75% of your pay for a number of years or until state retirement age.

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 17:06

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 15:41

Burnt out doesn't mean giving up work forever.

But it might mean a long break from work if you don't recognise burn out. While she is young and living at home she has options also. Why not use them?

in my 30s I had two years (still working but something completely different) away from my main career while DCs were small as I tried to keep going for so long in a burnt out state and became quite depressed.

You were in your 30s.

I had severe burn out in a full time professional career well into my 30s and needed time off.

This is a 23 yo who still lives with mum, as none of the stresses of independent adult life and still can't be grown up enough to answer the phone to her employer or deal with them in a meeting without support from her mum.

This is completely unsustainable. If she's burnt out in a part time job at that young age and can't cope with anything.

Calliopespa · Yesterday 17:08

Heatedblankettime · Yesterday 12:11

Agree. Especially in a nursery environment where children are constantly bringing in lurgies

I was thinking that! I reckon I'd be lucky not to get three lurgies in six months if I was in a nursery.

Calliopespa · Yesterday 17:09

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 17:06

You were in your 30s.

I had severe burn out in a full time professional career well into my 30s and needed time off.

This is a 23 yo who still lives with mum, as none of the stresses of independent adult life and still can't be grown up enough to answer the phone to her employer or deal with them in a meeting without support from her mum.

This is completely unsustainable. If she's burnt out in a part time job at that young age and can't cope with anything.

Is that supportive?

It sounds as though she is trying... What are you suggesting she do? Give up?