Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a perfectly acceptable reason to take the day off work?

323 replies

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:45

Dd (23) has an ongoing issue with her arm, she keeps getting horrendous pain (waiting for investigations but it’s likely to be due to hypermobility/ joint issues). The pain is severe and excruciating to the point she can’t talk eat move etc as it’s so bad.
standard painkillers don’t touch it. Codeine makes her uncontrollably vomit so can’t take that. She has called in sick to work today and been told that it’s not acceptable and they need to have a meeting as it’s the third time it’s happened this year. She literally can’t do her job safely (nursery) so surely they are BU?

OP posts:
TiredShadows · Yesterday 20:46

YANBU for it being an acceptable reason to not be working.

Something that might help with her struggling to communicate at work on this is Rhys Morgan's workplace playbook, designed for neurodivergent professionals. They've been helpful for me when I returned to work after being suddenly hospitalised. Having script options while I wasn't at 100% made it less overwhelming and helped me think through what was causing issues and what I could do to put it into place.

One of the first tips in it, for any disabled adult, is what many on here have said - joining a union. Some of them also have learning support.

Where I work, there is a meeting after any sick absence, and it turns into absence manage after 4 sick leaves in a year or a certain amount of days. We still have quite a few disabled people who need more than that, it's just managed. I've not yet hit the limit, but I have regular meetings around my adjustments and preventing absences.

We have done the physio self referral but the GP said they will likely want to have the results of the scan and a doctors opinion before doing anything

Can she go back, get a second opinion? My DH has had physio repeatedly for damage and trapped nerves in his back without any scans.

MissMoneyFairy · Yesterday 20:47

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 20:36

At the moment yes but if we work towards some goals and get the cause of the pain identified and treated she will likely be ok in the future ?

Whats causing the burnout? Is it the pain which a physio can assess if the doctor hasn't carried out an assessment, it could be a injury, where on her arm is the pain. Does any thing in particular bring on the pain? If she gets a diagnosis and it's treatable then she should be able to work but if its the asd that's causing her so much stress and burnout you have to think realistically about what she can manage, even if that means going on benefits with very few working hours. In what way does she struggle with adults,his it she feels anxious or is it more of a management/authority issue, she gets on well with parents. If she's not physically able to safely care for children then she has to look at different options.

MelonGoo · Yesterday 20:50

Is this real? Or some kind of faux commentary on the state of our young NEETs?

If it is real, for the love of God do not go with the meeting with her. She is an adult!!

I would suggest the fact that she's now had three failed employments means she needs to re-evaluate. And a short sharp shock wouldn't be the end of the world, but I expect you will cushion it for her and on she will go into employment no.4.

Maybe take the break and encourage her to have a very deep rethink.

Summertimesadnessishere · Yesterday 20:51

hihelenhi · Yesterday 19:17

Agreed, three absences in 12 months is not anywhere near unacceptable or unusual in itself, so in that sense it's not so outrageous that it would trigger a review with management. I'm a former manager, I wouldn't have called a review for three absences in a year, someone gets sick, has a cold, whatever lurgy they pick up, ffs. Three DAYS is not excessive. More might be. So is it more than that?

Because if it's due to a health issue that is ongoing, unpredictable and may be long term, that may seriously impact an individual's capacity to do the job they're paid for, of course that does need to be addressed and discussed. They need to understand the problem, what, if any provisions can be made.

And sorry but it IS massively weird for an adult employee to have her mother calling in sick for her and wanting to attending meetings with work because their "adult" child cannot cope. This is infantilising and enabling.

Agree about the mother ringing up - I missed that bit ! Yes she needs to deal with it - did mum say she was an ASD individual though- I think it’s fine to attend an interview with a witness if there is a chance she could be put on some form of warning etc. and someone with special needs would need to ensure that was dealt with fairly. I’m not sure if those needs are defined and understood and she has a genuine diagnosis. I know my employer if the absences indicated an ongoing problem would make a call to occupational health if only to cover themselves in the event that it ended up at a tribunal we would need to show we put appropriate accommodations in place. But it’s also in her interests to have the occupational health assessment to ensure everyone’s safety and well being.

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 20:52

If your daughter has ASD, its perfectly understandable that she can manage the routine tasks of looking after and interacting with children (who don't actually demand typical social responses) but she's struggle in a formal work meeting: the anxiety of the unexpected, slow processing of auditory information, not being able to judge people's feelings about what they say.

I can also understand that she can only manage part time work: the work environment is going to be more tiring for her than most people. It's like saying to a NT person, "well, you can work 8 hours a day 5 days a week, why not 10 hours a day, 7 days a week?" It's not sustainable.

I think you need to discuss with her what reasonable adjustments for the meeting that help her participate might look like. It might be having someone to at the meeting take notes, and for her to have advanced written notice of the content of the meeting so she can plan responses. Maybe even having the meeting online, so she could feel in a safe place at home while she does it. Her mum speaking for her probably isn't a reasonable adjustment, I'm afraid.

I'm really sympathetic to your daughter here, and the pain sounds horrible and her workplace don't sound very empathetic. But I also think that handing in her notice because of a work meeting is not an anxiety-driven response, and supporting her in doing this is probably going to reinforce that she can't cope with situations like this.

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 20:53

MelonGoo · Yesterday 20:50

Is this real? Or some kind of faux commentary on the state of our young NEETs?

If it is real, for the love of God do not go with the meeting with her. She is an adult!!

I would suggest the fact that she's now had three failed employments means she needs to re-evaluate. And a short sharp shock wouldn't be the end of the world, but I expect you will cushion it for her and on she will go into employment no.4.

Maybe take the break and encourage her to have a very deep rethink.

Dd isn’t a NEET - never has been as she has always been in education or work ? If she has a break she will then be back in education. Shes never claimed benefits so it’s got nothing to do with that . She’s always lived at home and doesn’t need benefits she was either at school or college supported by us or working.

OP posts:
trossardmartinelli · Yesterday 20:53

localnotail · Yesterday 20:23

Well, it all depends. If you are going to get punished for being ill, or even sacked, of course people will not take time off. I personally would leave and look for another position with a better employer, but I guess you dont have this option if you have a public sector job with good benefits.

People aren't even getting ill though. Thats my point. We get full pay for 6 months if we're sick and nobody would be on anyone's case for being off sick. People just don't get ill much. Getting ill enough to need 1 or 2 days off work a month just isn't normal.

SuperMagicHappyForest · Yesterday 20:56
  1. she needs to get a fit to work note giving her the time off to recover - that will be the GP. She will not be insured to work if she is not fit.
  2. she needs to get the sickness absence policy to understand their triggers and approaches tonsickness
  3. with over 2 years employment she has full rights so they can’t just let her go without going through a process
  4. she needs to ask for an occupational health referral to identify reasonable adjustments (which can include an addition sick leave allowance for this issue). This will also establish if she is covered by the equalities act (unlikely given what you have said but it is possible).
  5. if covered by the equalities act (and frankly even if not) she should say she believes she is - therefore the employer needs to actively support her with reasonable adjustments. If not there could be a claim for discrimination (but that’s a tough one to prove.
  6. she should join a union.
maxslice · Yesterday 21:00

glogg · Yesterday 11:53

I find that crazy. How are people supposed to hold down a job if even 3 absences for justified sickness over one year is considered unacceptable.

Because of three verified legitimate absences over an ENTIRE YEAR? Whoa, that’s incredibly harsh.

CrazyMidget · Yesterday 21:00

Mygreyhair · Yesterday 11:50

From a manager point of view, 3 absences within a 12-month period is high and a meeting should be called to find out if there is anything underlying.

If, as you say, there is an in-going medical issue, they should look at what adjustments they could make to her working day so she could attend. They may offer an occupational health assessment.

Ultimately though, she needs to be able to do her job. In the long term, is this job something she can realistically do?

Three sick days in a year is high???

Franjipanl8r · Yesterday 21:04

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:09

She often needs support with this kind of thing as gets stressed and will potentially struggle to assert herself

dear lord do not go to her work meeting and stop calling in sick for her! She’s going to be replaced pretty quickly if she can’t advocate for herself. You need to let her grow up, she’s an adult!

SylvanMoon · Yesterday 21:06

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 20:53

Dd isn’t a NEET - never has been as she has always been in education or work ? If she has a break she will then be back in education. Shes never claimed benefits so it’s got nothing to do with that . She’s always lived at home and doesn’t need benefits she was either at school or college supported by us or working.

Your DD may have always been in education or work, but obviously not full-time, nor very successfully. She's not got GCSEs but has some sort of Level 2 (?) childcare diploma and is unable to work more than 30 hours. She may never have claimed any sorts of benefits and it's great that you've been able to and continue to support her. But how is she going to support herself when you are not there for her? And I'm still really curious as to why you're not exploring what's causing her to be so much in need of rest? Does she have an autoimmune disease of some sort or is just that she gets stressed at a certain point?

Skippythemagnificent · Yesterday 21:06

CrazyMidget · Yesterday 21:00

Three sick days in a year is high???

No, three separate instances of being sick is high. You could go off sick for two weeks then come back and carry on and that is fine. But taking three separate lots of sick leave is a lot. No healthy adult needs to miss work for sickness 3 times in fairly quick succession.

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 21:10

SylvanMoon · Yesterday 21:06

Your DD may have always been in education or work, but obviously not full-time, nor very successfully. She's not got GCSEs but has some sort of Level 2 (?) childcare diploma and is unable to work more than 30 hours. She may never have claimed any sorts of benefits and it's great that you've been able to and continue to support her. But how is she going to support herself when you are not there for her? And I'm still really curious as to why you're not exploring what's causing her to be so much in need of rest? Does she have an autoimmune disease of some sort or is just that she gets stressed at a certain point?

No I think it’s just a combination of autism and the pain issue now on top of that ?

OP posts:
Clarabell77 · Yesterday 21:11

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 14:52

That's disturbing. She has to deal with other adults whilst caring for children.

If she can only relate to children, I don't think I'd want her looking after mine.

Disturbing?! Such drama.

Don’t be ridiculous.

maxslice · Yesterday 21:15

Summertimesadnessishere · Yesterday 19:08

I agree! 3 absences in 12 months isn’t much at all!! How long is each absence? You cannot lift children safely with an arm that’s in agony or expect someone who is vomiting to come into a nursery - what kind of insanity is this. Even my brutal redundancy target driven American tech company doesn’t get this strung up. I had 3 weeks off and then another 2 separate weeks this year for illness. I think she should ask occupational health to evaluate her and make accommodations as if they don’t she could sue them for the lack of support and safety issues. I work in HR!

Yes! Not relevant to the current issue of her pain, but children in Nursery are little Petri dishes overflowing with viruses and bacteria they are eager to share with everyone. I’d be tremendously impressed with any nursery work who called out sick only three times a year. UK sick police’s seem to be absolutely draconian.

MissMoneyFairy · Yesterday 21:18

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 21:10

No I think it’s just a combination of autism and the pain issue now on top of that ?

Is there a particular task or activity that's triggering the pain, does it go by resting.

Ally886 · Yesterday 21:19

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 15:13

We as parents are perfectly happy to support her if she needs a break from employment however long that may be - a short break now and potentially retraining isn’t a bad thing as she’s not coping currently

I'll be blunt here. You're not equipping her with the resilience to retrain to do anything.

Regardless of the role she doesn't have the skills to be professional.

If she can't hack nursery work I despair

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 21:23

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 17:06

You were in your 30s.

I had severe burn out in a full time professional career well into my 30s and needed time off.

This is a 23 yo who still lives with mum, as none of the stresses of independent adult life and still can't be grown up enough to answer the phone to her employer or deal with them in a meeting without support from her mum.

This is completely unsustainable. If she's burnt out in a part time job at that young age and can't cope with anything.

I'm a lawyer but would be quickly burnt out working with small children and with employers that make a fuss over a genuine injury. And I don't have autism.

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 21:28

MissMoneyFairy · Yesterday 21:18

Is there a particular task or activity that's triggering the pain, does it go by resting.

We can’t pinpoint anything. The first time it happened as it’s her left arm we went to a and e as advised in case it was heart related as she was screaming in agony (it had woken her in the early hours). The other times just a sudden sharp pain then 24-72 hours of agony and it will abruptly stop which is why I think it’s something to do with a nerve ?

I think I was really worried because in general she doesn’t complain, never has about physical things. She broke her leg when she was a child and was in nowhere near as much pain as this so it’s concerning.

OP posts:
Mygreyhair · Yesterday 21:32

CrazyMidget · Yesterday 21:00

Three sick days in a year is high???

Not three days in particular, but three absences, yes. I worked in a school with 70 staff and very few ever had 3 or more absences.

MissMoneyFairy · Yesterday 21:37

Whereabouts on her arm, it could be referred pain from neck or shoulder, what did the GP say, did they carry out an assessment of her arm movement. I'd go back to the GP and physio, something must be causing it , why does the GP think it's rheumatology. Did she ever get an xray or scan and blood tests when she went to a&e. If its unpredictable and she can't think of a trigger then how is she going to manage it, she can't just keep taking odd days off, that's not good for her or her employer.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · Yesterday 21:38

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:04

Referral to rheumatologist and a scan . I have a suspicion it may be nerve pain though, something that keeps getting trapped as it is always very sudden very severe but will last 24-72 hours then abruptly stop.
She did try naproxen it totally knocked her out so she can’t take that for work unfortunately

I have nerve pain (from a graft site) ans also chronic nerve pain in shoulder....

It sounds very similar.

Really hope she gets a decent diagnosis and treatment.... It's miserable to have as you can't plan easily.

I think if this is long term - it may count as disability under the EQA... (any lawyers please correct me!)..
And disability related absence is treated differently legally.

KookyFish · Yesterday 21:38

Kindly, you're talking about her life as its anything to do with you (but it isnt), 'yes I think it's best she has a break, goes back to college etc, gets a new job, works less hours, doesn't claim benefit etc'.
At 23 if my mother had this level of input into my life plans she would be told where to go, she needs to make all these decisions without your 'help'.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · Yesterday 21:41

Ally886 · Yesterday 21:19

I'll be blunt here. You're not equipping her with the resilience to retrain to do anything.

Regardless of the role she doesn't have the skills to be professional.

If she can't hack nursery work I despair

Wow... You're all heart.

I worked in a nursery in my 20s... And in a professional career from my 30s onwards ...

Nursery was much more stressful... The noise alone....

And ASD will amplify everything.