Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to congratulate Rachel from York on her upcoming pregnancy (Source: HR in a library)

296 replies

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:10

Having a work laptop is great. Lets you work anyway, on a train, in a cafe, even in a library

But I always remind my colleagues that be aware of your surroundings.

So a few weeks ago, I was in a public library in York. Noticed a woman on a work laptop near the non fiction book section.

She then put on her headset and started a Teams meeting.

She was discussing HR strategy, pay rises and then Rachel's* upcoming maternity leave. She was talking loudly - as people do with headphones on.

Discussed pay for the person covering maternity leave, maternity pay

So congrats Rachel on your pregnancy - and to everyone else, remember your surroundings

*Name changed

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Megifer · 17/11/2026 10:05

If you answer my q earlier at 9.18am id be genuinely happy to help you.

And go for it! Could do with more trainers I'm getting a bit tired and bored of it now 😂 theres probably a few "train the trainer" courses out there.

Nonnegotiables · 17/11/2026 10:06

I think the post Covid sell off of office buildings and space has influenced this heavily as well. We no longer have meeting room space or even a table, only desk cubicles so you can’t even physically sit alongside the other person to talk let alone have a confidential meeting. Share office with several other teams who shouldn’t be able to hear our confidential discussions but literally sit back to back with us. Only way to meet in person is to find a quiet cafe spot or go for a walk. If both colleagues work from home you can have a confidential meeting on Teams but I have team members who only work from the office as no room for an office set up at home.

Berlinlover · 17/11/2026 10:06

Another one of the many reasons people should go back to the office.

IvysMum12 · 17/11/2026 10:10

MellowSubmarine · 17/11/2026 07:16

Who on earth thinks a public library is an appropriate place for a work HR call!

I quite agree, where I live, it's the local coffee shops where people are "working from home."

CatNoBag · 17/11/2026 10:10

MurphysColeslaw · 17/11/2026 08:25

I think it’s more about the ‘optics’ of it as people tend to say these days.

I'm on that train regularly, or the one before, usually not even on a Friday, and I'd say it's more of a challenge to find an adult NOT drinking something alcoholic. I'm not sure what part they were most annoyed about - the prosecco, the working on a train , or using ChatGPT. All complete non-issues. I'd only be annoyed if she was one of the ones who treat it as a full extension of their office, talking out loud with colleagues and shouting down the phone that they're on a train so the signal isn't very good. Would the Sunday Mail (for it was their story I believe) be happier if she'd clocked off for the weekend at 5 on the dot? I'm always working on the train, good time management.

Failedcrunchymum · 17/11/2026 10:11

I once made small talk about with the woman at the Sure Start centre before a parent and toddler play session, and she suggested a new advice and support service for parents. She described it in vague terms as just another information resource for parents and asked if I was interested and I naively agreed. The reception area filled up with local mums who knew me, including my NDN, right at the time the Sure Start woman came over with a form to fill in, but instead of me filling it in at home, she asked the questions out loud, right amongst the crowd of parents, about whether I had experienced any physical DV, other types of DV, whether I thought I might have PND. I said no, I don't think this service is for me. I wish I'd told her exactly how insensitive and dangerous she'd been.

Pollyanna87 · 17/11/2026 10:11

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:30

https://exploreyork.org.uk/libraries/explore-at-york-stadium/

Up near Monks Cross
Library
Cafe
Pool
Climbing wall
Blood taking
Eye testing

Thanks!

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:14

Megifer · 17/11/2026 10:05

If you answer my q earlier at 9.18am id be genuinely happy to help you.

And go for it! Could do with more trainers I'm getting a bit tired and bored of it now 😂 theres probably a few "train the trainer" courses out there.

My skill is knowing the answer before I ask people questions - very much a part of my posting style - I don't need help on Outlook and email - I am curious to see how much knowledge you have - especially on the technical side - which I am VERY good at - but if you are happy to engage, I look forward to it

"But, before I do, because I know your posting style i just want to check - when you say initials, you mean people's initials yes? And any comms following those initials would potentially be around a situation or issue they are involved in, yes?"

Yes - NHS guidance says initials are ok - if other methods are not available - it could be in a social care environment where carers are discussing a client as 1 client could have many carers

All mobile messaging services used by healthcare professionals must adhere to additional security and privacy standards which at present many do not uphold.

Despite WhatsApp having end-to-end encryption which covers the data in transit. The data on the phone and servers must also comply with the additional security and privacy standards.

Instant Messaging Guidance

There is no formal arrangement between users and the messaging services in respect of processing and storing patient information which is fundamental under DPA/GDPR.

Some healthcare professionals believe that WhatsApp can be used if the entire patient data is removed and fully anonymised.

However, by fully anonymising the information to safeguard privacy it overlooks the principle ‘to do no harm, which was the principle attributed to Thomas Inman the Liverpool surgeon.

When using WhatsApp all healthcare professionals discussing the patient must be fully confident about the identity of the patient (positive patient identification), to avoid patient harm resulting.

By using WhatsApp, a medium to transfer anonymised information, healthcare professionals are prioritising patient confidentiality over patient safety.

Instant messaging can have clinical utility but remember that the law places obligations on organisations to protect patient confidentiality.

If you are a healthcare professional, you may also have to defend yourself against regulatory investigation if you have not taken sufficient steps to safeguard confidentiality

OP posts:
CloveRinse · 17/11/2026 10:17

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:33

I did tell her afterwards that I could hear everything she said - I do a lot with GDPR training and I said that basically she was totally breaking her company's GDPR policies

What was her response / reaction?

sprinklesandshine · 17/11/2026 10:18

That’s ridiculous. Why didn’t she do the meeting at home?

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:20

CloveRinse · 17/11/2026 10:17

What was her response / reaction?

She accused me of harassing her Grin

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:20

sprinklesandshine · 17/11/2026 10:18

That’s ridiculous. Why didn’t she do the meeting at home?

Maybe she'd been to the gym after taking her kids to school?

Who knows?

OP posts:
Cattyisbatty · 17/11/2026 10:21

Crazy!! Good you pointed it out.

RafaFan · 17/11/2026 10:27

There was a woman in my local public library having an online meeting about people in need who had applied for emergency funding from the non-profit she worked for. She also had papers spread all over the table. It's a small town, and I know at least one of the families she was talking about.

I have no idea why anyone thinks this is appropriate.

Electricavenuedreams · 17/11/2026 10:27

EmeraldSlippers · 17/11/2026 07:17

What kind of library allows people to have online meetings there??
Any that I use are very strict on what is acceptable noise.
Agree with the point that you shouldn't be talking about confidential information in public though!

A few near us have co-working areas where teams calls etc are permitted. It's "hub" so CAB are there a bit and the local councillor and benefits advice etc. it has a quiet room separate to the rest.

wouldratherstickpinsineyes · 17/11/2026 10:28

I did my Dad’s shopping in Waitrose the other week and when getting back into the car, could hear the entire ‘ought to be kept confidential’ conversation that the driver of the car next to mine was having on her vehicle’s Bluetooth. She was broadcasting to the entire car park at maximum volume. Completely clueless and totally oblivious.

Ohwhatfuckeristhis · 17/11/2026 10:28

BrandiedAromatics · 17/11/2026 07:52

This was one of the headlines in the papers a couple of days ago:

Quaffing prosecco on the train, Burnham aide writes PM's speech on cost of living using Chat GPT
The Downing St aide using AI to make the Prime Minister's words more 'emotive' was also seen quaffing prosecco as he wrote about the cost-of-living crisis en route to a party conference.
The adviser was working on the speech on the 17.03 train from Euston to Holyhead on Friday, where a fellow passenger spotted him using the AI assistant.
While supping the bubbly, he polished Mr Burnham's speech to Welsh Labour members in Llandudno on Saturday.

Given that prosecco is currently cheaper in morrisons than a large Starbucks, its hardly a Marie Antoinette situation, that said he should be usinga privacy screen.

madaboutpurple · 17/11/2026 10:29

I have heard plenty of inappropriate discussions with people using their phones on buses and trains. I heard one lady ordering clothes from a catalogue and she gave her card number out, told people on the bus which days she was in work and to put the parcel in her blue bin if she was out. Another one it turned out he was talking to his brother and they were discussing if they were both likely to be locked up after being in court. It turned out to be a GBH charge. People on the bus started moving away from the man.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:29

I've passed NHS workers having Teams meetings in their car.
You can clearly hear the conversations

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:33

Most data breaches can be presented with simple effective measures such as a privacy filter

Email is the biggest cause of data breaches

I am not going to say how you can reduce that technically as I am looking forward to @Megifer explaining it

There is also paperwork - keeping it safe on the move, keeping it safe at home - and ensuring that if it is lost, people know what was lost and whose data was lost

Again, maybe @Megifer could explain her best practices for that

OP posts:
Monty36 · 17/11/2026 10:38

I have seen someone marking exam papers on a train. And marking them really quickly I would add. Everyone nearby was staring. You could see the exam board headed paperwork.

When in hospital I had to point out to the Dr’s that closing a flimsy curtain did not mean I had privacy. Conversation wise. Especially as there was an inconsiderate husband who was sat permanently with his wife who was in the bed next door on what was a ward for women and female related concerns.

I agree people seem to forget what they are saying or doing and where they are.

You never know who is listening !

Electricavenuedreams · 17/11/2026 10:39

RafaFan · 17/11/2026 10:27

There was a woman in my local public library having an online meeting about people in need who had applied for emergency funding from the non-profit she worked for. She also had papers spread all over the table. It's a small town, and I know at least one of the families she was talking about.

I have no idea why anyone thinks this is appropriate.

Unfortunately some smaller organizations don't have policies against this sort of this until after they happen because they just don't think. I've worked with PII a lot in my career in different sectors and organisations and it's always been policy of the organisation that when discussing PII we need to be in specific environments such as alone in a home office or even if at work, make sure the office you are in (because sometimes we hot desked across different places) has a right to the information. Because not everyone in an organisation has the same level of access.

I'm not above reporting people for this sort of stuff though - I think it's dreadfully poor practice and it fair on the often vulnerable individuals they work with.

magicstar1 · 17/11/2026 10:40

I once received an email from someone with my name. She was a social worker and was emailing case files to her personal email, and mistakenly left out a letter in her address.
I only read a couple of lines before I realised what it was and contacted her immediately. She had the cheek to have a go at me about reading something private!!! I had deleted it already, and told her to be more careful.
That was before GDPR was brought in and now I'd certainly report her.

Negroany · 17/11/2026 10:40

Megifer · 17/11/2026 09:18

Honestly mate? Not reading all that.

Im happy to explain what the connection is if you genuinely want to engage in good faith.

But, before I do, because I know your posting style i just want to check - when you say initials, you mean people's initials yes? And any comms following those initials would potentially be around a situation or issue they are involved in, yes?

The op mentioned GDPR in her third post, so it's entirely reasonable to mention DSARs.

I agree, the NHS has most definitely got that wrong if that's their guide. I counsel my teams not to use initials, or maybe just one, but to assign codes.

Initials can be disclosable in DSARs unless you have a good reason not to include them (for example, if the person's initials were OK).

Anyway, yes the NHS guidance is problematic. Though the guidance posted doesn't seem to be specifically about DSARs or even GDPR.

CalledNeededYoga · 17/11/2026 10:43

Hellohelga · 17/11/2026 09:33

Offices have meeting rooms.

Indeed they do! I’d someone thinks this conversation is appropriate in the open plan of a library, they probably also think open plan office is acceptable.

In addition, my office has walls so thin you can hear every detail of the meeting next door.

Swipe left for the next trending thread