Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to congratulate Rachel from York on her upcoming pregnancy (Source: HR in a library)

296 replies

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:10

Having a work laptop is great. Lets you work anyway, on a train, in a cafe, even in a library

But I always remind my colleagues that be aware of your surroundings.

So a few weeks ago, I was in a public library in York. Noticed a woman on a work laptop near the non fiction book section.

She then put on her headset and started a Teams meeting.

She was discussing HR strategy, pay rises and then Rachel's* upcoming maternity leave. She was talking loudly - as people do with headphones on.

Discussed pay for the person covering maternity leave, maternity pay

So congrats Rachel on your pregnancy - and to everyone else, remember your surroundings

*Name changed

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
JudgeJ · 17/11/2026 10:44

Reminds me of being on a crammed full upper deck of a bus when a woman was clearly seeking advice about her allegedly cheating boyfriend from the person on the other end. She was so loud that a lot of the passengers chipped in with their opinions, some even started arguing between themselves about it!

Itiswhysofew · 17/11/2026 10:44

In the library I use, the staff are noisier than the patrons. I literally remember librarians shushing all over the place when I was young - it really did happen.

TheWeeDonkeyFella · 17/11/2026 10:45

I often hear stuff I shouldn't on the train and don't understand how this is happening so frequently these days. When my organisation started rolling out mobile kit enabling us to work while travelling to meetings on trains, remotely etc (about 25 years ago now!) privacy, security and having awareness of surroundings was drilled into us.

Not just business talk though, some of the very personal conversations I've heard on speaker in the supermarket queue or even just passing someone in the street make me wonder if people don't realise that people around them can hear everything or just don't care who hears their personal business.

Megifer · 17/11/2026 10:45

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:14

My skill is knowing the answer before I ask people questions - very much a part of my posting style - I don't need help on Outlook and email - I am curious to see how much knowledge you have - especially on the technical side - which I am VERY good at - but if you are happy to engage, I look forward to it

"But, before I do, because I know your posting style i just want to check - when you say initials, you mean people's initials yes? And any comms following those initials would potentially be around a situation or issue they are involved in, yes?"

Yes - NHS guidance says initials are ok - if other methods are not available - it could be in a social care environment where carers are discussing a client as 1 client could have many carers

All mobile messaging services used by healthcare professionals must adhere to additional security and privacy standards which at present many do not uphold.

Despite WhatsApp having end-to-end encryption which covers the data in transit. The data on the phone and servers must also comply with the additional security and privacy standards.

Instant Messaging Guidance

There is no formal arrangement between users and the messaging services in respect of processing and storing patient information which is fundamental under DPA/GDPR.

Some healthcare professionals believe that WhatsApp can be used if the entire patient data is removed and fully anonymised.

However, by fully anonymising the information to safeguard privacy it overlooks the principle ‘to do no harm, which was the principle attributed to Thomas Inman the Liverpool surgeon.

When using WhatsApp all healthcare professionals discussing the patient must be fully confident about the identity of the patient (positive patient identification), to avoid patient harm resulting.

By using WhatsApp, a medium to transfer anonymised information, healthcare professionals are prioritising patient confidentiality over patient safety.

Instant messaging can have clinical utility but remember that the law places obligations on organisations to protect patient confidentiality.

If you are a healthcare professional, you may also have to defend yourself against regulatory investigation if you have not taken sufficient steps to safeguard confidentiality

Ok. I'll help.

Initials are potentially PII, especially when combined with other identifiable data and information.

You said you advise your team to use initials on WA. You brought that up, as even thouugh this thread is about conversations and confidentiality, you, rightly so, connected that to confidentiality/data minimisation, GDPR principles basically.

by your own admission, staff should know who the initials refer to - meaning the person is identifiable. Which makes it PII, and assuming theyre discussing health, special category data.

With GDPR, data subjects have the right to request data held about them - DSAR. This is why i said you would/should know why i said advising staff to use initials is "oof" - bear in mind at this point i didnt know you allegedly work in the NHS although that doesnt make a difference, people can still get complacent with what info they share on WA. As you'll know from the Blackpool Victoria case.

If someone/a patient was to put in a DSAR, requesting a search for their initials and X (X being a situation, date, event, and/or other parameters such as comms between named colleagues/HCPs) that can reveal who they are to someone who can identify them from that information - say the receiver - then that information is potentially discloseable in a DSAR. And remember - people get complacent, which is where the risk comes in.

DSARs are a headache, which is also where my 'oof" comes in.

Ultimately, my point was, advising people to use initials when discussing an identifiable, living person, can give them a false sense of security. Although im not entirely surprised the NHS havent really expanded on why to give context and aid people's understanding.

You've now done your usual tactic of "but whats that over there, explain that then". Again absolutely fine, but im definitely not playing that game. Find someone else to try and tie in knots, not gonna work on me 😊

Stillreadingalot · 17/11/2026 10:49

EmeraldSlippers · 17/11/2026 07:17

What kind of library allows people to have online meetings there??
Any that I use are very strict on what is acceptable noise.
Agree with the point that you shouldn't be talking about confidential information in public though!

Many libraries offer meeting rooms or private spaces. Lots of people do work in libraries, to make use of free WiFi for example but people with jobs such as HR/social work etc should be aware of the need to maintain confidentiality - they shouldn't need library staff to remind them

bababamama · 17/11/2026 10:51

I must admit we have a particular person we are supporting that we meet in a cafe bar because it would not be appropriate to meet in private, she has a history of making accusations against people! She deserves support but our personal protection from unfounded allegations is also imperative. A quiet corner of the restaurant (they know us and we know the right time of day) is the best compromise (we wouldn’t normally even go as a pair, but we do in this case). Needs must. Online meetings however are inexcusable

NotInMyyName · 17/11/2026 10:51

Same kind of story. I was in the waiting area of an office that rented out space to different businesses. Think of a v grand set of victorian town houses joined. Small city with a dominant single industry. Most people either work directly or supply it etc.

Couple of suited and booted type guys joined and started to tell each other how one of them had “massaged” figures for a big invoice to charge a client too much. And yes I worked for that company. And even worse I was associated with that project. I was of course invisible to them. That changed when I was called for my appointment and I asked them to resubmit their invoice with a detailed breakdown for my attention. I made sure my boss knew when i got back and we had a review meeting with their senior staff over all invoices to date, which were a few £m p.a. The waiting room guys were not there. But Im not sure I would have recognised them tbh!

Karma is satisfying and doesn't happen nearly enough.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:52

Negroany · 17/11/2026 10:40

The op mentioned GDPR in her third post, so it's entirely reasonable to mention DSARs.

I agree, the NHS has most definitely got that wrong if that's their guide. I counsel my teams not to use initials, or maybe just one, but to assign codes.

Initials can be disclosable in DSARs unless you have a good reason not to include them (for example, if the person's initials were OK).

Anyway, yes the NHS guidance is problematic. Though the guidance posted doesn't seem to be specifically about DSARs or even GDPR.

Codes are good too.

But you will see it's not about DSARs as WhatsApp messages are like post it notes - they should be transferred to the Clinical Record

They can then be deleted - there is no guidance on how long a WhatsApp message needs to be retained as they should be routinely deleted

Look at Covid and all those Government by WhatsApp - Sir Humphrey would have gone spare!

The Skeleton in the Cupboard

  • Minister, what was all that in aid of? -

I have learnt some interesting facts.

  • I hope it does not happen again.
  • I beg your pardon?

You cannot speak to people in the department.

  • Why not?

How can I advise you if I don't know what's said? I must know what is going on.
You cannot have private conversations! - You may be told things that are not true! -

You can put me right.

But they may be true! Not entirely false, but misleading, open to misinterpretation.

  • You're trying to keep things from me.
  • Absolutely not, Minister.Minutes must be taken, records must be kept.
You won't be here for ever, nor will we. In years to come If Cartwright were moved tomorrow, how could we check information? -

Cartwright won't be moved tomorrow.

  • Oh, really? -

Alex Andrews from the Mail to see you.

  • Ah, hang on. I'd like you to minute this. Everything must be minuted, you know.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/non-corporate-communication-channels-for-government-business/using-non-corporate-communication-channels-eg-whatsapp-private-email-sms-for-government-business-html

19 - Significant government information in NCCCs should be captured into government systems to support accountability.

You are responsible for deciding whether this applies to each communication using professional judgement and considering the context.

20 - You may receive unsolicited communications via NCCCs. If a conversation becomes more significant, consider switching to a government system or making sure significant content is subsequently captured within a government system.

21 - How to capture significant information:

a - Copy, forward, screenshot or export it to a government system, OR

b - Record its substance in a message, note or document on a government system

22 - If you are a minister or a senior official, consider including private office staff in communications groups and tasking them to undertake such capture.

23 - Capture significant information into government systems at a frequency appropriate to the content and context, including how often you use the NCCC. You should carry out a final review before you change device or leave your post.

24 - ‘Disappearing message’ functions have a role in limiting the build up of messages on devices. You must ensure that any such use does not impact on your recordkeeping or transparency responsibilities.

to congratulate Rachel from York on her upcoming pregnancy (Source: HR in a library)
OP posts:
FamBae · 17/11/2026 10:54

I remember way back in the early nineties, before mobile phones and the internet was commonplace, my ds was at playgroup, one of the mums worked for the local council and brought in waste paper for the children to draw and paint on; one child took their picture home and the parent complained that it had a list of rent arrears on the back, including details of the arrears for one of the other playgroup mums.

On a train a good few years ago before Insta became a thing, I overheard two people talking about an interview they had conducted; one said that they had been keen to offer until they had seen the girls facebook account, goodness knows what she had been posting, it was certainly an eye opener that potential emplyers facebook stalked you.

Megifer · 17/11/2026 10:56

Negroany · 17/11/2026 10:40

The op mentioned GDPR in her third post, so it's entirely reasonable to mention DSARs.

I agree, the NHS has most definitely got that wrong if that's their guide. I counsel my teams not to use initials, or maybe just one, but to assign codes.

Initials can be disclosable in DSARs unless you have a good reason not to include them (for example, if the person's initials were OK).

Anyway, yes the NHS guidance is problematic. Though the guidance posted doesn't seem to be specifically about DSARs or even GDPR.

One of my first slides is along the lines of "never ever think that using initials or nicknames, or even someones hair colour, means that what you're then saying about them is confidential and not discloseable to them"

My 'proper' employer has a really basic e-learning course on GDPR and data confidentiality, only about 20 mins long, its even covered in there.

HectorPlasm · 17/11/2026 10:58

My 2p worth:

  1. Lanyards - don't wear them in public. When bored, I've googled the details and found FB page, LinkedIn page, company site etc. When coupled with bits of their conversation - however trivial - there a real phishing / whaling risk as a result
  2. Not quite the same but there is an urban legend about a presentation in front of a very large group of people where a message popped up from his mate who had shared their red hot curry the previous night and advised that 'he had an arse like the back of Batman's car' ...
Needtosoundoffandbreathe · 17/11/2026 10:59

Tryagain26 · 17/11/2026 10:01

People have always worked on trains, prepared briefing notes, written speeches etc there often is no other time to do it so journey time is work time.
I don't see the issue. And he was probably trying to get ideas from AI to spark him imagination I doubt the whole speech will be AI.
And obviously given who wrote the story the quaffing prosecco was written to cause an emotive response. He was having one drink and he probably paid for it himself.
I don't see that as the same as someone loudly talking about HR or medical issues in public

Edited

That was on a mobile phone so no excuses for not shielding it from others. And that's the point, it's okay to work on public transport, but you have to consider what is appropriate in terms of confidentiality, security and GDPR.

JingsMahBucket · 17/11/2026 11:01

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:33

Most data breaches can be presented with simple effective measures such as a privacy filter

Email is the biggest cause of data breaches

I am not going to say how you can reduce that technically as I am looking forward to @Megifer explaining it

There is also paperwork - keeping it safe on the move, keeping it safe at home - and ensuring that if it is lost, people know what was lost and whose data was lost

Again, maybe @Megifer could explain her best practices for that

@cakeorwine alright, knock it off you two and get a room! 😂 You’re derailing your own thread for us Nosey Parkers on here who want to read all the crazy stories 😂

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 11:03

Megifer · 17/11/2026 10:45

Ok. I'll help.

Initials are potentially PII, especially when combined with other identifiable data and information.

You said you advise your team to use initials on WA. You brought that up, as even thouugh this thread is about conversations and confidentiality, you, rightly so, connected that to confidentiality/data minimisation, GDPR principles basically.

by your own admission, staff should know who the initials refer to - meaning the person is identifiable. Which makes it PII, and assuming theyre discussing health, special category data.

With GDPR, data subjects have the right to request data held about them - DSAR. This is why i said you would/should know why i said advising staff to use initials is "oof" - bear in mind at this point i didnt know you allegedly work in the NHS although that doesnt make a difference, people can still get complacent with what info they share on WA. As you'll know from the Blackpool Victoria case.

If someone/a patient was to put in a DSAR, requesting a search for their initials and X (X being a situation, date, event, and/or other parameters such as comms between named colleagues/HCPs) that can reveal who they are to someone who can identify them from that information - say the receiver - then that information is potentially discloseable in a DSAR. And remember - people get complacent, which is where the risk comes in.

DSARs are a headache, which is also where my 'oof" comes in.

Ultimately, my point was, advising people to use initials when discussing an identifiable, living person, can give them a false sense of security. Although im not entirely surprised the NHS havent really expanded on why to give context and aid people's understanding.

You've now done your usual tactic of "but whats that over there, explain that then". Again absolutely fine, but im definitely not playing that game. Find someone else to try and tie in knots, not gonna work on me 😊

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/non-corporate-communication-channels-for-government-business/using-non-corporate-communication-channels-eg-whatsapp-private-email-sms-for-government-business-html

With GDPR, data subjects have the right to request data held about them - DSAR. This is why i said you would/should know why i said advising staff to use initials is "oof" - bear in mind at this point i didnt know you allegedly work in the NHS although that doesnt make a difference, people can still get complacent with what info they share on WA. As you'll know from the Blackpool Victoria case.

You would know that Whatsapp messages are routinely deleted and transferred into official records - as Government and NHS advice says

If someone/a patient was to put in a DSAR, requesting a search for their initials and X (X being a situation, date, event, and/or other parameters such as comms between named colleagues/HCPs) that can reveal who they are to someone who can identify them from that information - say the receiver - then that information is potentially discloseable in a DSAR. And remember - people get complacent, which is where the risk comes in.

Yes - correct - if the WhatsApp messages haven't been deleted, they can be disclosed under a DSAR

Of course the Receiver would know who they are under a DSAR - people writing anything down about a client should always know that it can be revealed in a DSAR. That's basic data protection - anything you write down about a client can be revealed under DSAR. That's why off the record conversations are good

ltimately, my point was, advising people to use initials when discussing an identifiable, living person, can give them a false sense of security. Although im not entirely surprised the NHS havent really expanded on why to give context and aid people's understanding.

What sense of security?
If someone read it by accident, they would struggle to know who it was about

The people in the conversation know who it is about. They also know that it can be accessed via an SAR

Using initials is NOT a way to discuss clients without their knowledge.
It's a way of keeping it confidential from other people

You've now done your usual tactic of "but whats that over there, explain that then". Again absolutely fine, but im definitely not playing that game. Find someone else to try and tie in knots, not gonna work on me

I think you will find I have demolished your "explanation" - you mistook confidentiality as a way of keeping it confidential from the client - whereas it's a way of preventing a data breach

Clearly a big part of GDPR is preventing a data breach
I presume on your £400 sessions, you tell people the best way to prevent data breaches?

At £400, I would expect so

Using non-corporate communication channels (e.g. WhatsApp, private email, SMS) for government business (HTML)

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/non-corporate-communication-channels-for-government-business/using-non-corporate-communication-channels-eg-whatsapp-private-email-sms-for-government-business-html

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 11:05

JingsMahBucket · 17/11/2026 11:01

@cakeorwine alright, knock it off you two and get a room! 😂 You’re derailing your own thread for us Nosey Parkers on here who want to read all the crazy stories 😂

I hope people are reading the advice though and thinking about the training they've had at work and procedures

OP posts:
Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 17/11/2026 11:07

wizzler · 17/11/2026 08:39

I was on a train to London when a man across the aisle was discussing the financials of his area of the business and smugly explaining where he had hidden some contentious costs in the accounts where the accountant consolidating the books wouldn’t see it. I was that accountant !

@wizzler - how did you deal with that? I don't know enough about the accounting process to know what you would need to do in circumstances like this? Sorry if this is a really stupid question.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 11:08

Megifer · 17/11/2026 10:56

One of my first slides is along the lines of "never ever think that using initials or nicknames, or even someones hair colour, means that what you're then saying about them is confidential and not discloseable to them"

My 'proper' employer has a really basic e-learning course on GDPR and data confidentiality, only about 20 mins long, its even covered in there.

Confidential from whom?

Who do you think people are trying to keep things confidential from when initials in a Whatsapp are used?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 11:10

Megifer · 17/11/2026 10:56

One of my first slides is along the lines of "never ever think that using initials or nicknames, or even someones hair colour, means that what you're then saying about them is confidential and not discloseable to them"

My 'proper' employer has a really basic e-learning course on GDPR and data confidentiality, only about 20 mins long, its even covered in there.

Do you work for a firm offering GDPR training?

Is it a half day course or a 1 hour course?

OP posts:
Megifer · 17/11/2026 11:10

JingsMahBucket · 17/11/2026 11:01

@cakeorwine alright, knock it off you two and get a room! 😂 You’re derailing your own thread for us Nosey Parkers on here who want to read all the crazy stories 😂

Im done now tbf, op isnt engaging in good faith and keeps trying to change the subject as per their usual MO. I wish id noticed their NN before I posted 😂

I do have a story I can share - once overheard someone being interviewed in McDs and the guy asked if she had any plans to have children as they need flexibility because one of their current staff was off long term with depression. So a double whammy. My DP gripped my hand as he must have felt me ense up and about to go over and butt in.

JuliaAgrippina · 17/11/2026 11:11

I had diffcult HV after a move and they insited I attend a HV drop in clinic - so Mum poped along to show I had support. The HV were set up in a corner of GP open plan waiting room. In front of another HV with another young mother and baby - my Mum an entire room full of waiting patients and reception staff I was being asked about sex life/contraception and mental health and DV inquiry questions - it was my Mum who asked WTF - neither me or other mother had been asked if we were okay discussing things like that.

Apperently they'd used to have a room with door that shut but safety reason they worked in pairs so had two mothers in at once then room was needed so they went in GP waiting area. It apparently never crossed anyone mind how inappropriate the setting was till Mum made it very clear.

I've heard inappropriate conversation waiting to pick up the kids, on public transport and in open plan offices.

A PP mention the helpful neighbour being a potential gossip when DH was in hopsital I was very taken aback how much medical information was just given to IL and my parents - they weren't even asking. I on other had explained who I was and why I was asking - if DH wasn't around - mainly as his wife and under same roof I'd be one dealing with support after and one who needed to know when he'd be back- and the attitude to me was fucking awful. This time round with Dmum in hopsital I was being grabbed and info dumped on and knew more than Dmum or siblings and I was trying to take a back seat.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 11:12

Megifer · 17/11/2026 11:10

Im done now tbf, op isnt engaging in good faith and keeps trying to change the subject as per their usual MO. I wish id noticed their NN before I posted 😂

I do have a story I can share - once overheard someone being interviewed in McDs and the guy asked if she had any plans to have children as they need flexibility because one of their current staff was off long term with depression. So a double whammy. My DP gripped my hand as he must have felt me ense up and about to go over and butt in.

I am engaging in good faith

I think you believe that initials are designed to keep things confidential from the patient - which is as funny misunderstanding

Everyone can read my answers for themselves

Change the subject?

Are you seriously saying that you think teaching people about preventing data breaches is NOT part of the £400 session you offer?

I am stunned

OP posts:
Lovemycat2023 · 17/11/2026 11:14

This is why I chose to WFH most of the time if I couldn’t have a meeting f2f in a meeting room. Agree that open plan hot desking offices can be inappropriate too, although in my office there are areas where only certain teams can sit for this reason.

EmeraldSlippers · 17/11/2026 11:16

Stillreadingalot · 17/11/2026 10:49

Many libraries offer meeting rooms or private spaces. Lots of people do work in libraries, to make use of free WiFi for example but people with jobs such as HR/social work etc should be aware of the need to maintain confidentiality - they shouldn't need library staff to remind them

But this clearly wasn't a meeting room or a private space...
Absolutely no problem with working from a library, but making calls there there (and thus disrupting other people's work) is something I've never seen allowed.

Hoppinggreen · 17/11/2026 11:16

I sat in a hotel lobby a few weeks ago (also in York) and listened to someone who I REALLY hope was not actually an Accountant give some really dodgy tax advice
I am also not an Accountant but I have had my Business for around 15 years and used to do SME Mentoring so I know a few things but even I knew it was well dodgy
I hope the guy checked with someone properly qualified before he ended up in deep shit with HMRC - who according to matey boy never check anything so you can do what you want

PeonieLover · 17/11/2026 11:17

I attended the CIPD HR professionals conference at the Excel last year. While I was in the queue for the ladies, two ladies in front of me were discussing an employment tribunal case! They actually said they agreed with the claimant but needed to ensure that the employer wasn't held liable!

Another HR professional in front of them turned round and said that they shouldn't be discussing it in a public space. They gave her the evil eye but carried on anyway. Absolutely shocking, I hope the lady reported them to their employers because their name badges displayed their company names & job titles.