Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to congratulate Rachel from York on her upcoming pregnancy (Source: HR in a library)

296 replies

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:10

Having a work laptop is great. Lets you work anyway, on a train, in a cafe, even in a library

But I always remind my colleagues that be aware of your surroundings.

So a few weeks ago, I was in a public library in York. Noticed a woman on a work laptop near the non fiction book section.

She then put on her headset and started a Teams meeting.

She was discussing HR strategy, pay rises and then Rachel's* upcoming maternity leave. She was talking loudly - as people do with headphones on.

Discussed pay for the person covering maternity leave, maternity pay

So congrats Rachel on your pregnancy - and to everyone else, remember your surroundings

*Name changed

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
LetMeButterYourParsnips · 17/11/2026 09:22

I was in a hospital last week with someone and we sat there listening to reception calling people to make appointments.

So now I know all about Jim Smith’s and Bob Brown’s health conditions. Except I’m not supposed to know, because of their privacy and the names were a lot more identifiable than the ones I used.
I wondered if I should have said anything, but the person I was with didn’t want me to.

Mokel · 17/11/2026 09:23

These people who discussed private matters of a client/customer/user/colleague in the public whilst working.

How would they like it if their private issues were discussed or left notes/account in public?

ImAnElf · 17/11/2026 09:27

I heard an entire meeting about next seasons tv scheduling for one of the bigger channels - was tempted to chime in with my opinion.

All the financials of one particularly large client for an investment company in their pre meeting meeting. Sat there and googled all the info on the client and the investment company.

I quite miss my train journeys

Pollyanna87 · 17/11/2026 09:28

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:18

Ir's a very open library with a sports centre and NHS faciitites

Which library in York has a sports centre, please?

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:29

ImAnElf · 17/11/2026 09:27

I heard an entire meeting about next seasons tv scheduling for one of the bigger channels - was tempted to chime in with my opinion.

All the financials of one particularly large client for an investment company in their pre meeting meeting. Sat there and googled all the info on the client and the investment company.

I quite miss my train journeys

I am off to London on Friday - will be interesting what can be overheard

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:30

Pollyanna87 · 17/11/2026 09:28

Which library in York has a sports centre, please?

https://exploreyork.org.uk/libraries/explore-at-york-stadium/

Up near Monks Cross
Library
Cafe
Pool
Climbing wall
Blood taking
Eye testing

Explore at York Stadium - Explore York

Information about Explore at York Stadium. What to get there, when it's open, what's available, how to contact staff and who is in charge.

https://exploreyork.org.uk/libraries/explore-at-york-stadium/

OP posts:
Mokel · 17/11/2026 09:32

I remember I visited a hospital for an appointment in heavy winds. Staff were pushing a trolley of patients records between buildings without covering the trolley. The winds blew the top 2-3 records off the trolley and the member of staff just scooped them up. Pages from one patient’s record could have easily slipped into another’s

What is most concerning was there is an internal entrance to the building which is a very long way around. But the staff member thought it was ok to do a shortcut outside with a trolley overflowing with patients’ records in heavy winds

Hellohelga · 17/11/2026 09:33

CalledNeededYoga · 17/11/2026 07:31

In an open plan office that conversation is still wildly inappropriate!

Offices have meeting rooms.

TheRealMagic · 17/11/2026 09:35

Mokel · 17/11/2026 09:23

These people who discussed private matters of a client/customer/user/colleague in the public whilst working.

How would they like it if their private issues were discussed or left notes/account in public?

Some of these are absolutely the individuals fault and they are personally to blame. Some of them - like hospital staff calling to make appointments in the earshot of other patients - might be issues that the staff member themselves has raised, been clear they're uncomfortable with and been told that they have to carry on working in that non-private space, in which case the fault is with their employer.

Megifer · 17/11/2026 09:36

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:22

I REALLY think you should read that before engaging

Not wasting my time reading an NHS policy when policy cannot override GDPR, and it doesnt appear to have provided guidance as to why relying on use of initials can still be a risk.

Besides, I had to read and update enough of their policies so they were compliant when I worked in the NHS 😂

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:38

Megifer · 17/11/2026 09:36

Not wasting my time reading an NHS policy when policy cannot override GDPR, and it doesnt appear to have provided guidance as to why relying on use of initials can still be a risk.

Besides, I had to read and update enough of their policies so they were compliant when I worked in the NHS 😂

Tell me you know nothing about GDPR without telling me you know nothing about GDPR

OP posts:
MrsShawnHatosy · 17/11/2026 09:42

EmeraldSlippers · 17/11/2026 07:17

What kind of library allows people to have online meetings there??
Any that I use are very strict on what is acceptable noise.
Agree with the point that you shouldn't be talking about confidential information in public though!

Most of our public libraries are hubs, they have separate working spaces and some even have small meeting rooms you can hire.

LochLoughton · 17/11/2026 09:43

Our library also houses a Customer Service Centre for the local council. Not in a separate area, just a counter built into a corner plus a desk and chairs. I've been working at a library table and heard the names, address, DOB, account numbers and other confidential information of visitors to the desk. Even if members of the public try to speak quietly, the staff repeat the information back to them at top volume. Everyone on that floor can hear!

Megifer · 17/11/2026 09:46

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:38

Tell me you know nothing about GDPR without telling me you know nothing about GDPR

Ok so youre not up for engaging in good faith. Thats cool 😊 glad I didnt waste my time, especially as I usually charge £400 a session depending on delegate numbers.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:50

Megifer · 17/11/2026 09:46

Ok so youre not up for engaging in good faith. Thats cool 😊 glad I didnt waste my time, especially as I usually charge £400 a session depending on delegate numbers.

Seriously - tell me you know nothing about GDPR and NHS guidance

You will obviously be aware that the guidance says that it's not a patient record and should be transferred to the patient record, other NHS guidance makes clear that you should ensure you don't confuse the patients - and also the messages should be deleted asap to reduce the risk of a data breach

But I assume you know that - clearly an SAR search is hard for initials - but OTOH, staff should know who the initials refer to

Maybe I should charge £400 a session?

It sounds like I know more than you - I assume you have practical experience in the real world and those WhatsApp rules aren't knew?

  1. What would you say is BEST PRACTICE to reduce the chance of sending an email in Outlook to the wrong person?

2)What can an organisation use in Outlook to ensure data remains confidential?

3)If using a secure link to open a message, what is best practice for sending the password?

4)What kind of encryption is best - the method Proton uses or the one GMail uses?

OP posts:
Banjas · 17/11/2026 09:51

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:33

I did tell her afterwards that I could hear everything she said - I do a lot with GDPR training and I said that basically she was totally breaking her company's GDPR policies

Well done you.💐
Inappropriate behaviour should be called out every time.
Could she be reported to her company so they are aware of what happened / is happening ?
Poor “Rachel” getting her private info broadcast like that.

toiletpaperthief · 17/11/2026 09:53

Her PR meeting seems to have "made your day" as you have created a whole thread on MN with it, why not address it to her directly? versus of a bunch of people who may or may not have LOUD teams meetings inside public libraries. (personally I wouldn't dream of it, I'd go to the park or an empty corner in the pub).

Floristian · 17/11/2026 09:54

Happyholidays78 · 17/11/2026 07:56

Please report this if it's not too late. I'm a Social Worker & I'm pretty sure I would get sacked if I did this (& rightly so). I cannot believe what I'm reading on this thread! If I have to make a call I do it back at home or in the office & if it's super urgent I call from the car.

I agree. Anyone in the public sector being careless with confidential information should be reported to their organisation.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:56

toiletpaperthief · 17/11/2026 09:53

Her PR meeting seems to have "made your day" as you have created a whole thread on MN with it, why not address it to her directly? versus of a bunch of people who may or may not have LOUD teams meetings inside public libraries. (personally I wouldn't dream of it, I'd go to the park or an empty corner in the pub).

Edited

If you read my thread, you will see I did just that

HTH

OP posts:
HenriettaHippopotamus · 17/11/2026 09:56

I think most of these are the fault of the people especially if you intentionally set up a private meeting in a public place or start public phone calls etc. Some such as in hospitals and with receptionists etc are likely the fault of the employers as it's always hard not to hear private details when standing in the queue of the GP receptionists. Not to mention the curtains in wards. I feel so uncomfortable overhearing private details.

I do feel more sympathy for people who are in situations such as having someone ringing them and they're stuck in a bus or somewhere they can't get to any private space easily. Maybe they've been waiting for the call for days and don't want to risk losing more days to waiting on another call. Obviously still not good to be talking private matters but it's not as blatant as initiating the call in such a place.

TellMeAnother · 17/11/2026 09:57

I was in the (packed) pharmacy attached to our GP surgery a few years back and a young bloke had handed over a prescription for some tablets that were out-of-stock. The assistant made a phone call to another branch to see if they had any but it was either a bad line or too noisy so she raised her voice. She mentioned the meds name twice but obviously couldn't be heard so yelled, "IT'S FOR CHLAMYDIA!"

TwentyDunhill · 17/11/2026 09:59

Vikingforexample · 17/11/2026 07:19

i was in a cafe in a hospital and a lady from MacMillan was discussing end of life care with two clearly distressed people on the next table. She got stuck into their income and benefits and seemed oblivious to her surroundings and to the discomfort of the couple she was “helping.”

Omg you just reminded me, I was in hospital when I was about 19, and the woman in the bed opposite me was at least late 80's, and she was really upset and in pain, I went and gave her a hug a couple of times and kept pressing my buzzer aswell to try and get a nurse. No-one came to help her, but the next morning the doctors came round and pulled the curtain round her bed (so soundproof those curtains) and asked her if she wanted a DNR! She didn't know what that meant so they told her in the simplest terms, it was horrible. She started crying again, the doctors were telling her it would probably be sensible to have one, but it's completely up to her. She kept saying "so, if I die, you won't try and bring me round??! "
I got discharged before she met her maker thank god! Poor woman

lovemenomore · 17/11/2026 10:00

These are shocking!
I work for HMCTS in Crown Court and Family Court. Obviously we see and hear a lot of sensitive/distressing info.

I popped out for a sandwich and saw some people in the same shop that I know live in my street, but not to speak to. Went back to work and low and behold they were the next case I was on. I am not allowed to work on a case where I even remotely know of somebody that's involved so I had to email my manager to let her know. I didn't even know these peoples names!

I often see people from the cases in shops if I go out on the lunch break and it is so awkward to even see them as you by then know why they are in court and what they have done/facing. I avoid going out at all if I can as I don't want to see anyone. Let alone talk about it with anyone I know - we have counsellor's available if we have a bad case as we cannot go home and vent to partner/wife/husband etc.

Tryagain26 · 17/11/2026 10:01

BrandiedAromatics · 17/11/2026 07:52

This was one of the headlines in the papers a couple of days ago:

Quaffing prosecco on the train, Burnham aide writes PM's speech on cost of living using Chat GPT
The Downing St aide using AI to make the Prime Minister's words more 'emotive' was also seen quaffing prosecco as he wrote about the cost-of-living crisis en route to a party conference.
The adviser was working on the speech on the 17.03 train from Euston to Holyhead on Friday, where a fellow passenger spotted him using the AI assistant.
While supping the bubbly, he polished Mr Burnham's speech to Welsh Labour members in Llandudno on Saturday.

People have always worked on trains, prepared briefing notes, written speeches etc there often is no other time to do it so journey time is work time.
I don't see the issue. And he was probably trying to get ideas from AI to spark him imagination I doubt the whole speech will be AI.
And obviously given who wrote the story the quaffing prosecco was written to cause an emotive response. He was having one drink and he probably paid for it himself.
I don't see that as the same as someone loudly talking about HR or medical issues in public

koffielepeltje · 17/11/2026 10:04

Mochudubh · 17/11/2026 09:00

GPs receptionists are the worst for this*. At my practice they practically shout down the phone and everyone in the waiting room can hear every detail.

"What's your name? How do you spell that, Mr Sinclair? S-I-N-C-L-A-I-R. OK, date of birth? 12/11/56 have I got that right?, Address? 22 Acacia Avenue, is that A-C-A-C-I-A? Good" "Now, you say you've a problem with your bowels".

*Not all, at my old practice the reception was separate from the waiting room and you were given a laminated card with a number so the doctor didn't even have to say your name when you were called.

Ours is the same. A small practice with a single small waiting room adjacent to the reception area. You can hear everything being discussed with receptionists in person or on the phone. You can ask for a private room if you require privacy. In a village like mine, you may well know the person talking to the receptionists.