Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think England Rugby fans should not sing over the Haka at Twickenham

207 replies

cakeorwine · 16/11/2026 18:34

Yes - Twickenham. Not the new name

I like the Haka - and I want to hear it. It's an amazing spectacle - and it can be challenged - but England fans seem to be the only ones to sing over it

I think it's quite a new thing to whistle over it

I like the Wales response - that was awesome

But this is what England fans do - it's disrespectful and some of us want to hear it. Plenty of chance to sing Sweet Low during the game

It's just not in the spirit of rugby - TBH

(I am aware this is a controversial opinion!)

Even the French don't do that....the crowd are silent here

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/MUie3gESFsU?si=rR2AtKPWLXAXa4o5

OP posts:
LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 12:36

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 12:31

It is a fact that England fans do it

And I am English

It's a fair few English who happily and bizarrely jump on the English bashing bandwagon.

Cailleach1 · 17/11/2026 12:37

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 12:07

I have lived in the UK for the past 25 years and am a citizen and I am not American so your judgement and presumptions are ridiculous. I said FROM not living across the pond. Your quickness and need to be right had led you down a presumptive path to suit your own narrative.

And just to be clear, there are more countries across the pond who had slaves than just Americans (including Brits over here so it wasn't just Americans from across the pond). Maybe crack a book.

Time has moved on including outdated offensive songs that are defended in 2026 as being okay.

Edited

Well, unfortunately for many around the world, slavery (or practices akin to slavery) still exists in many places. The African continent, and the Arab world to name two. Indentured workers also exist in places such as India. I am sure there are many other places where lives are stolen and discarded in bondage of some sort. Especially those of young girls. Afghanistan seems to be a hellhole for women. Where female children are sold to men, to do with as they wish.

ETA: Sorry, this is a derail, isn’t it really. Possibly better on another dedicated thread.

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 12:48

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 12:26

But it's only England fans who have now made it a tradition

I think its noticeable with England because of swing low.

There are always pockets of fans when they come to landsdowne who try to get something going over it.

Low lie is a harder tune to catch than swing low and it next catches fire to the and same extent.

But it's not universally loved it respected outside England.

I'm no fan of wish rugby, but I'm a big fan of them treating the haka this way

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 12:58

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 12:48

I think its noticeable with England because of swing low.

There are always pockets of fans when they come to landsdowne who try to get something going over it.

Low lie is a harder tune to catch than swing low and it next catches fire to the and same extent.

But it's not universally loved it respected outside England.

I'm no fan of wish rugby, but I'm a big fan of them treating the haka this way

Edited

*English rugby

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 13:00

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 12:36

It's a fair few English who happily and bizarrely jump on the English bashing bandwagon.

They think it makes them better people..

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 13:12

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 13:00

They think it makes them better people..

Edited

Or maybe I am bashing people who sing over the Haka - and they just happen to be English

It would be the same if the French did it
But they don't make it a tradition

OP posts:
Cailleach1 · 17/11/2026 14:53

Maybe it would be more of an even footing if all countries put on their little displays. Time limits all the same.

Scots could do a turn with ceremonial clay mor. The Welsh could do Owain Glyndwr etc. Irish, English, French and Italians ditto. Outside NZ, other Southern Hemisphere do their shows too. It’d certainly be interesting to see what the Australians and South Africans do.

It’d be a bit of a palaver though. The national anthems are enough for me. Everyone just wants the match to start.

Doubt it’d change now though. However, having said that, new changes are allowed for the NZ team. Seemingly that gesture that looks like slitting the throat was not in the older, traditional one. It was only introduced in 2005.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 18:18

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 13:12

Or maybe I am bashing people who sing over the Haka - and they just happen to be English

It would be the same if the French did it
But they don't make it a tradition

I always thought that a suitable French equivalent of the haka would be to blockade the try line with hay bales and set fire to the posts.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 18:26

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 10:28

I think you can have all that and still understand why, particularly during a 20 year or so period where New Zealand were the dominant team on the planet (but thankfully kept hilariously bottling world cups), some people dislike the way NZ used their position as pretty much the only profitable team in the sport for so long to force others to bend the knee and even got world rugby to issue rules around what is acceptable in response.

It's not enough that they are allowed to do the haka, it has to be after the anthems whether they're home or away, or else we'll just do it in the changing room and then call the Welsh disrespectful.

It's not enough that we do it after the anthems, you must watch and respect it, no going and practicing your drop kicks like campese used to do.

We're allowed to issue a war cry where we mimic slitting your throats and challenge you but you can not walk up on us or we'll tell teacher.

You can't respond by throwing some grass in the air or we'll separate your shoulder.

Forming a boomerang? Disrespectful
Scowling? Disrespectful

They used their position to ingrain a sporting advantage in to the official pre match ritual, and fair play to them, I'm sure Rassie is pissed off he doesn't have a similar weapon.

No problem with people who love the haka and want to enjoy it etc, but I think you have to accept that 20-30 years of watching the governing body give a team that's going to put 60 points on you anyway a perceived sporting advantage rubs a lot of fans up the wrong way.

Edited

I don't think that Rassie with his traffic light signalling is in a position to complain about unfair advantages.

And that's before we even get into the level of SA school rugby and the advantages that gives.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 19:20

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 18:18

I always thought that a suitable French equivalent of the haka would be to blockade the try line with hay bales and set fire to the posts.

That would work Grin
I have no problem with the teams responding to the Haka and I think they should be allowed to get up close and personal

It's disappointing that the All Blacks get precious about that

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 19:28

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 19:20

That would work Grin
I have no problem with the teams responding to the Haka and I think they should be allowed to get up close and personal

It's disappointing that the All Blacks get precious about that

Ireland could have the right to match through the oppositions changing rooms with pipes and drums because well it's historic and we've always had the right to do it.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 19:33

Italy lines up facing the opposition, stares them down with deadly seriousness, and then after losing in the first half promptly jogs across the halfway line to join the other team.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 19:35

England could do a Brexit Hakka where England lines up for the anthems, then deliver a speech about taking back control of the pitch, and immediately walks off into the tunnel before the game even starts.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 19:37

Scotland would have to be a Braveheart inspired half way line moon in unison.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 19:40

And Wales where the front row sets up a makeshift toll booth across the opposition's 10-metre line, refusing to let any English-registered players cross into Welsh territory until they pay an extortionate cash-only crossing fee. Everyone else can travel freely at no cost.

Dutch1e · 17/11/2026 19:41

YvonnMcgruder · 16/11/2026 23:59

The haka is a war dance to intimidate the opposition, hence why some versions performed against certain rivals, also feature a cut throat hand gesture. It gives the all blacks a psychological advantage, England fans have chosen to counter this by singing in response, seems fair to me. It's competive rugby and highly charged, not an afternoon ballet.

This particular haka may well be a war dance but there are so many hakas performed for so many different moments.

It's emotion in motion, I love haka. One of my favourites is this tribute to Mr Dawson Tamatea, a brilliant teacher and co-creator of this particular haka, performed here to farewell his body after his death

OP, I'm with you. If an opposing team has a challenge of their own I love to see it (like when some of the Pacific Island teams play against each other, but any slice of any culture would be brilliant to watch).

But a crowd being a bunch of drunken boors singing a song created by Black slaves in the American colonies is just cringey.

And yes I am from Aotearoa, and yes the Hakarena was golden! I wish more teams would come up with their own challenges.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 19:42

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 19:28

Ireland could have the right to match through the oppositions changing rooms with pipes and drums because well it's historic and we've always had the right to do it.

But what tune would they play?

Would it be an apolitical march or a banging one?

Would Orla approve?

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/Y7meZZeYllo?si=vkHlvsupohXVwR0s

OP posts:
SomeOtherUser · 17/11/2026 20:19

I love the haka and find it so cringy when the opposing fans bleat feebly over it. A bit of grace costs nothing!

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 20:24

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 19:42

But what tune would they play?

Would it be an apolitical march or a banging one?

Would Orla approve?

Well the forwards and the backs would fiercely disagree on the choice of tune leading to a massive punch up.

The English would come in to try and settle things down a bit but end up getting blamed for everything (possibly the Jews as well).

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 21:03

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 20:24

Well the forwards and the backs would fiercely disagree on the choice of tune leading to a massive punch up.

The English would come in to try and settle things down a bit but end up getting blamed for everything (possibly the Jews as well).

The English were famously just trying to settle things down in Ireland and catching unjustified blame

Plmnki · 17/11/2026 21:21

Rugby fans being disrespectful oiks? As someone who used to live in twickenham, and endure selfish drunken morons invuading gardens, this is soooo unsurprising.

SquirrelGG · 17/11/2026 21:55

Takemehomedesertroad · 17/11/2026 08:20

👏👏👏🙄🙄 I speak for many! I don't give a shit how to spell her name to be honest. Wonder why she fucked off to Australia then?

Edited

Probably to get away from ignorant people such as you.

SquirrelGG · 17/11/2026 22:00

HelenaWaiting · 17/11/2026 10:48

It's part of Maori culture. The NZ team is mainly white. I'm not respecting cultural appropriation from a people they treated like shit for 200 years.

You can look very white and still have Maori heritage you know.

Occasionalsnaccident · 17/11/2026 22:13

Why do you make a point of saying Twickenham, not Allianz stadium?

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 22:16

Occasionalsnaccident · 17/11/2026 22:13

Why do you make a point of saying Twickenham, not Allianz stadium?

Because it's Twickenham
Been that most of my life
Like the Marathon Bar

OP posts: