Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think England Rugby fans should not sing over the Haka at Twickenham

207 replies

cakeorwine · 16/11/2026 18:34

Yes - Twickenham. Not the new name

I like the Haka - and I want to hear it. It's an amazing spectacle - and it can be challenged - but England fans seem to be the only ones to sing over it

I think it's quite a new thing to whistle over it

I like the Wales response - that was awesome

But this is what England fans do - it's disrespectful and some of us want to hear it. Plenty of chance to sing Sweet Low during the game

It's just not in the spirit of rugby - TBH

(I am aware this is a controversial opinion!)

Even the French don't do that....the crowd are silent here

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/MUie3gESFsU?si=rR2AtKPWLXAXa4o5

OP posts:
Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 02:55

cakeorwine · 16/11/2026 22:07

And it only seems to be England fans who do it - I don't remember them doing it when I was younger so am not sure when this started

Op you’ve been shown examples of other fans doing this.

You’ve had a few wines and got a bee in your bonnet about proving how cool and un-English you are.

Nobody’s shown up to your party. It’s time to go to bed now. Night all.

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 06:39

SquirrelGG · 17/11/2026 00:57

Well aren't you a charmer! Remember that the next time someone shows you no respect - no-one owes it to you either.

I don't believe I said anyone did, so all is good, my end.

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 06:41

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 02:55

Op you’ve been shown examples of other fans doing this.

You’ve had a few wines and got a bee in your bonnet about proving how cool and un-English you are.

Nobody’s shown up to your party. It’s time to go to bed now. Night all.

Funny how it's always the English used as examples of disrespect - anyone would think we were the only British nation.

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 06:42

cakeorwine · 16/11/2026 19:07

But why does it seem that only England fans do it?

Probably because they've got more personality.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:00

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 02:55

Op you’ve been shown examples of other fans doing this.

You’ve had a few wines and got a bee in your bonnet about proving how cool and un-English you are.

Nobody’s shown up to your party. It’s time to go to bed now. Night all.

I would disagree with you - and clearly people have showed up and agreed with me.

At 2.55 am, I was asleep and not posting - so not sure why you suggested going to bed.

Some fans do it occasionally but for England fans, it's become a tradition that's hard to break

Why is it UnEnglish to say that I don't think England fans should sing over the Haka?

Let the team respond how they want - but fans should just enjoy the spectacle. Younger fans should be able to see the Haka that they have seen on TV up closr and live - and not have it drowned out

There's also group psychology - imagine not wanting to sing but everyone around you is singing - who wants to be the odd one out?

It might have started in 2006

https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/news/henry-unhappy-with-haka-treatment

"New Zealand coach Graham Henry and centre Ma'a Nonu have condemned the Twickenham crowd for their reaction to the Haka in the All Blacks' win at 'headquarters' on Sunday.

English fans responded with a rendition of the anthem "Swing Low, Sweet Chariot".

Henry said: "I thought the crowd was excellent apart from when they were singing their song during the Haka, which I think is a bit questionable and they'll be reminded next time that it's not the right thing to do."

Nonu added: "I think the Haka's been around in rugby for 100 years and it is a shame that when we play, other teams disrespect it like that.

"It's special to us as players and that's their way of putting us off which is a shame.""

In 2018, England fans were actively encouraged to sing by Dylan Hartley

England supporters have been urged to drown out the haka with Swing Low, Sweet Chariot before Saturday’s showdown against the All Blacks.

Eddie Jones said this week he pays so little attention when the haka is taking place “they could be playing the Spice Girls and I wouldn’t know”. But it has become a tradition for Twickenham goers to greet the customary Maori challenge with a loud chorus of England’s long-serving anthem.

Doing so has split opinion with the former New Zealand centre Ma’a Nonu previously accusing England fans of “disrespect” while their ex-head coach Graham Henry has described it as “not the right thing to do”

Owen Farrell on Friday moved to play down the relevance of facing the haka but his co-captain Dylan Hartley said: “Vocal is good. Be vocal at the weekend. The haka is great, Swing Low is great, everyone gets excited about both things. It creates a great atmosphere.”

The England outside-centre, Henry Slade, added: “Last time the All Blacks played here the crowd were singing at the same time as the haka and that will probably create an unbelievable atmosphere and environment.

The All Blacks captain, Kieran Read, insisted his side would not be fazed by any responses however, either from England’s players or supporters. “We do the haka as a challenge but it is more about us connecting as a team. The opposition can do what they like,” he said. “I certainly get a kick out of it and I’m sure the crowd does as well. Whether they sing or not, it adds to the atmosphere. For me it’s a great part of the game.”

Henry unhappy with Haka treatment - The British & Irish Lions Website

https://www.lionsrugby.com/en/news/henry-unhappy-with-haka-treatment

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 07:13

In any event I would much rather watch the England Red Roses women's matches - far more classy and interactive with the fans.

InterestedDad37 · 17/11/2026 07:32

I love a good haka - and OP is right, I would expect rugby fans to show it some respect. One of the things that I love about rugby is the respect usually shown to other teams, the ref, ref's decisions etc 🏉
I know some New Zealanders thinks it's gone a bit far (there is a comment earlier in the thread about this) but...
Here's one performed by schoolkids for their deceased teacher (who was very involved in promoting Maori culture)
I find it incredibly moving.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:35

InterestedDad37 · 17/11/2026 07:32

I love a good haka - and OP is right, I would expect rugby fans to show it some respect. One of the things that I love about rugby is the respect usually shown to other teams, the ref, ref's decisions etc 🏉
I know some New Zealanders thinks it's gone a bit far (there is a comment earlier in the thread about this) but...
Here's one performed by schoolkids for their deceased teacher (who was very involved in promoting Maori culture)
I find it incredibly moving.

Edited

There are some amazing Hakas out there - it's not just a war dance

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 17/11/2026 07:38

YvonnMcgruder · 16/11/2026 23:59

The haka is a war dance to intimidate the opposition, hence why some versions performed against certain rivals, also feature a cut throat hand gesture. It gives the all blacks a psychological advantage, England fans have chosen to counter this by singing in response, seems fair to me. It's competive rugby and highly charged, not an afternoon ballet.

This. I’ll be there in person singing to show our team we love them.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:40

jeaux90 · 17/11/2026 07:38

This. I’ll be there in person singing to show our team we love them.

England fans will sing anyway - even after the Haka

Why do it during the Haka?

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 17/11/2026 07:44

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 07:40

England fans will sing anyway - even after the Haka

Why do it during the Haka?

Did you read any of the posts? It’s a psychological advantage to intimidate. It’s not a national anthem that will always get the respect it deserves.

Takemehomedesertroad · 17/11/2026 07:53

cakeorwine · 16/11/2026 19:21

What do you mean by that?

I mean exactly what I said.

Many New Zealanders do not care or like it. I have no idea why you care. It's hardly offensive, ess than 20% of the population is of Maori descent. Have you lived in New Zealand?

The haka is applauded aboard much like Jacinda Ahern was, the PM that ruined the country..I'm a kiwi, I lived there 30 years, my parents, DS and extended family live there, I have a house there and visit multiple times a year.

I am also at Twickenham on Saturday wearing an All Blacks hat and I will sing my national anthem. I will cringe at the throat slitting of the haka.

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 07:56

InterestedDad37 · 17/11/2026 07:32

I love a good haka - and OP is right, I would expect rugby fans to show it some respect. One of the things that I love about rugby is the respect usually shown to other teams, the ref, ref's decisions etc 🏉
I know some New Zealanders thinks it's gone a bit far (there is a comment earlier in the thread about this) but...
Here's one performed by schoolkids for their deceased teacher (who was very involved in promoting Maori culture)
I find it incredibly moving.

Edited

Yes and if they sang over that it’d be a problem. But it’s a rugby game, not a memorial service.

SquirrelGG · 17/11/2026 08:02

Takemehomedesertroad · 17/11/2026 07:53

I mean exactly what I said.

Many New Zealanders do not care or like it. I have no idea why you care. It's hardly offensive, ess than 20% of the population is of Maori descent. Have you lived in New Zealand?

The haka is applauded aboard much like Jacinda Ahern was, the PM that ruined the country..I'm a kiwi, I lived there 30 years, my parents, DS and extended family live there, I have a house there and visit multiple times a year.

I am also at Twickenham on Saturday wearing an All Blacks hat and I will sing my national anthem. I will cringe at the throat slitting of the haka.

You can cringe all you like, many NZers will be watching with pride. You don't speak for all of us. Tbh I don't take much notice of people who can't even spell a former PM's name correctly 😉And, for what it's worth, she didn't "ruin the country", what a load of tripe.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 08:09

Takemehomedesertroad · 17/11/2026 07:53

I mean exactly what I said.

Many New Zealanders do not care or like it. I have no idea why you care. It's hardly offensive, ess than 20% of the population is of Maori descent. Have you lived in New Zealand?

The haka is applauded aboard much like Jacinda Ahern was, the PM that ruined the country..I'm a kiwi, I lived there 30 years, my parents, DS and extended family live there, I have a house there and visit multiple times a year.

I am also at Twickenham on Saturday wearing an All Blacks hat and I will sing my national anthem. I will cringe at the throat slitting of the haka.

If you read my posts, you will see why I care

  1. I like to hear it,
  2. I think children at the game should be able to hear it,
  3. fans who like it should be able to hear it
  4. rugby, as any true fan should know, is about respect for the opposition and I don't think it's respectful - let the team challenge it themselves
OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 08:10

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 07:56

Yes and if they sang over that it’d be a problem. But it’s a rugby game, not a memorial service.

Still not respectful - and Rugby Union, as I am sure you know, is about respect

OP posts:
Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 08:18

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 08:10

Still not respectful - and Rugby Union, as I am sure you know, is about respect

I thought it was about rugby

Takemehomedesertroad · 17/11/2026 08:20

SquirrelGG · 17/11/2026 08:02

You can cringe all you like, many NZers will be watching with pride. You don't speak for all of us. Tbh I don't take much notice of people who can't even spell a former PM's name correctly 😉And, for what it's worth, she didn't "ruin the country", what a load of tripe.

👏👏👏🙄🙄 I speak for many! I don't give a shit how to spell her name to be honest. Wonder why she fucked off to Australia then?

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 08:23

LuckyHazelFox · 16/11/2026 23:32

Absolutely nothing to do with the AIBU, except to signal your virtue.

You right it doesn’t except to pile on the disrespect of England fans.

It isnt virtuous to point out offensive songs culturally appropriated and frankly wrong. To dismiss with virtue signalling is frankly offensive.

oviraptor21 · 17/11/2026 08:30

nomas · 16/11/2026 19:43

YANBU.

There is usually silence when a country’s anthem is played at football games.

Why is it different at rugby games?

Not very respectful.

They have already sung the NZ anthem. The haka is in addition to the anthem. I think the fans are mostly just bored by it now, and it does reek a bit of cultural appropriation.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:09

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 08:18

I thought it was about rugby

Tell me you know nothing about rugby without telling me you know nothing about rugby

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:11

oviraptor21 · 17/11/2026 08:30

They have already sung the NZ anthem. The haka is in addition to the anthem. I think the fans are mostly just bored by it now, and it does reek a bit of cultural appropriation.

What makes you think that?

OP posts:
RedSheep26 · 17/11/2026 09:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 09:21

oviraptor21 · 17/11/2026 08:30

They have already sung the NZ anthem. The haka is in addition to the anthem. I think the fans are mostly just bored by it now, and it does reek a bit of cultural appropriation.

I imagine if England insisted on being quietly respected while they did something in addition to their anthem it would be ‘English exceptionalism’

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 09:21

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:09

Tell me you know nothing about rugby without telling me you know nothing about rugby

Which team have you played for? I’m impressed.