Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think England Rugby fans should not sing over the Haka at Twickenham

207 replies

cakeorwine · 16/11/2026 18:34

Yes - Twickenham. Not the new name

I like the Haka - and I want to hear it. It's an amazing spectacle - and it can be challenged - but England fans seem to be the only ones to sing over it

I think it's quite a new thing to whistle over it

I like the Wales response - that was awesome

But this is what England fans do - it's disrespectful and some of us want to hear it. Plenty of chance to sing Sweet Low during the game

It's just not in the spirit of rugby - TBH

(I am aware this is a controversial opinion!)

Even the French don't do that....the crowd are silent here

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/MUie3gESFsU?si=rR2AtKPWLXAXa4o5

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:24

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 09:21

Which team have you played for? I’m impressed.

I have played rugby and trained at Harlequins

OP posts:
Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 09:32

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:24

I have played rugby and trained at Harlequins

I’m impressed! Did the fans sing over the haka during friendlies..?

MrsShawnHatosy · 17/11/2026 09:36

The Haka is an expression of the indigenous language, culture and customs of New Zealand, a country colonised by the British. As such it deserves respect. The first verse of God Defend New Zealand is in Maori by the way. Do some NZers cringe about that too?

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 09:36

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 09:32

I’m impressed! Did the fans sing over the haka during friendlies..?

Have you seen the price of Twickenham tickets?

I can't say - my Bayesian logic suggests they do but I would need to see the videos

No one is collecting data on this

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 09:48

Happyindevon · 17/11/2026 08:18

I thought it was about rugby

And I think this is the difference in mindsets.

If you haven't played rugby then watching a rugby match is in many ways not different to watching any other sports match (except the rules of course). You have a drink with friends, have fun, cheer on your side and not quite understand all the rules but enough to understand a try and who is winning or losing

However watching rugby either as an existing or ex player at a decent level then it is quite a different feeling. You know much it hurts when you get hit, that you are willing to put yourself at risk so that the girl next to you doesn't get hurt and knowing full well that she will do the same for you, doing your job so that other team mates don't have to pick up your slack and put themselves at greater risk
and lastly trying to put on a positive attitude (so you don't drag everyone else down) when it's cold, muddy, pissing it down and you are losing.

So knowing and having experienced of all of that you tend to have not just respect for your own teammates but also immense respect for the opposition as well who are going through the exact same thing and same feelings.

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 10:28

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 09:48

And I think this is the difference in mindsets.

If you haven't played rugby then watching a rugby match is in many ways not different to watching any other sports match (except the rules of course). You have a drink with friends, have fun, cheer on your side and not quite understand all the rules but enough to understand a try and who is winning or losing

However watching rugby either as an existing or ex player at a decent level then it is quite a different feeling. You know much it hurts when you get hit, that you are willing to put yourself at risk so that the girl next to you doesn't get hurt and knowing full well that she will do the same for you, doing your job so that other team mates don't have to pick up your slack and put themselves at greater risk
and lastly trying to put on a positive attitude (so you don't drag everyone else down) when it's cold, muddy, pissing it down and you are losing.

So knowing and having experienced of all of that you tend to have not just respect for your own teammates but also immense respect for the opposition as well who are going through the exact same thing and same feelings.

I think you can have all that and still understand why, particularly during a 20 year or so period where New Zealand were the dominant team on the planet (but thankfully kept hilariously bottling world cups), some people dislike the way NZ used their position as pretty much the only profitable team in the sport for so long to force others to bend the knee and even got world rugby to issue rules around what is acceptable in response.

It's not enough that they are allowed to do the haka, it has to be after the anthems whether they're home or away, or else we'll just do it in the changing room and then call the Welsh disrespectful.

It's not enough that we do it after the anthems, you must watch and respect it, no going and practicing your drop kicks like campese used to do.

We're allowed to issue a war cry where we mimic slitting your throats and challenge you but you can not walk up on us or we'll tell teacher.

You can't respond by throwing some grass in the air or we'll separate your shoulder.

Forming a boomerang? Disrespectful
Scowling? Disrespectful

They used their position to ingrain a sporting advantage in to the official pre match ritual, and fair play to them, I'm sure Rassie is pissed off he doesn't have a similar weapon.

No problem with people who love the haka and want to enjoy it etc, but I think you have to accept that 20-30 years of watching the governing body give a team that's going to put 60 points on you anyway a perceived sporting advantage rubs a lot of fans up the wrong way.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:38

1dayatatime · 17/11/2026 09:48

And I think this is the difference in mindsets.

If you haven't played rugby then watching a rugby match is in many ways not different to watching any other sports match (except the rules of course). You have a drink with friends, have fun, cheer on your side and not quite understand all the rules but enough to understand a try and who is winning or losing

However watching rugby either as an existing or ex player at a decent level then it is quite a different feeling. You know much it hurts when you get hit, that you are willing to put yourself at risk so that the girl next to you doesn't get hurt and knowing full well that she will do the same for you, doing your job so that other team mates don't have to pick up your slack and put themselves at greater risk
and lastly trying to put on a positive attitude (so you don't drag everyone else down) when it's cold, muddy, pissing it down and you are losing.

So knowing and having experienced of all of that you tend to have not just respect for your own teammates but also immense respect for the opposition as well who are going through the exact same thing and same feelings.

Exactly

The Captains talk to the Ref. No arguing
Back 10 yards

When the game ends, a tunnel is formed and players all go to the bar afterwards

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:41

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 10:28

I think you can have all that and still understand why, particularly during a 20 year or so period where New Zealand were the dominant team on the planet (but thankfully kept hilariously bottling world cups), some people dislike the way NZ used their position as pretty much the only profitable team in the sport for so long to force others to bend the knee and even got world rugby to issue rules around what is acceptable in response.

It's not enough that they are allowed to do the haka, it has to be after the anthems whether they're home or away, or else we'll just do it in the changing room and then call the Welsh disrespectful.

It's not enough that we do it after the anthems, you must watch and respect it, no going and practicing your drop kicks like campese used to do.

We're allowed to issue a war cry where we mimic slitting your throats and challenge you but you can not walk up on us or we'll tell teacher.

You can't respond by throwing some grass in the air or we'll separate your shoulder.

Forming a boomerang? Disrespectful
Scowling? Disrespectful

They used their position to ingrain a sporting advantage in to the official pre match ritual, and fair play to them, I'm sure Rassie is pissed off he doesn't have a similar weapon.

No problem with people who love the haka and want to enjoy it etc, but I think you have to accept that 20-30 years of watching the governing body give a team that's going to put 60 points on you anyway a perceived sporting advantage rubs a lot of fans up the wrong way.

Edited

I agree - teams should be able to respond how they want - not the supporters

I don't understand that attitude - they should have let the Welsh sing

Forming a V, getting close up and personal - it builds up atmosphere

But not singing over it - has anyone ever asked the All Blacks why they object to a team's response?

OP posts:
MrsShawnHatosy · 17/11/2026 10:45

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:38

Exactly

The Captains talk to the Ref. No arguing
Back 10 yards

When the game ends, a tunnel is formed and players all go to the bar afterwards

Captains shake hands with the ref afterwards and thank him.

HelenaWaiting · 17/11/2026 10:48

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 16/11/2026 19:30

Cringey? It's part of their culture. How can you possibly describe it as cringey? It sounds as though you are threatened by other countries traditions.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=J3SRO-S3DDA
Do you think the New Zealand soldiers performing the Haka are cringey too?

Edited

It's part of Maori culture. The NZ team is mainly white. I'm not respecting cultural appropriation from a people they treated like shit for 200 years.

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 10:55

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 10:41

I agree - teams should be able to respond how they want - not the supporters

I don't understand that attitude - they should have let the Welsh sing

Forming a V, getting close up and personal - it builds up atmosphere

But not singing over it - has anyone ever asked the All Blacks why they object to a team's response?

But the fans are a consequence of the team throwing their toys out of the pram and the governing body placating them.

If the opposition team were allowed to meet them head on, like France 2007, and you let the stadium and crowed get hyped and go wild then I don't think you get the singing over it so much or people bitching about it.

But I think fans quite rightly get sick of being told that anything their team and country does to meet the challenge is disrespectful and that one team is allowed to shout they're ready to go to war and the other team has to stand their calmly, 60 seconds before kickoff.
So naturally they go "well if the team aren't allowed answer them back we will/ if they think they get to dictate what is happening in our home ground and calling the shots then we're not going to let them."

I think if NZ hadn't been so fucking precious about how teams respond to them slitting their throats and saying "let's go to war " then it could actually be great for the game and you'd get more instances like France which produced an incredible atmosphere and game

lcakethereforeIam · 17/11/2026 10:59

Perhaps the opposing fans should listen quietly then, at the end, hold up cards giving them a mark out of 10 for the quality of the singing and dancing?

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 17/11/2026 11:01

HelenaWaiting · 17/11/2026 10:48

It's part of Maori culture. The NZ team is mainly white. I'm not respecting cultural appropriation from a people they treated like shit for 200 years.

I know that the Haka has been embraced by many many non Maori New Zealanders.
And I know some people view it's performance by non Maoris as cultural appropriation.
However I see the way it is performed at national events such as rugby matches as a tribute to the Maori origins of the country and an acknowledgement of their culture.
I know this divides opinion.

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 11:10

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 08:23

You right it doesn’t except to pile on the disrespect of England fans.

It isnt virtuous to point out offensive songs culturally appropriated and frankly wrong. To dismiss with virtue signalling is frankly offensive.

Some people like to suck the life out of everything - otherwise known as professional offense takers. Christians and English are right up there for the two biggest targets of the POT.

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 11:29

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 11:10

Some people like to suck the life out of everything - otherwise known as professional offense takers. Christians and English are right up there for the two biggest targets of the POT.

Nope I’m neither. Not offended easily and don’t generally care but coming from across the pond and hearing this is shocking in its offended.

Some people don’t want to acknowledge clear offence and blatant negative actions.

Choosing to say that something is being made offensive for the sake of it is right - but this isn’t the case at all here.

Swing Lo is a slave song. Sing by African Americans during slave times about their hope to be released from racist, slave ownership. It is offensive.

Cailleach1 · 17/11/2026 11:53

I remember when Brian O’Driscoll knelt down, picked up grass and threw it in response to the Haka. NZ then proceeded to spear tackle him early on in the game. A filthy move that is now thankfully illegal. Also thankfully he didn’t get seriously, or fatally injured.

It does look very performative to see the European looking fellows doing it, and pretending like it is their culture.

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 11:54

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 11:29

Nope I’m neither. Not offended easily and don’t generally care but coming from across the pond and hearing this is shocking in its offended.

Some people don’t want to acknowledge clear offence and blatant negative actions.

Choosing to say that something is being made offensive for the sake of it is right - but this isn’t the case at all here.

Swing Lo is a slave song. Sing by African Americans during slave times about their hope to be released from racist, slave ownership. It is offensive.

Offensive - to YOU. Quite frankly, if you live across the pond, im not sure you're in any position to lead the lectures on slavery. Time has changed, people have moved on. That song won't be going anywhere.

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 12:07

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 11:54

Offensive - to YOU. Quite frankly, if you live across the pond, im not sure you're in any position to lead the lectures on slavery. Time has changed, people have moved on. That song won't be going anywhere.

I have lived in the UK for the past 25 years and am a citizen and I am not American so your judgement and presumptions are ridiculous. I said FROM not living across the pond. Your quickness and need to be right had led you down a presumptive path to suit your own narrative.

And just to be clear, there are more countries across the pond who had slaves than just Americans (including Brits over here so it wasn't just Americans from across the pond). Maybe crack a book.

Time has moved on including outdated offensive songs that are defended in 2026 as being okay.

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 12:10

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 12:07

I have lived in the UK for the past 25 years and am a citizen and I am not American so your judgement and presumptions are ridiculous. I said FROM not living across the pond. Your quickness and need to be right had led you down a presumptive path to suit your own narrative.

And just to be clear, there are more countries across the pond who had slaves than just Americans (including Brits over here so it wasn't just Americans from across the pond). Maybe crack a book.

Time has moved on including outdated offensive songs that are defended in 2026 as being okay.

Edited

Are you including rap in your ban? That's one genre full of sexism and violence.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/11/2026 12:18

The haka is a war dance intended purely to intimidate the opponents, so I don’t see why opposing teams shouldn’t sing over it.

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 12:22

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/11/2026 12:18

The haka is a war dance intended purely to intimidate the opponents, so I don’t see why opposing teams shouldn’t sing over it.

Exactly.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 12:26

HamHamHam · 17/11/2026 10:55

But the fans are a consequence of the team throwing their toys out of the pram and the governing body placating them.

If the opposition team were allowed to meet them head on, like France 2007, and you let the stadium and crowed get hyped and go wild then I don't think you get the singing over it so much or people bitching about it.

But I think fans quite rightly get sick of being told that anything their team and country does to meet the challenge is disrespectful and that one team is allowed to shout they're ready to go to war and the other team has to stand their calmly, 60 seconds before kickoff.
So naturally they go "well if the team aren't allowed answer them back we will/ if they think they get to dictate what is happening in our home ground and calling the shots then we're not going to let them."

I think if NZ hadn't been so fucking precious about how teams respond to them slitting their throats and saying "let's go to war " then it could actually be great for the game and you'd get more instances like France which produced an incredible atmosphere and game

But it's only England fans who have now made it a tradition

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 12:27

lcakethereforeIam · 17/11/2026 10:59

Perhaps the opposing fans should listen quietly then, at the end, hold up cards giving them a mark out of 10 for the quality of the singing and dancing?

Seven

Friends Tv GIF
OP posts:
LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 12:29

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 12:26

But it's only England fans who have now made it a tradition

Yep, thought so. Just another English bashing thread.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2026 12:31

LuckyHazelFox · 17/11/2026 12:29

Yep, thought so. Just another English bashing thread.

It is a fact that England fans do it

And I am English

OP posts: