Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls on trips need female staff?

78 replies

Notmytelescope · Yesterday 10:32

I am a scout leader and have a different opinion to some others in my group.
Our scouts 10-14 years are a mixed group and I think it is important that a female leader is present on overnight trips. This is not required by the rules - which just require a certain number of leaders.
Other leaders (who are all fathers of daughters) feel that this is unnecessary and indeed some are offended that I think girls need a female when staying away overnight.
AIBU to think a mixed group needs mixed leaders too?

OP posts:
CruCru · Yesterday 10:35

I think most school trips want at least one female and one male staff member for overnight stays (where the school is mixed sex).

KnittedPenguinHat · Yesterday 10:36

I agree with you. Our primary school has a high amount of male teachers but a female LSA would also go on residential trips with them.

SquirrelBlue · Yesterday 10:38

Considering the recent news and the potential safeguarding implications of an overnight stay, it feels completely ridiculous that this is even questioned. For a mixed sex overnight stay, you need at least one adult of each gender.

BusyGreySnail · Yesterday 10:39

I agree. Imagine if one of them got their period or something, DD would be mortified going to a man about that.

leafinthewind · Yesterday 10:40

I'm a Scout leader too. I'm a woman, and I've been on camps with only female leaders, but never seen a camp in my Group / Unit go with only male leaders. That's a function of our volunteers, though, and nothing to do with policy.

I don't think having a single sex leadership team and mixed sex young people is ideal, but I don't think it's a deal-breaker either. I think the leadership team should be thoughtful about potential issues which might arise but, except for extreme circumstances, I can't see a problem. I mean, if we had a young person who had a bad accident and required some personal care in the gap between the accident and the ambulance arriving, I might wish we had a matching-sex leader on hand - but really it would be low down the list of things to worry about under the circumstances.

I think male leaders can prepare well for girls having periods, for example, so I wouldn't worry about the day-to-day things so much. If I saw an all-male leadership team prepping a camp, I might offer to go and talk to the girls about period prep before the camp, for example. But we have a box of products, so the physical prep is already done.

TempestTost · Yesterday 10:42

Yes. Sometimes things don't need to be an official rule, but they are still best practice. If there isn't some overwhelming reason not to, it's really a good idea.

It will help protect the male leaders as well.

Are they worried about finding someone? That can be a problem.

Ablondiebutagoody · Yesterday 10:45

Better to have the trip with single sex leaders than not have the trip.

BoredZelda · Yesterday 10:46

Ask the offended men if they think their presence in the boys’ life brings something female leaders don’t provide. I’m sure they will have lots of opinions on that.

I would also suggest that boys on a camp would benefit from a female staff member being present too. A q- year old away from mum and dad, probably for the first time is far more likely to speak to a trusted female than a trusted male.

ComtesseDeSpair · Yesterday 10:47

It’s best practice and many girls wouldn’t feel comfortable speaking to a male leader about some things. Is the context that you’ve expressed your view that a trip shouldn’t go ahead if there are no female leaders available, and other leaders are reluctant to cancel trips for everyone in this case?

TraitorOrFaithful · Yesterday 10:48

Ablondiebutagoody · Yesterday 10:45

Better to have the trip with single sex leaders than not have the trip.

This.

Bestbeforenow · Yesterday 10:52

A man who cannot imagine that an unrelated girl might be more comfortable with a female leader isn’t entirely suited to the position imo.

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 11:02

Ive been on extra camps so there was a female leader present. Theres not always one on normal Scout nights though.

DiNozzoComingBack · Yesterday 11:04

Yes, in a mixed sex group I think it should be mixed sex leaders. In a single sex group I think it can be all the same sex or you can have mixed sex leaders (ie an all boys group can have all male leaders or it can also include a female but it can't be all female leaders and vice versa).

Springtimeinsunshine · Yesterday 11:09

Bestbeforenow · Yesterday 10:52

A man who cannot imagine that an unrelated girl might be more comfortable with a female leader isn’t entirely suited to the position imo.

This.

There are reasons why women and girls have single sex spaces and if a man cannot understand a young girl needing privacy and dignity from males then he shouldn't be in a safeguarding position.

itstoolateforsnacks · Yesterday 11:12

Bestbeforenow · Yesterday 10:52

A man who cannot imagine that an unrelated girl might be more comfortable with a female leader isn’t entirely suited to the position imo.

Yes, well said. For the ones taking offence, this is even more of a concern. It’s not about them. It’s about how the kids feel. It’s not even just some of the girls that would prefer to go to a female, some of the boys might too. In a mixed sex group, both sex leaders should be available for kids to choose from.

GotTheTShit · Yesterday 11:14

It doesn't matter how much a father of a daughter feels he is qualified to deal with a random girl getting her period for the first time. It'a about how the girl feels.

I also bet no matter how lovely and informed the father, most girls would rather talk to their mums about this sort of thing.

ScholesPanda · Yesterday 11:29

Ideally I think leaders of both sexes should be available.

However, what's the context - are the male leaders trying to exclude female leaders from certain activities (which is a big red flag) or are they desperately trying to ensure an activity the kids want to happen does happen even if no female leaders are available to help?

What happens if a group can't find any female volunteers- does that group just fold or do they never go away on camp?

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 11:40

This sort of thing wouldnt be an issue if more people, male and female, were willing to volunteer. Nearly every Scout group that closes does so due to lack of adults... not children.

Saturdaysfairies · Yesterday 11:41

Yes. A mixed group should bring leaders of both sex.

My DD secondary school just went away two nights with her class and two male teachers. She wasn't bothered. She thinks these two teachers (both fathers) know more about teenage girls than the rest of the universe. Fair enough.

TheVexatiousGrapefruit · Yesterday 11:52

As always, it depends. When DD was a Scout, all the leaders were male, but the other sections had female leaders, so on group and family camps there was always at least one female and usually several. The girls had their own tent.
On more adventurous scout-only camps, DD (or another) was sometimes the only girl. It was a non-issue; one of the female leaders would be the ‘home contact’ and be available to advise or visit camp if necessary.
And for jamborees the leader teams were always mixed anyway.

Edited to add: DD was always better looked after on scout camp than guide camp!

RaggedRocks · Yesterday 12:17

A trans scout leader could tick both boxes

Springtimeinsunshine · Yesterday 12:26

RaggedRocks · Yesterday 12:17

A trans scout leader could tick both boxes

No they wouldn't. They are either biological male OR biological female. Never both.

ButMyGoshDontYouKnowIt · Yesterday 12:30

Has that changed then? When I was a venture scout a very long time ago, we had to convince someone's older sister to come on camps as we couldn't go without an adult female.

budgiegirl · Yesterday 12:49

In an ideal world, it would be best to have leaders of both sexes.

But what if there are no female leaders available? Should the troop never go camping?

IMO, as a cub leader, as long as parents have been told beforehand that it will be single sex leaders, so they can chat to their children, and make an informed decision on whether to send them, then camps with single sex leaders are better than no camp at all.

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · Yesterday 12:50

I've seen groups of boys managed by all female leaders.

If these are responsible dads who are capable of looking after their own daughters why do you assume that they cannot look after other similar girls?

I fear that the adverts perenially showing incompetent men have seeped into our normal life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread