Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls on trips need female staff?

81 replies

Notmytelescope · 16/11/2026 10:32

I am a scout leader and have a different opinion to some others in my group.
Our scouts 10-14 years are a mixed group and I think it is important that a female leader is present on overnight trips. This is not required by the rules - which just require a certain number of leaders.
Other leaders (who are all fathers of daughters) feel that this is unnecessary and indeed some are offended that I think girls need a female when staying away overnight.
AIBU to think a mixed group needs mixed leaders too?

OP posts:
Goinggreymammy · 16/11/2026 14:08

I am a Beaver leader -mixed sex group. Our group used to have a requirement to have at least one male and one female leader was at all activities. It was very limiting and things ended up being cancelled a lot.
For camping it probably is preferable to have a mix of leaders but not necessary .... its not like a female leader can do some personal care a male leader cannot because one leader cannot be alone with a youth member anyway so a second leader would be onlooking, and we have to be so careful with safeguarding. We are not even allowed in the tents with the youth members. So ultimately I dont think it makes much difference.

Edited typo/extra word which was unclear.

PerplexedOnceMore · 16/11/2026 14:30

OP is this for a specific camp or is a theoretical scenario? Are there any female leaders in your Scout troop? Are there any willing Scout mums who would volunteer to attend camp? If there are no willing volunteers and you feel strongly about it what are you doing to try and get more women to volunteer within scouting?

Whilst we may struggle to attract new volunteer leaders we always have parents who are willing to volunteer for camp. Camps take a long time planning so it shouldn't be an issue that creeps up on you. There should be plenty of time to get a Scout DBS through.

For anyone comparing this to teacher led trips the two situations are not comparable. Teachers are paid. Scout leaders are volunteers.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 16/11/2026 14:33

I'm surprised scouting allow this.

I organise trips for my DC sports club and their governing body insists on male/female supervision if a mixed group is going.

Is there a mum who could volunteer and get the relevant DBS in time?

AnnaBegins · 16/11/2026 15:05

At our scout group we've always had this as an informal rule. It's often been me - I'm down as an "Occasional helper" to maintain my DBS, but I'm just one of the wives.

Given that we are yet to have a scout camp without an issue with periods, usually some poor little thing getting hers for the first time, it's been a godsend.

I trust all the male leaders, but it's not about them, it's about that 11 year old who is embarrassed. That's the important one.

cordeliaflynne · 16/11/2026 15:55

It used to be advised as best practice but that seems to have fallen by the wayside these days. (My suspicion is that it went around the time they were tying themselves in knots trying to accommodate special treatment for trans adults and young people whilst trying not to sound like they were. Hard to find the right wording to say that a mixed sex leadership team is best practice when you are desperate never to mention sex at all)

The problem with "better a camp with no female leaders than no camp at all" is that it does tend to discriminate against some of the girls who will be put off going on the event. They will almost certainly not mention that that is why they are not going. Unfortunately, that leaves the male leaders who don't think that it is problem none the wiser.

Our Group would be unlikely to plan an event with a single sex leader team. A leader from another section or a partner (with a Scouts DBS) would be roped in to attend as well.

I have absolutely had the experience at camp where the mother of one of the gave me a heads up about her daughter expecting to start her period on camp - one of the first she has had. The mum chose to quietly let me know - not one of the other male leader who were also about. I am sure that comes as absolutely no surprise to any woman reading this that she made that choice. I didn't need to do anything, she didn't need to explain anything but we all knew exactly why she had given me that heads up and I'm sure both the mum and the Scout were reassured over the weekend simply because she had been able to let me know.

Scout has a very robust equal opportunities policy and it is alway useful to consider indirect discrimination

Ohwhatfuckeristhis · 16/11/2026 16:13

Saturdaysfairies · 16/11/2026 11:41

Yes. A mixed group should bring leaders of both sex.

My DD secondary school just went away two nights with her class and two male teachers. She wasn't bothered. She thinks these two teachers (both fathers) know more about teenage girls than the rest of the universe. Fair enough.

I was EVC at my school for many years and guidance from County(and then written onto the Educational Visits policy of the trust) was that for residential visits staff of both sexes should attend. Most male teachers would be reticent to take mixed sex groups overnight. Not only to protect girls and their needs, but also to protect themselves against false accusations or being put into uncomfortable situations.

helpfulperson · 16/11/2026 16:24

Mangosunflower · 16/11/2026 13:32

No, they don't. They are either a biologically a man or a women, they are not both.

I presume it was a joke.

BlueSherbet · 16/11/2026 16:26

Notmytelescope · 16/11/2026 10:32

I am a scout leader and have a different opinion to some others in my group.
Our scouts 10-14 years are a mixed group and I think it is important that a female leader is present on overnight trips. This is not required by the rules - which just require a certain number of leaders.
Other leaders (who are all fathers of daughters) feel that this is unnecessary and indeed some are offended that I think girls need a female when staying away overnight.
AIBU to think a mixed group needs mixed leaders too?

I agree with you, there are certainly some issues where a same sex leader would be appropriate (for either sex).

But this is exactly why girls should have stuck to the girl guides, instead of invading the boy scouts.

TheThirteenthFairy · 16/11/2026 16:27

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · 16/11/2026 12:50

I've seen groups of boys managed by all female leaders.

If these are responsible dads who are capable of looking after their own daughters why do you assume that they cannot look after other similar girls?

I fear that the adverts perenially showing incompetent men have seeped into our normal life.

It's not about the dads though. It's about unrelated girls in the camp who may not wish to speak to him about personal matters. Why do so many of you not understand this?

EvelynBeatrice · 16/11/2026 16:33

BlueSherbet · 16/11/2026 16:26

I agree with you, there are certainly some issues where a same sex leader would be appropriate (for either sex).

But this is exactly why girls should have stuck to the girl guides, instead of invading the boy scouts.

‘Invading’ is an odd choice of word for the presence of people who were invited in. Children - female children - were invited to join - ‘invasion’ implies force imposed on an unwilling recipient.

I agree that the existence of single sex groups is a good idea as are mixed - allows plenty of choice for all.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 16/11/2026 16:33

At school we always had to have male and female teachers on school trips in case someone had an accident in the toilet etc.

BeLemonMoose · 16/11/2026 16:45

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 16/11/2026 16:33

At school we always had to have male and female teachers on school trips in case someone had an accident in the toilet etc.

Seriously once kids are beyond young ages, teachers would not get involved in this anyway.

Laiste · 16/11/2026 16:47

Yes.
Mixed group mixed sex leaders.

Ligesani · 16/11/2026 16:47

BoredZelda · 16/11/2026 10:46

Ask the offended men if they think their presence in the boys’ life brings something female leaders don’t provide. I’m sure they will have lots of opinions on that.

I would also suggest that boys on a camp would benefit from a female staff member being present too. A q- year old away from mum and dad, probably for the first time is far more likely to speak to a trusted female than a trusted male.

My experience as a cub leader is that all of the children would gravitate towards me as the female leader rather than go and ask any of the male leaders anything if they woke up overnight or felt sick.

I think best practice would be to have mixed sex leadership especially if you have mixed sex children on the camp.

However I know how difficult it is getting people to volunteer so I would agree with a previous poster who said that all men leaders and the camp happening would be better than the camp not going ahead at all.

Ligesani · 16/11/2026 16:49

BlueSherbet · 16/11/2026 16:26

I agree with you, there are certainly some issues where a same sex leader would be appropriate (for either sex).

But this is exactly why girls should have stuck to the girl guides, instead of invading the boy scouts.

Girls did not invade scouting, scouting was facing the need to increase numbers or close down completely and so they chose to open up to girls as well as boys in order to increase numbers.

St0rmF0rce · 16/11/2026 17:03

Ligesani · 16/11/2026 16:49

Girls did not invade scouting, scouting was facing the need to increase numbers or close down completely and so they chose to open up to girls as well as boys in order to increase numbers.

Precisely. Girls didn't invade scouting, they saved it.

BlueSherbet · 16/11/2026 17:05

EvelynBeatrice · 16/11/2026 16:33

‘Invading’ is an odd choice of word for the presence of people who were invited in. Children - female children - were invited to join - ‘invasion’ implies force imposed on an unwilling recipient.

I agree that the existence of single sex groups is a good idea as are mixed - allows plenty of choice for all.

"Invited" is an odd choice of word to describe the outcome of a persistent campaign of lobbying and emotional blackmail hinting at sexism.

Its true that the scouts leadership made the decision ultimately, but there is more to the story after that.

There was a decades long (and ongoing) feminist campaign to deny men any social space of their own - from pubs, to golf clubs, to social clubs etc. There was nothing to stop women forming their own clubs, of course, but they prefer the satisfaction of ruining men's things 😂

This was the context I viewed the loss of the boy scouts against, which may explain my choice of language.

In truth, its good that some of these things have changed - but not all, some of these "mens places" were actually important for men socially and for their mental health. This is why the "mens sheds" movement sprung up to replace what was lost.

And while, as a married man with daughters, I am very much pro-womens rights and social spaces, one can easily see the rich irony in women now having to defend their own spaces against men dressed up as women.

But, hey we are on the same page - choice is good, single sex clubs or mixed. But I fear there are not the numbers to sustain all the choices.

I was in the scouts and wouldn't have been interested if girls had been in it. Though interestingly, I remember having female leaders - but no female members. Maybe that was the start of the change?

I didnt resent the female leaders, I respected them - they were just an authority figure, like any other leader.

But once girls are involved in something, many boys naturally view it as a "girls thing" and lose interest.

BirdLandedonmyHead · 16/11/2026 17:13

Woman have been Scout Leaders since WW1.
In fact, originally girls could also be Scouts as well!

AmnesiacDream · 16/11/2026 17:36

I think it would be ideal to have a woman on the team if there are girls going. But better to have the trip with an all male team than to not let the girls go.

BigDanDan · 16/11/2026 17:38

Easy solution - you volunteer as the female leader. It’s fairly quick for them to DBS you I think.

AmnesiacDream · 16/11/2026 17:39

BlueSherbet · 16/11/2026 17:05

"Invited" is an odd choice of word to describe the outcome of a persistent campaign of lobbying and emotional blackmail hinting at sexism.

Its true that the scouts leadership made the decision ultimately, but there is more to the story after that.

There was a decades long (and ongoing) feminist campaign to deny men any social space of their own - from pubs, to golf clubs, to social clubs etc. There was nothing to stop women forming their own clubs, of course, but they prefer the satisfaction of ruining men's things 😂

This was the context I viewed the loss of the boy scouts against, which may explain my choice of language.

In truth, its good that some of these things have changed - but not all, some of these "mens places" were actually important for men socially and for their mental health. This is why the "mens sheds" movement sprung up to replace what was lost.

And while, as a married man with daughters, I am very much pro-womens rights and social spaces, one can easily see the rich irony in women now having to defend their own spaces against men dressed up as women.

But, hey we are on the same page - choice is good, single sex clubs or mixed. But I fear there are not the numbers to sustain all the choices.

I was in the scouts and wouldn't have been interested if girls had been in it. Though interestingly, I remember having female leaders - but no female members. Maybe that was the start of the change?

I didnt resent the female leaders, I respected them - they were just an authority figure, like any other leader.

But once girls are involved in something, many boys naturally view it as a "girls thing" and lose interest.

Scouts let girls in because their numbers were dropping and they feared becoming financial non-viable.

BogRollBOGOF · 16/11/2026 18:31

BlueSherbet · 16/11/2026 17:05

"Invited" is an odd choice of word to describe the outcome of a persistent campaign of lobbying and emotional blackmail hinting at sexism.

Its true that the scouts leadership made the decision ultimately, but there is more to the story after that.

There was a decades long (and ongoing) feminist campaign to deny men any social space of their own - from pubs, to golf clubs, to social clubs etc. There was nothing to stop women forming their own clubs, of course, but they prefer the satisfaction of ruining men's things 😂

This was the context I viewed the loss of the boy scouts against, which may explain my choice of language.

In truth, its good that some of these things have changed - but not all, some of these "mens places" were actually important for men socially and for their mental health. This is why the "mens sheds" movement sprung up to replace what was lost.

And while, as a married man with daughters, I am very much pro-womens rights and social spaces, one can easily see the rich irony in women now having to defend their own spaces against men dressed up as women.

But, hey we are on the same page - choice is good, single sex clubs or mixed. But I fear there are not the numbers to sustain all the choices.

I was in the scouts and wouldn't have been interested if girls had been in it. Though interestingly, I remember having female leaders - but no female members. Maybe that was the start of the change?

I didnt resent the female leaders, I respected them - they were just an authority figure, like any other leader.

But once girls are involved in something, many boys naturally view it as a "girls thing" and lose interest.

Scouting voted to let girls in to counter falling rolls of members. Girl Guiding has never needed to put it to the vote. Males can be unit helpers and hold advisory roles (often Scouters sharing specific skills) but not full Leaders in charge of units.

Many men's spaces came at a major cost of networking that excluded women from networking and professional progression. Things like socialising on the male-only golf course would mean that males would get to know each other and favour each other in professional life and freeze women out of professional progression. I remember my dad doing lots of corporate semi-informal networking at places like golf-courses and horse races back in the 80s/ 90s towards the end of that era. In his line of work, the women he worked with were secretaries and admin staff, not management.

Single-sex socialising is important to both sexes, but not at a cost of exclusion in wider society which is what used to happen with many men's membership groups. Female only spaces have not had that wider professional influence on society. There are still influential male spaces such as the Free Masons.

Back to the main point of the thread, there are often issues on camps that benefit from a female leader necessary. Not just periods (which are common) but it's surprising how many young people have continence/ urinary/ bowel issues that need sensitivity. It is better if a same-sex leader can enter sleeping/ hygiene facilities if there is an issue that needs resolving. First aid is another potential issue, particularly if doing adventurous activities that could affect any part of the body.

If no one is avaliable then that should be clear but it could easily come at a cost of deterring participants.
One way around it is to appeal to other units in the group/ district or team up with other units, although Guiding/ Scouting require seperate DBS checks.

BogRollBOGOF · 16/11/2026 18:49

BlueSherbet · 16/11/2026 17:05

"Invited" is an odd choice of word to describe the outcome of a persistent campaign of lobbying and emotional blackmail hinting at sexism.

Its true that the scouts leadership made the decision ultimately, but there is more to the story after that.

There was a decades long (and ongoing) feminist campaign to deny men any social space of their own - from pubs, to golf clubs, to social clubs etc. There was nothing to stop women forming their own clubs, of course, but they prefer the satisfaction of ruining men's things 😂

This was the context I viewed the loss of the boy scouts against, which may explain my choice of language.

In truth, its good that some of these things have changed - but not all, some of these "mens places" were actually important for men socially and for their mental health. This is why the "mens sheds" movement sprung up to replace what was lost.

And while, as a married man with daughters, I am very much pro-womens rights and social spaces, one can easily see the rich irony in women now having to defend their own spaces against men dressed up as women.

But, hey we are on the same page - choice is good, single sex clubs or mixed. But I fear there are not the numbers to sustain all the choices.

I was in the scouts and wouldn't have been interested if girls had been in it. Though interestingly, I remember having female leaders - but no female members. Maybe that was the start of the change?

I didnt resent the female leaders, I respected them - they were just an authority figure, like any other leader.

But once girls are involved in something, many boys naturally view it as a "girls thing" and lose interest.

There absolutely were barriers to women setting up their own versions too. Inheritance, financial autonomy, bequests and experience for a start.

The FA actively banned females from playing football in 1921. If girls had no culture of playing football in schools or clubs, and females have legal and financial restrictions on obtaining the assets required, they can't just set up their own version. In the 1990s, girls still frequently weren't playing football in PE at school. It's taken 80+ years to even get female football on the radar, and over 100 years on from that ban women's football is billions of pounds per year behind men's in the scale of infrastructure and influence despite England having a women's team that can win tournaments.

That's been the level of challenge to women reaching an equal level of men, and barriers were put up widely across institutions, systems and society.

A society of old boys club mentality and segregation wastes the talent pool of 50% of the population to the detriment of all.

Females benefit from female spaces for safety.
Males benefit from male spaces for influence.

Ligesani · 16/11/2026 22:46

BigDanDan · 16/11/2026 17:38

Easy solution - you volunteer as the female leader. It’s fairly quick for them to DBS you I think.

She could go as a parent helper, but to be a leader you need to do training as well as the dbs and it's not especially quick.

lottiegarbanzo · 16/11/2026 22:59

Bestbeforenow · 16/11/2026 10:52

A man who cannot imagine that an unrelated girl might be more comfortable with a female leader isn’t entirely suited to the position imo.

Indeed. I agree with you OP.

Lots of girls would be uncomfortable approaching ‘someone else’s dad, the leader’ about periods, or other personal concerns.