Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls on trips need female staff?

81 replies

Notmytelescope · 16/11/2026 10:32

I am a scout leader and have a different opinion to some others in my group.
Our scouts 10-14 years are a mixed group and I think it is important that a female leader is present on overnight trips. This is not required by the rules - which just require a certain number of leaders.
Other leaders (who are all fathers of daughters) feel that this is unnecessary and indeed some are offended that I think girls need a female when staying away overnight.
AIBU to think a mixed group needs mixed leaders too?

OP posts:
whippersnapper55 · Yesterday 06:52

My sister started her periods at Guide camp. I think she'd have been very uncomfortable going to an adult male for help, and probably would have just tried to deal with it herself!

MidlifeMiseryGuts · Yesterday 07:48

Of course they do. How stupid and arrogant of the male leaders to think differently. The usual sexism.

PerplexedOnceMore · Yesterday 08:50

What happened to the OP?

Mermaidmusing · Yesterday 09:26

About 10 years ago, my step-daughter and her best friend joined the Scouts briefly when they were 13, and went on a weekend camping trip, where they were the only 2 girls. There was no adult female present, all the leaders were male.

The girls were sexually harassed by boys throughout the weekend, asked for blow jobs, threatened with ‘teabagging’ and continual sexual comments. Not all done in front of the adults, but a lot of the comments were in front of the leaders, and were laughed off as ‘banter’.

My SD was very subdued when she came home and the story came out over the next few days. Long story short, we contacted the Scouting HQ and made a very robust formal complaint. We did eventually receive a fulsome apology and the scout leader was actually dismissed. Some of the boys then targeted my SD as the trouble maker who had got him removed and subsequently she and her friend no longer felt welcome and left the Scouts altogether.

It was a really sad and disturbing episode. I am shocked to hear that trips are still being conducted with no adult female present; girls are very vulnerable when outnumbered in a traditionally male environment like this and require the protection of adult females.

I would never ever recommend the Scouts to girls based on our experience, and clearly nothing has actually changed over the past 10 years. So depressing.

feemcgee · Yesterday 09:30

Definitely, there should be a female lead there too, this isn’t a new thing, I remember my mum as a teacher requiring a male to go on overnight trips too more than 20 years ago.

FennelSnack · Yesterday 09:31

Yes they do. The fact that some of the dads can't understand it is evidence in itself of why it's needed.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page