Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas with dogs and a baby

474 replies

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 07:28

We usually spend Christmas with my parents, my brother, his wife and children, sister and her husband and my SIL and her husband and children at our house. Over the last 3 years we have got 2 dogs and earlier this year my sister had a baby.

My sister has decided she doesn’t want her baby around our dogs so told me she won’t be coming to us for Christmas. I told her I understood and we will catch up another time. My sister seemed fine with that.

My parents have now told me that we should have offered to make other arrangements for our dogs like leaving them with friends or putting them in kennels so that we can all spend Xmas together. Apparently my sister was upset that we didn’t offer this but didn’t want to say. I haven’t spoke to my sister again yet. My brother has told my husband that my parents and sister think we are being selfish putting our dogs before their baby’s first Xmas.

I had no idea it was an issue and that they would expect our dogs to go elsewhere. We are not willing to send our dogs away anyway and I don’t see it as putting our dogs first. When I spoke to my sister before I did say we can keep the dogs separate to the baby but I understand that she didn’t want to take any risks. I thought she was happy for us to see each other at another time.

Do people really expect you to send your dogs somewhere so they can come for Christmas. Are we being unreasonable to say no?

OP posts:
wildnwilde · 16/11/2026 11:55

What kind of dogs whata the temperament ? I don't see the issue with you spending Xmas apart either way . You have your lives they have theirs . No need for anyone to be offended or feel guilty !

Junglejune · 16/11/2026 11:56

Screamingabdabz · 16/11/2026 09:32

As it’s your home YANBU. But I do think it’s harsh to put your animals above your sister’s new baby and not even try and reassure her or try and reach a compromise so you can all enjoy Christmas together.

I’m with your mum and sister. The newborn is a far more important part of family life than your dogs. Not to you maybe. And that’s clearly why they’re upset.

She has tried to reach a compromise though. She’s offered to keep the dogs separately. She’s said it’s fine if the rest of the family have Christmas elsewhere. But that’s apparently not enough. She has to host everyone AND remove the dogs from their home. How is that compromise that’s capitulation.

insertgenericusername · 16/11/2026 11:56

donuttiest · 16/11/2026 10:59

Many children are understandably scared of dogs. The majority of dog owners are horrendouse owners.

85% of UK dogs are left on their own for 5 hours or more. Dogs are are just a fashion accessory for most owners.

They are locked up whilst their owners fuck off to work and are obediently waiting their return to occupy the few hours remaining in their owners day.

Walk through any town and you won't have to go far to see a dog owners inability to control their animal.

Visit an outlet village or shopping/towncentre and watch as owners struggle to keep their barking dogs off one another.

Yet it's up to those who don't own a dog to acclimitise children to the chaos that dog owners bring.

Over 32,000 dog attacks last year. 2 dog bites per 100 people on average. The stats don't lie.

Maybe pick an argument?

are owners shit and selfish for leaving their dogs alone for 5 hours, or is the OP shit and selfish for wanting to take her dogs with her on Christmas Day (which isn’t actually what’s happening here, but it’s what your argument originally was)

wildnwilde · 16/11/2026 12:06

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 08:03

One is a poodle and one is a shih tzu. Both are well trained and have been around young children. I respect my sisters decision to not want her baby around them though.

Yeah she's being ridiculous BUT anxiety as a new mum is not always rational . Let them get on with it you've not been unreasonable. She may relax a bit and your pooches and doggies may become friends eventually

Justusethebloodyphone · 16/11/2026 12:10

WitchesBritches · 16/11/2026 08:52

Yes, she's 'allowed to be as overprotective as she wants to be, what is spectacularly shit is to wait until five weeks before Christmas, agree with the OP that they will get together another time, then whines to the family that her sister is selfish. She's known for at least four months if not, 13 or more that she had no intention of spending Christmas at her sister's house if the dogs were going to be there & why shouldn't they be, they live there?

they're a poodle and a Shih Tzu, not a pair of XL bullies, & and a not yet crawling baby.

no one is suggesting putting the dogs & baby in the sitting room by themselves all day, with no adults present, the OP even offered to put the dogs in a separate room. What exactly do you think the risk is with a poodle and a Shih Tzu half a dozen adults??

She's being ridiculous, but worse than that she's being incredibly rude and causing issues. Getting the rest of the family on side, calling her sister selfish.

Edited

Delete all as I replied to the wrong message

wildnwilde · 16/11/2026 12:11

MsSquiz · 16/11/2026 09:39

I find the “no dogs around babies” weirdo if I’m honest. DD1 was 1 week old at her first Christmas and around 2 dogs who gave her a sniff and forgot she was there! DD2 was 8 months old and the dogs did very well out of her sharing her lunch!

anyway, it wasn’t even a discussion, your sister said she isn’t coming. She didn’t make any request or ask your thoughts… she sounds a bit dramatic and PFB.

I would say to your parents that the dogs will be in a separate room if she would like to come, but they aren’t being sent away. And leave it at that.

Dogs can be so beneficial to children if properly introduced and socialised . It's sad rhatbalot of ppl see them as a big bad wolf now . My best friend in childhood was our dog ,she was 6 mths older than me .

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:13

Of course you should have offered to make other arrangements for your dogs. Your excluded your sister from Christmas - she’s not unreasonable not to want dogs around her baby and I’m sure your parents would
much rather spend Christmas with their grandchild than your animals.

i’m actually in exactly the same situation - will have a 10 day old baby at Christmas after a c section - no way will I be entertaining BILs dog in the slightest and I expect PIL to say the same

PurpleThistle7 · 16/11/2026 12:14

What a bizarre jump here. You are being totally reasonable (and I say this as someone very allergic to dogs who is also kind of scared of them. Try not to make that my kids' problem though)

MagicMelanie · 16/11/2026 12:16

Why is it fair enough? What breed are they?

Of course it's fair enough for someone to not want dogs around their 4 month old baby. Whatever the breed.

insertgenericusername · 16/11/2026 12:16

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:13

Of course you should have offered to make other arrangements for your dogs. Your excluded your sister from Christmas - she’s not unreasonable not to want dogs around her baby and I’m sure your parents would
much rather spend Christmas with their grandchild than your animals.

i’m actually in exactly the same situation - will have a 10 day old baby at Christmas after a c section - no way will I be entertaining BILs dog in the slightest and I expect PIL to say the same

Then you or or PIL will host, yes?

SL2924 · 16/11/2026 12:16

Can you get a pen to put the dogs in for the day? Then they are still home but gated off from the baby?

FurbySaysYummmm · 16/11/2026 12:16

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:13

Of course you should have offered to make other arrangements for your dogs. Your excluded your sister from Christmas - she’s not unreasonable not to want dogs around her baby and I’m sure your parents would
much rather spend Christmas with their grandchild than your animals.

i’m actually in exactly the same situation - will have a 10 day old baby at Christmas after a c section - no way will I be entertaining BILs dog in the slightest and I expect PIL to say the same

The OP doesn't need to make alternative arrangements for the animals that everyone knows live in her house.

If you don't wish to spend time in a relatives home during the holiday season because they have dogs then that's fine but you can't dictate that you get to go to someone's house, have them host you and expect them to send the dogs away.

If you don't like it the suggestions being made (in this case the dogs being in another room) then no one is forcing you to come.

MagicMelanie · 16/11/2026 12:18

A friend of mine said his daughter wouldn’t let their dog in the house when she had a newborn. She does allow it now. Sounds like your sister is in PFB mode

I think it's less PFB mode, more common sense. I never let dogs in my house when my children were small and I still don't.

BarnacleBeasley · 16/11/2026 12:20

I don't think dogs and babies belong together but I do think the sister and other family members are being really weird. If it were a mobile toddler who would be rampaging around winding the dogs up, fair enough, but a baby who's too little to crawl yet and two well-trained small dogs would be very easy to keep separate. And I write this as someone who managed to keep my own dog separate from my baby for the first two years (never in same room unattended; baby never touched dog).

Yeswoman · 16/11/2026 12:22

Can someone else not just host? Surely that's the most reasonable solution and keeps everyone happy.

Suzjspik · 16/11/2026 12:22

There is no way my dog would be going in kennels at christmas ! Cruel! I have young nephews (3 and 6 months) and an excitable dog, I always keep them apart when they visit.

AIBUfamilydrama · 16/11/2026 12:24

It’s a bit of a tough one and I think you’re being a bit U but also not as well, I do feel like Christmas this year it would be nice if your nephew was the centre of attention, especially as he took a while coming, as you said. It would be nice for your sister. It seems a bit sad to have your sister not join you for Christmas over something so easily fixable. Could your dogs not go and stay at your parents for a few hours, or your partners parents if they’re close by?

I do also think your sister is being a bit previous as well though.

MagicMelanie · 16/11/2026 12:24

I will confess I have found it very hard to get my head around the modern/urban version of dog ownership where dogs are treated like humans

Ditto

BeeDavis · 16/11/2026 12:26

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 07:51

No but he is only 4 months old. So far, we have been the ones to visit them but she’s never said that’s because of our dogs, just that it’s easier for us to go to them so she has all the baby stuff.

My baby is 5 months old and we have a dog.. does she understand that people have dogs and babies at the same time? The baby will more than likely be held most of the time or be in a crib/cot! She sounds batshit and this will probably be the first in a long line of ridiculous requests to benefit her and her precious little baby.

ClaredeBear · 16/11/2026 12:26

CaptainCalm · 16/11/2026 07:59

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable but you do sound perhaps a little detached from your nephew in your posts, using ‘the baby’ to describe him. Are you particularly close?

Her reaction is quite strong so I wondered if there is more to it? Are the dogs and aggressive breed, have they ever nipped anyone before, are they all over the house (on sofas, beds, upstairs, bouncing up at people when they walk in) As a non-dog person she might be worried about this perhaps?

My sister was “the baby” for years!

HoleMealFlower · 16/11/2026 12:26

Is she suffering from post natal depression or anxiety?

Yeswoman · 16/11/2026 12:27

MagicMelanie · 16/11/2026 12:24

I will confess I have found it very hard to get my head around the modern/urban version of dog ownership where dogs are treated like humans

Ditto

I find it totally crazy how some people will happily leave their dogs alone for a few hours when it suits them but when it comes to christmas and making totally understandable adjustments for babies and children you get the whole "but the dog deserves a nice Christmas too" spiel

CharlieEffie · 16/11/2026 12:28

How ridiculous. You offered to keep them separate. Of course you shouldnt 'put your dogs in a kennels' at christmas!!

MagicMelanie · 16/11/2026 12:29

Mine would be, as they just sleep, so we would just shut them in the largest bedroom with a bowl of water and let them out every few hours to toilet. Just a one off, for one day, while not idea, this wouldn't hurt them

I think it's many people's experience that while people will promise to keep the dogs out of the house, usually at some point they say 'shall we just let the dogs in and see how it goes?' and in come the dogs. It is for the avoidance of this that I never accepted an invitation where it was promised, having realised it is generally just lip service.

CharlieEffie · 16/11/2026 12:29

Yeswoman · 16/11/2026 12:27

I find it totally crazy how some people will happily leave their dogs alone for a few hours when it suits them but when it comes to christmas and making totally understandable adjustments for babies and children you get the whole "but the dog deserves a nice Christmas too" spiel

She offered to keep the dogs seperate. The dogs dont deserve getting sent off to the kennels for christmas