Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas with dogs and a baby

474 replies

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 07:28

We usually spend Christmas with my parents, my brother, his wife and children, sister and her husband and my SIL and her husband and children at our house. Over the last 3 years we have got 2 dogs and earlier this year my sister had a baby.

My sister has decided she doesn’t want her baby around our dogs so told me she won’t be coming to us for Christmas. I told her I understood and we will catch up another time. My sister seemed fine with that.

My parents have now told me that we should have offered to make other arrangements for our dogs like leaving them with friends or putting them in kennels so that we can all spend Xmas together. Apparently my sister was upset that we didn’t offer this but didn’t want to say. I haven’t spoke to my sister again yet. My brother has told my husband that my parents and sister think we are being selfish putting our dogs before their baby’s first Xmas.

I had no idea it was an issue and that they would expect our dogs to go elsewhere. We are not willing to send our dogs away anyway and I don’t see it as putting our dogs first. When I spoke to my sister before I did say we can keep the dogs separate to the baby but I understand that she didn’t want to take any risks. I thought she was happy for us to see each other at another time.

Do people really expect you to send your dogs somewhere so they can come for Christmas. Are we being unreasonable to say no?

OP posts:
ThatWhiteElephant · 16/11/2026 22:54

Cla7 · 16/11/2026 09:16

Mumsnet loves dogs so you’ll get a lot of reassurance here, but my opinion is that YABU to put your dogs above spending Christmas with your sister and your newest family member. Poor sister, being a new mum can be very isolating as it is, and now having to spend Christmas alone must be a hard blow.

But SomewhereBeautiful isn’t putting her dogs before the baby, she has said that the dogs will be separated at all times, in another room. How is that not good enough?

I know SomewhereBeautiful wouldn’t consider kennels (I agree with this), but even if she would, there would be no chance of any availability at this time of year anyway.

WhatYouWearing · 16/11/2026 22:55

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 22:22

My parents moved into a 1 bedroom warden controlled/sheltered housing place a few years ago so there is even less room there. It would be a squeeze for everyone at my sister’s house but their comment was very rude. I told my sister she’d be better to just have a quiet Xmas with her husband and baby and let everyone pop in to visit over a few days.

Maybe your sister wanted a baby’s first Christmas alone at her home with her DP and has played a blinder how to get it without being the bad guy.

Hosting Christmas is hard work. You don’t have a ‘bloody’ dog problem. You have a family problem.

Hellohelga · 16/11/2026 22:56

There’s no reason a baby can’t be around dogs. If she chooses not to come that’s her choice. You’ve offered another date which I think is fine.

Hellohelga · 16/11/2026 23:02

Btw there’s no way you’ll get kennels spaces now 6 weeks before Christmas, even if you wanted to.

Redragtoabull · 16/11/2026 23:25

Christmas in your own home with your own babies sounds perfect, enjoy it. Everyone else can have their own day in the way they want. Not a hope in hell I would be sending my pets away to appease a princess when I'm the one hosting. They should graciously decline and make their own plans, not whine to the rest of the family, such a pathetic stance. They'd all get a realistic Fuck Off from me and watch them start scrabbling about what to do as I gently shut the Christmas door on them all.

Uniqueusername3 · Yesterday 04:03

I'd tell your parents not to bother coming, they'll just ruin it.

I'm not a dog person, I have cats but I'm not really a cat person either, they're not my baby's or my family, they're pets. I don't care about spending Christmas with them. But I wouldn't be shelling out and adding another job to take my pets somewhere for someone else to look after them so I can host someone at Christmas.

Is anyone offering to foot the bill of the boarding and do the running around? Does anyone contribute to the costs and work of hosting so many people for Christmas?

I think your sister is being selfish and precious and actually a fair bit spiteful to be going behind your back bitching and inviting everyone to go to hers instead, she said you're welcome to come too but only because you opened the conversation with her and she had already invited everyone else without talking to you about it. And she's clearly ran straight back to your parents bitching again to trigger your parents text. I think in a few years when she's, hopefully, out of the pfb fog she'll realise how ridiculous she's been and the mess she's caused.

Your parents are incredibly rude and bitchy.

fuchsteufelswild · Yesterday 04:49

How is a separate room not good enough? Even if someone leaves a door open, which is already unlikely if you only need to go in to check their water and take them around the block, a Poodle and a Shih-Tzu (!) will hardly launch themselves at someone holding the baby first thing.

If your sister had wanted to find a solution she would have told you, and earlier too to sort this out. I agree with PP that she has played a blinder using you and the dogs.

Credittocress · Yesterday 06:00

She’s taking the piss, you proposed a solution which anyone can see is reasonable, but she is using the baby as a winning hand to try and bend the family to her will.

Id stop by hers on Christmas Day, let your parents sulk alone at there’s. Then I’d declare her Christmas such a success you think you, her and your brother should alternate Christmas going forwards. Let her year of silliness keep making demands on her for years to come and buy you some years off.

cuddlebear · Yesterday 06:51

Well done on not allowing your parents to triangulate between you and DSIS.

I would be tempted to get strategic flu and let your rude parents eat toast at home on Christmas Day!

Ophy83 · Yesterday 07:35

Her fears about the dogs seem a bit extreme. Even if someone inadvertently let the dogs in, her baby will be in a room with multiple adults who can intervene before anything happens. The baby won't be off exploring the house or getting in the dogs' faces like an older child might

If she really does want to be with the family at Christmas you could suggest she and the baby join you and the dogs for a walk sometime in the next few weeks just so she can see how they ineract, which may calm her a little. As others have said though, it may be that she actually wants a small Christmas and this is a way of achieving that without hurting your mum's feelings

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:39

Ophy83 · Yesterday 07:35

Her fears about the dogs seem a bit extreme. Even if someone inadvertently let the dogs in, her baby will be in a room with multiple adults who can intervene before anything happens. The baby won't be off exploring the house or getting in the dogs' faces like an older child might

If she really does want to be with the family at Christmas you could suggest she and the baby join you and the dogs for a walk sometime in the next few weeks just so she can see how they ineract, which may calm her a little. As others have said though, it may be that she actually wants a small Christmas and this is a way of achieving that without hurting your mum's feelings

I think you are allowed to be a bit pfb when you literally have a 4 month old baby who is your first born.

Credittocress · Yesterday 07:44

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:39

I think you are allowed to be a bit pfb when you literally have a 4 month old baby who is your first born.

You can be PFB if it means you’re being protective. But you can’t use it to play the family off against each other

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:48

Credittocress · Yesterday 07:44

You can be PFB if it means you’re being protective. But you can’t use it to play the family off against each other

From what the OP has said, that is not what the sister has attempted to do.

User3353821614 · Yesterday 07:54

Your sister is overreacting about the dogs.

I would check she’s ok as it sounds like she could be suffering from post natal anxiety. Normal with a new baby, yes, but this sounds a bit worrying.

Credittocress · Yesterday 08:00

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:48

From what the OP has said, that is not what the sister has attempted to do.

Really?

She said she knows it’s a lot to ask for us to not have our dogs there but would like us to do it so that we can all spend Xmas together.

She insists she didn’t call us selfish though and just mentioned it to our parents in passing as she was disappointed and that they’ve made it into more.

As much as I’ve assured her about keeping the dogs separate, she doesn’t want to take any risks and thinks someone will leave a pet gate or door open.

My dad has text me tonight to say he’s disappointed to not have a family Xmas this year all because of those bloody dogs.

Reads exactly like the sister is using the parents desire to have a family Christmas to manipulate the situation. Shes holding a hard line of the dogs can’t be there, no compromise, and using her parents to brow beat the OP. Funny straight after the sister’s conversation it’s all been reported back to the parents and kicks off again. If it wasn’t a manipulation it wouldn’t have been reported back because Christmas had already been sorted so there was no change to report

Ophy83 · Yesterday 08:01

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:39

I think you are allowed to be a bit pfb when you literally have a 4 month old baby who is your first born.

That's why I've suggested a walk as a safe way for the dogs and baby to meet - the dogs will probably greet sis and baby but are likely to be much more interested in spending most of the time running off into the woods etc. If a first interaction goes well the sister may feel more relaxed about visits. Honestly 4 months is a far better age for them to meet than waiting until the baby is mobile or worse, at the toddler stage of actively wanting to chase the dogs/pull their tails.

MyMilchick · Yesterday 08:08

Ophy83 · Yesterday 07:35

Her fears about the dogs seem a bit extreme. Even if someone inadvertently let the dogs in, her baby will be in a room with multiple adults who can intervene before anything happens. The baby won't be off exploring the house or getting in the dogs' faces like an older child might

If she really does want to be with the family at Christmas you could suggest she and the baby join you and the dogs for a walk sometime in the next few weeks just so she can see how they ineract, which may calm her a little. As others have said though, it may be that she actually wants a small Christmas and this is a way of achieving that without hurting your mum's feelings

Exactly, its not like OP has 2 big Pitbulls, its a shitzu and a poodle 😂

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 08:08

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:48

From what the OP has said, that is not what the sister has attempted to do.

Thanks. I don’t think my sister has done that either. It seems she was disappointed and a bit sad and then mentioned it to my parents who have twisted it into something more and then told our brother that she thinks we are selfish. My sister apologised for not talking to me more about how she felt and understands why we don’t want to send our dogs away. Everything is fine between me and my sister.

She’s feeling very tired as my nephew isn’t sleeping well and I think that probably played a role in her not realising how our parents would take what she said. They are very focused on their new GS at the moment which is lovely but they’ve overreacted about this.

We had a good talk about how she’s feeling and I don’t think she has PND but she is feeling a little anxious and says she’s not sure when she’ll be ok with the dogs. She is going to see her GP if it continues. Although some people may think it’s too much for her to not want her baby around my dogs, I do understand her concern there. We have only got dogs as our kids are older and we wouldn’t have got them when out children were little. She doesn’t seem overly anxious about other things and there is nothing wrong with being a bit PFB when he is so precious to us all. She lets us all hold and look after her baby, she’s taking him out to baby groups and seems happy, just tired so I think it’s within norms for a first time mum. Her husband is away with work this week so I’m going to stay with her on Thursday night so she can get a full nights sleep.

OP posts:
ThisWiseRobin · Yesterday 08:08

To summarise:
Your sister is weird
Your parents are just horrible
Your dogs love you unconditionally and would never hurt you.

I know who I would rather spend the day with.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 08:09

Credittocress · Yesterday 08:00

Really?

She said she knows it’s a lot to ask for us to not have our dogs there but would like us to do it so that we can all spend Xmas together.

She insists she didn’t call us selfish though and just mentioned it to our parents in passing as she was disappointed and that they’ve made it into more.

As much as I’ve assured her about keeping the dogs separate, she doesn’t want to take any risks and thinks someone will leave a pet gate or door open.

My dad has text me tonight to say he’s disappointed to not have a family Xmas this year all because of those bloody dogs.

Reads exactly like the sister is using the parents desire to have a family Christmas to manipulate the situation. Shes holding a hard line of the dogs can’t be there, no compromise, and using her parents to brow beat the OP. Funny straight after the sister’s conversation it’s all been reported back to the parents and kicks off again. If it wasn’t a manipulation it wouldn’t have been reported back because Christmas had already been sorted so there was no change to report

If the OP is happy that she has sorted things out with her sister then I think that is all that matters.

We are talking about the logistics of one family occasion. It doesn’t have to be a huge drama.

Credittocress · Yesterday 08:12

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 08:08

Thanks. I don’t think my sister has done that either. It seems she was disappointed and a bit sad and then mentioned it to my parents who have twisted it into something more and then told our brother that she thinks we are selfish. My sister apologised for not talking to me more about how she felt and understands why we don’t want to send our dogs away. Everything is fine between me and my sister.

She’s feeling very tired as my nephew isn’t sleeping well and I think that probably played a role in her not realising how our parents would take what she said. They are very focused on their new GS at the moment which is lovely but they’ve overreacted about this.

We had a good talk about how she’s feeling and I don’t think she has PND but she is feeling a little anxious and says she’s not sure when she’ll be ok with the dogs. She is going to see her GP if it continues. Although some people may think it’s too much for her to not want her baby around my dogs, I do understand her concern there. We have only got dogs as our kids are older and we wouldn’t have got them when out children were little. She doesn’t seem overly anxious about other things and there is nothing wrong with being a bit PFB when he is so precious to us all. She lets us all hold and look after her baby, she’s taking him out to baby groups and seems happy, just tired so I think it’s within norms for a first time mum. Her husband is away with work this week so I’m going to stay with her on Thursday night so she can get a full nights sleep.

Why would she get a full nights sleep with you there, but not her husband? Is he not pulling his weight?

TVHedgehog · Yesterday 08:17

It sounds like the dogs will be securely kept away, and if for some reason they did get out there are plenty of people around to prevent them getting to the baby. Presumably the baby is not going to be left unattended in the middle of the floor at any time, to be honest I think you’re being very generous in your understanding of her concerns as a first time mum. Realistically what are the chances of anything happening?

Out of interest does this family Christmas happen every year? Do the spouses of your siblings ever spend Christmas with their own families, and you with your in laws?

thepariscrimefiles · Yesterday 08:18

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 08:08

Thanks. I don’t think my sister has done that either. It seems she was disappointed and a bit sad and then mentioned it to my parents who have twisted it into something more and then told our brother that she thinks we are selfish. My sister apologised for not talking to me more about how she felt and understands why we don’t want to send our dogs away. Everything is fine between me and my sister.

She’s feeling very tired as my nephew isn’t sleeping well and I think that probably played a role in her not realising how our parents would take what she said. They are very focused on their new GS at the moment which is lovely but they’ve overreacted about this.

We had a good talk about how she’s feeling and I don’t think she has PND but she is feeling a little anxious and says she’s not sure when she’ll be ok with the dogs. She is going to see her GP if it continues. Although some people may think it’s too much for her to not want her baby around my dogs, I do understand her concern there. We have only got dogs as our kids are older and we wouldn’t have got them when out children were little. She doesn’t seem overly anxious about other things and there is nothing wrong with being a bit PFB when he is so precious to us all. She lets us all hold and look after her baby, she’s taking him out to baby groups and seems happy, just tired so I think it’s within norms for a first time mum. Her husband is away with work this week so I’m going to stay with her on Thursday night so she can get a full nights sleep.

You sound like a lovely caring sister. Your parents, on the other hand, sound like trouble-makers.

They have refused your sister's invitation to Christmas Dinner. What are they intending to do now? I bet that they still expect to come to your house on Christmas Day but will make lots of passive-aggressive little digs about the dogs and how mean you are being to your sister.

lazyarse123 · Yesterday 08:20

Credittocress · Yesterday 08:12

Why would she get a full nights sleep with you there, but not her husband? Is he not pulling his weight?

The husband won't be there so can't pull his weight. Talk about trying to cause problems when there aren't any.

Tulipsriver · Yesterday 08:23

Not unreasonable to keep your dog in his home, but I'm surprised your mum didn't offer to spend the day with your sister instead. My mum would definitely put being there for a babies first Christmas before going wherever she usually spent Christmas. Are you sure your sister isn't upset with your mum and she's passing on the blame?