Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas with dogs and a baby

474 replies

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 07:28

We usually spend Christmas with my parents, my brother, his wife and children, sister and her husband and my SIL and her husband and children at our house. Over the last 3 years we have got 2 dogs and earlier this year my sister had a baby.

My sister has decided she doesn’t want her baby around our dogs so told me she won’t be coming to us for Christmas. I told her I understood and we will catch up another time. My sister seemed fine with that.

My parents have now told me that we should have offered to make other arrangements for our dogs like leaving them with friends or putting them in kennels so that we can all spend Xmas together. Apparently my sister was upset that we didn’t offer this but didn’t want to say. I haven’t spoke to my sister again yet. My brother has told my husband that my parents and sister think we are being selfish putting our dogs before their baby’s first Xmas.

I had no idea it was an issue and that they would expect our dogs to go elsewhere. We are not willing to send our dogs away anyway and I don’t see it as putting our dogs first. When I spoke to my sister before I did say we can keep the dogs separate to the baby but I understand that she didn’t want to take any risks. I thought she was happy for us to see each other at another time.

Do people really expect you to send your dogs somewhere so they can come for Christmas. Are we being unreasonable to say no?

OP posts:
Yeswoman · 16/11/2026 12:30

CharlieEffie · 16/11/2026 12:29

She offered to keep the dogs seperate. The dogs dont deserve getting sent off to the kennels for christmas

I'm not suggesting kennels. Someone else could host and the dogs could be left at home, surely?

canklesmctacotits · 16/11/2026 12:30

To many non-dog people, you absolutely are putting the dogs before your sister and nephew. It sounds like what you say: “my dogs are going to stay in their home, you’re a guest, come or don’t”. To them, you’re putting animals above humans, and loved and cherished humans at that. I’m a non-dog person and would have thought this once upon a time but have come to learn the place the dogs hold for some people.

I wouldn’t be surprised if your parents peeled off with this sister and their new grandchild, and presumably that will cause drama because you mum will have to host because sister with a 4mo can’t be expected to. Then parents will say family is split over Christmas and that’s all because of two small dogs - be prepared for this to be all your fault.

Personally I think your sister is being ridiculous but I do get it. She might calm down as her son grows. Is there any chance she can bring the baby k er for a visit before Christmas so she can see what your home is actually like, while she keeps a close eye on the baby? Shihtzus are gentle as they come in my experience but the poodle could be a bit much. But acclimating the dogs to the baby will work - and you can tell her that her baby will also need to acclimate to a house full of people and a broken routine and all the noise and messed up naps!!

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:33

BeeDavis · 16/11/2026 12:26

My baby is 5 months old and we have a dog.. does she understand that people have dogs and babies at the same time? The baby will more than likely be held most of the time or be in a crib/cot! She sounds batshit and this will probably be the first in a long line of ridiculous requests to benefit her and her precious little baby.

Maybe she thinks that people shouldn’t have dogs and babies at the same time and that those people who do are extremely reckless

Yeswoman · 16/11/2026 12:33

canklesmctacotits · 16/11/2026 12:30

To many non-dog people, you absolutely are putting the dogs before your sister and nephew. It sounds like what you say: “my dogs are going to stay in their home, you’re a guest, come or don’t”. To them, you’re putting animals above humans, and loved and cherished humans at that. I’m a non-dog person and would have thought this once upon a time but have come to learn the place the dogs hold for some people.

I wouldn’t be surprised if your parents peeled off with this sister and their new grandchild, and presumably that will cause drama because you mum will have to host because sister with a 4mo can’t be expected to. Then parents will say family is split over Christmas and that’s all because of two small dogs - be prepared for this to be all your fault.

Personally I think your sister is being ridiculous but I do get it. She might calm down as her son grows. Is there any chance she can bring the baby k er for a visit before Christmas so she can see what your home is actually like, while she keeps a close eye on the baby? Shihtzus are gentle as they come in my experience but the poodle could be a bit much. But acclimating the dogs to the baby will work - and you can tell her that her baby will also need to acclimate to a house full of people and a broken routine and all the noise and messed up naps!!

This is the best response on here.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:34

Itshotchocolatetime · 16/11/2026 10:57

The dogs are part of the OP's family, I'm sure the OP and her family want the dogs there for Christmas. It's unreasonable of the sister to request this, and if the OP were to give in, then there would be the expectation that the dogs are sent away every year. Keep your dogs at home with you OP.

Thankfully a dog will never have any concept of Christmas so it doesn’t matter

ClaredeBear · 16/11/2026 12:34

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:13

Of course you should have offered to make other arrangements for your dogs. Your excluded your sister from Christmas - she’s not unreasonable not to want dogs around her baby and I’m sure your parents would
much rather spend Christmas with their grandchild than your animals.

i’m actually in exactly the same situation - will have a 10 day old baby at Christmas after a c section - no way will I be entertaining BILs dog in the slightest and I expect PIL to say the same

The difference here is that she’s hosting in her house, she’s not taking the dogs to the parents.

ClaredeBear · 16/11/2026 12:36

canklesmctacotits · 16/11/2026 12:30

To many non-dog people, you absolutely are putting the dogs before your sister and nephew. It sounds like what you say: “my dogs are going to stay in their home, you’re a guest, come or don’t”. To them, you’re putting animals above humans, and loved and cherished humans at that. I’m a non-dog person and would have thought this once upon a time but have come to learn the place the dogs hold for some people.

I wouldn’t be surprised if your parents peeled off with this sister and their new grandchild, and presumably that will cause drama because you mum will have to host because sister with a 4mo can’t be expected to. Then parents will say family is split over Christmas and that’s all because of two small dogs - be prepared for this to be all your fault.

Personally I think your sister is being ridiculous but I do get it. She might calm down as her son grows. Is there any chance she can bring the baby k er for a visit before Christmas so she can see what your home is actually like, while she keeps a close eye on the baby? Shihtzus are gentle as they come in my experience but the poodle could be a bit much. But acclimating the dogs to the baby will work - and you can tell her that her baby will also need to acclimate to a house full of people and a broken routine and all the noise and messed up naps!!

This is a very balanced view but it assumes the dogs have somewhere nice to go. Who is going to take dogs on Xmas day?

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:37

ClaredeBear · 16/11/2026 12:34

The difference here is that she’s hosting in her house, she’s not taking the dogs to the parents.

I still think it would have been prudent to have offered to have done something about it - anyone with half a brain cell should realise most people with babies don’t want them around dogs. It should have been part of the invitation.

FurbySaysYummmm · 16/11/2026 12:38

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:37

I still think it would have been prudent to have offered to have done something about it - anyone with half a brain cell should realise most people with babies don’t want them around dogs. It should have been part of the invitation.

Is offering to have them in a separate room not doing something about it then? Hmm

insertgenericusername · 16/11/2026 12:39

Yeswoman · 16/11/2026 12:27

I find it totally crazy how some people will happily leave their dogs alone for a few hours when it suits them but when it comes to christmas and making totally understandable adjustments for babies and children you get the whole "but the dog deserves a nice Christmas too" spiel

Or, there’s the type of owner who doesn’t leave their dog for longer than 5 hours at an absolute stretch (and even then it’s very rare), regardless of whether it suits them or not.

my own set up this year is we are going to my sisters.
She has dogs of her own. There will be around 12 people there. She knows my dog isn’t left whenever I fancy, she also knows that it would be a lot to have my dog there the whole time, especially when we’re squeezing in an extra dining table. She also really wants me and my family to come, so she suggested he comes after dinner.

I’m more than happy with that, it’s the perfect set up. It means lunch will be relaxed, it means I’m not clock watching, and it means that my dog isn’t stuck at home alone for longer than would be comfortable.

some people care about their dogs. It’s not a crime.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:40

FurbySaysYummmm · 16/11/2026 12:38

Is offering to have them in a separate room not doing something about it then? Hmm

Maybe the sister has reason to believe they won’t actually stay in a separate room. I’ve seen this with dog people time and time over

FurbySaysYummmm · 16/11/2026 12:43

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:40

Maybe the sister has reason to believe they won’t actually stay in a separate room. I’ve seen this with dog people time and time over

Assuming that's relevant which seems unlikely given the OPs responses, then surely as she is an adult and she can say actually I don't feel comfortable with that especially with the baby why don't you come to mine or we go to mum and dads and someone else can host instead.

Why is it on the OP to offer solutions but no one else?

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 16/11/2026 12:43

So you are going to all the trouble and expense of hosting your whole family (again) and now your mother is making demands that you evict the dogs too.

Your sister is obviously perfectly entitled to not have her baby around the dogs. It's entirely possible she wants to stay put and have a first Christmas at home just the three of them after what has probably been an exhausting 4 months or her husband wants to see his family for a change and the dogs are just the useful excuse.

Your mum however, is being deeply unreasonable. I would simply point out that it's an invitation to your home, on your terms and family are free to make alternative plans if they wish.

SatsumaSeeds · 16/11/2026 12:45

Some people have gone crazy about not allowing dogs near their pfb. The normal thing to do is to keep the dogs in one part of the house whenever the baby will be on the floor or otherwise reachable by a dog. Finding somewhere else for them to stay is expensive, unnecessary extra work, and unkind to the poor dogs.

These aren't dangerous breeds, and she's being ridiculously over-cautious.

ClaredeBear · 16/11/2026 12:46

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:37

I still think it would have been prudent to have offered to have done something about it - anyone with half a brain cell should realise most people with babies don’t want them around dogs. It should have been part of the invitation.

Well, I can see why you might only have your houseplants for company!

nidvideouioui · 16/11/2026 12:49

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 07:51

No but he is only 4 months old. So far, we have been the ones to visit them but she’s never said that’s because of our dogs, just that it’s easier for us to go to them so she has all the baby stuff.

This makes even less sense to me, a 4 month old isn’t even going to be walking so why are the dogs an issue? What does she think will happen, especially seeing as you offered to put them in a different area?

gannett · 16/11/2026 12:52

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:37

I still think it would have been prudent to have offered to have done something about it - anyone with half a brain cell should realise most people with babies don’t want them around dogs. It should have been part of the invitation.

You are aware that many many babies are born into households where a dog/dogs/other pets are already present?

I've no skin in the game as I have neither babies nor dogs, but from what I've observed both growing up and with my parent friends now - there's no assumption that dogs should be kept away from babies to the point of kenneling them.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:52

gannett · 16/11/2026 12:52

You are aware that many many babies are born into households where a dog/dogs/other pets are already present?

I've no skin in the game as I have neither babies nor dogs, but from what I've observed both growing up and with my parent friends now - there's no assumption that dogs should be kept away from babies to the point of kenneling them.

Of course I’m aware - I think it’s a reckless and stupid thing to do.

cantthinkofagoodusername2026 · 16/11/2026 12:53

Can you be sure that your sister is in fact upset, and it's not just your parents saying so?
I don't think your sister is wrong for not wanting her baby around dogs, nor do I think you're wrong to not want to be without your dogs.

There are a lot of people on MN that think that people who don't love dogs are basically the Devil, but you don't know what peoples' experiences with dogs have been. I think it's unreasonable to expect everyone to love dogs.

insertgenericusername · 16/11/2026 12:54

cantthinkofagoodusername2026 · 16/11/2026 12:53

Can you be sure that your sister is in fact upset, and it's not just your parents saying so?
I don't think your sister is wrong for not wanting her baby around dogs, nor do I think you're wrong to not want to be without your dogs.

There are a lot of people on MN that think that people who don't love dogs are basically the Devil, but you don't know what peoples' experiences with dogs have been. I think it's unreasonable to expect everyone to love dogs.

She does probably know what her sisters experience with dogs has been though.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 12:54

SatsumaSeeds · 16/11/2026 12:45

Some people have gone crazy about not allowing dogs near their pfb. The normal thing to do is to keep the dogs in one part of the house whenever the baby will be on the floor or otherwise reachable by a dog. Finding somewhere else for them to stay is expensive, unnecessary extra work, and unkind to the poor dogs.

These aren't dangerous breeds, and she's being ridiculously over-cautious.

Edited

Some people have gone crazy about not allowing dogs near their pfb.

i think it is direct response to how bonkers people have become about dogs these days. Wouldn’t have needed to be said before because it would have been obvious that the dogs and babies should not mix. Now it is apparently not obvious so people have to vocalise it.

MagicMelanie · 16/11/2026 12:57

Maybe the sister has reason to believe they won’t actually stay in a separate room. I’ve seen this with dog people time and time over

This. The promise is often empty.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 16/11/2026 12:57

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 16/11/2026 10:45

but, why? Are they great big aggressive things? Or calm family dogs?

Being around animals is good for children, even babies unless they are dangerous

Thank goodness for some sense!

Toomanywomen · 16/11/2026 12:58

Not wanting the added expense and inconvenience of kennelling dogs over Christmas is not treating dogs as humans. I do wonder how some MNers treat their families.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 16/11/2026 13:02

MagicMelanie · 16/11/2026 12:57

Maybe the sister has reason to believe they won’t actually stay in a separate room. I’ve seen this with dog people time and time over

This. The promise is often empty.

Protests about the dog being sad and left out and “oh please could he come in just for a little bit?” And before you know it, your boundary is a curtain!