Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas with dogs and a baby

465 replies

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 07:28

We usually spend Christmas with my parents, my brother, his wife and children, sister and her husband and my SIL and her husband and children at our house. Over the last 3 years we have got 2 dogs and earlier this year my sister had a baby.

My sister has decided she doesn’t want her baby around our dogs so told me she won’t be coming to us for Christmas. I told her I understood and we will catch up another time. My sister seemed fine with that.

My parents have now told me that we should have offered to make other arrangements for our dogs like leaving them with friends or putting them in kennels so that we can all spend Xmas together. Apparently my sister was upset that we didn’t offer this but didn’t want to say. I haven’t spoke to my sister again yet. My brother has told my husband that my parents and sister think we are being selfish putting our dogs before their baby’s first Xmas.

I had no idea it was an issue and that they would expect our dogs to go elsewhere. We are not willing to send our dogs away anyway and I don’t see it as putting our dogs first. When I spoke to my sister before I did say we can keep the dogs separate to the baby but I understand that she didn’t want to take any risks. I thought she was happy for us to see each other at another time.

Do people really expect you to send your dogs somewhere so they can come for Christmas. Are we being unreasonable to say no?

OP posts:
MarysSilverBells · Yesterday 07:33

Nobody of any 'importance' would displace my dogs from mine and their home for any reason.

It would annoy me even more that your sister doesn't have the guts to say anything direct, and instead stirred things up against you.

You could say the dogs can be shut in a different room if thats possible, though I wouldnt even do that.

Toomanywomen · Yesterday 07:39

I backed out of previous Christmas arrangements when I got my most recent dog. Didn’t want to be the reason others missed out and didn’t want to put people in a predicament. He doesn’t go to kennels, we just stay home. Now you know what your family thinks, you should probably suggest you do the same.

I tend to think most dog threads on mn are made up (to drive engagement?) but good luck if this is real OP, you’re going to be called all sorts on here.

everyonedeservesbetter · Yesterday 07:39

You offered to keep the dogs separate from the baby. That’s all you can do.

I have never heard of anyone sending their dogs away for Christmas just to be able to host a family dinner. It’s an odd request.

I hate to say it but your sister’s baby’s first Christmas isn’t your responsibility.

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 07:42

Toomanywomen · Yesterday 07:39

I backed out of previous Christmas arrangements when I got my most recent dog. Didn’t want to be the reason others missed out and didn’t want to put people in a predicament. He doesn’t go to kennels, we just stay home. Now you know what your family thinks, you should probably suggest you do the same.

I tend to think most dog threads on mn are made up (to drive engagement?) but good luck if this is real OP, you’re going to be called all sorts on here.

They all come to our house usually as we have more space. We are fine with anyone who wants to go elsewhere so they get to be with the baby.

OP posts:
Mirrorxxx · Yesterday 07:44

You can’t put your dogs in kennels for Christmas. Your sister is dramatic. Has her child never been around dogs?

Flamingojune · Yesterday 07:46

Why cant your dogs be around a baby

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 07:48

Flamingojune · Yesterday 07:46

Why cant your dogs be around a baby

She doesn’t want them to be which is fair enough.

OP posts:
itstoolateforsnacks · Yesterday 07:48

I’m guessing they don’t realise that it’s not that easy to just ‘send dogs away’? It’s expensive, having dog carers that are reliable and also available at xmas isn’t easy. Kennels is an absolute no way for many dogs, they wouldn’t cope and many owners wouldn’t want to put them through it.

I think you all need to have a discussion. Explain your reasons and that you haven’t meant upset, and explain your own upset at everyone talking behind backs like this. The dogs and baby are now part of everyone’s lives for good so you all need a long term plan. Is it possible that there are some training needs with the dogs which make your sister wary? Or just general not wanting to have to supervise dogs with baby?

Joystir59 · Yesterday 07:50

oue three dogs ( 2 Shih Tzus and a spaniel) are all kind and relaxed around young children but are of course supervised closely at all times so children are educated on how to approach and touch them, dogs are not allowed to take food from hands etc etc, but there is no way I would be sending my dogs away at any time at anyone’s request

FurbySaysYummmm · Yesterday 07:50

So your sister wants you to still host everyone at yours for Christmas at great expense no doubt and also ship your dogs off somewhere else again at great expense rather than host Christmas herself? Fuck that for a game of soldiers

Hummingbird233 · Yesterday 07:51

What breed are your dogs? I think that matters as to what’s reasonable.

Im surprised your sister left it to now to say that though, surely she knew when she was pregnant even that she wouldn’t want to do it at yours with the dogs.

I think you need to let your parents, especially, know that they can swap plans in future years and you’ll be fine with that. They’ll likely want to follow the grandchildren at Christmas time and perhaps it’s worth letting them know that’s ok, as they may feel awkward if it’s always been at yours.

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 07:51

Mirrorxxx · Yesterday 07:44

You can’t put your dogs in kennels for Christmas. Your sister is dramatic. Has her child never been around dogs?

No but he is only 4 months old. So far, we have been the ones to visit them but she’s never said that’s because of our dogs, just that it’s easier for us to go to them so she has all the baby stuff.

OP posts:
Ophy83 · Yesterday 07:52

Do they have a particularly aggressive reputation? If not, sounds like she is being over protective. You obviously don't leave dogs and little ones alone together, but most family dogs are very good with babies. Mine decided that his role was to look after DD and would station himself nearby her pram when she was napping.

AutumnOakTree · Yesterday 07:54

You’ve done nothing wrong.

Tickingcrocodile · Yesterday 07:54

I'm not a dog person but I don't think you are being unreasonable. You are going to the effort of hosting, you don't need to send your dogs away too.

Toomanywomen · Yesterday 07:54

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 07:42

They all come to our house usually as we have more space. We are fine with anyone who wants to go elsewhere so they get to be with the baby.

Sorry, didn’t read properly! I wouldn’t put my dogs in kennels. I’d do the same as you, invite them, but make it clear that there are no hard feelings if they don’t accept.

RampantIvy · Yesterday 07:54

Flamingojune · Yesterday 07:46

Why cant your dogs be around a baby

I imagine there are lots of reasons. For a start, dogs are pack animals and we don't know how they will react to a baby. It is sensible to keep them apart or closely supervised to start with.

As the OP has offered to keep the dogs in a separate room I think the sister is being a little over cautious.

bababamama · Yesterday 07:55

Offering to put the dogs in a different room and put on leads if in the same space as the baby is the right thing to offer, wouldn’t dream of putting dogs into kennels. Unless there’s some mitigating factor like the dogs have bitten children, I would be doing introductions so the dogs are used to the baby (always supervised obviously).

Phoenix1Arisen · Yesterday 07:55

You're not preventing them from celebrating their baby's first Christmas. It just won't be at your house, by their own choice.

HettyTagliatelli · Yesterday 07:56

Your Mum and sister are being rude. They seem to think the world revolves around this new baby. You’re good enough to host everyone but they think you’re out of order for not paying an additional expense on top for kennels or asking someone else to care for you dogs over Christmas? What about the small children in other people’s families?

Enjoy your Christmas with people who aren’t so self centred OP. The dog walk on Christmas Day has always been especially lovky IME.

Onlyme7575 · Yesterday 07:56

Mirrorxxx · Yesterday 07:44

You can’t put your dogs in kennels for Christmas. Your sister is dramatic. Has her child never been around dogs?

The best comment

MyLifeInBooks · Yesterday 07:56

Suggest that someone else hosts Christmas this year and you'll attend leaving the dogs at home.

Flamingojune · Yesterday 07:57

SomewhereBeautiful · Yesterday 07:48

She doesn’t want them to be which is fair enough.

Why is it fair enough? What breed are they?

CaptainCalm · Yesterday 07:59

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable but you do sound perhaps a little detached from your nephew in your posts, using ‘the baby’ to describe him. Are you particularly close?

Her reaction is quite strong so I wondered if there is more to it? Are the dogs and aggressive breed, have they ever nipped anyone before, are they all over the house (on sofas, beds, upstairs, bouncing up at people when they walk in) As a non-dog person she might be worried about this perhaps?

LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 07:59

One of my dogs is nuts so I happily lock all three away in my (extremely comfy) spare room when young children come over.

But no dog owner is sending their dogs to kennels for Christmas for one baby, what an idiotic ask. It would cost £160 to put mine in kennels overnight and no kennels is taking dogs for only ONE NIGHT over the Christmas period when they’re fully booked for the whole week

Your mum can just fuck the fuck off.