Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas with dogs and a baby

474 replies

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 07:28

We usually spend Christmas with my parents, my brother, his wife and children, sister and her husband and my SIL and her husband and children at our house. Over the last 3 years we have got 2 dogs and earlier this year my sister had a baby.

My sister has decided she doesn’t want her baby around our dogs so told me she won’t be coming to us for Christmas. I told her I understood and we will catch up another time. My sister seemed fine with that.

My parents have now told me that we should have offered to make other arrangements for our dogs like leaving them with friends or putting them in kennels so that we can all spend Xmas together. Apparently my sister was upset that we didn’t offer this but didn’t want to say. I haven’t spoke to my sister again yet. My brother has told my husband that my parents and sister think we are being selfish putting our dogs before their baby’s first Xmas.

I had no idea it was an issue and that they would expect our dogs to go elsewhere. We are not willing to send our dogs away anyway and I don’t see it as putting our dogs first. When I spoke to my sister before I did say we can keep the dogs separate to the baby but I understand that she didn’t want to take any risks. I thought she was happy for us to see each other at another time.

Do people really expect you to send your dogs somewhere so they can come for Christmas. Are we being unreasonable to say no?

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 16/11/2026 09:35

Melsy88 · 16/11/2026 09:30

Agree, it's bonkers!

What's bonkers is the number of women who still don't have enough self-belief to look a relative in the eye and say "yes, I am putting my dogs first because I don't believe your fears about them being around the baby are justified" and instead have to try to convince themselves somehow that they are not choosing their dogs over the presence of their sister at a Christmas gathering.

I would choose the dogs too, but at least it be honest with myself about it!

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 09:36

sittingonabeach · 16/11/2026 09:24

Do you think other members of your family are making more of this than your sister?

I don’t know. I am going to see my sister today so I’ll find out exactly who has said what. My sister is usually like me and says what she means so it could be that this is mainly my mums opinion. I just wanted to see if most people think it’s reasonable to not make alternative arrangements for our dogs with a new baby in the house before I spoke to her about it.

OP posts:
Melsy88 · 16/11/2026 09:38

Imdunfer · 16/11/2026 09:35

What's bonkers is the number of women who still don't have enough self-belief to look a relative in the eye and say "yes, I am putting my dogs first because I don't believe your fears about them being around the baby are justified" and instead have to try to convince themselves somehow that they are not choosing their dogs over the presence of their sister at a Christmas gathering.

I would choose the dogs too, but at least it be honest with myself about it!

Ok. 🤣

MsSquiz · 16/11/2026 09:39

I find the “no dogs around babies” weirdo if I’m honest. DD1 was 1 week old at her first Christmas and around 2 dogs who gave her a sniff and forgot she was there! DD2 was 8 months old and the dogs did very well out of her sharing her lunch!

anyway, it wasn’t even a discussion, your sister said she isn’t coming. She didn’t make any request or ask your thoughts… she sounds a bit dramatic and PFB.

I would say to your parents that the dogs will be in a separate room if she would like to come, but they aren’t being sent away. And leave it at that.

Megifer · 16/11/2026 09:40

Not a chance Id send my dog away. Youve offered a perfectly fine solution, she is being absolutely ridiculous.

She'll cringe when she thinks of this in a year or so.

MsSquiz · 16/11/2026 09:41

Cla7 · 16/11/2026 09:16

Mumsnet loves dogs so you’ll get a lot of reassurance here, but my opinion is that YABU to put your dogs above spending Christmas with your sister and your newest family member. Poor sister, being a new mum can be very isolating as it is, and now having to spend Christmas alone must be a hard blow.

Then she probably shouldn’t have decided to tell her sister that she wasn’t going for Christmas…
that was her decision, not decided by the OP!

LondonLass2026 · 16/11/2026 09:41

My partner's sister had twins a few years ago and totally refuses to see us. We've been in this house 5 years and she still hasn't seen it. This is because of her having had the children, and us having two dogs.

Part of why I moved to the NE of England years ago is that my partner said he's really close to his family, and we all live near each other, but if we want to see her we have to see her at someone else's home as her house is still being built. She won't come to us due to the dogs.

She absolutely will not let her children around any dog, and they will scream every time they see one. Our families all go out a few times a year as they take their mother to lunch occasionally, and they have meltdowns in the street when a dog passes by.

Like fuck my dogs would get put into kennels at Christmas because of someone else's neurotic behaviour. This is their home. One of my dogs is elderly and wouldn't cope with a kennel.

AlphabetMole · 16/11/2026 09:45

I'm not particularly a dog person, but I wouldn't have any issue with a non mobile baby being around a dog for one day. It's likely to be much less risky than a mobile older child who might poke or pull at the dog.

OP, it sounds like you and your sister are fairly close and you don't want to go in all guns blazing and alienate her. So, although you're definitely not in the wrong, I'd adopt a conciliatory attitude. I'd tell your mum and sister, 'ok, we can't put the dogs in kennels over Christmas as it's unreasonable and too expensive, but we'd love to see you and this is what we can do (separate rooms etc.). We don't want to put any pressure on you though, and understand if you don't want to come'.

herbetta · 16/11/2026 09:46

Ask her to put her baby in a nursery or to leave the baby with friends so you can all spend the time together without it being a problem. The baby doesn't Trump the dogs.

ChrisTheBastard · 16/11/2026 09:46

Imdunfer · 16/11/2026 09:32

That's true but it doesn't change what I wrote.

She should be shown the asthma research

I wouldn't mind seeing this research please, if you have a link 🙏

Sorry, just found it. It's a legitimate paper in a respectable journal. Interesting...

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4805472/

WutheringTights · 16/11/2026 09:46

bababamama · 16/11/2026 08:00

Ps when we introduced my sil’s baby to my ddog we let him approach on a lead (he already knew them of course) he pulled the sock off, licked her foot then walked away, we then let him off his lead - he went straight to his toy box and brought the baby a stinky old tennis ball and dropped it next to her, went a few paces away and waited for the 8 week old baby the throw it… wishful thinking! First baby he had ever met as mine were 10+ when we got him

I’ll be honest, I have the daftest, most gentle, steadiest Labrador you could ever meet and he is treated like a full member of the family, but there is no way I’d allow him close enough to a baby to lick their foot. Too much risk if something goes wrong.

However, I think the OP’s sister is being dramatic. It’s perfectly possible to keep the dogs and the baby separate in a house big enough to host the number of adults that the OP seems to be hosting. I’d keep one room completely dog-free using stair gates, so that the baby has somewhere to nap/ kick on the floor etc, and let the dogs roam the other spaces in the house. Babies are easy to manage around dogs, it’s harder when they’re toddlers and wanted to go everywhere.

Allendeavour26 · 16/11/2026 09:47

I never let dogs around my children when they are small babies just because the crying and noises can be upsetting to dogs when they are not used to them, and equally the dogs can scare the babies too and I just would feel like I had to be alert all the time. However I would never demand someone lock their dogs away in their own home. She was right to not attend, but unrealistic to expect you send the dogs away.

AlphabetMole · 16/11/2026 09:49

herbetta · 16/11/2026 09:46

Ask her to put her baby in a nursery or to leave the baby with friends so you can all spend the time together without it being a problem. The baby doesn't Trump the dogs.

I think that is just stoking the flames though. If the OP gets on well with her family, who are usually sensible, then surely the first option is to find a compromise. It sounds like her sister is being a bit PFB, but lots of us get like that after the first baby arrives until we've got our heads around parenting. It's quite a stressful time.

PigeonsAmongstTheCats · 16/11/2026 09:51

You're absolutely not being unreasonable, no!

My dogs are my family and this is their home. If people come to visit then they have to accept that my dogs also live here. No way would I put them in kennels to accommodate someone wanting to visit.

MrsShawnHatosy · 16/11/2026 09:53

DeftGoldHedgehog · 16/11/2026 09:21

The options are not coming to OP or the emotive spending Christmas alone, as if sister will be out in the snow with her baby in a Dickensian scene, noses pressed to the window while the rest of the family enjoy turkey and all the trimmings, dogs sat up at the table. For one thing, even if sister didn't go anywhere at Christmas she would not be ALONE, as she has a husband and new baby.

Give her a few years and she’ll want to spend Christmas at home “with her own little family” and moan about being expected to go anywhere else.

FurbySaysYummmm · 16/11/2026 09:53

AlphabetMole · 16/11/2026 09:49

I think that is just stoking the flames though. If the OP gets on well with her family, who are usually sensible, then surely the first option is to find a compromise. It sounds like her sister is being a bit PFB, but lots of us get like that after the first baby arrives until we've got our heads around parenting. It's quite a stressful time.

As I said earlier the OP has tried to compromise. She said she would separate the dogs into another room or meet up with them on another day. It's also notable that she is the only one who has actually tried to offer solutions. I'm not sure what other compromise she could reasonably offer?

Cherrysoup · 16/11/2026 09:54

Obviously you aren’t being unreasonable. I wonder, if as you say, your mum is the driving force here? Would love an update if you have time.

AutumnLover1999 · 16/11/2026 09:58

Your sister is being very unreasonable,but I can kind of see the other side as either way you'd have to put them in boarding if they won't come to you,but you'd,I'm assuming,want to spend Christmas with them,unless they are very local and you can pop back to check on the dogs at home?

thisismeithinkorisit · 16/11/2026 10:02

what's the geography here? when you say come to you do you mean for a few hours for lunch or evening over for a week?

LongDarkTeatime · 16/11/2026 10:03

YANBU if your dogs are well behaved.
If your family have been comfortable with your dogs up until now, it’s curious what issue they are now seeing.
What ‘risk’ do you think your sister is imagining she is protecting her baby from?

Words · 16/11/2026 10:05

Put the baby in kennels instead 😁

Mooselove · 16/11/2026 10:06

Your sister and mum are being absolutely ridiculous. You have said you will put the dogs in another room and that should be good enough for them.

No way on earth would I be making my dogs go to kennels at Christmas

DiscoCherries · 16/11/2026 10:08

SomewhereBeautiful · 16/11/2026 08:12

Oh god not detached at all. We are besotted with him. My sister has waited a long time for him. All the rest of the kids in the family are at least 13 year older than him so everyone is very excited to have a little baby again.

This could be why she’s so nervous, if you’ve had a difficult journey to becoming a parent the postpartum anxiety can be so, so high. I don’t think you should put your dogs in kennels at all but I’d be empathetic, perhaps suggest rooms the dogs can be in so they’re away from the baby while they’re there, reassure her you’ll be keeping a very close eye. If she still says no, fine - but I’d be delicate if you can.

Attheendofthenight · 16/11/2026 10:09

Mirrorxxx · 16/11/2026 07:44

You can’t put your dogs in kennels for Christmas. Your sister is dramatic. Has her child never been around dogs?

Suggest she puts her baby in daycare. . See how she reacts

Cyclingmummy1 · 16/11/2026 10:09

I'm not a dog lover, but no way would I expect anyone to send their dog away so that I could stay over, baby or not. Look at it as a new routine for everyone.