Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think more people need to employ themselves?

156 replies

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 19:24

With all the talk of job losses and redundancies etc. Do you think more people need to go self employed and not rely on someone else to employ them and pay them?

OP posts:
Superscientist · Yesterday 11:40

tapasparatodas · Yesterday 01:14

You don't sound like a dick but as someone who's been self-employed and spent the best part of a decade trying to make a career out of some of these suggestions, I can say with some confidence that almost nobody is making a living from the ones I personally tried (proofreading/writing/editing as well as translation and some in-person tuition and private teaching etc). I made equivalent of around 50% minimum wage most months after costs (and there are plenty) despite working at least 16 hours a day often with only 2 or 3 full days off in a month (I have ME/CFS though and loads of brain fog - others might have been able to take on more and get nearer to minimum wage or even slightly beyond it if they were unusually fast). And I was actually deemed successful in that I got far more work than others I know and came away with many glowing reviews (I had a strong academic record). I'd say I had good business skills given my degree in business from a high ranking university and pushed hard for the highest rates I could but it made little difference. Had I been working in the same industry 30 or 40 years ago I'd have made a living going by data on the rates people were able to charge back then - I know people my parents age who have houses bought from working in these fields but it's almost unheard of these days - the rates have been destroyed. Ultimately there are just too many people competing for the work and you cannot charge enough unless you are exceptional (and nobody really is so early on in their career - increasingly fewer and fewer people are later on in their career either). I was lucky in that I had no mortgage or rent and also no kids. I'm disabled though so there was no option of regular employment.

Having hung around in a lot of self-employment chat forums, I've read posts by people who have tried some of the other things on your list. They were having much the same experience. You might get some work but the chances of making enough to support yourself let alone dependents was slim to none - it was pocket money at best for people with a wealthy spouse or who still lived with their parents.

According to like Startups.co.uk 96% of wholly self-employed workers in the UK are not currently saving into a pension pot - I'd imagine that's it's almost impossible to make enough to do so in the current climate. You are barely earning enough to eat with some of the things on your list. Although maybe some of the things are in the 4%. I'd doubt it though. I reckon that's made up of tradesmen and some self-employed doctors and other HCPs. Very high set-up costs and good health required for those though so not an option for most even if they have the aptitude!

I agree with this, I'm genuinely quite concerned by a self employment bubble at the moment with the turning hobby in to self employment type of self employment.

I just can't see what they charge can cover all of their expenses, pension provisions, holiday and sickness cover, taxes and so on.

We have been watching we made it at market at the moment and for the hours some are having to work for the level of pay I can't see how they earn enough to weather any storms that come there way. One was working 6-7 days a week and making £20k a year after costs, it's not an easy life. A family friend is a florist and grows and makes beautiful arrangements and she's really busy to the point of enlisting her mum's help at times to manage demand but at the same time the amount she is making for the hours she's putting in to the business is not a lot.

Tutoring is one of the things I have been considering as a source of pocket money income whilst I'm not well enough to work properly and it's not easy. To get on to many of the tutor websites to advertise and find clients request 2 years experience. It would also be the exact opposite of what I would want as it would be outside of school hours meaning either putting my child into after school club or in the evenings and weekends, most probably both for £20-30 an hour for the tutor session which would also have to cover the time before the session for prep time. To get to full time hours I would be looking at doing 4h every evening (4-8) - 20h over Mon - Fri followed by 6h every Saturday and Sunday to bring me to the 32h I used to work although over 4 days in paid employment and that's if I can find 16-32 students who want tutoring at one time and all year round. Doing 6-10 hours a week say one evening and a day time on Saturday would be more practical but very much in the topping up income category rather than a viable alternative to employment.

JengaCupboard · Yesterday 11:49

I don't necessarily disagree with the idea, but the assumptions/delivery appears somewhat short sighted. Having the skills to deliver a chargeable service, does not automatically mean you have the ability to actually run a business. Or everyone would.

Plus there needs to be a market for what you're offering, targeted research, competition, securing a material supply at the right price, ACTUALLY being good enough to make it worthwhile taking on the hideous amount of hassle involved to actually run a successful business properly.

ghostyslovesheets · Yesterday 11:53

FriNightBlues · 16/11/2026 16:32

I’m a self-employed sole trader in the Finance/IT sector. Off the top of my head, I have to do:

Business banking
Monthly invoicing
VAT Registration and quarterly returns
Making Tax Digital quarterly submissions
Annual self assessment tax returns
Pension Contributions
Indemnity insurance
Software licensing

My clients are all existing contacts who seek me out so I’ve never yet had to look for work. That would add in a shed load of effort.

Can everybody really do all that? I doubt it.

Edited

Exactly this - I could go self employed but I don’t want to have to deal with all of this - I like a nice reliable salary!

1dayatatime · Yesterday 17:57

MagpiePi · Yesterday 11:39

Far far easier to get a safe public sector job in a protected unionised environment and enjoy a relaxed life whilst complaining about how underpaid you are and how "rich" need to pay more taxes.

I guess you've never worked in the public sector? If not, why not, as it is sooo easy to get a cushy job there?

Actually I have worked in the public sector for 6 years when I was much younger. It was completely piss easy and relaxed to the point of boredom.
Most people seemed to be focused on how to scam overtime and get an early pension.

I made the decision to leave to the private sector to get a significant pay rise in order to buy our first house. But now in my older years I would jump at the chance of a similar public sector job just to kick back and relax with a great pension but unfortunately there are none in my area of expertise in my region / area.

Plont · Yesterday 21:20

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 19:31

Eh. How come you didn't get it.

Instead of relying on a firm to employ you or a business you go self employed .

You don't really rely on an employer . Employ yourself.

I don’t see the difference between providing a service for a company and them paying me, or providing a service for a private client and them paying me. Either way I am being paid for the service I provide. I am still providing the same service and one would pay pension, national service contributions, bonus, holiday pay, company car, etc., and the other might pay a bit more, but I’d have to sort everything else out myself. I’m still providing the same service whoever pays me.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · Yesterday 21:28

Whaleandsnail6 · 15/11/2026 19:47

I work in a prison...how exactly do you suggest I replicate that to become self employed?

Some jobs are crucial to society and cannot be done as self employed.

You convert your garden shed to a jail. Round up a few wrong uns and stick them in your shed. Downside is getting the wrong uns to pay you. You'll be self employed as per OP suggested though. 🙄😂

New posts on this thread. Refresh page