Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think more people need to employ themselves?

156 replies

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 19:24

With all the talk of job losses and redundancies etc. Do you think more people need to go self employed and not rely on someone else to employ them and pay them?

OP posts:
Sweetandsaltycaroline · 16/11/2026 21:28

Im not anti self employment, I am self employed myself....but im.not naive enough to think that its a cure-all for anyone whos looking for a job.

Some trades or industries....and certain personalities and skill-sets are more suited to it than others

Some things you can set up with very little outlay, others require a significant amount of capital to get started. A friend was made redundant during covid. They used their redundancy money to set up their own business, and it was really busy for about a year and a half and they made decent money. Then it tapered off and they had to go and do something else. But the point was they had money to invest to start it

Xkk · 16/11/2026 21:30

Security. As self employed you have to pay your taxes, to chase and keep clients, to stay competitive, to have tools/skills, to chase invoices, find the cheapest suplier, to haggle, to predict the market, to make sure you have enough money coming in to stay afloat. Some months you work only to cover your rent/insurance/pay the supliers. Up to 80% of buisnesses fail in the first 2 years. You have no guaranteed holiday, no guaranteed income. You are not approced for mortgage as easily. The capital you invest might be lost if you don't get customers in time. Sometimes people put their life savings in, make loans and come out with more debts. You are very very naive of you think is easy being self employed.

InterestedDad37 · 16/11/2026 21:32

Everyone could become a self-employed careers advisor, and advise their paying clients to become self-employed careers advisors. That'd probably work 🤔. 100% employment.

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:32

XenoBitch · 16/11/2026 21:23

If you have no savings, then what do you live on when building up your company?

Usually start as a side hustle, build from there, earn enough to quit your job.

One of the best ways to build a business is to do it while you have a job (gives you security while you make the right decisions)

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:34

Sweetandsaltycaroline · 16/11/2026 21:28

Im not anti self employment, I am self employed myself....but im.not naive enough to think that its a cure-all for anyone whos looking for a job.

Some trades or industries....and certain personalities and skill-sets are more suited to it than others

Some things you can set up with very little outlay, others require a significant amount of capital to get started. A friend was made redundant during covid. They used their redundancy money to set up their own business, and it was really busy for about a year and a half and they made decent money. Then it tapered off and they had to go and do something else. But the point was they had money to invest to start it

I do think if it were taught in schools and a recognised path we wouldn’t know the difference. Employment is seen as the norm and it’s very difficult to imagine self employment because we’re not taught those skills from an early age.

Good skills like

Communication
Budgeting and finance
Business
Sales
Marketing

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:36

Frankenspencer · 16/11/2026 21:17

Capital to live on while you get established, if nothing else? What do you live on otherwise?

I’ve built up a self employed business while having a job.

XenoBitch · 16/11/2026 21:37

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:32

Usually start as a side hustle, build from there, earn enough to quit your job.

One of the best ways to build a business is to do it while you have a job (gives you security while you make the right decisions)

If you have no job?

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:53

XenoBitch · 16/11/2026 21:37

If you have no job?

Well then what the heck have you got to lose? You can set a business up for free.

XenoBitch · 16/11/2026 21:55

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:53

Well then what the heck have you got to lose? You can set a business up for free.

I am rubbish at reading tone on here, but I hope that is sarcasm.

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:57

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:53

Well then what the heck have you got to lose? You can set a business up for free.

No it’s genuine and I’m not being obtuse, why not try to set up a business if you have no job and nothing to lose?

XenoBitch · 16/11/2026 21:57

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:57

No it’s genuine and I’m not being obtuse, why not try to set up a business if you have no job and nothing to lose?

With what money?

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:11

XenoBitch · 16/11/2026 21:57

With what money?

You don’t need money if you sell a service

XenoBitch · 16/11/2026 22:14

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:11

You don’t need money if you sell a service

What service would that be?

Not everyone has skills to sell. Unless you mean selling your body 😲I would not put that past some people on here.

FiveEightNine · 16/11/2026 22:17

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:11

You don’t need money if you sell a service

Business insurance? Equipment, material or transporation?

How do you know whether the idea is a viable business or whether the effort would be better spend job hunting/working on employability?

PollyBell · 16/11/2026 22:39

So op with people who employ themselves how muxh do they need or use in their own life relies on other people being employed?

So of everyone employs themself as you put it how would that work for general daily life for everyone?

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:49

FiveEightNine · 16/11/2026 22:17

Business insurance? Equipment, material or transporation?

How do you know whether the idea is a viable business or whether the effort would be better spend job hunting/working on employability?

You’re thinking in physical products!

VA
Online tutor (say you’re fluent in French, teach French)
Dog sitting/walking
Proofreading/writing/editing
Cleaning - using other people’s materials initially
customer service
online community moderation
Accountability partner
Tech Help for older people

very low cost
If you live in or within driving/walking distance of a more affluent area - house sitting, professional organising, dressing (such as at Christmas), gift wrapping
Pet taxi - if you have a car for people that don’t have a car
Elderly companionship - very sad but it is more and more popular
Flat pack furniture assembly

I know some of these aren’t great but hopefully gives you an idea.

i don’t mean to sound like a dick, I just wish more people knew that they have skills or experience that others do want and will pay for!

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:50

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:49

You’re thinking in physical products!

VA
Online tutor (say you’re fluent in French, teach French)
Dog sitting/walking
Proofreading/writing/editing
Cleaning - using other people’s materials initially
customer service
online community moderation
Accountability partner
Tech Help for older people

very low cost
If you live in or within driving/walking distance of a more affluent area - house sitting, professional organising, dressing (such as at Christmas), gift wrapping
Pet taxi - if you have a car for people that don’t have a car
Elderly companionship - very sad but it is more and more popular
Flat pack furniture assembly

I know some of these aren’t great but hopefully gives you an idea.

i don’t mean to sound like a dick, I just wish more people knew that they have skills or experience that others do want and will pay for!

Life admin support! I would love this if I could afford it. Someone to sort our all that shit like insurance and getting best deals

tapasparatodas · Yesterday 01:14

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:49

You’re thinking in physical products!

VA
Online tutor (say you’re fluent in French, teach French)
Dog sitting/walking
Proofreading/writing/editing
Cleaning - using other people’s materials initially
customer service
online community moderation
Accountability partner
Tech Help for older people

very low cost
If you live in or within driving/walking distance of a more affluent area - house sitting, professional organising, dressing (such as at Christmas), gift wrapping
Pet taxi - if you have a car for people that don’t have a car
Elderly companionship - very sad but it is more and more popular
Flat pack furniture assembly

I know some of these aren’t great but hopefully gives you an idea.

i don’t mean to sound like a dick, I just wish more people knew that they have skills or experience that others do want and will pay for!

You don't sound like a dick but as someone who's been self-employed and spent the best part of a decade trying to make a career out of some of these suggestions, I can say with some confidence that almost nobody is making a living from the ones I personally tried (proofreading/writing/editing as well as translation and some in-person tuition and private teaching etc). I made equivalent of around 50% minimum wage most months after costs (and there are plenty) despite working at least 16 hours a day often with only 2 or 3 full days off in a month (I have ME/CFS though and loads of brain fog - others might have been able to take on more and get nearer to minimum wage or even slightly beyond it if they were unusually fast). And I was actually deemed successful in that I got far more work than others I know and came away with many glowing reviews (I had a strong academic record). I'd say I had good business skills given my degree in business from a high ranking university and pushed hard for the highest rates I could but it made little difference. Had I been working in the same industry 30 or 40 years ago I'd have made a living going by data on the rates people were able to charge back then - I know people my parents age who have houses bought from working in these fields but it's almost unheard of these days - the rates have been destroyed. Ultimately there are just too many people competing for the work and you cannot charge enough unless you are exceptional (and nobody really is so early on in their career - increasingly fewer and fewer people are later on in their career either). I was lucky in that I had no mortgage or rent and also no kids. I'm disabled though so there was no option of regular employment.

Having hung around in a lot of self-employment chat forums, I've read posts by people who have tried some of the other things on your list. They were having much the same experience. You might get some work but the chances of making enough to support yourself let alone dependents was slim to none - it was pocket money at best for people with a wealthy spouse or who still lived with their parents.

According to like Startups.co.uk 96% of wholly self-employed workers in the UK are not currently saving into a pension pot - I'd imagine that's it's almost impossible to make enough to do so in the current climate. You are barely earning enough to eat with some of the things on your list. Although maybe some of the things are in the 4%. I'd doubt it though. I reckon that's made up of tradesmen and some self-employed doctors and other HCPs. Very high set-up costs and good health required for those though so not an option for most even if they have the aptitude!

MagpiePi · Yesterday 08:15

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 21:32

Usually start as a side hustle, build from there, earn enough to quit your job.

One of the best ways to build a business is to do it while you have a job (gives you security while you make the right decisions)

What about the school leavers and university graduates who have never had a job and can't rely on parents to keep them?

Its like the joke about the lost traveller who asks for directions and is told by a wily old local, 'Well, first thing, I wouldn't start from here...'

FoodoftheDog · Yesterday 08:20

Tradespeople need to do an apprenticeship and then typically get experience before they set up their business. DH is a professional he set up on his own for years then insurance companies stopped insuring smaller practices and he had to get a job for a bigger practice. Where are all these job areas you can just set up as self employed without experience?

Are you self employed @girlfriend44

mondaytosunday · Yesterday 08:44

Well just how would that work? I’m a graphic designer. So I would have to find clients and pay for all the software myself? It would cost a lot of money up front and I don’t see people lining up for my services, especially now with AI everyone thinks they can design stuff! And that’s in a profession that lends itself to freelancing. My friend who is a personal trainer (also lends itself to freelance) does it full time but it took a few years before she was truly self sustaining and when she had a foot operation she earned nothing for three months and had to rely solely on her DH’s salary.
Most people start in the hours around their day job for months of not years (or not ever) before they earn enough.
Plus nurses can’t employ themselves. Retail/service industries can’t . Sure they might have ambitions to start their own cleaning or catering firm or even nursing agency but whoa the upfront investment, the paperwork, the taxes.. and no one I know who has successfully started a business has paid themselves for the first two years. And often it’s before kids or when they are older.
Sure it can be done. Tradespeople that I’ve worked with all are self employed. But they took years working under someone else after learning the skills as they then have to learn the business side, and often get accredited that way.
My beautician has her own business. But first five years of her career she worked for someone else to build up her clientele and get the confidence and savings to buy the equipment. She then rented a room in a hair salon. Then saved more and was able to rent a standalone space. Then worked hard to get more clients and was able to hire someone to do nails. She took years. She also had a husband to help during lean times, otherwise she may never been able to get her own place.
It is naive in the extreme to tell someone to ‘just go work for yourself’. One reason there are fewer jobs out there is even established businesses are struggling.

1dayatatime · Yesterday 09:57

Xkk · 16/11/2026 21:30

Security. As self employed you have to pay your taxes, to chase and keep clients, to stay competitive, to have tools/skills, to chase invoices, find the cheapest suplier, to haggle, to predict the market, to make sure you have enough money coming in to stay afloat. Some months you work only to cover your rent/insurance/pay the supliers. Up to 80% of buisnesses fail in the first 2 years. You have no guaranteed holiday, no guaranteed income. You are not approced for mortgage as easily. The capital you invest might be lost if you don't get customers in time. Sometimes people put their life savings in, make loans and come out with more debts. You are very very naive of you think is easy being self employed.

Exactly- you would have to be completely mad to want to set up your own business in the UK.
Think of the stress, pressure, health impact (including suicides) .
As you say 80% fail in the first three years and even if you are the lucky 20% then the Government will tax the hell out of you and those on the left will hate you for being "rich". People are always jealous of what you've got but never jealous of what it took to get there.

Far far easier to get a safe public sector job in a protected unionised environment and enjoy a relaxed life whilst complaining about how underpaid you are and how "rich" need to pay more taxes.

FiveEightNine · Yesterday 10:36

labamba007 · 16/11/2026 22:49

You’re thinking in physical products!

VA
Online tutor (say you’re fluent in French, teach French)
Dog sitting/walking
Proofreading/writing/editing
Cleaning - using other people’s materials initially
customer service
online community moderation
Accountability partner
Tech Help for older people

very low cost
If you live in or within driving/walking distance of a more affluent area - house sitting, professional organising, dressing (such as at Christmas), gift wrapping
Pet taxi - if you have a car for people that don’t have a car
Elderly companionship - very sad but it is more and more popular
Flat pack furniture assembly

I know some of these aren’t great but hopefully gives you an idea.

i don’t mean to sound like a dick, I just wish more people knew that they have skills or experience that others do want and will pay for!

I'm not. I'm just not ignoring the costs involved.

Pet taxi - you need the car in better than average state and insurance.
Dog walking - insurance and getting to the place.

Yeah, some of the onlines might keep low cost if you have the right equipment at your home alrady.

Anyway, many aren't really business ideas, more like jigs, good to get a bit of extra caah, but not really a replacement for employement.

labamba007 · Yesterday 11:06

FiveEightNine · Yesterday 10:36

I'm not. I'm just not ignoring the costs involved.

Pet taxi - you need the car in better than average state and insurance.
Dog walking - insurance and getting to the place.

Yeah, some of the onlines might keep low cost if you have the right equipment at your home alrady.

Anyway, many aren't really business ideas, more like jigs, good to get a bit of extra caah, but not really a replacement for employement.

Say that to our local flat pack furniture man he’s raking it in.

There is such a push back to this though which I find fascinating. Insurance is 20-30 a month. At an employed job travel can cost that much. There’s always going to be some costs attached to working.

But it’s the degree people tie themselves in knots making out that they can’t set up a businesses without capital when the majority of businesses are set up without capital.

MagpiePi · Yesterday 11:39

1dayatatime · Yesterday 09:57

Exactly- you would have to be completely mad to want to set up your own business in the UK.
Think of the stress, pressure, health impact (including suicides) .
As you say 80% fail in the first three years and even if you are the lucky 20% then the Government will tax the hell out of you and those on the left will hate you for being "rich". People are always jealous of what you've got but never jealous of what it took to get there.

Far far easier to get a safe public sector job in a protected unionised environment and enjoy a relaxed life whilst complaining about how underpaid you are and how "rich" need to pay more taxes.

Far far easier to get a safe public sector job in a protected unionised environment and enjoy a relaxed life whilst complaining about how underpaid you are and how "rich" need to pay more taxes.

I guess you've never worked in the public sector? If not, why not, as it is sooo easy to get a cushy job there?