Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think more people need to employ themselves?

156 replies

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 19:24

With all the talk of job losses and redundancies etc. Do you think more people need to go self employed and not rely on someone else to employ them and pay them?

OP posts:
AmnesiacDream · 15/11/2026 20:28

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 20:09

Billionaires?
You can employ yourself without being a billionaire.

You can employ yourself without being a billionaire, BUT almost all businesses that end up being successful are started by people who have enough family wealth that they don't need to earn a wage for a few years. That's not the position of the vast majority of Brits.

StockingsByTheFire · 15/11/2026 20:28

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 19:57

Trying to tell me you know my business history without telling me you haven't got a clue who you're talking to

Hiya. I'm a qualified accountant.

I run a charity at the mo, but still have retained some of my old client base and do the books of around 45 tiny sole traders to medium size Ltds and a couple of other entity types. I've been doing at least this number of cases for 20+ years from originally being in private practice. I guess what I'm trying to say is I know a lot of people who run their own businesses. A broad cross section.

Whilst I don't know your business history, what I do know is that your comments are demonstrating a poor level of understanding towards the majority of the self employment sector.

GrantMyWishes · 15/11/2026 20:30

I actually agree with you OP. My granddaughter lived through senior school during Covid, and really suffered because of it. She left school to go to college but didn't enjoy it, and ended up slobbing around on the sofa all day on her phone. One day she woke up and realised that this wasn't doing her any good, had a think about things that people frequently want, and found a niche in the market. She decided to become self employed, and works her butt off, but loves having the freedom of being her own boss, and plans to expand her business in due course. So while this wouldn't be for everyone, for some people it really CAN work. Yes it's hard, but at least she's not claiming benefits.

edwinbear · 15/11/2026 20:31

I also work for a multinational bank. As PP mentioned above, I can’t realistically set one of those up and my employer clearly isn’t doing OK as (like many banks) they’re about to make thousands of people redundant. If they were doing well, they wouldn’t need to. And the people who run the bank I work for are considerably more experienced and smarter than I am.

Nevermissabeat · 15/11/2026 20:31

Whaleandsnail6 · 15/11/2026 19:47

I work in a prison...how exactly do you suggest I replicate that to become self employed?

Some jobs are crucial to society and cannot be done as self employed.

Lock yourself in your house and don't let yourself out.

NobodyEvenCares · 15/11/2026 20:35

Smallestshadow · 15/11/2026 20:21

You need a skill you can actually make a living out of AND good business sense/acumen. Combining those three things is very difficult. You also need access to start up funds etc. There’s no holiday pay, sick pay, pension, job security.

You also need to be good enough at so many things: marketing, networking, sales, invoicing, providing quotes, etc etc.

Most people can’t or don’t want to have to be absolutely everything in a role.

IdleGossip · 15/11/2026 20:41

Arlanymor · 15/11/2026 19:32

No business is free to set up, you need capital.

Not true. Perhaps if you want to start a bricks and mortar shop, drive a taxi, be a plumber - those sorts of businesses yes you will need premises, a vehicle, tools etc.

But if what you are selling is you and your skills in graphic design, accounting, portrait painting, tour guiding, maths tutoring - you don't need any capital at all.
Getting enough clients for a full time salary though is another matter.

Chilly80 · 15/11/2026 20:44

You quit your job then and free it up for someone else and employ yourself

SylvanMoon · 15/11/2026 20:47

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 20:00

Your experience is yours. It doesn't automatically make it everybody else's reality. A little less assumption and a little more perspective wouldn't go amiss.

Wow! With that wonderfully sweet and empathetic attitude is it any wonder that you're unable to be an employee? What jobs are you suggesting should be made all self-employable rather than employees working for an employer? How would you restructure education, local government, NHS, prisons, manufacturing (to name but a few employers) in such a way that would enable all those employees to be self-employed and the same tasks being done?

SwingAndRelax · 15/11/2026 20:48

I work in a prison...how exactly do you suggest I replicate that to become self employed?

Grin Well I suggest not doing the thing you're trained in and skilled in that is required by society, but take in some ironing instead. Apparently there are people falling over themselves to pay a fortune for this vital service!
SwingAndRelax · 15/11/2026 20:50

What if you go freelance, become successful and need to take on another member of staff to keep the business running at full profit potential?

Presumably OP would advise that employee not to work for the people they've inspired with this thread, because they shouldn't rely on anyone else?

Churchbell · 15/11/2026 21:04

OP sounds like just the sort of easy going, helpful, self employed person anyone would be happy to deal with. You can see why she's been so successful that she's now moving on to motivating others.

TiredShadows · 15/11/2026 21:51

Been there, done that, taking a break from it in the Civil Service in a profession much like Whaleandsnail6 where I'd prefer not to go any further into private sector.

Also, the general advice for those who are employed who are interested in self-employment to remain employed while building up a business. Not just 'go employ yourself' -- which still requires relying on others to pay them and more. Accepting that reliance is part of the process.

There has already been a move of more people doing both employment and self-employment, that's what caused the gig economy issues in the first place -- a lot of people feeling they've no other options. It works for some, but it's not a great place to start from. As I said, been there, done that.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 15/11/2026 22:12

I mean DH did it and it was easy and cheap to start. He only makes around £5,000 a year and is earning way less than minimum wage considering the hours he puts in but it does let him work around our son's needs.

So when I was made redundant, being self employed wasn't really an option given that we actually have bills to pay and like to eat.

Cruftsrecommended · 15/11/2026 22:26

I have been self employed since 2016. Had a break of a year or so in that time due to health, but set up and ran 2 successful, completely different businesses in that time.
No capital needed for either. So it can be done. But I’m a one-man band. Not employing others etc.
I couldn’t go back to being employed now. But I had partners to support me in the first few months while I was waiting for clients to build up.

XenoBitch · 15/11/2026 22:29

This is just a new take on "take in ironing".

girlfriend44 · 15/11/2026 22:46

GrantMyWishes · 15/11/2026 20:30

I actually agree with you OP. My granddaughter lived through senior school during Covid, and really suffered because of it. She left school to go to college but didn't enjoy it, and ended up slobbing around on the sofa all day on her phone. One day she woke up and realised that this wasn't doing her any good, had a think about things that people frequently want, and found a niche in the market. She decided to become self employed, and works her butt off, but loves having the freedom of being her own boss, and plans to expand her business in due course. So while this wouldn't be for everyone, for some people it really CAN work. Yes it's hard, but at least she's not claiming benefits.

👏 👏

OP posts:
MagpiePi · 15/11/2026 22:55

I’ve decided to win the Euromillions instead of going to the bother of employing myself.

puppyinapumpkinpatch · 15/11/2026 23:04

Self-employment can be amazing, but it's not a good fit for everyone. It comes with a lot of risk, and if you don't have the right personality (motivated, self-starter) and the right set of skills, along with some luck, you're probably better off with traditional employment.

The potential rewards are there, but you work hard for them. There's less of a safety net in place, unless you've provided it for yourself.

Ponderingwindow · 16/11/2026 00:28

No matter how talented or qualified a person might be, self employment success hinges on constantly being good at sales. That is a rare skill.

Revisiontimetable · 16/11/2026 00:38

I think OP is trying to ask about entrepreneurial spirit and whether people limit themselves when considering what they could do. Trouble is you've just asked quite a blunt and over simplified question. It's like those "Your next job could be in cyber!!1!11!" adverts, as though it's a) easy and b) desirable for everyone to shift jobs around to certain industries or ways of working that are easier for government to handle.

This country faces huge challenges and changes which affect our care system, health, schooling, energy, computing, the financial markets and regulated industries. There are some really tough choices to make about what we value and the shape of our future labour market as a result.

This post just feels like OP thinks everyone should get on their bike and start an etsy shop.

Takeapause · 16/11/2026 01:09

OP has a point.

If you are maybe Gen Z or young millennial, the idea of self employment with minimal skill is easier to grasp but still hard as every market is becoming saturated.

I know young people selling clothes and stuff on resell platforms, starting with their own stuff then reinvesting it in stock. I know people who have finished uni and are tutoring GCSE and a level, earning abit from that. Hairdressing … there are loads of wanted skills that you can do whilst you job hunt. If you do it for a while, it can then become experience that these employers are looking for as entry jobs have become impossible to find.

It’s a different generation who have access to the internet - so it would most likely be a D2C type business. If they are lucky they could get headhunted or turn it into a reliable business.

But yes - that path is difficult, but why not if nobody will employee you after looking for years?

Friendlygingercat · 16/11/2026 01:12

When you go for an interview and you admit to being or having been self employed it can go against you. Employers want someone who is meek and will fit in and not someone assertive and clever enough to run their own business.

Opus3 · 16/11/2026 01:13

I started a business this year. Knocked it on the head after 3 months because people are self centered entitled shits.

I am working on something that won't need me to deal with the above.

Takeapause · 16/11/2026 01:13

Friendlygingercat · 16/11/2026 01:12

When you go for an interview and you admit to being or having been self employed it can go against you. Employers want someone who is meek and will fit in and not someone assertive and clever enough to run their own business.

What about when you have zero experience? Employers are not employing those people either.