Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to contribute to Christmas Dinner… money instead?

308 replies

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

OP posts:
Lordofmyflies · 15/11/2026 16:52

I'd just message her and say " I will obvs provide the pudding as asked but it probably won't stand up to being made days ahead and travelling. To save mess, my solution is get it delivered on the 24th. Would you like me to get a selection of puds or anything else I can get delivered on that day?" Then buy whatever she requests from cook.net or Waitrose entertaining.

Anywherebuthere · 15/11/2026 16:52

Offer the money or make it there?
Or alternatively discuss a different food contribution which suits you both?

RandomCactus · 15/11/2026 16:58

Of course she’s expecting you to need some kitchen time to prepare the tiramisu. She’s not expecting you to bring one on 21st. Stop overthinking it and just make a tiramisu!

PinkMicrowave · 15/11/2026 16:58

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:34

I really feel this whole thing has gotten derailed.

Year after year I see post on MN from people who want finalincal contribution to their hosting. The response on here is that it's vulgar to do so and that it's much more 'proper' to ask for people to bring dishes.

Could it not be the case that SIL is more than happy to make/source a tiramisu herself and would actually prefer money, but feels unable to do so and has asked me to bring a pudding instead?

Presumably she is spending a lot of time cooking so possibly it's the investment of time and labour she wants to even out, not the finances. A bit like if she'd asked you to knit a scarf for her present but you decided to buy a nice one from a shop instead. It's still nice, but maybe she sees your time and skill as the key assets?

Maybe different if you know her to be someone who will in fact buy a lot of ready-prepared stuff in and doesn't care. I don't know - you know her better than us.

NotARealWookiie · 15/11/2026 16:59

I’d probably message her and say - can I just check the logistics of fridge space etc for the tiramisu? I have a really good recipe I’ve made before and would love to make for everyone but would need x amount of hours in Xmas eve to prepare it an a shelf in the fridge. Is this doable or shall I order the cook one?

I think people appreciate a direct approach. The host gifts also sound lovely.

Wadsworthy · 15/11/2026 17:00

Just get up early and make it there.

Calamitousness · 15/11/2026 17:03

I’d order one to be delivered there on Xmas eve or 23rd and tell sil that’s the plan and you can’t make it and bring it etc.

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 17:04

well…. I’ve text her.

I said that I would brave the supermarket on 23rd, so if she keeps a list of anything and everything she needs last minute, I can pick that up at the same time as my ingredients.

I asked for her to block out an hour in the kitchen on 24th for me to make it and clean-up. I also provided exact external measurements of the ceramic dish I will bring with me so she can work out fridge space and not have to worry about keeping a dish for me to use.

I did also ask if there was any financial contribution we could make given how expensive Christmas is.

OP posts:
katgab · 15/11/2026 17:05

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:34

I really feel this whole thing has gotten derailed.

Year after year I see post on MN from people who want finalincal contribution to their hosting. The response on here is that it's vulgar to do so and that it's much more 'proper' to ask for people to bring dishes.

Could it not be the case that SIL is more than happy to make/source a tiramisu herself and would actually prefer money, but feels unable to do so and has asked me to bring a pudding instead?

It could be but I’d read it as she’d like help with the cooking of Christmas lunch so she suggested a dish for you to bring. The simplest way to find out is to ask her. Giving her the money is certainly a help but doesn’t remove the work involved which might be on her mind. If the dish is proving difficult ask / suggest an alternative or get a ready made one.

claracluck71 · 15/11/2026 17:06

Why not just make ahead and freeze it? Ask if there will be freezer space and then just defrost and finished off off with grated chocolate/cocoa the day before.

My sister-in-law always asks what she can bring to contribute to Christmas - we usually seem to end up hosting - and we generally ask her to bring some wine. We never have trouble finding room for the two bottles she’ll bring for a 5-day family gathering…🙄

Delatron · 15/11/2026 17:07

I’m not sure if your message sounds a little passive aggressive. Saying you’ll ’brave the supermarket’ on the 23rd.

I think maybe she just didn’t think about logistics. I would have said could I bring the ingredients and use the kitchen for an hour when suits her and not in her way. And hope that she changes it to a pudding you can make at home.

Delatron · 15/11/2026 17:09

This is the second thread I’ve seen where people descend on relatives for at least 5 nights over the festive period. That’s a lot. Who decides this? If I was hosting this would be my idea of hell! A couple of days is enough.

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 17:10

Delatron · 15/11/2026 17:07

I’m not sure if your message sounds a little passive aggressive. Saying you’ll ’brave the supermarket’ on the 23rd.

I think maybe she just didn’t think about logistics. I would have said could I bring the ingredients and use the kitchen for an hour when suits her and not in her way. And hope that she changes it to a pudding you can make at home.

Jesus Christ, I forget that an OP can do no right on MN.

Do you think I copy and pasted my exact WhatsApp message? I guarantee the text she received will not be interpreted as passive aggressive.

OP posts:
Ophy83 · 15/11/2026 17:13

You make it there on Christmas Eve, at a time when SIL isn't using the kitchen

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 17:14

Delatron · 15/11/2026 17:09

This is the second thread I’ve seen where people descend on relatives for at least 5 nights over the festive period. That’s a lot. Who decides this? If I was hosting this would be my idea of hell! A couple of days is enough.

I agree it's a long time. SIL and BIL suggested it.

The 5 DC are at an age where they play together so sweetly and love time with their cousins - when it's time to go home after a normal weekend visit there's often one hiding somewhere in the hopes of staying longer 😂 They're also at an age where they all believe fully, a year or two more and the older ones will grow out of it. We all agreed it was a particularly magical age, and SIL suggested it was an opportunity for a special Christmas - probably never to be repeated, unless the nagging of kids becomes unbearable next year!!!!

OP posts:
Wadsworthy · 15/11/2026 17:16

It sounds lovely @ThatsVertigo And your tiramisu as well!

Delatron · 15/11/2026 17:19

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 17:10

Jesus Christ, I forget that an OP can do no right on MN.

Do you think I copy and pasted my exact WhatsApp message? I guarantee the text she received will not be interpreted as passive aggressive.

Ok - hopefully she’ll change her idea on the dessert then when she realises the logistics of you having to go to the supermarket on the 23rd and then use her kitchen to make.

If she was the one that suggested such a long stay then all good. She’s a better person than I am!

PeonieLover · 15/11/2026 17:19
  1. I'd order tirasmisu and deserts from Cook to be delivered the day before you need them. You're over thinking things.
  1. Also, I'd book a hotel or air b n b near sils and pop in and out during the 4 days. This way you're not in each other's pockets plus you'll have another kitchen to store & prep food if you go for the air b n b option.

Over 10 people stuck in a house with at least 1 bathroom, kids and dogs is not my idea of fun. Book an apartment/ air b n b so you all don't drive each other mad over Christmas.

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · 15/11/2026 17:21

I don't think making it in an "unfamiliar kitchen" would be a problem, they aren't complicated. And if you're going on the 21st then there's plenty of time to find a time when the kitchens empty. You also wouldn't need to buy the stuff before going, the car will be chilled enough.

However I don't a marks and spencers dessert would be just as nice, if not nicer.

MotherofTerriers · 15/11/2026 17:24

Your tiramisu recipe sounds like mine, if making it in a "strange" kitchen I'd take an electric whisk with me, there's a lot of whisking and I usually use 2 at home to stop overheating...............

SoozyWoozy5 · 15/11/2026 17:27

Onwardsandupwards3 · 15/11/2026 15:26

Bring the ingredients in a cool bag and make it there the day before it is needed.

This!

OffTheMap · 15/11/2026 17:29

I give my brother £150 towards the huge Christmas provisions bill AND take a substantial food contribution.

Pick a simpler recipe, take the ingredients with you in a cool bag with ice blocks , get your DH to be alongside washing up the bowls etc, find a quite time when everyone is watching a film or whatever.

But discuss this in advance with SIL, the fact that you will need the kitchen for xxx time. And see if there is something you could make that can be made in advance. (Have a few things to suggest)

ChocolateCinderToffee · 15/11/2026 17:30

Ask her if she minds one from Waitrose or M&S.

Otherwise, make it there. It's not full of hard-to-source ingredients, after all.

PermanentlyExhaustedPigeonZZZ · 15/11/2026 17:31

Ask her to buy the ingredients (and pay her back) and make the tiramisu, and also give £150 to cover your portion.

It'll be much nicer for everyone to have a home cooked one.